Brian Good Challenge: Name one independent architect or engineer who agrees with NIST

Wrong. Read the OP. A lot of these have nothing to do with the NIST reports. Just glancing over, I am guessing that none of these actually support the current NIST collapse hypothesis.

This propensity of 9/11 bedunkers to assume some kind of mysterious majority on the subject was also dealt with here, with their same embellished list of supposedly expert, but in fact largely unrelated papers.

However, nomasters, there probably are some a & e's who would claim to support the NIST reports. But we have never seen any of them post here, for example, using their real names and presenting credible arguments.

Tony Szamboti says he doesn't know a single engineer who has actually looked into this who still supports the official reports. And we see here on this forum too, posters who call themselves engineers also are rejecting both the Bazant and the NIST WTC collapse explanations.

So it's no secret that the NIST reports are seriously flawed. Very few working engineers have time to examine them, let alone take on such a controversial issue. It unfortunately becomes controversial for the very reason that NIST, the standard bearing agency of the U.S. government, has published something -- under their name -- that is scientifically questionable. I would think this can make things very uncomfortable for those in related professions.
Two things Ergo said here are flat out wrong.

1) NIST people told me personally that a) fireproofing of steel beams is being improved 2) the long-span trusses are not being used in the new codes due to the dangers of thermal expansion.

2) It's true that many of the journal articles in here do not specifically refer to the collapse mechanisms themselves. However, those articles that somehow relate to the 9/11 catastrophe accept the premise of natural collapse due to fires, weakening steel, and gravitational momentum. Not one of them assumes any kind of controlled demolition. If they did they would state it, and the papers would not be about the same subjects at all. They would be meaningless as written if their starting points were with the assumption of controlled demolition.

There are many, many articles published in journals in my list that specifically show some aspect of the natural collapse scenario; in fact, some of these articles predated the NIST Report but all taken together they show a continuity of cultivation and refining of the natural collapse theory. To say that there is no support for the NIST Report when every national structual engineering association in the world has stated their support for the major findings of the NIST Report is absurd.

I await response, I think I have more than met the origional challenge of this thread.
 
Last edited:
...
Someone please confirm, but I don't believe Tony is a licensed engineer.
...

Correct. Tony Sz. is not on the NJ or PA rosters of licensed Professional Engineers, nor does he or AE911Truth claim he is.

He is still a degreed and (afaik) practicing mechanical engineer.

...
Tony Szamboti says he doesn't know a single engineer who has actually looked into this who still supports the official reports. ...

Tony Sz. also says he has talked to many engineers in his region and showed them his "evidence". Fact is: There is no evidence that he has convinced even one single civil or structural engineer - none from his home state of New Jersey gave their name to that crap petition.
 
First of all...I'm a licensed Structural Engineer that has taken the time to read the NIST reports front to back, and feel they are still the best explanation for the collapse of WTC buildings on 9/11. Are the NIST reports perfect? of course not. Are the NIST reports seriously flawed? No...that's truther BS and lies.

BTW...I know of hundreds (yes, hundreds) of structural engineers who understand and support the findings of the NIST reports.

Additionally, I have communicated directly with Tony Szamboti (thru email), when I reviewed his computer model for building 7. He knows I have read and support the findings of the NIST reports. So he knows of at least one engineer who has looked into this issue and still supports the NIST reports.

Someone please confirm, but I don't believe Tony is a licensed engineer.

Ergo…I’m still waiting for a truther to post one credible argument...but we are still a big fat zero in that department.

If Tony is a member of the AIA then we can discount his statements.
 
And for the umpteenth time, building codes, with the exception of obvious fireproofing and egress improvements, have largely not changed as a result of the NIST reports.

Well, obviously the fireproofing and egress improvements.

But apart from that, what have the Romans ever done for us?

:D
 
2) It's true that many of the journal articles in here do not specifically refer to the collapse mechanisms themselves. However, those articles that somehow relate to the 9/11 catastrophe accept the premise of natural collapse due to fires, weakening steel, and gravitational momentum. Not one of them assumes any kind of controlled demolition. If they did they would state it, and the papers would not be about the same subjects at all. They would be meaningless as written if their starting points were with the assumption of controlled demolition.

Yup. IMO there is a HUGE difference between disagreement with collapse mechanisms and agreement that fire and damage didn't bring the buildings down, which is why I find ergo and some others' arguments interesting but absolutely irrelevant to this subforum. And, IMO disagreements with collapse mechanisms aren't worth my spending my tax money on a "new investigation into 9-11".
 
Last edited:
It already is over 50 percent. Way over.

Look, if you poll a hundred people in the USA on whether the sky is blue and all of them give you the same answer, that's pretty good evidence that the majority of people in the USA agree on that answer. It doesn't matter that 100 is only a tiny percentage of the US population.

Likewise, if you have 1830 independent architects and engineers on record as disagreeing with the NIST report and 0 on record as supporting it, that's a pretty darn good indication of general agreement in the architecture and engineering communities.

Still waiting for that one name.

It looks like we can add statistical sampling to the long list of things nomasters doesn't understand. My guess would be that he also has nobachelors and nohighschooldiploma.
 
I'm here. I have previously provided evidence of my professional credentials to the mods, including ARB and RIBA details, and can do so again if required.


As a forum mod, I can confirm that Architect has indeed provided the detailed evidence described.

(Now awaiting a challenge to prove I really am a mod...)
 
I hear Dinwar will add that blue mod thing to your title for $20 and a carton of pall malls
 
As a forum mod, I can confirm that Architect has indeed provided the detailed evidence described.

(Now awaiting a challenge to prove I really am a mod...)

I believe you title is "moderator" and not "mod".

/idiot truther semantics
 
Why is this so hard for you guys? Shouldn't you be able to find somebody who is well known in his or her field, maybe from a university or a reputable firm, who has publicly presented evidence before a board of competent professionals for peer review? If not, why not? Could it be that nobody is willing to jeopardize their professional reputation by supporting something that they - and all of their colleagues - know is a sham?
 
Yup!

Just like my daughter does after playing a game with me, storms off claiming she's won, even if she did not.

My son insists on replaying the game until he can win. (seems like another troofer tactic, though they will never win. :D)
 
No, this is not true. You can support the findings and conclusion of something while pointing out a punctuation or grammar error. What you can't do is say "Well, I generally support the NIST findings.... except for the sagging trusses pulling in the columns bit," because that was the entire purpose of the report.
And anybody making such a statement would, of course, need to be an utter moron.

To find out WHY the buildings collapsed. If the WHY of it is wrong, you can't say "sure, but I support the rest of it." That's invalid.
The problem for you lot is that that was precisely the final blow to the structural integrity of ther towers.

And for the umpteenth time, building codes, with the exception of obvious fireproofing and egress improvements, have largely not changed as a result of the NIST reports.

What the **** else did they need to change to protect human lives?
 
Hi Brian,

Have you not responded to my long post with literally hundreds of people and articles etc in support of the natural collapse theory because you are so happy to have gotten a really solid answer to your question? Or was it a challenge not a question? Are you happy with the list I provided you? Let me know I await your thank-you or other response.
 
Hi Brian,

Have you not responded to my long post with literally hundreds of people and articles etc in support of the natural collapse theory because you are so happy to have gotten a really solid answer to your question? Or was it a challenge not a question? Are you happy with the list I provided you? Let me know I await your thank-you or other response.

So Chris...you believe nomasters could be everyone's favor internet truther Brian "snug bug" Good. I will admit, the thought crossed my mind.

Have you met Brian in person? If so, is he as intense and nutty as he comes across on the internet?

MHM
 
So Chris...you believe nomasters could be everyone's favor internet truther Brian "snug bug" Good. I will admit, the thought crossed my mind.

Have you met Brian in person? If so, is he as intense and nutty as he comes across on the internet?

MHM
"Brian Good Challenge" is the name of this thread so I assumed nomasters was Brian Good, but no I haven't met him. So it's "nomasters" I am asking for a response from, whether he happens to be Brian or not! I haven't met either Brian OR nomasters as far as I know.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom