chrismohr
Master Poster
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2011
- Messages
- 2,080
Two things Ergo said here are flat out wrong.Wrong. Read the OP. A lot of these have nothing to do with the NIST reports. Just glancing over, I am guessing that none of these actually support the current NIST collapse hypothesis.
This propensity of 9/11 bedunkers to assume some kind of mysterious majority on the subject was also dealt with here, with their same embellished list of supposedly expert, but in fact largely unrelated papers.
However, nomasters, there probably are some a & e's who would claim to support the NIST reports. But we have never seen any of them post here, for example, using their real names and presenting credible arguments.
Tony Szamboti says he doesn't know a single engineer who has actually looked into this who still supports the official reports. And we see here on this forum too, posters who call themselves engineers also are rejecting both the Bazant and the NIST WTC collapse explanations.
So it's no secret that the NIST reports are seriously flawed. Very few working engineers have time to examine them, let alone take on such a controversial issue. It unfortunately becomes controversial for the very reason that NIST, the standard bearing agency of the U.S. government, has published something -- under their name -- that is scientifically questionable. I would think this can make things very uncomfortable for those in related professions.
1) NIST people told me personally that a) fireproofing of steel beams is being improved 2) the long-span trusses are not being used in the new codes due to the dangers of thermal expansion.
2) It's true that many of the journal articles in here do not specifically refer to the collapse mechanisms themselves. However, those articles that somehow relate to the 9/11 catastrophe accept the premise of natural collapse due to fires, weakening steel, and gravitational momentum. Not one of them assumes any kind of controlled demolition. If they did they would state it, and the papers would not be about the same subjects at all. They would be meaningless as written if their starting points were with the assumption of controlled demolition.
There are many, many articles published in journals in my list that specifically show some aspect of the natural collapse scenario; in fact, some of these articles predated the NIST Report but all taken together they show a continuity of cultivation and refining of the natural collapse theory. To say that there is no support for the NIST Report when every national structual engineering association in the world has stated their support for the major findings of the NIST Report is absurd.
I await response, I think I have more than met the origional challenge of this thread.
Last edited: