Business Astrology

T'ai Chi said:


It was already pointed out by Dann that: , is a Danism meaning: 'I'll neglect whatever he says'.

Why you ask her if she's going to stalk somebody in response is a mystery.
I suspect, and I may certainly be corrected, that this was originally interpreted as meaning: "I shall jump [all] over his writings and anything which is related to it" in the sense that the term "to jump all over" something is a colloquialism that means to pursue something frantically by every means available. Therefore the sentence can easily be translated to mean that Karen was going to frantically chase Dann's writings across the internet, i.e to stalk him. Fortunately this notion has been adequately dispelled.

Nothing divides us like a common language!
 
I have only now read this thread - and it is the most interesting thread I have read on this forum in a long while. I would be delighted if there were more astrologers, homeopaths etc. willing to answer questions on this board.

Well, actually not so many questions have been answered. I have noticed as well (as Dann pointed out) that Karen answered specific questions by posting long and vague posts, and by quoting large paragraphs of other posters just adding "and what is your problem with that?".

She NEVER answered the most interesting question (in my opinion) about what constitutes the exact moment when a company is established. What if a group of people decided to start a company over a videoconference, one person being in New York at 6am local time, the other in London at 11am, and the third one in Helsinki at 1pm local time? And they register the company on the Cayman islands for tax purposes? What time and lattitude and longitude would an astrologer choose? I don't think astrology could take into account any of these things, probably because astrology is a product of times when people and ideas travelled much less fast.

I suppose in the same way it is impossible to say, at least in some cases, what constitutes an individual's exact itme of birth? What if a person was delivered prematurely on a transatlantic flight? Surely the time of birth is purely arbitrary in this case?

My personal opinion is actually that the problem is not that astrologers can do as well as business consultants, but that consultants can be as vague as astrologers, and that often a company paying for a consultant's services accepts similar vague statements and prognoses. If the consultant has good verbal and presentation skills, they can bulls**t their way around and get away with it. I am not a consultant myself, this is the opinion I formed after talking to a couple of people working as consultants.
 
Tanja: "My personal opinion is actually that the problem is not that astrologers can do as well as business consultants, but that consultants can be as vague as astrologers, and that often a company paying for a consultant's services accepts similar vague statements and prognoses. If the consultant has good verbal and presentation skills, they can bulls**t their way around and get away with it. I am not a consultant myself, this is the opinion I formed after talking to a couple of people working as consultants."

dann: And like the astrologers: When the company goes bankrupt, nobody ever doubted that this was bound to happen ...
 
Tanja said:
My personal opinion is actually that the problem is not that astrologers can do as well as business consultants, but that consultants can be as vague as astrologers, and that often a company paying for a consultant's services accepts similar vague statements and prognoses. If the consultant has good verbal and presentation skills, they can bulls**t their way around and get away with it. I am not a consultant myself, this is the opinion I formed after talking to a couple of people working as consultants.

Oh, you are so right. While it is not general, there are consultants out there who can spout the most incredible vapid bullsh1t, talking for hours and not saying a single thing.

Consulting is a very much needed business, though. I'm not putting it down (I'm a consultant meself) or anything. Consulting is basically selling information/knowledge: E.g. I know a great deal about a certain part of computing, but have absolutely no idea about e.g. economics. My job is to give the best possible advice to the client within my own field, while the client will get his economical advice somewhere else. It is then up to the client to decide what to do with the information he gets.

To claim that you can give sound advice on all aspects of how to run any kind of company is to fool yourself and the client. That's why business astrologers cheat their clients: They pretend to derive knowledge from celestial sources that will solve all your company's problems.

The trick is to distinguish between the bull and the bread. That is why asking direct questions is so crucial. That is why Karen Boesen doesn't want to answer them.
 
Zep said:
Welcome, Jaymz, and thanks for your input!

Thank you.


Zep said:

For the record, Karen's original quote was:Given the "translation" that you have supplied, it would appear that Karen is saying here that she is going to ignore not only what Claus Larsen says, she is also going to ignore anything Dann says too. Would that be your understanding?

Yes it would.

Zep said:

If so, do you have an opinion if this would be a good or a bad thing?

Actually in this particular thread and since it is Karen's first visit to the forum, I would have preferred if Claus and Dann had assumed a more passive role. The bad blood (and words) between the two gentlemen and Karen gives her an easy way out, and it will not be difficult for her to quote passages from Claus or Dann to show that she left the forum due to abuse, and not because she was unable to answer the simple questions she was asked.

Of course I understand why Claus and Dann have a hard time staying silent during Karen's accusations but they should both remember that sometimes it is better to let someone else argue your case.

I have read several of Dann's and Claus's arguments both here and on Skeptica.dk and I consider them both to be very informed and well spoken. However I often find them trying to beat Karen in her own game: Aggressiveness.

I find that unnecessary as well as damaging for their cause. They have a great case, and presenting it in an aggressive manner only gives Karen excactly what she wants: a chance to play the innocent victim.
 
Karen Boesen said:
Dann Simonsen!

You know perfectly well, that you NEVER will get any answers from me. I find you repulsive. You are forcible and the way you treat other people in your socalled " discussinons " is perfectly illustrated below:

"Dann Simonsen to chief consultant, legal psychiatrist Toni Haugen: "You are an unintelligent, pretentious, amateur interpreter".

I'm aggressive, and I give Karen Boesen a chance to play the innocent victim???
 
"Af Karen Boesen (kb) indsendt onsdag, d. 26. november, 2003 - 09:41:
"Endnu en trussel. Forbløffende at der er ikke er nogen astrologer, der tager afstand fra dette.
/Claus Larsen "

Det er der da sikkert også. Men hvad skulle det hjælpe dig? Om så der var 500 astrologer, der gik i fakkeloptog for at redde dig, ville du únder alle omstændigheder få en røvfuld.
Forøvrigt ikke en ny trussel. Blot en gentagelse af den gamle. Mere så du ikke glemmer den og tror, at den hellige grav er velforvaret."


dann: my translation:
"Another threat. Amazing that no astrologer repudiates this.
/Claus Larsen"

Somebody probably does. But what good would it do you? Even if 500 astrologers held a torchlight procession to save you, you would still get a thrashing.
By the way, it's not a new threat. Just the old one being repeated. Just to make sure that you don't think yourself safe.


dann: Claus Larsen is being aggressive???
Believe me, the "chance to play the innocent victim", to paraphrase an old song, no, no, you can't take that away from her.
More examples? Go to the www.astrologforeningen.dk and use "røvfuld" as your searchword ...
 
Jaymz,

I'm very direct. I want some answers. I am not satisfied with a vapid one, I want to see the facts, the data, the evidence.

And I have very little tolerance for frauds.

So, I don't stop, when people try to give answers that are not answers at all, but merely hot air and flummery. I dig deeper, until I find whether people have evidence of their claims, or whether they don't.

You can call that "aggressive" if you like.
 
dann said:


I'm aggressive, and I give Karen Boesen a chance to play the innocent victim???

I'm sorry Dann. I should have pointed out that I see Karen as much more aggressive than you and Claus combined.

What I had in mind was stuff like this from Claus:
"But, you have to admit that, at times, Karen is very entertaining. In a frantic, frothing, maniacal sort of way."

I must admit that a person like Karen deserves all the ridicule she gets. I have (as you) witnessed her calling a board administrator "fascist" and several other things that were hardly called for.

However I believe in choosing the high road even when arguing people like her. Even though Karen is 10 times more abusive than Claus she will still feel justified in leaving this thread due to abuse, and she will still be able to use the above quote as "proof" that skeptics are mean and cynical.
 
Jaymz said:

Even though Karen is 10 times more abusive than Claus she will still feel justified in leaving this thread due to abuse, and she will still be able to use the above quote as "proof" that skeptics are mean and cynical.

dann: Exactly! You can't take that away from her!
 
Jaymz,

You don't like Karen being described as "frantic, frothing, maniacal"?

A few gems from Karen:

"Men hvis det kan glæde dig, kan vi sagtens udvide min lovning om en røvfuld til alle medlemmer af Skeptica.dk - med undtagelse af Anja Andersen - hvis jeg bliver generet i at udføre mit lovlige arbejde."

"But if it pleases you, we can easily expand my promise of a thrashing to all members of Skeptica.dk - with exception of Anja Andersen - if I am bothered in my lawful work"


"...at hele polimikken med disse skeptikere, som jo blot skulle have haft en røvfuld..."

"...that the whole controversy with these skeptics, who only should have had a thrashing..."


Karen in a nutshell:

"Jeg siger/skriver, hvad der passer mig, og jeg argumenterer aldrig for noget af det!"

"I say/write what I feel like, and I never argue for any of it!"

How Karen looks at criticism:

"Jeg tåler ikke kritik, vil under ingen omstændigheder acceptere indblanding. Er argumentresistent! Kan det siges tydeligere?"

"I cannot stand criticism, will under no circumstances accept interference. Is argument-resistant. Can it be said more clearly?"

Guess not...
 
Well, "am resistant to arguments", would be a little clearer ...
 
Originally posted by Claus

Jaymz,

You don't like Karen being described as "frantic, frothing, maniacal"?

No I don't. Not because she deserves to be treated with respect, but because diagnosing people with mental illnesses should be something she does and only her!


BTW - you forgot this little beaty:

Originally posted by Karen Boesen

KB: "Hvis du en dag viser dig i mit regi og forsøger at optage med skuldt kamera or whatsoever, så klapper jeg dig ganske enkelt nogen på skrinet. Så mange, som jeg overhovedet kan overkomme, inden politiet ankommer.

Translation by Jaymz:
"Should you ever show yourself on my turf and try recording with a hidden camera or whatever, I will beat you in the head. As many times as I can manage before the police arrives.
 
dann said:


quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Jaymz

Even though Karen is 10 times more abusive than Claus she will still feel justified in leaving this thread due to abuse, and she will still be able to use the above quote as "proof" that skeptics are mean and cynical.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


dann: Exactly! You can't take that away from her!

You can't take away the fact that she will always feel justified, I agree. But you can take away the "proof" by using a tone as for instance Zep and Brown (amongst others) have done in this thread.

I don't mean to lecture either you or Claus in how to behave. I am sure you already know that. I'm just asking you to consider how some of your posts might look to an outsider.

Or maybe it's just me - I hope some of the other JREF'ers will give me their take on the situation?
 
It's true, Jaymz, if I had never used these words to sum up the activities of retired forensic psychiatrist Toni Haugen,
"You are an unintelligent, pretentious, cheap deliverer of homespun interpretations" (my translation this time)
Karen Boesen would never have been able to quote me. (Her point being that I dared to treat this distinguished gentleman, MD and forensic psychiatrist!, in this manner).
However, every time she quotes me (in public!), it gives me the opportunity to tell the whole story, which is very educational, I think.
A similar thing happened when the astrologers repeatedly called Mogens Winther a "liar" and "deceiver" because he had posted certain birth data as his own and only revealed that they weren't, when the astrologers had interpreted everything that they thought they new about him into the horoscopes based on the false data.
They felt justified in using these terms to describe Mogens Winther, which gave us the opportunity to tell the whole story. I used to stress the point that Mogens Winther was the one who revealed the truth, the astrologers never 'exposed' the 'deceiver' as they'd like to think.

As I see it, skeptics often gain a lot from using the good-cop/bad-cop routine! And believe it or not: for a very long time Danish astrologers thought of me as the good skeptic!
 
I can see that the webmaster not yet has removed me from this forum, and I could not resist to come back to see, what has happened since yesterday.

I have read some of the threads - very quickly - others not.

There was a gentleman, who argued against Cl and Simonsen. He was afraid that I should " use " the statements of these 2 creatures in a "wrong way". Be sure I will!
The skeptics have taught me that.
One takes a few words here - put them together with some other words in another context, then we make up some fantasies ourselves - and then, then, then............ we have her statemensts. Goebbels could not have done that much better.

I saw that a person mentioned that I have called the moderator of the skeptic forum in Denmark a fascist . '' The truth is that Mr. Wolf presented HIMSELF as a satanist and a fascist!
Both CL and Simonsen were about to be expelled from this skeptic forum because of their way of communication.
But then all the skeptics started to fight each other, and the whole board was closed down. It was extremely funny. All we astrologers leaned back and laughed. Simonsen among others were called " a religious skeptic " etc. etc. They had only allowed CL to be there for so long, because they thougt that he was about 20 years old. ( He has passed his forties. )

And yes Simonsen about Winthers data. 2 - 3 amateur astrologers tried to say something about Winthers false data. The rest of us were silent. We know too well that Winther is extremely dishonest, so why should we waste our time on his false data.

Well gentlemen! It has been a pleasure to be in here. Most of you - not all - seem to be just as narrowminded as the 3 Danish skeptics, you have met so far.
 
The "good cop/bad cop" analogy is very good. The thing is, these people will slander skeptics no matter what. I really don't know what is best, but perhaps it is simply not worth the trouble to argue with them, except to expose them to the hypothetical audience of lurkers. One thing I know is that a good fight draws a crowd.

Hans
 
" : for a very long time Danish astrologers thought of me as the good skeptic!


__________________
dann"

Good Lord!!!!!! Who was that astrologer/astrologers?? Try to tell the truth - just for one time in your lifetime!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom