Business Astrology

Karen Boesen said:
Yes Hans, you are a typical skeptic.

Thank you!

For the articles contact Mogens Winther, he subscribes to all that stuff.
The last article on clairvoyance and astrology in regard to recruitment was in " IN " - February 2004. Exclusive magazine.

Mmmm, not exactly a publication I would call sincere. But exclusive it is ;).

You have been able to read about me in ALL the Danish newspapers. Lots of articles over the last 15 - 16 years. I don`t collect all that stuff anymore, because I have lost interest in it. Also countries in Europe and USA have written a lot.

Well, at least you were mentioned a lot in connection with that TV series, I'll give you that.

The other day Winther published a media list of me. You can find that here too.

Do you have any suggestions of what I should call you Hans?

Actually, you don't appear to need suggestions on what to call people :rolleyes:.

-- But thank you for answering some of my questions

Hans
 
Oh Mr. Hans, I am SO sorry. Of course I should have known long ago, that I should be very, very, very, very serious, if a person like you ( anonymous?) should be satisfied.
When you accused me of lying, I mentioned the last interview in " IN", because that was easy to follow up.

But Mr. Hans, I have been interviewed to the following, VERY, very, very, very serious magazines - among a lot of others:

4 pages in Boersen - the Danish Wall Street paper. I had one of the front pages all by myself. One of the articles was about the journalists chart. " Predicted my move and changing in my career. "
What do you think Mr. Hans. Isn`t that great?

3 different interviews in " Erhvervsbladet". Including the front page once. Interviews with clients etc.

1 interview in " Arbejdsgiveren ". A publication for the company owners here in DK.

Also Mr. Hans, I have been interviewed to " Fortune". American. I don`t know if it was printed or not. I never followed up on it.

Furthermore: Berlingske, Politiken, Information etc. etc.
Hopefully that is good enough for such a serious person like you.

Off for the time being. Maybe I will be back later.
To CL. No need to continue. You only have one goal for all your scriblings. To put yourself in the center.
 
Karen Boesen said:
Oh Mr. Hans, I am SO sorry. Of course I should have known long ago, that I should be very, very, very, very serious, if a person like you ( anonymous?) should be satisfied.
Hans is not anonymous. Anyone who has been around this forum for any length of time at all will know his full name, his personal web site address, and his job. In fact, I think he actually named the company he works for earlier in this very thread.

Hans has even gone to homoeopathic bulletin boards without hiding his identity, the only non-homoeopath I know who has dared to do that. So of all the people to sneer at as "anonymous", he's entirely the wrong one to pick.

Rolfe.
 
What does the fact that Karen has been interviewed by some "VERY, very, very, very serious magazines" have to do with the validity of business astrology?

Karen claims she has no interest in defending astrology, she only came to this board to defend her own reputation. Perhaps a poll might indicate how successful she has been at that. Personally, I have a much lower opinion of her now than I did before she started posting here.

Ms. Boesen seems to subscribe to the "best defence is a good offence" school of thought and she has certainly proven to be offensive.

:rolleyes:
 
Business astrology and KB

Hello again...

No, I havent't forgotten anything and yes, I have read all the posts in this thread :)

My point is just just to point out that

in Randis Commentary on feb 6th 2004 it is presented as such as KB after having said )on isba congress)that she belivies that LEGO has a superhoroscope (a comment i personally do not agree with !) then the next citation from KB are factually correct.
(about the sacking of Lego's ceo/director)

But the way it is pesented make it appear, as if KB says this on the ISBA conference in Denmark in oct 2002(as is she just changed her mind about lego's horoscope being a superhoroscope, when she, apparantly in oct 2002 just learned that Lego were in dire financial need and hence sacked their CEO/director)

What I react to, is ,as I see it, the false presentation by mr. Randi in his commentary on Feb 6th (as no source is given by mr. Randi to where he has KB*s 2. comment on Lego*s horoscope from)

Also the whole tone about KB is patronizing (as least in my opinion) --- and it also states that (forgive me if i do not cite quite accurately) that 'everybody did not know about Lego's finacial trouble...) And as most Danes will tell you, the danes actually do care about LEGO (R) and how it fares them in the world of business...

And most danes have heard and know about Lego's financial trouble in the latest 3-4 years...(which has something do with the fact that the children i DK does not play anymore (or very very little) when the reach the age og 6 or 8).

All I wanted eas to point out that in my opinion, KB was treated unfairly by mr. Randi --- because on his commentary on Feb 6th 2004 it seems that KB changed her mind on Lego's superhoroscope...way back on oct 2002 when she gave a lecture on Lego's horoscope and suddenly a note, appararently came in the door, (at the isba conference) with a message that Lego had sacked their CEO/director) just under the ISBA conference.

And then suddenly announced to the audience that now Lego's horoscope was not a superhoroscope because an aspect between sun and saturn...(at least that was how i interpreted mr. Randis commentary)

But as I intended to show:

KB said rightly in oct 2002 that lego had as superhorosope
But she did not say anything about the progessive saturn square radix(birth) sun before she WAS asked a question about it in the danish astrologyforum.dk --- on jan 8TH 2004...(15 months after the ISBA conference)

Nowhere is this to de found at/in Mr. Randis commentary on feb 6th 2004. That KB makes 2 different statements regarding Lego, at 2 different occasions, and at 2 different times.

(and finally,: things do not stand still; and the planets themselves do not stand still in reverence on our birth, nor a company's birth.

The planets are still moving about ---

and also finally

when new evidence is presented one must be willing to take one's results (and meanings) up to revision --- and apparently KB did not see the upcoming progesive square to lego's radix sun way back in 2002...

And this what i have to say on the matter for the moment :)

(thanks to Hans (i think) for translating the danish to english --- i'm sorry i wasn't able to do it myself --- bui i wasn't home all day yesterday to do it --- I do have a live that's about more than just sitting by the computer alle day :D)

aries
(who hopes this clarafies what my point is --- it is very difficult to
think in danish and translate in english --- but i hope at least the meaning is clear...)(it is too me in my head :D --- but i sometimes have a problem with communicating my ideas to the public ---
hope this isn't a problem here :) )

aries
 
Business astrology and KB

Hello again :)

I do not know why KB did not reveal all these dark and murky secrets a long time ago....only KB can tell you that...

(and by the way SOL= SUN in english, and 'tiltagende'= applicating meaing moving towards...)

But I do know that what KB is talking about on the jan 10th
as a REPLY to question she is getting from a visitor to the astrologyforum.dk

that is what astrologers call 'a progressive horoscope'

I.e. she (KB) talks about an uranus transit that moves over a certain spot in Lego's horoscope --- this event (or what we shall name it) IS present now... and so is the progressive saturn square sun...it is also present NOW...(in jan. 2004)

At the ISBA conference in oct 2002 KB just talked about the birth horoscope of Lego.(t least so far as i know :D)..and the date and the time when it was founded...(and i think the date augist 13 1932, is valid; the time can be questioned...but the time she got from phoning lego and asking. and the time she got was 6 00 CET time simply because a hard working man from Jutland, Denmark presumably started production as this time --- early in the morning...)

She did not talk about the future for LEGO...(not according to the information I have) --- so therefore she could not disclose any of the dark and murky secrets as one of the posters so elegantly put it.

Simply just because she (KB) did not gather any information about the future for Lego (and again --- i will stress that i never ever will telle anyone that their horoscope, be it a company or a man/woman, that their horoscope is a 'superhoroscope'.

The horoscope just is. period. What we chose to do with it, (and the potential, it shows us, (at least according to me,) is entirely
up to us...

aries
 
Karen Boesen said:
Oh Mr. Hans, I am SO sorry. Of course I should have known long ago, that I should be very, very, very, very serious, if a person like you ( anonymous?) should be satisfied.
When you accused me of lying, I mentioned the last interview in " IN", because that was easy to follow up.

*snip* Mr. Hans. Isn`t that great?

*snip*
I don't see any reason for your tone. You were giving the impression that papers were writing about you all the time. Well, you pointed out some articles, fine, I'll look a couple of them up.

I don't know if it is great. I do know that it does not constitute evidence of the validity of astrology.

My identity is not that hidden, but it is also not important. I'm not an authority in your area, just someone you could play ball with if you wanted to support your credibility. Seems you have opted for insulting people instead.

Hans
 
To aries.

You are not addressing ignorants or idiots here.

A Progressive Chart is by definition a forecast whether it concerns the day we are talking or this very minute or tomorrow.
 
Ahh, yes I found one in Boersen, but not the one you refer to, their online archive only goes back to 1996. When was your four-page article?

I found this one, from 1998 (Karen co-authored the text in one of the yellow boxes at the bottom of the page (page 14).

I'll quote part of it (my translation):

There is an ongoing debate about whether the use of astrology for recruiting should be prohibited. Users of astrology for hiring purposes are quite few, as it is normally economy the companes want to know about. But why not let the companies decide for themselves what tools they want to use for hiring? It is superfluous to legislate against something that is quite voluntary.

That the method is practically unused, can be due to the simple fact that it is cumbersome to use compared to the standard tests that are otherwiseused when hiring personnel. In any case, astrology only comes in during the final selection round.

The condition for the work of the business astrologer is that the company has obtained permission from the applicants, who supply the precise time of birth. This can take time.

The only other article from Boersen's archive that comes up when searching for "astrologi" (Danish for astrology) is a short notice where some politicians have an opinion on unemployed persons taking astrology courses on taxpayer's expense.

No four-page article. Have I misunderstood you, Karen?

Hans
 
Karen Boesen said:
I came here ONLY because I wanted to print my thread about Mr. Randi and his lack of credibility. Not because I wanted a discussion on/of my work.
Ms. Boesen is on my ignore list, but when I saw the above quotation, I felt moved to respond.

MS. BOESEN, HOLD ON RIGHT THERE.

First: your challenge to Mr. Randi's credibility attributed remarks to him that should have been attributed to others. I pointed this out in my very first post in this thread. It is the second posts of all of the posts in this thread. Do I need to quote it back to you?

Second: YOU were the one who brought up aspects of your business, and YOU were the one saying that those aspects were misrepresented. You clearly "opened the door" for us to ask about your business.

Third: When I asked you some straight questions about your business so that I could learn which aspects you believe were misrepresented and why they were misrepresented, I did not receive straight answers to my straight questions. I repeatedly and politely sought straight answers ABOUT THE ISSUES THAT YOU YOURSELF RAISED, and got none.

Fourth: Any person who thinks that she can publicly accuse a person of misrepresenting facts about her work, and who also thinks that facts about her work or that her own credibility ought not to be in question, does not have a mature grasp on reality.

Fifth: Any person who thinks that a puerile insult is a legitimate form of debate or rebuttal is, to be blunt, a shallow-brained person.

Ms. Boesen, just who do you think you are talking to?

We are not children. Many of us are smart, mature people, and we simply do not accept "because I say so" as a reason. When we, as intelligent adults, express a sincere interest in learning about a subject, we hope to be taught. We do not appreciate having our polite requests being impolitely ignored. We do not appreciate messages that are little more than blatant, rude insults. We do not appreciate being categorized as dishonest bunglers.

How would you like it if I said "All Danes are impolite," based upon my experience that you have been stunningly rude? I suspect you would not like it at all.

Do not bother to reply to this message. You have earned your spot on my "ignore" list, along with all of the other buffoons, blowhards and nut-cases currently there. Good day.
 
Karen Boesen said:

Sure, but our employees are doing much better than the poor Americans.
That is, what counts for us. We use to call it protection of the individual. From the rough capitalism. We would never accept an " Enron " case here in Scandinavia.
I cannot really say if Karen Boesen is telling the truth in this case. Very often, being an employee is not much fun in any country ...
Protecting the "poor Americans" and other individuals "from the rough capitalism" sounds like a good idea, however. Liberating them from it would be even better, but I do not think that business astrology serves any of those purposes - except, maybe, in the few cases where astrology might help convicted murderers or drug smugglers get a job in management. There are far too few career opportunities for those people anyway, so I can neither approve or disapprove of Karen Boesen's (voluntary or involuntary) contribution to this kind of rehabilitation of ex-convicts. That some people get the job and others don't - no matter how much they are in need of a regular income - is the real scandal, not the tools used for this kind of selection, be it a horoscope, an IQ test or a "serious" analysis of the skills of the applicants. I do, however, see one advantage to a company asking candidates for their exact birth data: It will make the employer's attitude to superstition rather obvious, thus enabling them to decide if they want to try their luck somewhere else or go along with it and pretend that they believe in it too.
It is hard to tell whether or not 'we Scandinavians' would ever "accept an "Enron" case". In general 'we' would prabably have as little influence on a case like that as the victims of Enron in the USA. Scandals in business occur here too, but usually on a much smaller scale due to the size of the companies involved ....
 
Brown said:
We do not appreciate being categorized as dishonest bunglers.

How would you like it if I said "All Danes are impolite," based upon my experience that you have been stunningly rude? I suspect you would not like it at all.

I hope that you do not intend to imply that Mrs. Boesen's behaviour is due to her having been exposed to "dishonest bunglers" and that she now merely makes the mistake of generalizing to all skeptics!? I do not think that you do, but it almost reads like that.
 
Business astrology and KB

Hello :)

Cleo ---

I'm sorry... I do not hold you or any other in this forums for neither ignorants or idiots.

But as I did not know how much knowledge you have on astrology;perhaps i went a tad/bit overboard, with explaining
what a progressice Chart is (and so on) (maybe it is because i'm a teacher :D --- )

Also I was trying to answer mr. winter's question in a sober manner...

Hope you understand :)

aries
(who again excueses if he has gotten any one in here to feel inferior, as an ignorant or an idiot --- this was never my intention)
aries
 
KB: That is, what counts for us. We use to call it protection of the individual. From the rough capitalism.

Who protects employees from your superstition - Karen ?

Letting a company directors personnal new age religion determine who is promoted, and who is fired - is surely capitalism at its worst, Karen.

Aries concerning the horoscope : “What we chose to do with it, (and the potential, it shows us, (at least according to me,) is entirely up to us...”

Negative. What is to be done with that horoscope, is up to the company director. How one of Karens victims did feel about that,
has been described in another newspaper article, which Karen has not referred to.

KB : But Mr. Hans, I have been interviewed to the following, VERY, very, very, very serious magazines - among a lot of others:

4 pages in Boersen - the Danish Wall Street paper. I had one of the front pages all by myself.

Sure - Karen - that article is also mentioned at your <a href ="http://www.businessastrologers.com/Isbainthemedia.htm">press-list . </a>

However - when researching for our second book on superstition - I asked "Boersen" for details.

First they were very astonished and claimed that Boersen that Boersen had never printed such an article. Then, after long research, it turned out that this article had been printed back in the 1980-s ! ! And as usual - no facts - but a lot of soft talk.
KB : Also Mr. Hans, I have been interviewed to " Fortune". American. I don`t know if it was printed or not. I never followed up on it.

Nothing appeared in <a href ="http://www.fortune.com/fortune/">Fortune</a>, how come ? Maybe this is due to your Pluto transit - that transit which did start an internal ISBA discussion concerning if the ISBA birth date had to be moved ?

KB on the Mengele story :
Yes that was false information. Winther send these data to a maschine, and afterwards he claimed that astrology did not work, because a maschine, was not able to detect the his grandfather ( another lie ?) Mengele, was a monster.

Oh, your competing astrologer – mr Giber – is a machine ? If so, who is then driving his claimed so expensive 500 000 Dollar Ferrari ?

Click to see his <a href = "http://www.giber.dk/job.htm">wonderful pages</a>

The last image on that page is the most amazing of all - here you may observe the parallels between business astrology and <a href =http://www.skepdic.com/physiogn.html>phrenology / physiognomy</a> - enjoy !
No doubt mr Giber is a talented man – here some quoting from the press article "The star among astrologers"...

"When people meet the first time - we get an impression of each other - which does not have to be reality- but is the mask we carry. That is why astrology is a useful tool concerning job-appointments , because the astrologer may tell, that this person carries a mask, but behind this mask - we find a truly different person. We may tear everything apart, and reveal both physical and intellectual capacities. "


According to a Danish, skeptical TV programme – “Your job is in the stars” – mr Giber is able to select / reject applicants in a very discreete way – only by looking at peoples birthday.

Of course – birth day data are much more easy available than e.g. information about birth hour and birth minute.

Any job applicant will easily tell you her birthday and year – but if you ask for birth hour – then the company faces the risk of being exposed to the skeptics.

However the Mengele story and the Jeff Dahmer story have together with Karens Murderhorrorscope performance http://www.randi.org/jr/051603.html (click for details)
revealed to public what astrology is really worth.
Quoting from the press :
Within the horoscope - which is denoted as a "cosmic Quality product" - mr Mengele , who is probably the person in World history - who has killed most people - gets a surprisingly positive valuation. "
A person - who sacrifies himself for the benefit of others - counteracts injustice and keeps "healing" those - who suffer.."
" He may forgive others - and has none or only a very few enemies - so the horoscope - which concludes that Mengele is most suited working with people. "

Later several efforts were given to explain what had gone wrong :

mr Giber to Ritzau Nov 24, 1996 : "Maybe Mengeles reletives would have recognised this description. It is often so, that the partner and parents feel, the criminal is a decent person. "
mr Giber in TV3 - Nov 29, 1996 : "all Germans were like that (Mengele) - more or less."...
and later again same year – “Birthdata should be accurate within +/- 2 minutes - else such a test is of no value...”
Then – in June 1997 – some one else than mr Giber had made this horrorscope : "it was made by someone who is called Lars, it is a Larsen in Copenhagen..."
Etc. Etc..


Let me end by quoting good old Kepler, whose name has been misused by (ISBA related) astrologers http://www.keplercollege.org/index.html so often

A mind is accustomed to mathematical deduction, when confronted with the faulty foundations of astrology, resists a long, long time, like an obstinate mule, until compelled by beating and curses to put its foot into that dirty puddle. Johannes Kepler, (1571-1630) In G. Simmons Calculus Gems, New York: McGraw Hill Inc., 1992.



MW
 
dann said:
I hope that you do not intend to imply that Mrs. Boesen's behaviour is due to her having been exposed to "dishonest bunglers" and that she now merely makes the mistake of generalizing to all skeptics!? I do not think that you do, but it almost reads like that.
Perhaps I should clarify. Ms. Boesen said:
Then - maybe some honest - skeptics claim that I should trust them. How should I know that they the the ones, whom they claim to be?
...
To me a skeptic means: a person, who is dishonest, who is bungling etc. etc.
What conclusion can I draw from a remark such as this, except that it is a slap in my face, and a slap in the face of others who have expressed an interest in the topic? The assertion insults the personal integrity of the others and myself, saying that we may not be what we say we are. What cause has there been for such a remark? None, as far as I can see.

And then we are treated to a frank exhibition of prejudice: skeptics are dishonest bunglers. What a stunning display of closed-mindedness!

Whether Ms. Boesen has actually been exposed to skeptics who have lied to her, I do not know. I think it is possible that some skeptics, like all people, might not have been totally above board. Whether Ms. Boesen has actually been exposed to skeptics who have bungled, I do not know. I think it is possible that some skeptics, like all people, might have made mistakes.

But, as I have said before, when one person accuses another of not telling the truth, the chances very good that not everything said by the other is untrue. I have earnestly tried to find out what matters are deemed untruthful or erroneous, and whether some assertions actually have a legitimate basis or whether they constitute a legitimate difference of opinion. I have been snubbed.

I have not bothered to read all of the childish name-calling that has taken place, but I have seen nothing that justifies such a prejudiced remark, and I most certainly take exception to it.
 
Aries :” I do not know why KB did not reveal all these dark and murky
secrets a long time ago....only KB can tell you that...”


Oh, sure, and mrs Boesen will not tell us that.

But please let me guess, could it be that mrs Boesen is only able to reveal – what the press has told her in advance ?

Only one way to find the truth : that is if mrs Boesen does the JREF test. But so far she has flatly refused, http://www.skeptica.dk/mw/astrologi/randi.htm

how come – mr Aries ?


/MW
 
Business astrology and KB

Hi :)

As i'm not mrs. Boesen I do not why she has refused to take the JREF test...

You, again, will have to task Mrs. Boesen, that

question...

aries
 
Re: Business astrology and KB

aries said:
Hi :) You, again, will have to task Mrs. Boesen, that question...
aries

Sure - and as a former teacher, you have never dared to ask that question yourself ?

.... Every newspaper in America has a daily astrology column. How many have even a weekly astronomy column? And I believe it is also the fault of the educational system. We do not teach how to think.....

- Carl Sagan, The Burden Of Skepticism, The Skeptical Inquirer, Vol. 12, Fall 87

/MW
 
Karen, I'm waiting for a response from you to my previous post here. I want to know if you really mean what you said about me and all the other reasonable people here.

You can see what sort of reception you have generated here with your blatant bad manners and selfish, childish behaviour. But I shall not be putting you on my ignore list - I am a very, VERY obstinate person, and I WILL wait for your response.

zep
 
I have gone through all the threads very quickly, and of course it would be impossible for me to answer them all.

What I can tell you is, the I don`t take Mr. Randi`s test, because I regard him and his fellow-skeptic Mr. Winther as being extremely untrustworthy. Sounds like a joke if anyone should want to deal with such creatures.

Have a great week end genttlemen!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom