Aepervius
Non credunt, semper verificare
Sure, I assume the conjecturer really meant same time and same place. Of course, we have to define "same time" and "same place" first. Let's say that "same time" means within a 4 hour period, which is about 1/4th of the time the US is "awake" enough to experience a mass shooting (I assume it's harder to shoot a bunch of people when they're asleep in their beds). "Same place" is a bit tougher. There are 381 MSAs in the US, the smallest of which is 55,000 people. Certainly if two mass shootings both happened in that smallest MSA - Carson City, NV - we would say that they happened in the same place. We might even be able to go twice as big and still say that. So let's assume that "same place" means both shootings happening within the same area in which 100,000 people reside. This would mean that, for example, the NY/NJ/Philly MSA would have 200 different areas. This kind of makes sense. I don't think anybody would say that a mass shooting in Manhattan happened in the same place as a mass shooting in Trenton, NJ.
According to the Census Bureau, about 83% of the US population lived in MSAs in 2003. I'll assume that the percentage stayed constant. That gives a total of 83% x 320 million people living in MSAs, or 265.6 million. There is approximately 1 mass shooting per day in the US, which comes to 1/4 for each 4 hour "same time" time slot for the whole US, which is 1/4 x 100,000/265,600,000 = 9.4 x 10^(-5) for any given time slot and area. To have two independent mass shootings in a particular time slot and area, would require squaring that, so the probability would be about 1 in 100 million (i.e. 8.86 x 10^(-9)). There are 4 time slots per day x 365 days per year x 265,600,000/100,000 areas = 3,877,760 time slot - areas in the country per year, so that gives us roughly (not precisely because I'm ignoring the possibility of more than one time-slot area experiencing a double mass shooting in a given year) 3,877,760 * 8.86 x 10^(-9) = 3.44% chance per year.
Hat off. In a way this is the most informative psot of the thread if the calculation are correct.