Business Astrology

Page 103-104:

"In reality, one must say that qua these aspects, the organization will have qualities handed on a platter, which it definitely needs. Especially because the position of the planets are of both concrete and creative nature, which is close to excellent. Nothing less."

Page 105:

"This company (LEGO) will always qua the positive aspects (Neptune in sextile to Venus) be able to develop and utilize the knowledge produced in the company."

This is not a prognosis? A horoscope? Please, Karen, you are using astrology to tell what will happen to the company!
 
Karen,

I am always trying to find simple but thorough ways of testing claims using the scientific method. I confess I know little to nothing about your profession. I was wondering if you were given the date/time/location of the birth of a company (but not its name,) would you be able to determine if that company is still in business? If you could, this would be an easy way to win Randi's money.

Also, could you explain to me what is the definition of the birth of a company.

Thanks
 
Karen Boesen said:
I don`t view astrology as a tool to tell people, what will OCCUR. To me the chart shows your possibilities. YOU are the one, who make the desions and the responsibility is yours too. A chart is not fatalistic.

Yes I know the theory according to which we can change the patterns of our birth chart since this it shows us directions. It's a common belief between those who practice psychological astrology or astrology of the psychology to be exact.

I believe that we view forecast/predictions different! To me a preciction is not to tell a compagny that they will go bankrupt. week or two. :)
Even if you wanted to do that you couldn't do it. :) Modern Astrology doesn't promise that can do such things.Astrology can predict only pleasant events :)

Reg. the LEGO chart: You have misunderstood! I have never presented the chart to anyone at all. I did not use it in my lecture either. Please reread my first mail.

Thank you for correcting me. I read it in the commentary but you denied that indeed, I am sorry.

I could have choosen a chart, which I had worked out myself. In my own head. A chart, which had nothing to do with a " real" company. It is not the important issue here. The important thing to me was to show my readers, what a structural analysis can reveal. Nothing else. Maybe the founding data for LEGO is the 21st of March 1932 or maybe 1931. Not important for my purpose. LEGO themselves don`t know either, so I decided to accept the date, which they themselves regard as their founding date. Also because it fit my purpose of a chart for a toy-company.

I am sorry Karen but I have the minimum of intelligence. Why didn't you use a company out of your head with which you wouldn't have to deal with problems that the accuracy of the birth data pose? What astrologers and mediums have in common ( and I find it totally normal) is that they want publicity that's why the try to deal with cases everybody knows. That's why you chose to analyze a well known company that for many people is synonymous to success.

Also, allow me to remark that by claiming that you could create a chart out of your head to show the structural analysis to your reader doesn't do you much good. It is as if you admit that you make the data fit your theories. Do you see the problem here? Do you see the problem of credibility that you create with such claims?

To say that one predicts already when one mention that a company is a Leo, sounds extremely odd to me. Do you think that we can sell that prediction to anyone? :)

You didn't just say that the company is a Leo if you see the parts of your book that Claus quotes you say more than that.

You have two serious problems so far that you have to be careful with how to deal with them:

1. First you mentioned that you could create a horoscope out of your head in order to show your readers the structural analysis. Problem of credibility.

2. If you insist that a birth chart analysis doesn't reveal the future of the individual then you will be in trouble in the future because Danes read this forum.

Maybe admitting an unfortunate prediction is better but this is just my opinion.

The question was: " Did I change my mind about the chart, when Lego got problems? " No I did not!I have not given the company one thought since I wrote my chapter, nor have I ever worked out a predition, progressive horoscope. That should be enough answer to the question.

Not really and I will explain you why what you say doesn't make sense.
You chose to analyze a sucessful and well-known company. You chose to present your structural analysis because you knew the company's success ( until the moment you wrote the chapter) and you believed that the popularity of the company would verify automatically your claims.

Take your time to answer because many people here found the discussion interesting and posed many questions. :)
 
Karen Boesen: I believe that we view forecast/predictions different! To me a prediction is not to tell a company that they will go bankrupt. week or two. I don't work that way at all. Maybe they will maybe not, how should I know? But what I CAN tell them is, that they might get some problems in a week or two because of this or that. How they solve these problems is their own business. Depending on their resources etc.
Karen, I'm confused by this paragraph. My confusion comes from this:

You tell us that you can tell a company that they might get some problems in the near future ("a week or two", in your example). That does sound very much like a prediction to me. Maybe you are not being absolutely pinpoint accurate, but overall, some change, some upheaval, some difference is predicted that will require possibly extraordinary corporate action. Would you agree that is what you are saying?

If so, then how can you deny, in the preceding sentences in the same paragraph, that you do not make predictions, such as major upheavals (bankruptcy within weeks, in your example - I would have thought that would be a corporate "problem" in most boardrooms)? Can you see my confusion?

And another point, if I may. I do understand what you are trying to say about the difference between a 1932 horoscope and a 1994 horoscope. The prospects for a company in 1994 may be vastly different from what they were in 1932. But this brings up the issue of how long any particular horoscope is valid for, so let me follow through with a line of thinking and then let you comment on it.

In 1932, a company horoscope indicates a particular outlook. In 1994, the future outlook is vastly different. In the 62 years in between, what caused the horoscopes to change? What would the outlook for that company have been in, say, 1940? Or in 1963? Or in 1980? What about the horoscopes for each and every year from 1932 to 1994? If the horoscopes change from year to year, or even month to month, what good are they for addressing corporate problems on that same time scale? Companies often have plans spanning more than 12 months, sometimes many years, but if the horoscope on which they take consideration changes in that time, what real confidence should they have in it as a corporate planning tool?

Oh, and CF, you promised...!
 
Dear Kopji,

thank you for your very interesting post.

I will suggest that you contact me by private mail: [email protected]

I can see that you are living in the states, and the best way for you to get an answer to your many and intelligent questions, is to contact - on a personal level - one of colleques in your country.

I can see that the amount of very large questions is risen, and if this continues, I am afraid that I will have to close down my business. It will be far too timeconsuming for me.

I am looking forward to hear from you!

/Karen Boesen
 
Walter,

no, I would not be able to tell you from a chart, if a company is still in business or not.

I don`t want to sound arrogant, but there have already been answers to your question in reg. to the founding horoscope. Please reread the earlier post.

/Karen
 
Karen Boesen said:
I can see that the amount of very large questions is risen, and if this continues, I am afraid that I will have to close down my business. It will be far too timeconsuming for me.

But surely, Karen...these questions must have popped up before. It cannot be news to you. You must have heard them before, so why not simply answer them?

They go to the very heart of how astrology works, the very foundations of it, one might say.
 
[

".Astrology can predict only pleasant events :)"

KAREN: ?? If so, what do you do with the rest of the charts indications?
I could give you lots and lots of exampels of " not pleasant " predictions, which have been " filled in".

Sometimes you also experience that a magazine/newspaper or whatever it can be, don`t want to print an article, even though they have ordered it themselves, if the company, which you are dealing with prohibites it, because it describes their situation too well and the " preditions " are too " unpleasant "

"I am sorry Karen but I have the minimum of intelligence. Why didn't you use a company out of your head with which you wouldn't have to deal with problems that the accuracy of the birth data pose?"

KAREN: The problems have arisen, because the skeptics are lying. If they were honest people, there would never have been a problem. I discussed with my assistent, if I should find some charts, not reveal the data or the company`s name, but only print the article. We agreed on that most people prefer to read about a company, which they know about.


" What astrologers and mediums have in common ( and I find it totally normal) is that they want publicity that's why the try to deal with cases everybody knows. That's why you chose to analyze a well known company that for many people is synonymous to success."

Karen: No, you are wrong. You impute a lot of motives to me, which I do not have at all. I can assure you the I have had more than enough publicity in my lifetime. Not only in Denmark but around the globe. I often say no to interviews too, because it had long ago started to bore me.

"Also, allow me to remark that by claiming that you could create a chart out of your head to show the structural analysis to your reader doesn't do you much good. It is as if you admit that you make the data fit your theories. Do you see the problem here? Do you see the problem of credibility that you create with such claims? ""

KAREN: no, I am sorry, I cannot see that!


" You didn't just say that the company is a Leo.. "

Karen: true, I did not, you did! :)


" 2. If you insist that a birth chart analysis doesn't reveal the future of the individual then you will be in trouble in the future because Danes read this forum."

KAREN: Sorry, how?

" Maybe admitting an unfortunate prediction is better but this is just my opinion. "

KAREN: Excuse me, what unfortunate prediction are we talking about?

May I remind you of my motive to be here.

For some years now, I have experienced that some, of course not all skeptics, including Mr. Randi, have spread a lot of lies about me. I do not care about critizisme, when it comes to peoples opinion on astrology. For my sake they can state any meaning, they may have.
But we have a few skeptics, including Mr. Randi, who hates astrology among a lot of other topics of " alternative " character.
Hate combined with lack of honesty is a very dangerous and very subjective.

So I have been called criminal etc. by these few fanatics. I have invited Mr. Randi to come to Denmark to prove his accusations, but he has refused that. Sad!
 
Karen Boesen said:
I could give you lots and lots of exampels of " not pleasant " predictions, which have been " filled in".

Can you make up your mind? Are they predictions or not?

Karen Boesen said:
Sometimes you also experience that a magazine/newspaper or whatever it can be, don`t want to print an article, even though they have ordered it themselves, if the company, which you are dealing with prohibites it, because it describes their situation too well and the " preditions " are too " unpleasant "

This touches on the very ethics of astrology: How can you ethically defend that you analyze LEGO - a company that has not asked you to do so - and reveal things that are crucial to the company, something that influences their future?

Karen Boesen said:
The problems have arisen, because the skeptics are lying. If they were honest people, there would never have been a problem. I discussed with my assistent, if I should find some charts, not reveal the data or the company`s name, but only print the article. We agreed on that most people prefer to read about a company, which they know about.

That should not be a problem: Just pick one of those companies that you have worked with. You know, those big Danish companies with thousands of employees.

Skeptics are lying? You are most welcome to show where.

Karen Boesen said:
No, you are wrong. You impute a lot of motives to me, which I do not have at all. I can assure you the I have had more than enough publicity in my lifetime. Not only in Denmark but around the globe. I often say no to interviews too, because it had long ago started to bore me.

Not quite correct: You also turn reporters down, because you are afraid they will write the truth about you and astrology.

Karen Boesen said:
no, I am sorry, I cannot see that!

You go back and change the data, so it fits your theory. Standard procedure in astrology.

Karen Boesen said:
Excuse me, what unfortunate prediction are we talking about?

LEGO. You predicted wrong.

Karen Boesen said:
I have invited Mr. Randi to come to Denmark to prove his accusations, but he has refused that. Sad!

That is a bald-faced lie, and you know it. It is you who refuse to meet him.
 
KB ; “Maybe the founding data for LEGO is the 21st of March 1932 or maybe 1931. Not important for my purpose. LEGO themselves don`t know either, so I decided to accept the date, which they themselves regard as their founding date. Also because it fit my purpose of a chart for a toy-company.”

<a href ="http://members.attcanada.ca/~ckuhne/legoinfo2.html">August 13, 1932 IS LEGOs founding date </a> - but sure, a family company like LEGO does not even know what year it was founded. Maybe they should hire an astrologer to help them out ?

But never mind – if your ISBA newsletter mentions that you have discussed moving the birth day of your own association (my letter above) in order to avoid weird Pluto induced experiences from skeptics, why should we at all take your astrology seriously ? :


Karen, I would like a Porsche and a Mercedes Benz – would you PLEASE move my birthday too ?





And how come, that you on On 10 January 2004 - 16:16 - even though your applied data were fictive - could “easily observe several reasons for firing the Lego company director” .

Do you make similar dramatic conclusions based on fictive data when selecting <a href ="http://www.erhvervsastrologi.dk/erhvervsastrologi/Nytdesign/Human%20Resources1%20english.htm">managers and employees
</a> at "your companies", of which – so you claim – some even 3 have in the order of 3-4000 employees ?


/ Mogens Winther
 
ZEP:

" You tell us that you can tell a company that they might get some problems in the near future ("a week or two", in your example). That does sound very much like a prediction to me. Maybe you are not being absolutely pinpoint accurate, but overall, some change, some upheaval, some difference is predicted that will require possibly extraordinary corporate action. Would you agree that is what you are saying?"

KAREN: yes, that is, what I am saying. I did not state earlier, that I did not predicte. I say that I did not give absolute predictions, which means that you are making a prophecy about the Day of Judgement -so to speak.
When you tell a company or a person that or this aspect does arrive, and that means so and so, they have the opportunity to take action. They can change plans, try to minimize the "damage", profit from the aspect or they can be prepared, change their attitude etc. etc.
As mentioned earlier, I am not the one, who choose the strategy, the company or whoever it is, do that themselves.

" And another point, if I may. I do understand what you are trying to say about the difference between a 1932 horoscope and a 1994 horoscope. The prospects for a company in 1994 may be vastly different from what they were in 1932. But this brings up the issue of how long any particular horoscope is valid for, so let me follow through with a line of thinking and then let you comment on it.

In 1932, a company horoscope indicates a particular outlook. In 1994, the future outlook is vastly different. In the 62 years in between, what caused the horoscopes to change? What would the outlook for that company have been in, say, 1940? Or in 1963? Or in 1980? What about the horoscopes for each and every year from 1932 to 1994? If the horoscopes change from year to year, or even month to month, what good are they for addressing corporate problems on that same time scale? Companies often have plans spanning more than 12 months, sometimes many years, but if the horoscope on which they take consideration changes in that time, what real confidence should they have in it as a corporate planning tool?"

KAREN: The founding chart, which I worked on in reg. to LEGO, or any other company for that matter, never changes. It is the same through all the years - unless some big changes happen in the life of the company.
The founding chart gives you an idea about the ressources, problems etc., which the company might have to deal with.

The prediction/progressive chart changes all the time. In fact every minute due to the movement of the planets/stars. It is compared to the founding chart, and it tells the owner, what aspects in the founding chart are affected for the time being. What that implies, what you might be able to do about it etc. etc.

Normally you work out a prognosis for 2 - 3 years, containing all the different periods etc. written reports. Then you can use the charts implication to work out a strategy plan. Nothing strange in that. :)

/Karen

Oh, and CF, you promised...! [/B][/QUOTE]
 
MW:

" August 13, 1932 IS LEGOs founding date - but sure, a family company like LEGO does not even know what year it was founded. "

KAREN: Right! I am sorry, but that is how it is!


MW : "But never mind – if your ISBA newsletter mentions that you have discussed moving the birth day of your own association (my letter above) in order to avoid weird Pluto induced experiences from skeptics, why should we at all take your astrology seriously ? :"

KAREN: Who has claimed that you shall? Do as you like! Not of my business.


MW : " Karen, I would like a Porsche and a Mercedes Benz – would you PLEASE move my birthday too ? "

KAREN: Do you really think that cars, boats etc. will make you happy? The other day you send a photo of your yacht. Very impressive. Or is it the yacht of the bank? Well, never mind, I belive it would be a good idea for you to change your character
anyway. Especially your Neptune must be under huge pressure.

MW : "And how come, that you on On 10 January 2004 - 16:16 - even though your applied data were fictive - could “easily observe several reasons for firing the Lego company director” ."

KAREN: you forget the little word: IF. You can select 10 different charts, and you might be able to find " fyring aspect " in all of them. Even though they have nothing to do with LEGO. You cannot separate a chart from it owner.

MW : " Do you make similar dramatic conclusions based on fictive data when selecting managers and employees
at "your companies", of which – so you claim – some even 3 have in the order of 3-4000 employees ?"

KAREN: as I have told you earlier. I now have one more big company. The 3 ones, were the ones I had back in 2000/1.
The business is expanding dear!

/Karen;)
 
Oh, by the way I forgot to mention, that some of the leaders of my latest - very big company - will participate as case stories in my next book. Coaching!

They have given my work 13 with an arrow upwards! The highest - almost impossible to accomplish.

Isn`t that great?!
 
Karen Boesen said:
Oh, by the way I forgot to mention, that some of the leaders of my latest - very big company - will participate as case stories in my next book. Coaching!

They have given my work 13 with an arrow upwards! The highest - almost impossible to accomplish.

Isn`t that great?!

What company is this? What are the names of these people?
 
Concerning KB-s claim, that LEGO does not even know what year it was founded.

However - this does not keep KB away from speculating in minutes - maybe LEGO was born a few minutes earlier than August 13, 1932 at 6.00 - because this would make LEGO a Double LEO :

KB-s book : "The horoscope ascendant is placed zero degrees in Virgo. We may suspect good old Ole Kirk Christiansen for starting his company a little before 6 am, so that the company would be a so-called double-Leo (with both the Sun and the ascendant in Leo) but we will never know."

But never mind, if it does not fit, she will move the birth day/year anyway.



The only bad aspect of all this heavenly nonsense is the fact that this astrology is applied to innocent people, people who have not asked for this.

Newspaper articles have given interviews with one of KB-s furious victims, and in addition revealed similar cases with Karens collegues : job applicants were rejected, if they refused to accept an astrological investigation.

The AER - a Danish ethical council - has adressed this problem in earlier reports, as well as one workers union.

In addition, this problem has been discussed in Danish Parlament - here businessastrology was forbidden in public and semipublic companies.

During that parlament discussion, the minister of work pointed out that this kind of astrology, where astrologers do ask employees for birth data - according to her best estimates is a violation of Danish Laws against racism.

Besides, as described before - this is a violation of international ILO rules on workers protection.

But astrologers do not care about such legal/moral problems - as mrs Boesen wrote so wonderful on the Danish Astrologers Board May 2003 :

“I say/write whatever suits me, and I won't present arguments for any of it.”



/MW
 
Karen Boesen said:
ZEP:

" You tell us that you can tell a company that they might get some problems in the near future ("a week or two", in your example). That does sound very much like a prediction to me. Maybe you are not being absolutely pinpoint accurate, but overall, some change, some upheaval, some difference is predicted that will require possibly extraordinary corporate action. Would you agree that is what you are saying?"

KAREN: yes, that is, what I am saying. I did not state earlier, that I did not predicte. I say that I did not give absolute predictions, which means that you are making a prophecy about the Day of Judgement -so to speak.
When you tell a company or a person that or this aspect does arrive, and that means so and so, they have the opportunity to take action. They can change plans, try to minimize the "damage", profit from the aspect or they can be prepared, change their attitude etc. etc.
As mentioned earlier, I am not the one, who choose the strategy, the company or whoever it is, do that themselves.

" And another point, if I may. I do understand what you are trying to say about the difference between a 1932 horoscope and a 1994 horoscope. The prospects for a company in 1994 may be vastly different from what they were in 1932. But this brings up the issue of how long any particular horoscope is valid for, so let me follow through with a line of thinking and then let you comment on it.

In 1932, a company horoscope indicates a particular outlook. In 1994, the future outlook is vastly different. In the 62 years in between, what caused the horoscopes to change? What would the outlook for that company have been in, say, 1940? Or in 1963? Or in 1980? What about the horoscopes for each and every year from 1932 to 1994? If the horoscopes change from year to year, or even month to month, what good are they for addressing corporate problems on that same time scale? Companies often have plans spanning more than 12 months, sometimes many years, but if the horoscope on which they take consideration changes in that time, what real confidence should they have in it as a corporate planning tool?"

KAREN: The founding chart, which I worked on in reg. to LEGO, or any other company for that matter, never changes. It is the same through all the years - unless some big changes happen in the life of the company.
The founding chart gives you an idea about the ressources, problems etc., which the company might have to deal with.

The prediction/progressive chart changes all the time. In fact every minute due to the movement of the planets/stars. It is compared to the founding chart, and it tells the owner, what aspects in the founding chart are affected for the time being. What that implies, what you might be able to do about it etc. etc.

Normally you work out a prognosis for 2 - 3 years, containing all the different periods etc. written reports. Then you can use the charts implication to work out a strategy plan. Nothing strange in that. :)

/Karen
Thank you for your information on this, Karen. But I remain confused even more so now. I hope you can help me understand.

In your first point (about "aspects" of horoscopes) you have confirmed that you are indeed seeing possible future events based on current data (i.e. the stars, planets, etc). In fact, you go on to use the word "prediction" for this yourself later. However, if a company or indeed a person chooses to take actions that avoid those potential problems, and indeed nothing bad eventuates, then the aspects' view of the future must surely have been flawed - what actually happened is not what the aspects indicated at that point in time. Is that not so?

And the same goes the other way, surely: aspects indicating a "positive" future may be overturned by the company or person making poor current decisions that lead to negative results for them. And I'm not referring specifically to LEGO here - that is too controversial. I'm just being generalised.

Altogether then, we would have four different situations: (a) the aspects are good and the results turn out good, (b) aspects good, results bad, (c) aspects bad, results good, and (d) aspects bad, results bad. That is, the aspects match actual events 50% of the time, all other influences not being considered. Which is exactly the same as flipping a coin heads or tails. Would you not agree? If not, why not?

And here's my dilemma: If I knew nothing about the future at all and I was about to make a momentous decision, would the results be any different if I did or did not know what my horoscope aspects were? Would I be any better off flipping a coin? And how do you think we could test if astrology is better or worse than chance?

With regard to the second point, do I now understand that you are saying that each horoscope made after the founding one is used only to show "variances" from the founding chart?

Then you introduced the qualifier to that statement, of "...unless some big changes happen in the life of the company." OK, what qualifies as "big"? I gather founding, bankruptcy and winding-up are "big", but what else is in this context? A record profit year? A float on the stock-market? Something less serious, like a new boss at the helm? I'm trying to get an understanding of what would be momentous enough to cause a change in the "founding horoscope".

And I thank you for the confirmation that horoscopes for a single entity change from minute to minute, although this simply adds to the confusion for me. What you seem to be saying is that a horoscope is only valid until the next horoscope is done, either minutes later or years later. Which would suggest that if you didn't like the horoscope that you received at any time, all you need do is wait a few minutes and get another one. And if you don't like that one, keep on waiting and getting new ones until you DO like one of them. Is that not so?

Thank you in advance, Karen.

CF - please let us talk with Karen also. We have not met her before like you have.
 
Zip,

I am sorry. No, I cannot help you any further. Would be too timecosuming. Please reread my post - or maybe even better: read some books on astrology.

CF has not met me and I thank to good that because of that I have not met him either. Hopefully this situation will continue in future. :)

/Karen
 
Karen Boesen said:
Zip,

I am sorry. No, I cannot help you any further. Would be too timecosuming. Please reread my post - or maybe even better: read some books on astrology.

CF has not met me and I thank to good that because of that I have not met him either. Hopefully this situation will continue in future. :)

/Karen
Karen, your books are not available in Australia (where I live) as far as I can find out, and they are EXTREMELY expensive to buy in from America. So I really would appreciate a response from you to my questions here on this forum. I was so looking forward to your answers. It would be a pity of there were none.

And we have plenty of time here to continue discussions - as much time as you need. You can do it in small portions if you think that it is too big to be done in one chunk. I don't mind, really!

And as you see, we are trying to keep Claus quiet so you can have your own say here uninterrupted and in your own words.

Please?

Zep
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom