Merged Christine O'Donnell: "Where in the Constitution is separation of Church and State?"

Crossbow

Seeking Honesty and Sanity
Joined
Oct 23, 2001
Messages
14,596
Location
Charleston, WV
Christine O'Donnell: "Where in the Constitution is separation of Church and State?"

Christine O’Donnell who is the Republican Senate nominee for the state of Delaware (and a real favorite of Sara Palin), shocked the audience at her recent display of constitutional ignorance by asking about the separation between church and state.

And since O’Donnell wants Creationism taught in public schools, then her desires conflict with a basic tenant of the law that she does may not know about, which is not a good thing for someone who will be responsible for writing and reviewing the law.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20101019/ap_on_el_se/us_delaware_senate_2

…

Coons said private and parochial schools are free to teach creationism but that "religious doctrine doesn't belong in our public schools."

"Where in the Constitution is the separation of church and state?" O'Donnell asked him.

When Coons responded that the First Amendment bars Congress from making laws respecting the establishment of religion, O'Donnell asked: "You're telling me that's in the First Amendment?"

…


And on the off chance that O’Donnell still does not know about this whole first amendment to the US Constitution thing, then here is the appropriate section:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; ...
 
Haha!

Maybe Christine O'Donnell should call it quits and become a writer at SNL. If NBC still owns Conan's intelluctual property, She and the Masturbating Bear can have an all out debate haha.
 
I've got to say that very little surprises me with her these days, but this, even for her, was a bit ridiculous.

TAM:)
 
I get what happened. There are plenty of people who think just because the phrase "separation of church and state" is not in the constitution that the idea has no constitutional basis. I think her saying, "You're telling me that's in the First Amendment?" actually referred to the phrase "separation of church and state".

So, even if she'd made her challenge more clearly, I would point out that the phrase "wall of separation between the church and the state" can be seen as coming from the legislative history of the First Amendment. Also, the Constitution spelled out a separation of powers that let the judiciary interpret laws (including the Constitution), and there's a boatload of court cases that recognize the separation of church and state (and even use those words).

So if she (and others of her ilk) claim that the phrase has no constitutional basis, they're actually challenging the entire system of checks and balances and separation of powers that recognizes case law.
 
So if she (and others of her ilk) claim that the phrase has no constitutional basis, they're actually challenging the entire system of checks and balances and separation of powers that recognizes case law.

That is generally it. They don't recognize the legitimacy of any constitutional caselaw that fails to fit within their concept of What The Constitution Really Says. Plus, the Constitution doesn't explicitly say the Court should have the last word as to what the constitution says or doesn't say, so they tend to have a problem with the whole institution of judicial review.



A lot of the TP intellectual tradition (giggle) seems to be filtered and watered down FTL conspiracy theory nonsense.
 
That is generally it. They don't recognize the legitimacy of any constitutional caselaw that fails to fit within their concept of What The Constitution Really Says. Plus, the Constitution doesn't explicitly say the Court should have the last word as to what the constitution says or doesn't say, so they tend to have a problem with the whole institution of judicial

And that's simply because no one has the last word in our system.

But, Article III Section 2 does indeed say that the Judiciary has this authority. It explicitly states that they have the authority to resolve conflicts "arising under this Constitution, the laws of the United States, and Treaties made. . . ". This section was slightly modified by the 11th Amendment--but the power is clearly and explicitly stated.

You're right, they're strict constructionist except when it's inconvenient. (Sort of like the way people claim to believe the Bible is inerrant except when you quote passages that they couldn't possibly agree with.)
 
You're right, they're strict constructionist except when it's inconvenient. (Sort of like the way people claim to believe the Bible is inerrant except when you quote passages that they couldn't possibly agree with.)

Or how Conservatives tend to support "states rights" when some state-or-local-level knuckle-draggers want to restrict a freedom (i.e. civil rights, sodomy laws, abortion rights, free speech), but balks and demands the federal government "do something" when states wants to legalize pot or same-sex marriage.
 
Last edited:
You're right, they're strict constructionist except when it's inconvenient. (Sort of like the way people claim to believe the Bible is inerrant except when you quote passages that they couldn't possibly agree with.)

It goes beyond that, I think. When a reasonable person comes across a Supreme Court decision that person does not agree with, that person generally stops at criticism. This applies regardless of one's interpretive theory. Reasonable people know that people can disagree.

It is another matter to, when disagreeing with an opinion, consider that opinion illegitimate and illegal on the basis that the Court is not following the real constitution.

The bible analogy would be more along the lines of how certain sects consider any other interpretation of the holy works to be blasphemy, work of the devil, etc.

Which is part of why I don't think the religious right crazies melding into this sort of subjective constitutional absolutism is a coincidence. Same reasoning, different text.
 
A very, VERY noticeable parallel between the teaparty literal interpretation "to the word" of the constitution, and the far right evangelicals and their strict interpretation of the bible, "to the word".

TAM:)
 
Which is part of why I don't think the religious right crazies melding into this sort of subjective constitutional absolutism is a coincidence. Same reasoning, different text.

A very, VERY noticeable parallel between the teaparty literal interpretation "to the word" of the constitution, and the far right evangelicals and their strict interpretation of the bible, "to the word".

Yep.

In both cases, it exhibits an astonishing level of ignorance. (Ignorance of the basics of American government in one case, and ignorance of the historical, cultural, literary, linguistic, etc. aspects of the collection of writings that comprise the Bible in the other.)
 
Last edited:


And one could easily change the punctuation marks on the quote from this:

"The First Amendment does?" O'Donnell asked. "Let me just clarify: You're telling me that the separation of church and state is found in the First Amendment?"

to this:

"The First Amendment does?" O'Donnell asked. "Let me just clarify: You're telling me that 'the separation of church and state' is found in the First Amendment?"

Even so, it's a minor point. It really doesn't matter whether or not that specific phrase appears in the text of the Constitution. This isn't a case of legal "magic words" but rather a long-standing and well substantiated principle that does indeed arise from the First Amendment.
 
That is generally it. They don't recognize the legitimacy of any constitutional caselaw that fails to fit within their concept of What The Constitution Really Says. Plus, the Constitution doesn't explicitly say the Court should have the last word as to what the constitution says or doesn't say, so they tend to have a problem with the whole institution of judicial review.

This generally matches the Libertarian nuttard view as well.
 
...
So, even if she'd made her challenge more clearly, I would point out that the phrase "wall of separation between the church and the state" can be seen as coming from the legislative history of the First Amendment. Also, the Constitution spelled out a separation of powers that let the judiciary interpret laws (including the Constitution), and there's a boatload of court cases that recognize the separation of church and state (and even use those words).
...


The phrase itself originates in a letter sent by President Thomas Jefferson to the Danbury Baptist Association in 1802.

Of course we had to wait until 1865 for the 14th amendment to extend that wall to separation to state governments (and local, etc). It seems that the Danbury Baptists were unhappy that
 
I think there is a bigger issue that has been missed.

Video timecode 2:00 to 2:25.

O'Donnell: Local school boards have the right to give equal time to the theory of evolution and Intelligent Design. The Supreme Court always said that it was up to local communities.

No. The SCOTUS ruling in Edwards v. Aguillard (1987) ruling barred the teaching of creation science in public schools.
 
The phrase itself originates in a letter sent by President Thomas Jefferson to the Danbury Baptist Association in 1802.

Of course we had to wait until 1865 for the 14th amendment to extend that wall to separation to state governments (and local, etc). It seems that the Danbury Baptists were unhappy that

Yes, I know. It was meant to reassure them that the wall was to protect them from government intrusion.

And, as I mentioned, the phrase has been cited in a great many court cases. It really is a well-established legal principle arising from the First Amendment and not a matter of "magic words".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom