Church Gives Away 100% of its Donations to Charity (?)

Puppycow

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
34,655
Location
Yokohama, Japan
I have a somewhat cynical view of religion and the religion business. While I think it would be too cynical to think of it only as a business (or racket), I also think it would be naive not to see it as, in most cases, a way for clerics to make a living. While most churches of course do give some of their donations (tithes) to charity, I think that this is probably window dressing for PR purposes.

So the cynical part of me was a bit skeptical about the following report on NBC news:

Here

(In case you can't watch the video, it's about a congregation that supposedly gives 100% of its donations to charity. They can do this because, for one thing, they don't actually have a physical church, but instead use (rent) the auditorium of their local high school.

1) Are we to take this at face value? Is this not a little too good to be true?
2) Can it last?
 
I have a somewhat cynical view of religion and the religion business. While I think it would be too cynical to think of it only as a business (or racket), I also think it would be naive not to see it as, in most cases, a way for clerics to make a living. While most churches of course do give some of their donations (tithes) to charity, I think that this is probably window dressing for PR purposes.

So the cynical part of me was a bit skeptical about the following report on NBC news:

Here

(In case you can't watch the video, it's about a congregation that supposedly gives 100% of its donations to charity. They can do this because, for one thing, they don't actually have a physical church, but instead use (rent) the auditorium of their local high school.

1) Are we to take this at face value? Is this not a little too good to be true?
2) Can it last?
1. No, it's not necessarily too good to be true.
2. Yes, of course.
 
What does it even mean to say the church gives 100% of its donations to charity? Even if they just rent a place, they've got to pay the rent, and that pastor presumably eats and lives somewhere (other than the coffee house). Does it mean they give 100% less their own operating expenses (and presumably a prudent reserve so they don't get kicked out of their auditorium)?

I'd rather see the money go to United Way. Then the kid with CP might get help without having a Bible pressed into her hand.
 
It's one thing to not accept claims without evidence, it's another not to look for evidence.

From Waterfront's website:

Jesus said, “Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.” Waterfront wants to follow that example by giving our Sunday morning offerings away each week to different causes . . . Causes that can help us to love God and people well. That might be a single mother trying to raise her children, hunger in a third world country, or helping a deserving person get out of debt.

There are probably donations that are received by the Church which aren't received as part of their Sunday morning offering and which aren't given away at the rate of 100%.

If you count that as a misrepresentation, I wouldn't blame the Church. For NBC the unqualified, unsubtle claim is a much better news story.
 
Jesus you guys are cynical. In the organizations I know, the money goes to maintaining the church and then charity (And yes, many do rent and many priests do live extremely frugally). As for maintaining the church, there is also a board that determines when a new expense should be paid.

And of course it is a way for priests to make a living, being a priest is a lifelong job serving a community spiritually (Yes, you may say that isn't really serving them, but obviously the community views it differently).
 
Private foundations are only required to give away in direct qualifying distributions 5% of their total value (averaged over 2 years).

100% of every Sunday is really very good.
 
Private foundations are only required to give away in direct qualifying distributions 5% of their total value (averaged over 2 years).

100% of every Sunday is really very good.

Only if more than 5% of their total income is Sunday donations. ;)
 
Well, there was Jim and Tammy Bakker, Oral Roberts, Jimmy Swaggart, Kent Hovind, Peter Popoff, Ted Haggard, . . .

So yes, I'm a little cynical. I admit that.

You do realize those are the gargantuan exceptions, and not the rule?
 
Private foundations are only required to give away in direct qualifying distributions 5% of their total value (averaged over 2 years).

100% of every Sunday is really very good.

Well, I guess I have to agree. I think that Jim Semradek is apparantly a credit to his faith. Jim Bakker is not. Most other churches are probably somewhere in between.
 
Private foundations are only required to give away in direct qualifying distributions 5% of their total value (averaged over 2 years).

Where'd you get that?

A quick google turned up this:

Under Canadian law, a charitable organization must spend at least 80% of the amounts for which it issued official donation receipts in the preceding year on its charitable activities.

and this:

A review of its tax returns shows that:
The United Way OC spent more than it took in for two of the past three years.
OC=Orange County.

And my local United Way:
Our pledge to you is that we will invest your gift strategically to positively impact our community by:

  • Giving more than 90 cents of every dollar to agencies and initiatives that provide health and human services, reducing agencies' fundraising costs and ensuring more money goes to helping to those in need.
  • Helping more than 1 million residents of the greater St. Louis area – 16 counties in Missouri and Illinois.
  • Relying on community volunteers to allocate funds to quality agencies.
  • Mobilizing volunteers, who keep our fundraising costs low and provide the region with hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of time.
  • Helping people find assistance with 2-1-1, a 24-hour information and referral helpline.

And oh by the way, here's what the Archdiocese of St. Louis has had to spend some big bucks on.
 
That's not impossible. The church could, for example, have investments which adequately cover their expenses.
 
You do realize those are the gargantuan exceptions, and not the rule?

I'm assuming you have heard of the Catholic church, the Pope and something used by many Christian businesses called tithing?

That said - the OP is a nice story and as other money making businesses not only allow but encourage marketing of their charitable activities, I see no reason why churches can't market their charitable activities for their money making business.
 
I'm assuming you have heard of the Catholic church, the Pope and something used by many Christian businesses called tithing?

That said - the OP is a nice story and as other money making businesses not only allow but encourage marketing of their charitable activities, I see no reason why churches can't market their charitable activities for their money making business.

Kind of like how a company might donate a million dollars to some worthy cause and then spend a hundred million dollars on an advertising campaign to make sure that everyone is aware of their charitable work?
 
Kind of like how a company might donate a million dollars to some worthy cause and then spend a hundred million dollars on an advertising campaign to make sure that everyone is aware of their charitable work?

Yes, that's it. In the churching business I think it's called building cathedrals, palaces and/or stadium churches.


Some companies follow the churching tried and tested business model of large, flambouyant buildings funded by the gullible (losers?) - Most people call it Las Vegas.
 
Last edited:
You do realize those are the gargantuan exceptions, and not the rule?

No, I don't know that. How do you know that?

What is the rule, anyway? You appear to know.

For myself, I don't find it at all hard to believe that an industry based on fantasy, myths, legends, and outright lies might harbor more than a few of that ilk. Most--probably all--of the ones I've ever known were greedy, money-sucking bastards, frankly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom