Child bride beaten in Yemen

Well, once again we see another Islamic country, practicing what appears to be pretty typical Islam, as its practiced around the world. Maybe it's not how Islam has evolved in America, but I believe that's more a function of America, and less a function of Islam.

And as usual, we see the 'Western' Muslim's excuses:

1) X is not only not a part of Islam, it's strictly forbidden (even if all the clerics promoting it point to passages in the Koran and recorded views of Mohammad to support it).

2) EVEN THOUGH X is condemned by Islam, it's obviously cultural bias to condemn a person who does this.

3) You can't claim your culture is superior, even though we frequently claim our culture is superior. And only one of us is raping and torturing people as 'cultural practice'.


Give me the 5% or so who honestly condemn it and the 80% or so who vocally support it instead of this namby-pamby middle who is making apologies for monsters.
 
Wow!! Who made you God, judge, and jury for the people of the world?

We did; as a rational, compassionate, individuals who know human suffering when we see it.

A policeman and a fireman have different roles to play in society. But yet they are equal.

Same with men and women the world over. It's just that in Islamic culture the lines are still drawn up as to what is acceptable and not acceptable.

Wrong. Gender is NOT a job description. We do not have any "roles to play in society" save for what WE decide, not by the command of your (or any other religion's) imaginary tyrant.

Civilized, freedom-loving cultures don't draw up lines of acceptability based on something as arbitrary as whether you have a penis or a vulva.

The West has let their young women become loose sluts and dress and act like blatant whores

Again, it's called FREEDOM... Deal with it!

While in Islamic society women are still raised pure and protected.

Yeah, as human chattle.
 
Last edited:
Aren't you?

You said yourself that it was against the law to rape an underaged child. Where's your indignation? The only thing you've done so far in this thread is criticize the West for being rightfully appalled.
The man was brought before a Yemeni court of law. Their decision has already been rendered and the case is closed. So I am not going to loose sleep over it.

The people on this forum used the incident to attack ALL of Islam and Muslims.

I was just defending some of the misinformed things said about the religion and it's people.
 
The man was brought before a Yemeni court of law. Their decision has already been rendered and the case is closed. So I am not going to loose sleep over it.

The people on this forum used the incident to attack ALL of Islam and Muslims.

I was just defending some of the misinformed things said about the religion and it's people.

That's the thing, the "husband" wasn't prosecuted, he was compensated.

You said yourself it is illegal to rape a child in Islam. Where's your indignation at the illogical ruling? Shouldn't he be charged with rape and severely punished?

Don't you have any self-criticism left or do you follow your religion's ruling whatever it says? Can't you see your own contradiction here?
 
Wow!! Who made you God, judge, and jury for the people of the world?

A policeman and a fireman have different roles to play in society. But yet they are equal.

Same with men and women the world over. It's just that in Islamic culture the lines are still drawn up as to what is acceptable and not acceptable.

The West has let their young women become loose sluts and dress and act like blatant whores

While in Islamic society women are still raised pure and protected.

Oh, surely you have not bought into that one too. As Dawkins said, "They're not my women." That is just over the top as far as I'm concerned.
 
Civilized, freedom-loving cultures don't draw up lines of acceptability based on something as arbitrary as whether you have a penis or a vulva
Really? There is the PGA and the WPGA.

And the MBA and the WMBA

Have you ever seen a real life woman who was a Navy Seal? Green Beret? Ranger?

(the slut Demi Moore doesn't count, it was just a movie!)
 
That's the thing, the "husband" wasn't prosecuted, he was compensated.

You said yourself it is illegal to rape a child in Islam. Where's your indignation at the illogical ruling? Shouldn't he be charged with rape and severely punished?

Don't you have any self-criticism left or do you follow your religion's ruling whatever it says? Can't you see your own contradiction here?
Her in America sometimes ultra liberal judges let pedophiles off with just probation or a slap on the wrist. I have seen it in the news several times.

The judge made the decision and it can't be reversed. What can you do?

Was the pedophile a Christian?
 
World opinion?

You mean Western opinion. Basically, America, Canada, and Europe.

The other 2/3rds of the world. Asia, South America, Africia, Middle East, China, Russia, India, etc.

Wish the West would shut up and mind their own business!![/QUOTE

Someday, hopefully, you will experience the kind of nightmare this brave little girl went through. Then we'll see the real you.
 
Her in America sometimes ultra liberal judges let pedophiles off with just probation or a slap on the wrist. I have seen it in the news several times.

The system has flaws, but they get registered as sex offenders and their rights are diminished as a result. They don't get compensated.

The judge made the decision and it can't be reversed. What can you do?

Protest.

Was the pedophile a Christian?

He was Muslim in this case.
 
I'm curious what others in the Islamic community in the US are saying about this. Is it possible that, as a Muslim, if one speaks out against the decision he is in danger of reprisals? I have noted in the past that veiled threats of violence were used by a certain poster when criticisms were leveled at his religion.
 
We did; as a rational, compassionate, individuals who know human suffering when we see it.



Wrong. Gender is NOT a job description. We do not have any "roles to play in society" save for what WE decide, not by the command of your (or any other religion's) imaginary tyrant.

Civilized, freedom-loving cultures don't draw up lines of acceptability based on something as arbitrary as whether you have a penis or a vulva.



Again, it's called FREEDOM... Deal with it!



Yeah, as human chattle.

Very good post.

Also- I like and respect loose sluts.
 
How was he punished?
The guy went to a Yemeni court and a verdict was given.

Justice was served whether you agree with the verdict or not.

I was not the girls or the guys lawyer. So I had no influence over the outcome.

This dialogue has gotten tedious and boring.

So I am going to call it a night.
 
The guy went to a Yemeni court and a verdict was given.

Justice was served whether you agree with the verdict or not.
So the definition of Justice is "Judge's verdict?"

I thought you believed in a higher morality than human morality. If you believe that Justice as a concept is defined by man's laws in a courtroom, then congratulations! You don't believe in a higher power or a higher ideal of Justice. So not only do you lack a belief in a personal God, you believe heavily in at least some of the central tenants of nihilism.

Eventually, therefore, you will throw of the trappings of a religion you do not believe in.
 
Really? There is the PGA and the WPGA.

And the MBA and the WMBA

As silly as that sort of segregation is, to compare it to the Muslism world's treatment of women is evidence of not only your disgusting misogyny, but your blatant stupidity.

Worst Tu Quoque ever!

Have you ever seen a real life woman who was a Navy Seal? Green Beret? Ranger?

Just because the U.S. Military is as sexist as you are does not make their moronic policies right. Women should be allowed to become SEALS, Green Beret, Rangers, or whatever so long as they can meet the physical qualifications.

Having a vagina shouldn't be one of them.

(the slut Demi Moore doesn't count, it was just a movie!)

Again, I find your Islamic notion of "respect" for women to be quite, quite, revealing.
 
Last edited:
So the definition of Justice is "Judge's verdict?"

I thought you believed in a higher morality than human morality. If you believe that Justice as a concept is defined by man's laws in a courtroom, then congratulations! You don't believe in a higher power or a higher ideal of Justice. So not only do you lack a belief in a personal God, you believe heavily in at least some of the central tenants of nihilism.

Eventually, therefore, you will throw of the trappings of a religion you do not believe in.
Are you really that lame??

It wasn't a stupid secular court like your kind believe in.

It was an Islamic Court governed by Sharia Law.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom