Off topic : Quick question, what if a Town knowing that the WBC would come to picket, quickly simply organize preventively a picketing of their own "picket for pretty flower" while spreading the word, or whatever nonsensical, and systematically blocked WBC picket... Would that be considered legally a hindering of their (WBC's) 1st amendment right ?
Even without looking, I doubt there is a Supreme Court case directly on point. If I had to make a well-educated guess by combining a few other precedents, I'd say "yes". I say that with a very high level of confidence.
Targeting a specific point of view as your scenario suggests, is damn near verboten. Only in extreme cases can the state attempt to enact measures that are not "viewpoint neutral". See
Texas v. Johnson (AKA hippy burns flag) for a particularly interesting example in a long line of cases. State acts of this nature are
presumed unconstitutional in court. To rebut that presumption, the state has to meet the most difficult standard of judicial review,
strict scrutiny. That is virtually unattainable given the current members of the SCOTUS.
The only serious wrinkles in your hypo are:
- what you mean by "blocked"
- whether or not the flower protest is "state action".
For the purposes of wrinkle number one, I'm assuming a worst case scenario: Phelps and the WBC completely denied the abillity to protest. If the WBC is completely censored by a state act, Phelps will always win. Considering the string of legal victories he has had (including one in the US Supreme Court), I am bewildered why towns keep trying to block him. On the other hand, a private group censoring Phelps cannot violate the 1st Amendment because the Constitution applies only to the government. A private group could in theory be liable for criminal or civil wrongdoing, though.
This brings me to the second wrinkle. The state has its own right to speech. Agencies are constitutionally allowed to draft official POVs on the tax payer dime. The state can even
fund or defund a group based solely on the content of their speech. For example, a city could
probably fund a private group planning to counter-protest the WBC without breaking any rules. (Provided they don't get in criminal or civil trouble, mentioned above.) Neither government speech of the funding of speech qualfies as a "state act" in and of itself.
The problem arises when the state goes beyond its taxing and spending power and starts recruiting citizens to act as de facto government employees. If the state gets
too involved in the protest, it could become a "state act" and any state act that censors a specific opinion is presumptively unconstitutional. Your scenario seems to suggest heavy government supervision so I believe your small town dictator would be in trouble. Where to draw the line between "state act" and "government speech" is an interesting discussion but I've blabbed enough for now.