Carly's Plan to Stump a Democrat

Secretaries of State... What did Powell accomplish? Rice?

Senators... What has Rubio accomplished? Graham? Cruz? Paul?

The point being, it's a trick question aimed at non critical thinkers.
 
Can we wait until the first scheduled debate before complaining that she not letting people see her debating ability? October 13, 2015. Las Vegas.

Well, she was already the presumptive nominee, before she had even given a press conference, let alone had a debate. This was presumably based on her accomplishments rather than her ability to articulate policy (which I have not heard her do coherently since 2008 frankly).

I'm no Hillary lover, but you are sounding a bit Hillary Derangement Syndrome in this post.

I am not a Hillary hater actually. I think she's generally smart and tough, although I think she may be in the midst of a rapid cognitive decline, either due to age or her head injury. I just also happen to believe that her reputation for being accomplished is mostly built on nothing. It's kind of like how Kim Kardashian is famous for being famous. Everybody thinks she's famous, so then she gets publicity which makes her famous. Everybody thinks Hillary's accomplished, so she gets elected Senator or appointed as Secretary of State or gets paid to make speeches for $200,000, and then she lists those things as accomplishments. It's a form of bootstrapping if you will.

ETA
post #7, if you have a moment.

Well Trump is certainly accomplished. He's developed a lot of commercial real estate, and he's gotten involved in dozens of ventures, mostly involving the branding of his name. He also produced and hosted a very successful reality TV series.

Scott Walker managed to pass a public union-busting bill in the most union-friendly state in the country.

Chris Christie prosecuted terrorists and later successfully fought unions, corruption and spending as governor in a very blue state.

Ben Carson of course was a trailblazing neurosurgeon.

Rand Paul was an ophthalmologist, just like Bashar al Assad.

Marco Rubio authored a book with 100 ideas for Florida's future, and he ultimately worked to pass a substantial number of them as Speaker of the House in Florida.

I can't think of much for Jeb Bush. He speaks Spanish fluently, so that's something.

Ted Cruz was apparently a brilliant lawyer. Some of his Harvard Law professors have said he was one of the smartest students they had ever seen.

John Kasich claimed to have done a lot of stuff while in the House and as Governor of Ohio. I'm not interested enough in trying to confirm it.

Mike Huckabee has been a talk show host and political commentator for some time.

Carly Fiorina engineered HP's takeover of Compaq, which involved a bruising battle with the Board of Directors. She thinks it was a good idea; some people don't. I am sort of agnostic on the issue, but I have never seen a convincing argument that it was a bad thing.
 
Last edited:
http://www.politico.com/magazine/st...y-clintons-greatest-accomplishment-213157?o=1 has a long list.

Of particular note is the statement, attributed to a prominent executive, saying that Hillary has devoted her life to public service and is an inspiration for many women. Oh, wait, it was Fiorina that said that. :-)

Here's the interview where Fiorina "praised" Hillary Clinton (it's at the end of the video):

Despite her sharp criticisms, even Fiorina couldn’t deny the upside of Clinton’s so-called woman card: “Of course Hillary Clinton has opened doors for women and of course she is a highly intelligent, hardworking woman who has dedicated her life to public service,” Fiorina said. “She has been an example and an inspiration for many woman and just the fact that she’s running for president is an inspiration to many women.”

...

Predictably, there was a caveat to Fiorina’s kind remarks: “But if we’re going to have a real conversation about tapping the potential of men and women, then we also have to be able to talk about track record, accomplishment, and policy, and that’s the ground upon which this debate needs to be had.”

The comment is completely consistent and fair.
 
Re "union busting" - I'm horrified you think pooping on the American workforce and reducing their capacity to avoid getting pooped on by corporate greed is an accomplishment.
 
Carly Fiorina engineered HP's takeover of Compaq, which involved a bruising battle with the Board of Directors. She thinks it was a good idea; some people don't. I am sort of agnostic on the issue, but I have never seen a convincing argument that it was a bad thing.
I have the dubious honor of having worked at HP during the time period in question. It was total corporate paralysis for two full years. NOTHING got done. The merged companies were too alike; every product had a clone competitor on the other side, every employee had an unknown number of dopplegangers duplicating their function precisely. Everyone being redundant meant everyone's job was suddenly on the chopping block, no matter how well they'd performed before.

Generally speaking, people reacted to that in the usual ways: trying to make themselves appear better by putting their subordinates on counterproductive death marches, or by gaming the politics to make themselves indispensable (I've got a good beer story about that), or checking out and simply coasting on a bare minimum of work until the axe got around to them and fell one way or the other. In any case, no one was at all interested in actual productivity.

As a result, not only did HP not profit from Compaq's market share, they couldn't even stay relevant in their own segments of the market during the time, and ended up having to cut more divisions just to stay afloat. It was a complete cock-up from beginning to end, and is directly responsible for why Carly's campaign contributions from the tech sector are close to nil.
 
Carly is perhaps a little light in the accomplishment department too. But I would vote for her because she's articulate and comes across as tough and decisive, and she says things I agree with. As I've said many times with respect to arguments here, the arguments speak for themselves, which means that you judge what you see not the process by which it came into existence. In Carly's case, I don't care about her tenure at HP or whatnot. I see her debate and speak and I like what I see.
Why you would vote for Carly is off topic. :cool:


In Hillary's case, she is trying to win the Democratic nomination without letting people see the current status of her debating and speaking ability.
You do know Clinton doesn't set the debate schedule, right? And that the election is more than a year away, Democratic Party debates are scheduled, as will be debates between the primary winners?


Her claim to the throne is not based on what she is capable of right now, but what she has achieved (which presumably is a good indicator of what she is capable of right now). I would like to know what she is achieved that is so amazing that we don't need to hear her debate in order to judge her fitness for office.
So you think a resume that includes lawyer, Senator and Secretary of State isn't worth much?
 
I have the dubious honor of having worked at HP during the time period in question. It was total corporate paralysis for two full years. NOTHING got done. The merged companies were too alike; every product had a clone competitor on the other side, every employee had an unknown number of dopplegangers duplicating their function precisely. Everyone being redundant meant everyone's job was suddenly on the chopping block, no matter how well they'd performed before.

Generally speaking, people reacted to that in the usual ways: trying to make themselves appear better by putting their subordinates on counterproductive death marches, or by gaming the politics to make themselves indispensable (I've got a good beer story about that), or checking out and simply coasting on a bare minimum of work until the axe got around to them and fell one way or the other. In any case, no one was at all interested in actual productivity.

As a result, not only did HP not profit from Compaq's market share, they couldn't even stay relevant in their own segments of the market during the time, and ended up having to cut more divisions just to stay afloat. It was a complete cock-up from beginning to end, and is directly responsible for why Carly's campaign contributions from the tech sector are close to nil.

Merging two companies which are almost identical actually can make a lot of sense, right? In fact, that's the theory behind single payer health care. You get rid of redundancy and overhead. Of course, you sacrifice competition when you allow similar companies to merge, but that's a price imposed on consumers, not the companies themselves.

Mergers and acquisitions always cause tremendous disruption. I don't doubt that you're accurately recounting your experience at HP, but, unless you were in a senior management position, you were only seeing a tiny piece of the picture. I don't deny that the acquisition turned into a ***************, but that could easily have had to do with opposition by the members of the Board (scions of the founders in particular) who didn't have the shareholders' best interests at heart.

As for HP's stock performance after the merger, I'm a big believer in lagged effects. The performance was absolute amazing starting the day Carly was forced out. Over the next 3 years, the stock was up 150%, far outperforming its peers. Almost any commentator you see on TV will attribute that performance to her successor. Although the market does tend to incorporate future expectations into the current stock price, I just don't think things happen that fast, especially at such a huge company.

Actually, looking back I see that the merger was announced on Sep 3, 2001, which was Labor Day. The business day before - Aug 31, 2001, HP stock closed at 23.21, and the business day after - Sep 4, 2001 - HP stock closed at 18.87. Of course, a lot of that decline was due to traders on Wall Street putting on the merger arbitrage (shorting HP and buying CPQ). Shortly after that, of course, the September 11 attack happened, which caused further decline in the markets and hurt the economy. The stock was around 20 when Carly left less than 3.5 years later, and then it hit 51.68 at the peak of the market prior to the global financial crisis - Oct 31, 2007. Today it is trading at 27.

I don't know. I'm inclined to think the merger was a good idea, but it took a while for the value to be recognized. I also think that maybe her successors didn't do such a great job.
 
<snip>

You do know Clinton doesn't set the debate schedule, right? And that the election is more than a year away, Democratic Party debates are scheduled, as will be debates between the primary winners?

Of course she had input into the debate schedule. She's trying to have as few debates as possible, as late as possible, so that nobody else can pick up momentum and funding and challenge her. If it wasn't for the email scandal eroding her aura of inevitability, nobody would even watch the debates. They might have even been canceled.

So you think a resume that includes lawyer, Senator and Secretary of State isn't worth much?

There are hundreds of thousands of lawyers in the country. It's hardly an accomplishment to be one. To be a good one is an accomplishment, but there is no evidence that she was good. As for Senator, she was elected based on the fact that she was a former President's wife. As Senator, she did very little. Two of her Senatorial accomplishments that have been highlighted are helping farmers in New York and helping getting money for 9/11 first responders who were supposedly sickened by the dust (which is mostly woo). Underwhelming to say the least, as are the other things mentioned.

Now, let's see what she did as Secretary of State. Negotiated the New START treaty with Russia over nuclear weapons. Whatever. I never even heard of that before. Negotiated a ceasefire between Hamas and Israel. Well, I remember that being annoyingly bad for Israel, but I suppose fans of Hamas considered twisting Israel's arm an accomplishment. Mustering support for additional sanctions against Iran. Well, maybe she did. I don't know exactly what she did or how. Perhaps she did a good job; perhaps she didn't. Iran's provocative behavior sure had a lot to do with the success of getting additional sanctions in place. As with Carly's merger between HP and CPQ, we just don't know if it was a good accomplishment or a bad one.

As with any accomplishments, you have to grade them against opportunities. For example, if somebody were President for 6.5 years, and all they had to show for it was a poorly implemented, half-baked health care law and a very weak and controversial "treaty" with Iran, I'd say that was a failed tenure. I certainly couldn't have accomplished that over the last 6.5 years myself, but I didn't really have the opportunity. So these things are all relative and should be judged on a curve.
 
Any and everything a republican candidate does is a worthy accomplishment -- talk show host (guffaw), wrote a book (guffaw), ophthalmologist (guffaw).

But nothing that Clinton has done merits as an accomplishment.

Sunmaster, to say that your bias is showing is a grand understatement. Said bias has been shaped into a flag and raised up an impressively tall pole.
 
Of course she had input into the debate schedule. She's trying to have as few debates as possible, as late as possible, so that nobody else can pick up momentum and funding and challenge her. If it wasn't for the email scandal eroding her aura of inevitability, nobody would even watch the debates. They might have even been canceled.

... remainder snipped due to relevance and tedium ...

My guess is that you have not heard this particular fact before 'sunmaster14', so I will attempt to explain it to you ...

Everyone who is participating in an important debate national debate will try to arrange the debate so that it is most advantageous for his or herself.

And if you want to know why everyone does this, then it is because everyone would like to be known as the winner of the debate after it is over.
 
You should start a thread. It's off-topic here. I am not interested in abortion in the slightest, and it's mostly irrelevant as far as the executive branch of the federal government is concerned.

Hmmmm not really. You have held up a comment from iCarly where she (and you) apparently cannot find information on the achievements of Hillary Clinton.

The Ginger one has quite rightly pointed out that iCarly's opinions aren't worth an awful lot if she is also describing imaginary videos.

It aint looking good so far...
 
Merging two companies which are almost identical actually can make a lot of sense, right? In fact, that's the theory behind single payer health care. You get rid of redundancy and overhead. Of course, you sacrifice competition when you allow similar companies to merge, but that's a price imposed on consumers, not the companies themselves.

Mergers and acquisitions always cause tremendous disruption. I don't doubt that you're accurately recounting your experience at HP, but, unless you were in a senior management position, you were only seeing a tiny piece of the picture. I don't deny that the acquisition turned into a ***************, but that could easily have had to do with opposition by the members of the Board (scions of the founders in particular) who didn't have the shareholders' best interests at heart.

As for HP's stock performance after the merger, I'm a big believer in lagged effects. The performance was absolute amazing starting the day Carly was forced out. Over the next 3 years, the stock was up 150%, far outperforming its peers. Almost any commentator you see on TV will attribute that performance to her successor. Although the market does tend to incorporate future expectations into the current stock price, I just don't think things happen that fast, especially at such a huge company.

Actually, looking back I see that the merger was announced on Sep 3, 2001, which was Labor Day. The business day before - Aug 31, 2001, HP stock closed at 23.21, and the business day after - Sep 4, 2001 - HP stock closed at 18.87. Of course, a lot of that decline was due to traders on Wall Street putting on the merger arbitrage (shorting HP and buying CPQ). Shortly after that, of course, the September 11 attack happened, which caused further decline in the markets and hurt the economy. The stock was around 20 when Carly left less than 3.5 years later, and then it hit 51.68 at the peak of the market prior to the global financial crisis - Oct 31, 2007. Today it is trading at 27.

I don't know. I'm inclined to think the merger was a good idea, but it took a while for the value to be recognized. I also think that maybe her successors didn't do such a great job.
You say things like "I've never seen a convincing argument," but if (admittedly anecdotal) personal experience and the company's stock performance and the opinions of experts who all said and still say it was a bad idea don't convince you, I wonder what, if anything, you would consider convincing? Stop and give it a nice long think.
 
You say things like "I've never seen a convincing argument," but if (admittedly anecdotal) personal experience and the company's stock performance and the opinions of experts who all said and still say it was a bad idea don't convince you, I wonder what, if anything, you would consider convincing? Stop and give it a nice long think.

Well, a detailed financial analysis of the synergies of the merger and the impact on HP's strategic position in the market. This article makes it seem like many of the people who thought it was a bad idea at the time came around to think that it was actually a good idea. And I showed in my previous post that the company's stock performance supports Carly's claim that the merger was a good idea. Perhaps you didn't follow that bit.
 
Hmmmm not really. You have held up a comment from iCarly where she (and you) apparently cannot find information on the achievements of Hillary Clinton.

The Ginger one has quite rightly pointed out that iCarly's opinions aren't worth an awful lot if she is also describing imaginary videos.

It aint looking good so far...

Once again I have to point out that the question is independent of Carly. She brought the subject up, but I have started a thread to answer the question because I'm interested in discussing Hillary's alleged accomplishments to see whether they're really feathers in her cap or, upon closer inspection, horns on her head.

Not surprisingly, we're at post 38 or so in the thread, and nobody but I have identified a single, concrete accomplishment of Hillary's. I've been given a couple of links to websites that purport to list some of her accomplishments, but no specific accomplishments have been provided here for discussion.
 
And I showed in my previous post that the company's stock performance supports Carly's claim that the merger was a good idea. Perhaps you didn't follow that bit.
No, you showed that the stock tanked from the day it was announced and didn't recover until they fired her three years later. That says "it was a bad, bad, terrible idea and everyone knew it" to me, but instead you argued that it was really doing better all along, it just took a while to be reflected in the price. It's just a huge coincidence that happened on the very day she was sacked.

By that logic George W. Bush should have received Obama's Nobel Peace Prize, and beating my head against the wall has significant health benefits.
 
No, you showed that the stock tanked from the day it was announced and didn't recover until they fired her three years later. That says "it was a bad, bad, terrible idea and everyone knew it" to me, but instead you argued that it was really doing better all along, it just took a while to be reflected in the price. It's just a huge coincidence that happened on the very day she was sacked.

You do realize of course that the merger was not unwound when Carly was fired, right?

Also, there was that little shock to the economy (which was already in a recession) that happened 8 days after the merger announcement. But maybe she should have seen that coming.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom