Charlie Black: Terrorist Attack on US would be a "Big Advantage" for John McCain

Puppycow

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
34,655
Location
Yokohama, Japan
Charlie Black: Terrorist Attack on US would be a "Big Advantage" for John McCain

John McCain's chief strategist, Charlie Black, thinks that a terrorist attack on US soil would a political boon for his candidate, as was the assasination of Benazir Bhutto:

The assassination of Benazir Bhutto in December was an "unfortunate event," says Black. "But his knowledge and ability to talk about it reemphasized that this is the guy who's ready to be Commander-in-Chief. And it helped us." As would, Black concedes with startling candor after we raise the issue, another terrorist attack on U.S. soil. "Certainly it would be a big advantage to him," says Black.
 
Charlie keeps bringing up controversy. I'd get rid of him.

I'm sorry, I meant have him resign to spend time with the family.
 
Something tells me Charlie's going to have a lot of time to spend with the family pretty soon.

Nov. 5 at the latest. ;)
 
In the "its true, but saying it out loud gets you in trouble" deparment. This guy was really dumb for doing that.
 
In the "its true, but saying it out loud gets you in trouble" deparment. This guy was really dumb for doing that.

I'm not entirely sure it's true, actually. Broadly speaking things that scare Americans on national security will play to McCain's advantage, but a terrorist attack would not only scare people, it would also have the effect of making the Bush national security policy look rather ineffective, and by extension, the McCain national security policy, and making Obama look better by comparison. (Depends on the size of the attack, I think.) A respectable opinion to hold, though.

But yes dumb, and the fact that his job for McCain is as a campaign advisor makes it worse. If he was just a policy advisor it would be one thing, but avoiding gaffes like this is kind of his job.
 
I actually feel sorry for the guy. He was asked a question. He answered it. If it was a legitimate question to be asked, it was a legitimate question to be answered. In that way it wasn't even like Hilary's Bobby Kennedy moment, which she brought on herself. I know it won't win any points, and a more adept speaker would have answered differently, but I just can't work up any moral outrage about a strategist who answers a question about how a hypothetical future event would impact a political campaign.

On a purely strategic side, I think he should have said, "The fact that we haven't had any attacks since September 11 ought to help John McCain, because it shows that the War on Terror is keeping them on the run." I think that's BS of course, but, it would have been a much better political answer. It's a bit sad that I think lying would have worked better than the truth.
 
Kind of like Hillary mentioning Bobby Kennedy's assasination.

I think Hillary was actually bringing up how the nomination process can go into June and using Kennedy as an example. I don't think her intent was to bring up the spectre of assasination. Unfortunately, it was worded poorly and the media decided to make a big deal out of it.
 
I'm not entirely sure it's true, actually. Broadly speaking things that scare Americans on national security will play to McCain's advantage, but a terrorist attack would not only scare people, it would also have the effect of making the Bush national security policy look rather ineffective, and by extension, the McCain national security policy, and making Obama look better by comparison. (Depends on the size of the attack, I think.) A respectable opinion to hold, though.

But yes dumb, and the fact that his job for McCain is as a campaign advisor makes it worse. If he was just a policy advisor it would be one thing, but avoiding gaffes like this is kind of his job.
that's an excellent point.
 
I'm not entirely sure it's true, actually. Broadly speaking things that scare Americans on national security will play to McCain's advantage, but a terrorist attack would not only scare people, it would also have the effect of making the Bush national security policy look rather ineffective, and by extension, the McCain national security policy, and making Obama look better by comparison. (Depends on the size of the attack, I think.) A respectable opinion to hold, though. ...


I tend to agree with this. It would call into question the wisdom of the current War on Terror (and by default, the Iraq war) and homeland security measures over the past 7 years. The longer there isn't a major/significant attack, the better those things tend to look as a whole for Bush/McCain and the Republicans. It's one of the strengths they have in current opinion polls on issues Americans are concerned about.
 
Ditto, I'm not sure its true. This would be an attack under the watch of a President whose terror agenda (which to me seems to be an agenda to KEEP us terrified!) McSame has endorsed. Could not be good for him.
 
Of course a terrorist attack would help the McCain campaign. I don't know where it is, but I saw a poll the other day on all the issues--health care, the economy, Iraq, you name it. The one area where McCain had a clear advantage on Obama was in handling terrorism.

The problem, for McCain, is that fighting terrorism has declined in importance as an issue. If it were to become significant again, McCain would move up sharply in the polls. There's no doubt about that in my mind.

That said, it's not exactly something to root for.
 
Of course a terrorist attack would help the McCain campaign. I don't know where it is, but I saw a poll the other day on all the issues--health care, the economy, Iraq, you name it. The one area where McCain had a clear advantage on Obama was in handling terrorism.

The problem, for McCain, is that fighting terrorism has declined in importance as an issue. If it were to become significant again, McCain would move up sharply in the polls. There's no doubt about that in my mind.

That said, it's not exactly something to root for.


IMO, it would only help if people didn't see it as a failure of Republican policies and initiatives over the past 7 years. While it's impossible to prevent terrorist attacks completely, if the public in general views the current policies and initiatives as a failure that allowed such an attack to occur again, then McCain is going to be at least a victim of guilt by association. If he can tie it to something the Democrats didn't allow to occur (certain opposition to legislation that if passed might have made a difference, etc.), then it could help McCain. But the short time span between such an event and the election may hinder even that from occurring.
 
Didn't someone say that the definition of a "gaffe" is speaking what we all know is the truth, at an inconvenient time to do so...or something like that.

TAM:)
 
Well, I admit that such an attack would work in McCain's favor in the places where xenophobia and FUD work well.

I also suspect that if I were one of those vile, murderous whackjobs who murder innocent people in the name of religion, I'd want something as close as possible to Bush for as long as possible, just to continue doing the job, now well started, and firmly established, of turning the USA into a second-world country.

I HOPE nothing of the sort happens!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom