Building My Pyramid

I think the whole "top to bottom-theory" originates from a case of reading quotes out of context.
In this case the Histories of Herodotus where it clearly states that "The upper portion of the pyramid was finished first, then the middle, and finally the part which was lowest and nearest the ground".
This quote is then, by some people, taken to mean that pyramid´of Giza was build top to bottom.

But if one reads the whole account of Herodotus concerning the Giza pyramid, then it will be clear that he starts out by stating that the pyramid was build in steps, starting with the placing of the base stones, and then a second course was placed on top of that, and so forth.

Then, as correctly described by Herodotus, the pyramid was finished by placing the cap-stone at the top, and then the builders would have worked their way down the pyramid, placing the outer casing from the top to bottom.
Admittedly speculation on my part, but I think it makes pretty good sense.

My source for this is Wordsworth´s edition of Herodotus Histories.
The part of interest in this case is Book Two, chapter 125, page 170.
Chapters 124 and 126 also deals with pyramid-building and the reign of Cheops.
 
I think the whole "top to bottom-theory" originates from a case of reading quotes out of context.
In this case the Histories of Herodotus where it clearly states that "The upper portion of the pyramid was finished first, then the middle, and finally the part which was lowest and nearest the ground".This quote is then, by some, taken to mean that pyramid´of Giza was build top to bottom.

But if one reads the whole account of Herodotus concerning the Giza pyramid, then it will be clear that he starts out by stating that the pyramid was build in steps, starting with the placing of the base stones, and then a second course was placed on top of that, and so forth.

Then, as correctly described by Herodotus, the pyramid was finished by placing the cap-stone at the top, and then the builders would have worked their way down the pyramid, placing the outer casing from the top to bottom.
Admittedly speculation on my part, but I think it makes pretty good sense.:)

My source for this is Wordsworth´s edition of Herodotus Histories.
The part of interest in this case is Book Two, chapter 125, page 170.
Chapters 124 and 126 also deals with pyramid-building and the reign of Cheops.
 
Well, I do claim to know a thing or two about the subject and I know of no such texts.
None of the pyramids known today has been build the way Bill suggest.
But I don't think that's his claim.
As far as I understand his simulation, the aim is to demonstrate that the Egyptians could have done it "Bill's way".
But they didn't.;)
Dear Members.
I cannot make claims about anything that I can't prove. I am trying to say that I think it is possible to build a pyramid this way. After you have seen the "junk" that I have researched and put on my webSite. then with a little imagination maybe you can also see that, Yes, it could be possible that they built them this way...Consider this, I will be using the mountain instead of ramps and I will also use it as a 'scaffold' for the workers to use, all level no lifting. Just a llittle 'Nudge' and the stones are in place! Thanks for your concern...The above quote from Maldon are my thoughts EXACTLY. Regards: Bill
 
Last edited:
Dear Members.
I cannot make claims about anything that I can't prove. I am trying to say that I think it is possible to build a pyramid this way. After you have seen the "junk" that I have researched and put on my webSite. then with a little imagination maybe you can also see that, Yes, it could be possible that they built them this way...Consider this, I will be using the mountain instead of ramps and I will also use it as a 'scaffold' for the workers to use, all level no lifting. Just a llittle 'Nudge' and the stones are in place! Thanks for your concern...The above quote from Maldon are my thoughts EXACTLY. Regards: Bill
Let's say your simulation is successful, then what? Do you feel you will have proven anything?
 
Let's say your simulation is successful, then what? Do you feel you will have proven anything?
I don't suppose he'll have proven anything, especially since it's only a computer modeling experiment anyway, but if nothing else he might provide another potential way to construct a pyramid that does not require space aliens, irretrievably lost esoteric wisdom, or biblical giants to accomplish.
 
Dear Members.
I cannot make claims about anything that I can't prove. I am trying to say that I think it is possible to build a pyramid this way. After you have seen the "junk" that I have researched and put on my webSite. then with a little imagination maybe you can also see that, Yes, it could be possible that they built them this way...Consider this, I will be using the mountain instead of ramps and I will also use it as a 'scaffold' for the workers to use, all level no lifting. Just a llittle 'Nudge' and the stones are in place! Thanks for your concern...The above quote from Maldon are my thoughts EXACTLY. Regards: Bill
I still don't get it. A mountainside is not level, it is a slope. It is a much steeper slope than the ramp method actually used, unless you go around the mountain...like the ramps did.

The ramp method also did not require lifting (i.e. straight-up lifting, which is what I assume you mean). Just pushing, a little "nudge" up the ramp.

I don't see why you have to simulate your method to prove it's possible. There is nothing out of the realm of possibility in your method as I understand it. It's just that compared to the methods actually used, it's needlessly complicated, horribly inefficient and wasteful. Plus, whether your methods are possible or not, it can readily be shown that your methods were not used in the construction of the pyramids.
 
I don't suppose he'll have proven anything, especially since it's only a computer modeling experiment anyway, but if nothing else he might provide another potential way to construct a pyramid that does not require space aliens, irretrievably lost esoteric wisdom, or biblical giants to accomplish.
Well if we are talking potential ways of construction....how about a simulation that floods the area, and then using barges to float the stones into place?

Seems just as likely as the model Bill's.
 
Well if we are talking potential ways of construction....how about a simulation that floods the area, and then using barges to float the stones into place?

Seems just as likely as the model Bill's.
Better barges than spacecraft, though. I agree that Bill's model is far-fetched and I consider it unrealistic and unnecessary, but it isn't totally barking mad, which in the pyramid world puts it in fairly select company.
 
Well if we are talking potential ways of construction....how about a simulation that floods the area, and then using barges to float the stones into place?

Seems just as likely as the model Bill's.


Now that's a cool theory!

It would also give them a level surface to align each course of stone.
 
I told you guys they used magnets to move the stones what more do you need to know I have spoken .
 
Yes, it could be possible that they built them this way...Consider this, I will be using the mountain instead of ramps and I will also use it as a 'scaffold' for the workers to use, all level no lifting. Just a llittle 'Nudge' and the stones are in place!

Hi Bill, where do the stones come from? Am I right in assuming that they are carved from the virtual mountain from more-or-less the same position as they take in the completed pyramid? Like a sculptor carves away "everything that isn't a horse", you will carve away the mountain to reveal the pyramid?

I still don't understand the "why" of this venture. Sure, you can convince yourself and others that this is one possible way to build a pyramid, but its not a very efficient way and not one for which there is any material evidence in Egypt.

Geologists are quite adept at showing why mountains exist where they do and where mountains have existed in the past that have been whittled away over the eons. Mountains generally come from plates of the earth's crust bumping into each other, or from volcanic activity. I am not aware of any such geological evidence of mountains in the Valley of the Kings nor am I aware of any huge piles of debris that would result from carving a mountain down to a pyramid.

So, while you may be able to prove that a pyramid could have been built this way, you will not be any closer to proving that any of the pyramids in Egypt were actually built this way. For that you will need physical evidence. But, if proving the Egyptian pyramids were built this way is not your goal, then why the pyramid project in the first place?
 
I don't want to make you mad...
Don't worry - I take nothing on this forum personally. You could call me names and I wouldn't get mad.

I need an answer to something that you said...
<snip>
...Is there a certain building 'CODE' that the ancient Egyptain builders had, and if I don't use it then my theory is no good?

Oh, no, of course not. Not that we have codified anywhere at least. They went though a long series of trial-and-error pyramids before they got it right. One earlier pyramid even changes pitch half-way up because they realized the slope they had chosen would be unstable given their construction techniques up to that point.

The point is that we have real physical evidence for their construction techniques. We have contemporary hieroglyphs showing sleds and barges moving large stones, we have remains of ramps and sled tracks, etc... Your theory is interesting, but there is no physical evidence to support it. Its not much different than me claiming that the ancient Egyptians used helicopters, and then building a pyramid using a helicopter as "proof". My helicopter theory would only hold water if remains of an ancient helicopter were found in Egypt.
 
I told you guys they used magnets to move the stones what more do you need to know I have spoken .

I wish. How cool would that be?

The ancient Egyptians were as much concerned with conquering their neighbors as any empire. If they had a plentiful supply of powerful magnets capable of moving massive boulders surely their first application would have been in the military, not in pyramid construction.

Ahh, "The Great Magnet Warriors of the Nile"! That would have been a way cooler movie than "The Greatest Story Ever Told".
 
Now that's a cool theory!

It would also give them a level surface to align each course of stone.
*lol* thanks :)

Building a canal (from the quarry), flooding and containing the building area, building the locks necessary (to raise the barges as the pyramid got taller), building the barges necessary, etc. would have been within their technical abilities.

However, I think the shear enormity of doing it this way would have been beyond them (in my opinion).

Maybe Bill can build another simulation based on this.
 
Dear Members
We have 6 pages on this topic, and on almost every one I have stated. 'I am not saying that this is the way the Pyramids of Giza were built. I said that with the technology, material and labor this is how I would have built ONE at that point in time' Let someone with their little spacecraft go through the post and count the times I wrote this. :-) I am puzzled at why this is so hard to understand. True, I am not an educated person. I was born in Arkansas so maybe I write in 'Hillbilly' and no one can read it! :-). Regards: Bill


,
 
Dear Members
We have 6 pages on this topic, and on almost every one I have stated. 'I am not saying that this is the way the Pyramids of Giza were built. I said that with the technology, material and labor this is how I would have built ONE at that point in time' Let someone with their little spacecraft go through the post and count the times I wrote this. :-) I am puzzled at why this is so hard to understand. True, I am not an educated person. I was born in Arkansas so maybe I write in 'Hillbilly' and no one can read it! :-). Regards: Bill


,

Well, then my only question is how would you build one if there were no mountains anywhere in sight?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom