California shooting

The left really is going full Ostrich on ISIS. Just ignore and minimize the problem and it will go a way. Ain't going to sell,at least in the US.

Ostrich? Hardly. But we'd like to fix the underlying problems in a way that actually resolves them, and doesn't cost us another Trillion dollars (1,000,000 Million for those of you still using the old British definition of Trillion.)

And it would be good if it didn't cause more Americans to die horribly in foreign places or worse, coming home maimed and finding that we have broken our promise to take care of them.
 
I thought this was a pretty tasteless article for the New York Daily News.

Looked pretty bang on to me. The guy posting the "death to all muslims" schtick is as nuts as the shooters.

Just somewhat less violent.
 
How so?

We've dropped thousands of bombs on these idiots. The US has just come back from a costly and almost comically useless war. It wasn't that long ago that the country was fed up with the war and demanded the troops come home.

Such short attention spans here.

What makes you think they're idiots?
 
Yes, that is their strategy. Stir up hate and reaction. Global war with Muslims. Bring on the end times.

Maybe their primary strategy is to associate a price-tag of random, mass brutality on the civilian populations of countries supporting attacks on ISIS positions in order to undermine popular support for those actions. Given time and more consistent application, it might turn out to be effective.
 
Or maybe they slaughter innocent, defenseless people for a political reason, and religion is just a rallying cry.
Maybe if you are in Syria and you hope to establish a new country you are the dictator of. But if you are shooting up your workplace for the benefit of someone one else, you are likely a religiously motivated idiot.
 
Nicholas Thalasinos and Sayed Farook argued over the inherent violence of Islam. Farook kills Thalasinos and 13 others.

Not sure how to score that.

Especially if the reports that Farook shouted "Islam is a religion of peace" during the killings is true.
 
Nicholas Thalasinos and Sayed Farook argued over the inherent violence of Islam. Farook kills Thalasinos and 13 others.

Not sure how to score that.

Especially if the reports that Farook shouted "Islam is a religion of peace" during the killings is true.

I'd say that Thalasinos won the argument, but it was something of a Pyrrhic victory.
 
Maybe if you are in Syria and you hope to establish a new country you are the dictator of. But if you are shooting up your workplace for the benefit of someone one else, you are likely a religiously motivated idiot.

Maybe religion is used to infuse militant/political movements with binding passion. And maybe those participating in these terrorist campaigns, whether as part of the mother ship or freelance, aren't necessarily "idiots". Not all scumbags are morons.
 
Nicholas Thalasinos and Sayed Farook argued over the inherent violence of Islam. Farook kills Thalasinos and 13 others.

Not sure how to score that.

Especially if the reports that Farook shouted "Islam is a religion of peace" during the killings is true.
You don't know that was the argument, do you? Maybe that's what Thal's wife said or it was some reporter's version. Maybe Thal argued the Palestinians were terrorists that left Israel no choice to oppress them.

There are many ways to frame these issues.
 
You don't know that was the argument, do you? Maybe that's what Thal's wife said or it was some reporter's version. Maybe Thal argued the Palestinians were terrorists that left Israel no choice to oppress them.

There are many ways to frame these issues.

What difference would either argument make to the decision by these two POS to slaughter innocent people with no means of defense? I could be missing your point.
 
What difference would either argument make to the decision by these two POS to slaughter innocent people with no means of defense? I could be missing your point.

Or you are moving goalposts in the discussion. Where did I suggest the difference mattered?

It was said these people were religious morons, then it was suggested it was political not religious and I merely said I didn't see any political benefit to these two.
 
Or you are moving goalposts in the discussion. Where did I suggest the difference mattered?

It was said these people were religious morons, then it was suggested it was political not religious and I merely said I didn't see any political benefit to these two.

What I suggested is that religion can be mixed with politics in order to add cohesion and self righteous passion to the cause. And just because you can't see any political benefit doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I think it very well might.
 
Last edited:
Maybe religion is used to infuse militant/political movements with binding passion. And maybe those participating in these terrorist campaigns, whether as part of the mother ship or freelance, aren't necessarily "idiots". Not all scumbags are morons.

And Religious and Political fantantcism are not exclusive.
 
Maybe their primary strategy is to associate a price-tag of random, mass brutality on the civilian populations of countries supporting attacks on ISIS positions in order to undermine popular support for those actions. Given time and more consistent application, it might turn out to be effective.

It worked in Spain about a decade ago.
But in France it seems to have had the opposite effect. Same, I think, in the US.
Not sure about the UK.In another sign that the world is going mad, I think France might be a more reliable ally against ISIS then the UK.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom