Child bride beaten in Yemen

If she is having sex outside of marriage. Then she is immoral and No different than a hooker. Except she is giving it away for free.

I don't even know where to start on how wrong this statement is. There are multiple avenues to reveal exactly how stupid this is.

I mean maybe we could start with the idea that sex is something that men want and women give.

Maybe we could start with the concept of marriage, and whether immorality as a concept can mean anything when a piece of paper turns an immoral act moral.

Maybe we should start with the idea that people should only have a relationship with one person in their entire life, no matter how much they or their partner change.

No, no, I give up. So. Much. Failure.
 
If she is having sex outside of marriage. Then she is immoral
Why?

and No different than a hooker. Except she is giving it away for free.
What makes you think she, or any woman for that matter, is "giving it away"? Are you suggesting that they don't *want* to have sex?

Hookers sell their bodies in exchange for money, usually out of desperation, not for the enjoyment of sex. But you know that, don't you? You're just trolling.
 
They don't prostitute out of desperation. They could go out and get a job. McDonalds is always hiring people.
OK, now this is definitely an answer suggesting you are a forum troll. Even you could not really be that stupid.

See post # 108 and remind yourself about that serious tunnel vision your stupid comment reflected.
 
Last edited:
OK, now this is definitely an answer suggesting you are a forum troll. Even you could not really be that stupid.
Please explain what is so stupid about they could get a real job?

They spend hours applying their trade.

Couldn't they use those same hours working a legitimate job.

Thousands of people work at McDonalds.

Are they somehow above other people who work and don't prostitute?
 
I wonder what percentage of Johns are actually Muslim men.

Since they are so sexually repressed, that wouldn't be far fetched to believe alot of them "indulge" in secret.
 
Last edited:
I did explain, in post #108.
Your fantasy explanation of why these women have to sell their bodies is silly.

Any woman could get out of the hooker trade and get a legitimate job at any fast food place. There is no previous training needed and you don't have to have any advanced education.
 
Clearly you didn't look at post #108, Sunni. You are just sticking your foot further into your mouth.
 
Clearly you didn't look at post #108, Sunni. You are just sticking your foot further into your mouth.
Please enlighten me about post #108 that you keep refering to. As I clearly don't see what your point is that you are trying to make. Thank You.
 
Many times what are cultural or traditional norms in a mainly Muslim country are attributed to Islam.

Female circumcism is a case in point. It is a tribal custom mainly found in Africia and predates Islam by thousands of years. It is practiced by Christian, Pagan, and Muslim African tribes.

To be clear, female curcumcision in NOT Islamic and is Not found in the Quran or any other Islamic texts. And is forbidden by the religion.

But Islamaphobes and other anti Muslim sources have made it seem like it is a standard Muslim practice.
A fair point and an Islamic scholar on the programme said emphatically that it is not allowed. The cleric in the turban begged to differ but then he was also big on execution of homosexuals and other lunatic ideas - I suspect he was just not a very nice person.
It certainly does not seem to be formally "forbidden". Is there a source supporting this statement? It is definitely the subject of much controversy.
There is Not one single verse in the Quran or in the Sunnah of the Prophet to support the practice.

It is a primitive custom in use long before Islam. Mainly done in Somalia, Sudan, and parts of Egypt.

No reputable Islamic Cleric condoneds or supports the ritual.

Uneducated Islamophobes in the West use it to denigrate Islam and Muslims.

I suppose the clerics over at al-Azhar who certified 'Umdat al-Salik (mainly Shafi'i school positions; differing positions pointed out) are islamophobes trying to denigrate Islam and Muslims. You know, the stuff they live by and preach as well as teach.

[quote='Umdat al-Salik, Purification, Ablution (Wudu), e4.0 THE BODY]
e4.3 Circumcision is obligatory (O: for both men and women. For men it consists of removing the prepuce from the penis, and for women, removing the prepuce (Ar. bazr) of the clitoris (n: not the clitoris itself, as some mistakenly assert). (A: Hanbalis hold that circumcision of women is not obligatory but sunna, while Hanafhis consider it a mere courtesy to the husband.)[/quote]
[quote='Umdat al-Salik, w52.1(368) Notes and Appendices - Ibn Hajar Haytami's List of Enormities](368) not getting circumcised, even after having reached puberty;[/quote]
 
Last edited:
I don't know exactly why, but most religious fundies have an inherited fear of women.

There are some parts of Arab history that survived through Islamic recordings which indicate a kind of matriarchy, ranging from Muhammad's first wive being a successful business woman on her own choosing her husbands herself as well as another woman who led a battle against Muslims. Can't remember the name of the latter though.
 
I suppose the clerics over at al-Azhar who certified 'Umdat al-Salik (mainly Shafi'i school positions; differing positions pointed out) are islamophobes trying to denigrate Islam and Muslims. You know, the stuff they live by and preach as well as teach.
Not quite sure what you point is?

Yes there are people like this Umdat fellow who believe in female circumcision. So what?

It is NOT found in the Quran nor taught by the Prophet.

As I have said before it is a traditional pre-Islamic custom mainly in Sudan, Somalia, and parts of Egypt. That is 3 Islamic countries out of about 70.


There are Churches in Tennessee that believe and practice that a Christian must handle poison snakes to be rightious. Should ALL of Christianity be judged by this small cult of people?


Should ALL Muslims be judged by a minority of people who practice this rite?
 
Not quite sure what you point is?

I would express this, but I fear I might violate the MA.

Yes there are people like this Umdat fellow who believe in female circumcision. So what?

amazon.com said:
Book Description
The new edition of the in-depth manual of Islamic law based on the Shafi'i school of thought, with a detalied index and commentary on specific rulings. 1,200 pages in an exceptional binding with Arabic and facing English text in two column format with occasional diagrams. 'Umdat al-Salik wa 'Uddat al-Nasik (Reliance of the Traveller and tools of the Worshipper) is a classic manual of fiqh. It represents the fiqh rulings according to the Shafi'I school of jurisprudence. The appendices form an integral part of the book and present original texts and translations from classic works by prominent scholars such as al-Ghazali, Ibn Qudamah, al-Nawawi, al-Qurturbi, al-Dhahabi, Ibn Hajar and other, on topics of Islamic law, faith, spirituality, Qur'anic exegesis and Hadith sciences. It has also biographical notes about every person mentioned (391 biographies) , bibliography of each work cited (136 works), and a detailed subject index (95 pages). Of the 136 works drawn upon in its commentary and appendices, 134 are in the original Arabic. The sections and paragraphs have been numbered to facilitate cross-reference.

That is 'Umdat al-Salik.

It is NOT found in the Quran nor taught by the Prophet.

Don't tell me, tell all the Shafi'i, Hanafi, Hanbali and Maliki who seem to 'make up' this stuff. For starters. Then move on to Shias if you want, since you already got like what, 90% of all Muslims covered it might not be necessary, right?

As I have said before it is a traditional pre-Islamic custom mainly in Sudan, Somalia, and parts of Egypt. That is 3 Islamic countries out of about 70.

Your paedo-prophet didn't seem to have a problem with it. Or are those scholars all lying? I don't think you want to go there. But hey, I am fine with you not liking the practice.
Are you actually one of those 'I'll only take what's in the Quran' type of Muslims? What about the Sunnah then? Ahadith? Just throw it out the window?

There are Churches in Tennessee that believe and practice that a Christian must handle poison snakes to be rightious. Should ALL of Christianity be judged by this small cult of people?

No, Christianity should be judged by what had been taught and transmitted in consent. You know, like the stuff you find in 'Umdat al-Salik when it comes to Islam.

Should ALL Muslims be judged by a minority of people who practice this rite?

No, since I am aware there's also sane people who are 'Muslims'. You know, like those who don't want to kill people because of their (lack of) religion or sexuality or freedoms they would certainly not enjoy in a pretty retarded culture Islam promotes.
 
Last edited:
Please enlighten me about post #108 that you keep refering to. As I clearly don't see what your point is that you are trying to make. Thank You.
:dig: :footinmou

You really should look at the post before you keep digging your hole deeper. You are looking sillier and sillier with your, get a job at McDonald's, claims.
 
Once again, it is not found in the Quran nor taught by the Prophet.

The Shafi'i school of Islamic thought is the main school found in both Sudan and Somalia.

Female circumcision is practiced by all Islamic women in both of those countries.

I believe that if the people in those countries want to practice female circumcision. That is their right and their business.



I only knew 'Umdat al-Salik by it's English name: "Reliance of the Traveller and tools of the Worshipper".
 
There's a big difference. They chose their professions. And they actually do have equal rights. You post a big lie claiming women are equal in Muslims societies.

I am pleased and completely unashamed to have had the privilege of growing up in a Western culture during the 'sexual revolution'. Sex is great fun. Only a selfish man thinks he has to have some woman who has not been with anyone else. And while I don't begrudge the choice of a woman to be a real "whore" if the woman so chooses to make money by those means, the vast majority of prostitutes in the world today are only prostitutes because their unequal status often leaves them with no education, extreme poverty, vulnerable to exploitation by men and with no options but to sell their body or starve.

I have an education and am not dependent on any man. I own my own home, have a successful business, raised a wonderful son who I am now putting through college. I live in a very nice house that is now paid for. My car is paid for. I don't need to worry about buying the best food in the grocery store. Clearly women are better off in my situation than one in the culture you claim is so 'equal'.

Women in hijabs 'need sunlight or risk illness'

Human Rights Watch - Women's Rights(Emphasis mine.)
O.K. here is post #108

What is the big deal about it? Seriously?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom