Building My Pyramid

Dear Bill ... I recall one time I was in a large, mostly empty, and rather dark room, carefully making my way to the other side where I could see a lighted "EXIT" sign, when the door at the other end of the room opened and two boys (probably no more than six years old) scampered in and headed at full speed to the other side where I was headed. Three quarters of the way there one of them ran headlong into a mobile coat rack. The was an awful crash as boy, coat rack, and hangars all clattered to the ground. And no small amount of crying right after.

The boys in this story--which is true, by the way--made a bad assumption (that the path to the other side was clear) based on incomplete information (lack of light). When they applied the bad assumption to their course of action, one of them had something bad happen to them.

On this forum we apply critical thinking, a set of skills one uses to assist with coming to correct conclusions. We take the slow, careful route, recognizing we are in the dark, trying to avoid accidents (and worse) by questioning assumptions (is the way really clear?) and taking appropriate action (we don't know, best go slowly).

As much as I felt sorry for the kid and his run-in with the coat rack, I was not at all surprised that it happened. Why? Because I recognize that it's dangerous to assume a clear path when you can't see where you're going. This came from having similar accidents myself, probably at a similar age.

What you've encountered here is a group of people who applied some elementary critical thinking skills to your posts (more accurately, to the websites you link to from your website) and found them badly lacking. It happens a lot around here, actually. The non-skeptical ones come running in here full speed and give us a lot of information. The more experienced and skeptical members immediately see where it's headed, and are not the least bit surprised when they immediately uncover stuff that, for us, is really out there.

If you stick around, and look past some of the jibes the more jaded members give out, you may learn a new way of looking at the world. You may be eighty, but you've managed to learn how to use a computer, surf the web, and post to an internet forum. Perhaps, too, you can pick up some critical thinking skills, and improve your life even more.
 
Dear Members,
I have never joined a forum before, I didn't know what they were for. But after a week with you folks I can see...It's a place for you to come, to belittle and make fun of each other. I don't need this. So, I will unsubcribe as soon as I can find the unsubcribe button! Regards: Bill

There is no 'unsubscribe' button. You have a few options. You can choose not to log in again. You can also send a Private Message to the site admins - Darat and Lisa Simpson - asking them to set your account to 'unregistered'.

Forums are for discussion. They are not for advertising, as has already been pointed out to you. If you choose to stay, there are plenty of other discussions going on here that you should choose to join.
 
Bill, I'd just like to second what Blue Mountain has said above (in that I hope you stick around, rather than that I set traps in dark rooms for small boys ;) )

It's usually a good idea to have a bit of a browse through a forum you're thinking of joining, since there are many different kinds of people out there, and birds of a feather tend to stick together in the forum world. This forum is probably the one most like the Monty Python sketch 'no, you came here for an argument', as even the most casual observations come under the spotlight to be dissected.

But, as Blue Mountain rightly says, that's because this particular corner of the internet is mostly populated by those of us who like to put interesting ideas to the test - and since your ideas sound interesting, there's no shortage of people wishing to follow this thread, understand your ideas, and examine them.

There have been many discussions on this forum around ancient Egypt, pyramid building, etc. in the past, so your thread wouldn't be out of place here at all, and I'm sure you could find other topics on here to interest you, since from your website it seems your interests are quite diverse.

And good luck if you don't stick around :)
 
Dear Snow,
You Have hit the nail right on the head!! This is exactly what I have been trying to say all along. The Egyptologists have been trying for hundreds of years to figure out how the pyramids were built and how those huge block were raised to the top.(481 feet). My way, they are always on level ground and can SLIDE them into place. I didn't realize this would be so complicated. If you or sombody had the time to just look at everything about the pyramid, it woulld be explained.

Someone beat you to it with a simpler, less contrived solution.
 
Bill, your internet project is an excellent idea and I am intrigued at the possible upside.

However, as cool as that may be, I have a load of questions about your theories on the pyramids and what evidence you base those theories on. Would you be willing to hang around and, in your spare time, outline you basic ideas and the evidence you feel supports them?

This site is really the perfect place to test out your novel ideas. I guarantee that people here will attack those ideas and test their foundations to see if they are sound. Keep in mind that this is not the same as attacking you personally (well, we try to keep it that way at least). Sound ideas, should any remain, will quickly be seized upon and used to build the theory back up on a solid foundation.

Personally, I think you're really on to something with the internet project idea and I am heartened to know this idea came from a man who has lived the majority of his life outside of the internet age. That just puts another nail the "old dog, new tricks" coffin and holds up hope for many of us old farts. But, having said that, the pyramid theories I can glean from your website appear to be not-too-well-thought-out and I would love to have you stay here and flesh them out.
 
Originally Posted by billnreno
Dear Members,
I have never joined a forum before, I didn't know what they were for. But after a week with you folks I can see...It's a place for you to come, to belittle and make fun of each other. I don't need this. So, I will unsubcribe as soon as I can find the unsubcribe button! Regards: Bill

....sorry, I was just making a little joke....... :(
 
Last edited:
Have you noticed that there are no mountains anywhere near the pyramids? If you have google earth, type in pyramids as the destination, and you will see what I mean.

Geology can tell us whether mountains used to be there. No dice on that one, either.

It's nice to have an idea, but you have to test it against the available evidence.
 
Like Madurobob, I hope you stick around. I really have some engineering quiestions about your idea, and hope you can address them, either directly, or, as your project progresses, through demonstration.

I'm no engineer nor am I a mathematician nor am I a historian or expert on Egypt. On the other hand, as you might guess from my avatar, I have a certain amateur interest in the logistics of moving a lot of dirt.
 
Hey Madurobob and all of you nice people.
Those are the nicest things that you said. I have been working on thiis theory for quite some time. And at eighty I don't have much time left. :-) Bob said that it has possibilities, I have studied everything I could fiind about Building Pyramids. They all say the same thing.'How did they get those huge stones to the top?' Well, I didn't say that this was how, I said that with the technology, material, tools and labor, this is how I would have built one at that point in time! It seems that Bob has looked at the project very close. And I wish some of you others had the time to also look...So it looks like I will stick around awhile, If I don't get Banned. I have been warned about putting links to web sites on my post. later, Regards: Bill
 
Hi, bill.

I'm a archaeologist and I work primarily in the middle east.
So one might say that this subject is in my neck of the woods.

I just wanted to say that the building of the pyramids is not that much of a mystery to modern day scholars.

The remains of ramps have been found at Giza and also the sites from where the stones were quarried.

As regards to the transportation of large objects, we have the Egyptians own account of how this was done (we actually have a wall painting showing the process). Basically they used a large sledge and a lot of manpower.

Don't know if I'm allowed to recommend literature but if so try to read the following books.

E. Hornung: History of ancient Egypt (page 63 will show the transport of a colossal statue)
B Kemp: Ancient Egypt, anatomy of a civilization. (page 131 will show a map of Giza including the ramps and quarries).

Please forgive my rusty english, I'm from Denmark:o
 
Hey Maldon:
Welcome to the forum. It's good to know that we have at least one Archaeologist among us. I am not one. I got interested in building the Pyramids because I am a retired construction carpenter and I have been on some big projects. I have studied this subject quite a bit. One thing I saw was that if they built a ramp with an incline to get the stones to the top. it would have to be 20 miles long and it would take longer to build it than to build the pyramid...I am glad you are here and I hope you also have a pet theory that we can discuss...Later Bill
 
OK. First I'm a layman, so please forgive me if I happen to say something stupid.

One thing I saw was that if they built a ramp with an incline to get the stones to the top. it would have to be 20 miles long and it would take longer to build it than to build the pyramid...
Two things come to my mind:
  1. I suppose they would have had not one long ramp, but shorter ones with stops in between? And you can probably count on it that they were at least able to construct a lever. So, my idea would be to use a system similar to a chain of sluices along a river, in order to overcome the height difference.
  2. It appears to me that the statement "it would take longer to build it than to build the pyramid" is self-refuting. The time to construct the ramp would be part of the total construction time, wouldn't it?
 
Last edited:
Another question that just came to my mind. Was the concept of the pulley known to Egyptians at the time?

Gotta make use of the opportunity to ask an actual archaeologist if one happens to be around. :) Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Bill, if as you say it would take a 20 mile ramp to get the stones to the top of the pyramid, then would it not also require a hillside 20 miles long to get to the top of the hill (assuming, as I believe is the case, that the stones were quarried from elsewhere)? That's a lot of hill to remove and scatter, and it seems to me that this would take longer to do than it would to build a ramp, which after all only has to approach the pyramid from one side, or wrap around it in a spiral fashion.

I think the question of how many people can drag how large a stone up how steep a ramp deserves further clarification. Twenty miles seems excessive.
 
Bill, have you checked out www.theforgottentechnology.com ?

The guy is a retired carpenter, and he and his son move 10-ton blocks of concrete around by hand. There are videos on the site, as well as descriptions of how his system works. He shows how a stair-step like ramp can be used to move large blocks, as well. Also, there are links to other pyramid sites. It's pretty fascinating. His contention is that people 2000 years ago (and more) were aware of simple technologies that we have mostly forgotten, or find incredible, in our mechanized age.
 
Another question that just came to my mind. Was the concept of the pulley known to Egyptians at the time?

Well, they had what we use to call a "proto-pulley". A mushroom shaped stone object with grooves carved over the head that, mounted into a stand of wood, would have guided the ropes for sharpe turns in the direction of the pull.

I think the question of how many people can drag how large a stone up how steep a ramp deserves further clarification. Twenty miles seems excessive.

Tests carried out by the NOVA Pyramid project (they build a pyramid to test the ancient techniques in action, so to speak) showed that 10-12 men could easily pull a 2-ton (2000 kilos) block mounted on a sledge up a ramp with a 6 degree slope.
The workforce of the Khufu pyramid (the biggest one) consisted of 20.000-30.000 people that worked in three month strints and were divided into crews of 20 men each
Other tests have shown that a load of 58-tons can be moved by 172 men.
The main quarry at Giza, form where the majority of the building-stones came, was situated right next to the pyramids.
I'm afraid I can't remember the exact distance:o but the transportation-time for each building block was less than half an hour (also according to the NOVA-tests).

I should of cause give you the opportunity to check my information.
For that purpose I would recommend the book The Complete Pyramids by Mark Lehner.
This contains a much more detailed description of the NOVA-project plus a complete presentation of all the Egyptian pyramids.
It will show the architectural evolution of these complexes and all the errors made in the process.
.
 
None of the pyramid building "estimates" for time spent in building the pyramid have taken into account the "very" important "time alteration" that occurs within the lateral boundaries of the pyramid. It is well known, as everybody has said who has studied the issue, including some very important professors, that time does not actually "flow" at the same rate inside a pyramid. Why do you think the mummies are so well-preserved? So, it takes a "lot" less time to build one, if you are careful to keep "everything" inside the walls as you build, due to this proven effect.

As the snake said to the giraffe, been down so long its all up to me.

Does this make sense?
 
The gentleman from Denmark who said that it was not a mystery how the pyramids were created, is right and wrong too. Anyone can figgure out how the stones at the bottom were laid out, but how did they get the pyramid to align right on the "compass" when supposedly they had no compasses? Also, the top block has been scientifically demonstrated that it cannot be balanced, but balance it does. So, someone had a lot of knowledge, and even today, with all of man's technology, no-one has bullt a pyramid and no-one knows how that top block can possibly be balanced against all the forces of nature.

As the fish said to the fisherman, its not sport to us.

Does that help?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom