Business Astrology

Karen Boesen said:
:) it seems as if Mr. Randi`s chatroom is managed just as bad as everything else, he is engaged in.
Karen,

I am trying to give you a fair hearing here, a chance to put your case fairly and show your evidence for business astrology. So is Cleopatra, so is Brown, so are many others. I would remind you that Mr Randi has posted only once on this forum about you, in this thread, and that was to welcome you here. I see no further words at all from him about you here, which means he has said nothing unpleasant about you at all.

Furthermore, Mr Randi does not speak for us, we do not speak for him, we are not his employees or spokespeople or puppets, we live all around the world and have many different points of view on many things. Please be VERY clear: this is NOT "Mr Randi's chatroom", any more than the Danish astrologers' chatroom belongs to you, Karen Boesen. He does not "manage" the JREF forum, never censors it, and rarely even visits here. We skeptics do criticise Mr Randi and his thoughts and actions here - he is not above comment and he accepts this gracefully. I repeat: this is NOT "Mr Randi's chatroom". So the thoughts and words and actions of skeptics here are entirely their own, not Mr Randi's.

So if you wish to play the innocent matyr by claiming that Mr Randi has somehow organised a campaign against you here on this forum then you are incredibly mistaken and wrong.

You, and any other astrologers who wish to, are more than welcome to be here and participate in our forum, and we insist that your words be yours and yours alone. You must be allowed to say here precisely what you wish to say.

However it does your words no good at all, and indeed a lot of harm, if you continually use them to make unfounded personal snipes at people - ad hominem attacks. That is merely childish playground bickering, and we consider that when people resort to that sort of thing, it means they have no real evidence at all. That makes for dull conversations here, so we will usually talk about something else instead.

But since you are new here, Karen, and especially since we are keen to hear your input, can I please ask that you stick to the subjects at hand and refrain from any more personal attacks.

Next point: If you have personal issues with Claus and Dann and Mogens and other Danish skeptics, please take them up elsewhere. We do not care to see some Danes fighting a petty personal battle here. That is not what this forum is for. Anyway, most of us have no idea what the heck you are all arguing about anyway - we have no idea of the history, and you don't seem to want to tell us when we ask for details. Oh well, that is your choice, but somewhere else, please.

OK, back to the topic??
 
Amen to that! Actually, there is a forum here called "flame war". Might I suggest that not only Karen, but certainly also Claus, Mogens and Dann, take their fight there. Then we could continue discussing astrology on a scientific level here.


----- Time will then show which thread get the most activity :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans, T'ai Chi,

In a perfect world, you are right. But we are not dealing with honest people here. I personally do not sit back and let lies stand unopposed. That is also what we are here for. Don't we speak out when e.g. Sylvia Browne lies about Randi? When PSI TECH lies about finding missing children?

You bet we do.

Karen shows no inclination to discuss astrology, scientific or otherwise. But her lies and accusations will be met with facts and evidence. I don't find that "sandbox"'ing at all.
 
KB and SB not honest and sincere?? :eek:

I'm stunned. Truely stunned.

Hans
 
CFLarsen said:
But that [reporting information about positions of planets in the sky at the time of a particular event] is not what astrologers do. Even though it is easy to point out that astrology has nothing to do with the actual sky, astrologers imagine they can predict the future, like the recent train accident in Iran.
Actually, I think some of them do. I believe there was a television program aired a few years ago (sorry, can't remember the name or the network... it might have been John Stossel on ABC but I'm not sure) in which two astrologers were independently asked to prepare horoscopes for a particular person who was born at a particular time. The astrologers both correctly identified what planets were rising, and what "houses" were involved, and so forth. In other words, they independently checked their almanacs and made some calculations and saw basically the same arrangement of the heavens at the time of this person's birth. So far so good.

The conclusions that they drew from the arrangement, however, were strikingly different from one another, and many of the conclusions were clearly way off base. Both astrologers passionately asserted that their work was based in science and mathematics, and yet their opinons, predictions and advice showed no consistency at all. In fields of science and mathematics, there is not necessarily 100 percent agreement on everything, but there is always some sort of consensus. With the astrologers, there was virtually no consensus (and if I remember right, the things they did agree on were inconsistent with the facts.)
CFLarsen said:
Most astrologers have actually abandoned this idea [gravitational effect], and now favors different explanations...
I understand this you are correct about this. The idea of gravitational influence was popular at one time, but has since fallen out of favor because it is inconsistent with formulas derevied from empirical evidence.
 
Brown,

Ah, let me clarify: I did not mean that they don't use computers (if they used almanacs, I think the tv show would have been in black&white!) to calculate the positions of the planets.

What I was pointing to was that these data do not correspond to the actual positions of the planets. That's why Mozart is both a Capricorn and an Aquarius.

Here's a comparison of how the two main astrologies, Western (Tropical) and Eastern (Sidereal) conflict:

astrosch01.gif


Of course, the Eastern zodiac is a few days off, too. None of the astrologies are using the correct star signs.

I can see that my sentence "But that is not what astrologers do" could have been worded better.
 
Jeff Corey said:

That's the Claus Larsen we all know and love. His maniac screaming.
Why I remember one time in a bistro in NYC, being embarassed by Claus, who wasn't used to strong US beer, maniacically screaming at the poor waitress and attempting to bite her ankles until restrained by members of New York Area Skeptics.
Who, of course, do not resort to maniac screaming and passively let people steal their tape recorders.
Yeah, right.
I understand that this little quip is being repeated as the truth on Danish astrology boards by KB. It was a joke, as anyone who knows about "strong US beer" would be able to discern. Also, the "Yeah, right" at the end should give it away.
The point of the quip and the previous post about Claus as a berserker Viking was that both could not be further from the truth.
 
Jeff Corey said:
I understand that this little quip is being repeated as the truth on Danish astrology boards by KB. It was a joke, as anyone who knows about "strong US beer" would be able to discern. Also, the "Yeah, right" at the end should give it away.
The point of the quip and the previous post about Claus as a berserker Viking was that both could not be further from the truth.

Well....the part about "maniacal screaming" is true, but only when at a McCartney concert.... ;)
 
Jaymz: “You can't take away the fact that she will always feel justified, I agree. But you can take away the "proof" by using a tone as for instance Zep and Brown (amongst others) have done in this thread.”

dann: No, Jaymz, you can’t possibly take away the proof by using any kind of tone. There is one reason why good behaviour will never serve its purpose in a discussion with people like Karen Boesen: If they have not got an actual quotation that they can use to discredit their opponents, all they have to do is invent one. And they do so, frequently.

Karen Boesen: "As said by Simonsen earlier: " your folk ( astrologers etc. ) are woo-woo`s, the sort of people, who the nazists looked at as " minor people": You can complain from now on and until the day you die. Noone will ever listen to you!" "

dann: You, Jaymz, are probably well aware of the fact that I never said anything remotely similar to this 'quotation' attributed to me. This is not just a question of Karen Boesen's inability to translate from Danish into English. Nothing is lost in this translation. This quotation does not exist and never existed anywhere in any language! This is fiction! If you make a search at www.astrologforeningen.dk using the word woowoo, what you get from my hand is a link like this:
Af dann simonsen indsendt tirsdag, d. 16. september, 2003 - 13:23:
http://www.watchingyou.com/woowoo.html
22. Refer to anyone who does not immediately agree with you as being uneducated on the matter, lacking in important information, or just plain too stupid to understand your magnificent statements.

dann: You won’t find any attempts from my hand (or anybody else’s, I presume) at trying to treat the astrologers, even theoretically, like the Nazis treated Jews, Gypsies, homosexuals or communists.
When Karen Boesen gets going, however, it isn’t very difficult for her to invent the ‘facts’ that she finds necessary to ‘prove’ that sceptics are very bad people.

Karen Boesen: "It is very difficult for me to understand that for instance Simonsen and CL attend a lecture on astro. They despise us as much as we despise them."

dann: I never attended a lecture on astrology, not even once, nor do I despise astrologers in general (and – in general – they don’t despise me), but I might consider despising those who are so completely unable to distinguish between reality and their own imagination that they probably don’t even know when they are dealing with one or the other. This may not impair you very much as a business astrologer, but it makes it impossible to have a reasonable discussion with these people. Karen Boesen probably knows that I never said anything like this, but since she finds it necessary for the sake of the argument, she feels justified in inventing the kind of quotation that would prove her right.

Karen Boesen: “Both CL and Simonsen were about to be expelled from this skeptic forum because of their way of communication.
But then all the skeptics started to fight each other, and the whole board was closed down. It was extremely funny. All we astrologers leaned back and laughed. Simonsen among others were called " a religious skeptic " etc. etc. They had only allowed CL to be there for so long, because they thought that he was about 20 years old. ( He has passed his forties. )”


dann: The facts in this case are as follows: I actually was banned from the so-called skeptic forum, not because of my ”way of communication”, however, but because I tended to disagree with the moderator/owner of the board, a Satanist posing as a skeptic.
“All the sceptics” never started to fight each other on the board, but the owner did shut it down. Among other things, he called me “an old religious man”. He gave proof to this claim by quoting professors at the University of Copenhagen and their criticism of my book about new-age religions. He was later forced to admit that the alleged quotation, if it existed at all, concerned somebody else. (It was hard not to, since I never wrote a book about this subject!) Nor am I in any way religious, by the way.
Claus was never actually banned from the board, but the moderator often threatened to do so – for the same reason that he banned me, and not because of Claus’ ”way of communication”.
So, Jaymz, it is simply not right when you say that, the less Karen has to work with the better. You cannot possibly put a limit to what Karen Boesen has to work with. Even the sky is not the limit in this case. Being a true astrologer, she is only limited by her imagination.
And I would never consider "trying to beat Karen at her own game", Jaymz. I wouldn’t be able to make up the lies that she is capable of. In the case of the quotation about Toni Haugen, the psychiatrist, I made specific references to the astrologers' board and the word that you can use to find the discussion. You know that I don’t lie, Claus and Mogens know that I don’t lie, but to everybody else, and in particular to Cleo who asked the question, this is probably a very efficient way of raising doubts about the truth of my messages:

"BTW. Reg. the " story " on Simonsen!
You believe that? No problems at all. How strange.
Well I know, what happened and I know that Simonsen is lying.
Did that occur to you at all?
__________________
Karen Boesen



PS Karen Boesen's latest 'fact' about Claus biting a waitress' ankle can be found at Den Røde Tråd: www.astrologforeningen.dk

Af Karen Boesen (kb) indsendt torsdag, d. 19. februar, 2004 - 07:38:
 
dann said:
Jaymz: There is one reason why good behaviour will never serve its purpose in a discussion with people like Karen Boesen: If they have not got an actual quotation that they can use to discredit their opponents, all they have to do is invent one. And they do so, frequently.

I must admit Dann, that the fact that Karen Boesen is already trying to use Jeff Coreys ironic statement to miscredit Claus, really proves your point beyond any doubt.

I didn't realize it before but I understand now that nothing is too low for this woman. I am amazed that a number of Danish astrologers allow themselves to be associated with her.
 
Jaymz said:
I must admit Dann, that the fact that Karen Boesen is already trying to use Jeff Coreys ironic statement to miscredit Claus, really proves your point beyond any doubt.

I explained it to her in Danish, and she had this to say:

Yeah, right. We all know your ability to talk around the issue. Of course you bit the waitress in the ancle, or tried to in your intoxicated state. Don't you think you should try some antabus?

And:

You know what, perhaps I should mention to you that I have had more than one client, who has had very good results from taking - or is taking - the "Sober Alcoholic" cure. Have you tried that? I am not aware of it's real name, but your doctor can probably help you with that.

The presentation is always the same: "Hello, my name is Claus Larsen, I am a sober alcoholic!" It is part of the therapy that you at once admit what you are.

There is more, but she tops it with an allusion to Corey's joke:

How did you get away from it? Overthere, people are very quick to file lawsuits for huge compensations. Was that why you escaped to Denmark, head over heels? You know, a little like Dracula - with the blood dripping out of the mouth.

I don't know if I may be so indiscreet to ask, but: Do you only bite when you have been drinking, or is that something that can come over you at any time?
Source

Karen Boesen will stop at nothing.

Jaymz said:
I didn't realize it before but I understand now that nothing is too low for this woman. I am amazed that a number of Danish astrologers allow themselves to be associated with her.

That is the really sad part. It doesn't matter what any astrologer will do, nobody speaks out against it. They cover for each other, and accept the lies - as long as it is meant to hurt their critics.
 
I've probably missed this somewhere but why won't Karen take the $1M challenge?

So many benefits - the money, the publicity, the 'in your face' to skeptics. Amazing that she won't go for it....
 
Let me adress some of the technical questions, which these business astrologers do not dare to answer.


First of all the question of how to correct a horoscope.


Astrologers often work with two set of birth data :

1) - the official birth hour + day - as registered by the hospital.

2) - the astrological birth data, specifying exactly at what hour the planets did infect the newborn child's brain.

The latter may be estimated by moving the birth hour forth and back, until the horoscope will fit additional data - e.g. year of graduation, year of marriage, etc.

With companies, a common correction point is the first day registered on the stock trade list.

Several amazing results may occur - another Danish business astrologer, Mr Giber (www.giber.dk) once even interchanged the birth order of two twins - in order optimize their horoscopes.

In general - astrologers however disagree on both which data, and which method should be applied during a birth data correction.

In Scandinavia, people prefer the socalled Kündig Correction, other astrologers apply the Kepler or Naibod methods. However - this is not the only controversy.

Astrologers usually divide the horizon into 12 zones - similar to compass directions . House 1 is approximately East - this may vary a bit from hour to hour.

House 10 points to the solar culmination - at Northern latitudes, this means straight South.

Each house has its own meaning - like a monopoly game. House 2 is the house of money. Zodiac sign number 2 was Taurus, so of course, Karen writes :

A company, born in Taurus, is par excellence a company strongly connected to finance. Or should be. The entire banking sector is one example.

This combination is a bit strange, the compass directions say houses are more or less fixed, South is South, all day long. However - the zodiac signs are moving fast - one full rotation within 24 hours.

Connecting the fixed house #2 with a moving zodiac sign #2 is maybe easy to remember - but just as stupid as relating Lions with Lemons, because both objects do start with the same letter "L".

Nevertheless, that is the way business astrologers work.

One more amazing example - house number 8 is the house of Death. The planet Mars in that house will give you a dramatic death, including "sharp metal knifes, etc.."

Zodiac number 8 is the Scorpion, so combining house #8 with zodiac #8 we now understand why Karen did claim that Scorpions often work :

"as Funeral Directors".

In addition, the system of houses poses several internal conflicts. If you ask an astrologer to make a horoscope for your company, please avoid the subsolar latitudes : a company born at + 23.47 Degrees latitude means that the Sun will pass Zenith at noon on June 23.

Zenith is neither South or North, so now it is not possible to adjust the 10th house direction, as a consequence the whole horoscope will fall apart.

Similar problems will happen in case you have a goldmine company in Greenland or Canada - at these latitudes, the first house direction may be missing, and again the house system breaks apart.

To make problems even worse - astrologers do neither agree on where these houses are placed, nor how big these houses are.

If you click here, you will see a comparison of 4 different systems - these systems may even turn upside down if you move to Southern latitudes.

Dean and Mather do mention one astrological congress which tried to solve the discussion on which house system should be applied, however - the conference did end up in one big shouting match... (oh no - not again..)

Maybe the best description of astrological culture was given by ex astrologer Joanna Asmun (1996):

"Astrologers are less literate than average ; they write badly and they read badly; there is almost no critical response; errors are ignored, corrections are not acknowledged. "

"They answer off the top of their heads., (quote from memory) ... and then get sidetracked into arguing about who's a liar... "
Ivan Kelly


As Richard Dawkins wrote :

Astrology is neither harmless nor fun, and we should see it as an enemy of truth.


/ Mogens Winther
 
Karen,

If you are still reading here, please indicate if you are interested in continuing a serious discussion with us or not on this thread.

many thanks
zep
 
CFLarsen said:
MRC_Hans, T'ai Chi,

In a perfect world, you are right. But we are not dealing with honest people here. I personally do not sit back and let lies stand unopposed. That is also what we are here for. Don't we speak out when e.g. Sylvia Browne lies about Randi? When PSI TECH lies about finding missing children?

You bet we do.

Karen shows no inclination to discuss astrology, scientific or otherwise. But her lies and accusations will be met with facts and evidence. I don't find that "sandbox"'ing at all.
Claus, WE can trade blows with you quite happily if we disagree, because we all know how to do it properly. But Karen Boesen and the other astrologers have still to learn these skills. Let them have their say, and allow us at least to "have a cup of coffee with them", before you come down like a Viking. No doubt, any differences in the facts will be sorted out soon enough.
 
Zep said:
Claus, WE can trade blows with you quite happily if we disagree, because we all know how to do it properly. But Karen Boesen and the other astrologers have still to learn these skills. Let them have their say, and allow us at least to "have a cup of coffee with them", before you come down like a Viking. No doubt, any differences in the facts will be sorted out soon enough.
I disagree. Claus is a bit over the top at times, but as our Euro representative of NYASk, we support his efforts to bite the ankles of these fools. And goniffs.
Totally.
 
ZEP:

No, I will not continue the " discussion ". I have learned from the past week that there is too much despise etc. on both sides. Skeptics towards people like myself for instance, who hold a different approach to life from their own.
From my point of view these people are more or less to be compared with the Taleban movement in Afganistan.

But of course there have been exceptions. Like you and Mr. Brown, who seem to be more open-minded that skeptics in general.

Kind regards,

Karen Boesen
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom