Book: A Christian Sceptic's Conversation With Atheists

Opening Paragraphs

`But I don't want to go among mad people,' Alice remarked.

`Oh, you can't help that,' said the Cat: `we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad.'

`How do you know I'm mad?' said Alice.

`You must be,' said the Cat, `or you wouldn't have come here.'
~ Alice in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll


An Introduction​

A Chance Meeting

I happened upon a certain internet forum by chance. I had been watching Phenomenon, a reality series starring the stage magician Criss Angel and the self-proclaimed psychic Uri Geller, and as I surfed the web reading about the show I came upon a forum dedicated to skeptics. For quite a few years I had been playing around mentally with an observation I had made about Faith Healers. I had watched a magic act at a fair and saw the magician use many of the same hand gestures, suggestions and he even created many of the same results – except he did all this in the name of entertainment and not in the name of God.
The question I posted on this internet forum was this:
Hi,

I'm sure you've seen those faith healers on TBN who do what they call "slaying in the spirit". It is where they touch someone on the forehead and they fall over.
Well - a few years ago I was at the state fair and saw a hypnotist. He used the exact same motions and techniques (minus any prayers). He touched them on the forehead in the exact same manner and they fell over (that is - those that got hypnotized)
Has anyone else seen any similarities? Has there ever been studies done on this? I am not completely sure how hypnotism works - can they be doing hypnotism techniques without knowing it?

Special Request: Please don't start posting your opinions on why Christianity is wrong because of fake faith healers, how these people are mean, dishonest, etc. This will only distract from this discussion. My concern in this post isn't those aspects of faith healing but rather
what technique they may be using.

Peace!

I had already been lurking for a few days on the forum, had taken part in a discussion on the home page and had seen how easy it was for a discussion to get sidetracked. The responses I got surprised me. They started out saying they agreed, but then some posters moved into questioning why I wasn’t skeptical of hypnotism and by post #13 descended into claims that my wife was highly suggestible, willingly playing along, or she was probably a liar. That was when I knew I had stumbled into unfamiliar territory for me – a virtual land that I felt a curious interest in and a compelling need to explore more of.
 
I'm offended!
You never sent me a quote to approve!
That means I am not in your book!

No fame for poor [X], it seems.


Oh well, best of luck to you, and congratulations on seeing it through. ;)

Cheers
(the first three lines of this post are in jest)

You're in their [X]! I PM'd you some info.
 
Last edited:
I"ll look forward to read your book and $9,95 is nothing. I'll order it the next time I buy some more books from Amazon, I still need The Order of the Stick, Volume 2: No Cure for the Paladin Blues by Rich Burlew and it is very hard to get in Europe.
 
You're in their X! I PM'd you some info.


Awesome!

I was aware I said yes. And I did suspect that you only PM'd the conditionals.
But your post made it sound otherwise.

Hooray, I'm famous (through an anonymous internet handle)!

I might have to buy a copy.
 
Awesome!

I was aware I said yes. And I did suspect that you only PM'd the conditionals.
But your post made it sound otherwise.

Hooray, I'm famous (through an anonymous internet handle)!

I might have to buy a copy.

Here are the people who gave me confirmed YES's. Not all of them were outright quoted though.

YES
godless dave
Beth
Tricky
neltana
The Atheist
UnrepenrtantSinner
DOC
Kahalachan
Marquis de Carabas
fuelair
That guy
Michael C
[X]

Not everyone who said YES was quoted though. I'll be sending you all a PM shortly.
 
When did you decide to write a book? Before you started posting here, or after?
 
Ok ordered.
I went and saw Hancock too, so I'm bad already. Yeah I'm a sucker patron, for supporting aspiring writers and artists. :)

Amazon says it will arrive around Aug 4th, when I will hopefully be lazily kayaking on the Colorado river near Moab.
 
'pop'

Ok I'm back from a short Moab area vacation. The Colorado River rafting was fun but we only got to do the 'Daily' (mostly a float trip) and were disappointed in not getting to a second day of class 3 and 4 rapids in 'Westwater Canyon'. Turns out that there was a mixup in the schedule and we missed that trip but NOT MY FAULT.
Got our money back though.
Sigh... nobody's ever gonna believe it was not my fault.

Book's here. Good ol' Amazon.
 
I bought the book and have read about half of it. I have to commend A Christian Skeptic on doing his best to capture the true feeling of the conversations he's had with atheists here. Part of the reason for that is that a majority of the book (the first half at least) is simply excised from our posts here. He has not edited the posts to change their meaning at all, as far as I can tell.

But the great strength of the book is also a weakness. It reads very much like one of our long religious discussion posts here. Indeed, you could get much of the book simply by reading the threads he has thoughtfully provided the links for like this one:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=101143

It doesn't include nearly enough commentary from him on what his impressions of the comments by atheists. I would have preferred a bit more "compare and contrast with Christian beliefs," and perhaps an enjoinment to the readers for more understanding of each other. Perhaps that comes in the second half.

I'll update this review when I finish the book.
 
Glad the book is arriving. I'm mailing out some more to a few people here and to some magazines. (Some Christian and Atheist magazines.)
 
It doesn't include nearly enough commentary from him on what his impressions of the comments by atheists. I would have preferred a bit more "compare and contrast with Christian beliefs,"

The target audience is Christians (particulary Christians who do not know any Atheists except what they hear from their peers) - so what I attempted to do (and hopefully accomplished) was to allow Atheists explain themselves in their own words. A Christian reading it already knows what they believe and will be contrasting their beliefs with what the Atheists are saying. (And as you know - their are many, many variations amongst Christian beliefs) I definitely do in later chapters post my own views and some conclusions I came to.

I'll have to wait to see if anything changes for you with the second half of the book before I comment further.

Thanks, though, for taking the time to read it.
 
Maybe I'm a bit of an old fogey, but one of the things I think is so awesome about living now is that people can publish books on Amazon or videos on YouTube or whatever to get their message out. I think there is great hope for a world that communication and publishing of ideas has become so accessible.

So I bought the book and even paid the shipping. Normally I would put this away till I found $25 worth of stuff, but this is my low reading season. :)

I do have some professional experience as an editor and writer, but mostly technical stuff. I can proudly say my emails are sometimes ignored or discarded by thousands of people.

Technical Comments

I sometimes judge a book by its cover; not completely mind you, but if it's an interesting book why not have an engaging cover?

'Conservation with Atheists' looks a bit like an old programming or computer book. The text on the screen is not computer text which gives it a pre-computer age 'retro' look. The rear cover is difficult to read and should probably have been white text on the darker background.

For Christian books I would avoid anything on the cover that can be easily divided into 666 or 616. The 33K resistors(?) on the rear cover are probably asking for trouble.

You might look up a book by a Quaker named Chuck Fager: 'Without Apology' (Kimo Press) - just for technical layout not content. This is a small distribution book that is presumably self-published. IMHO Quakers tend to bring a nice simplicity to things that is worth some study. In Chuck's book he uses only a single serif-font family and relies on the family italics, bolding, and spacing to provide an easy to read format. He could have used a more open font like Garamond, but is otherwise simple and easy to read. I can recommend the example.

I find shifting between sans and serif fonts to be a little harder to read. Just my advice, but keep to one font family.

Your page 75 is a good example of something I had trouble reading because of the mixture of fonts.
 
I finished the book this afternoon but will post a few comments, probably mostly of a technical nature rather than on content. I'm removing my little stickies as I go. :)


Not completely disagreeing with Tricky, but I liked the personal flavor and introduction of first few pages (1-13).

I don't really like the word "amongst" and prefer the simpler "among".

On page 11:

"I also came to appreciate the diversity of thoughts and opinions amongst them."

I would have rendered:

"I came to appreciate the diversity of thought and opinion among them".

This may sound like advice I don't keep, but using the word "In" to start a paragraph is an indication that it could probably be written more clearly.

Page 11, paragraph 3:

"In addition to chronicling and preserving these discussions and..."

Might be rendered:

"By chronicling and preserving..."

That would change it a little, but in favor of brevity and clarity. Just IMHO.

You introduced an idea on page 10 that I like, an artistic idea called 'negative space' in English. This is also known as "Ma". Good starting comment:

"Knowing what something isn't is the best way to learn about what something is."

Page 15
The Weak Atheist - Strong Atheist descriptions were not invented here, but are just common use. Might be Michael Shermer. Might look into to it and ascribe properly.

Same page: I'm pretty sure that the word "agnostic" was first coined by a friend of Darwin's named Huxley in the mid 1800's.

Page 42 - the information from Stark was interesting.

Page 63 - on Quantum Mechanics. I tend to agree with you, except that I would have concluded that free will and 'God' were incompatible ideas. If we really have free will how can God possibly know the outcome? This is a fairly deep question on the notion of 'revelation'. I agree that atheists tend to have a fixation on determinism that I fail to appreciate the value.

Chapter 6 - Honestly, I haven't really followed some of your threads here. I like science but it is pretty easy for it to go over my head. As I see it, from a lay-person's pov, it comes down nicely to the Biblical passage: "With God, all things are possible". This very statement seems "anti-science", and pits your beliefs against scientific progress. Science does what it does by saying that all things are NOT possible. 'Truth' to science, is not based on authority but is a regulative principle.

I think I understand the point you are trying to make on page 45. Theistic evolution could be possible but you would need to address why that is not like 'giving up' and ceasing exploration because God did it.

Chapter 7 - Did Jesus exist? I thought you laid out your case well. Historians I've met seem a little wacky to me though, so I am not as convinced as I might be otherwise.

A question that might be closer to the mark is 'if Jesus were alive today and read an account of himself, would he realize it was about him?'

Page 49 - I know atheists tend to rave about 'Gödel Esher Bach' I tried to finish Hofstadter's book and frankly, could not finish it. The zen koan was not helpful to me understanding your point.

As I see it, God is like this: Suppose 'I knew it all', and wanted to put everything about the universe in a book. So I write a book. But the book is incomplete, because it cannot describe itself. So I write a new book, and include a mention of the first book about everything in the universe. Oops. I did it again. Anyway, the idea of God is like this process. Without stepping outside the universe we cannot write a book that includes everything. I'm just saying, that although we may not be able to prove there is a God or not, it has been shown that the IDEA of God is a mathematical construction.


Page 83
"The dim light they live by is sufficing just fine, and until they need something brighter, they'll be content."

I realize your audience is Christians and this might offend some atheists. What I think is that if a believer honestly "gets the point" of atheists, they become one. It is a bit like your negative space idea you started with. An atheist sees the 'lamp', the 'face', and understands that they are both part of a greater whole. Likewise, atheism is such a realization.

Page 84
"...I realized a great difference between atheists and theists. Theists view things as what they are and more - everything seems to have a tint of something above and beyond what it is. Atheists don't."

I'm not sure if I would be offended by this or not, but it seems to be something called a 'hasty generalization'. As an atheist might say, 'we are cool with the garden as it is - it does not need magical fairies too.' (paraphrased, sorry)

I did look up and read the sermon on 'Justice' by McDonald. I do not generally find Christian apologetics very interesting or helpful, but your intended audience might.

Justice is a kind of harmony or balance, it needs a God to explain it as much as we need a God to appreciate a flower or sunset.
 
Finished the book last night. I scribbled some notes but don't have them with me, so I'll just make some general impressions.

It is quite true that ACS has had a good bit of vituperation aimed in his direction since he has been here, although not nearly as much as would have occurred had he not been unfailingly polite and non-combative. He also speaks favorably of quite a few members here, myself included, for which I am grateful. He counterbalances that, though, with a lot of generalizations about atheists, many of which are less than complimentary. Of course, there are good reasons, as listed above, why he might feel oppressed by "atheists in general".

But I have to say that overall, I am a little bit disappointed in the book. It seems to be more like continuation of his posts rather than an anthropological quest into the strange village of Atheists. There is not much of an instructive nature in his writing about how Christians might structure their interactions with atheists.

The first appendix is a complete mystery. It seems completely unrelated to the book at all, and appears to be more of an exercise in establishing his credentials as a Christian so that other Christians won't think he is a mole.

The second appendix is rather annoying. He suggests an interesting topic, decries his treatment by atheists, then says essentially "read this link" rather than discussing the topic. Perhaps he was in a hurry to go to press, but this sort of thing is distressingly similar to the kind of cut-and-paste "discussion" used by people who deserve a lot less respect than ACS does. I was disappointed.

All in all, it was an interesting read for those who like this kind of forum discussion. He has collected numerous interesting quotes by such forum luminaries as Tricky, and some incidental others. It is not, I would expect, particularly illuminating either for Atheists to understand Christians or Christians to understand atheists. It doesn't really have a message. It's more of a journal. But it is a fairly interesting journal, and the short time it takes you to read it won't be wasted.
 
"The dim light they live by is sufficing just fine, and until they need something brighter, they'll be content."

I realize your audience is Christians and this might offend some atheists.

I'll have to wait from some feedback from Christians since this sentence was directed at them and is in the context of - "Don't be unfairly critical (or frustrated) when an atheist is happy with their non-belief." :)

Page 84
"...I realized a great difference between atheists and theists. Theists view things as what they are and more - everything seems to have a tint of something above and beyond what it is. Atheists don't."

I'm not sure if I would be offended by this or not, but it seems to be something called a 'hasty generalization'. As an atheist might say, 'we are cool with the garden as it is - it does not need magical fairies too.' (paraphrased, sorry)
.

This is the only spot in the entire book where I (at least knowlingly - See response to Tricky below) used a generalization on all atheists. It's one mans opinion - the conclusion I came to when I was reflecting on the ease of communicating certain ideas with other Theists (be they Pagan or Christian) then with Atheists. As shown in the paragraphs before this quote.

This is the one spot I did feel an atheist would definitely disagree with me on. :)

Thanks for taking the time to give your thoughts Kopji.
 
OK. Second attempt at posting. The database went nuts there for a second and I lost the first attempt. :(

He also speaks favorably of quite a few members here, myself included, for which I am grateful. He counterbalances that, though, with a lot of generalizations about atheists, many of which are less than complimentary. Of course, there are good reasons, as listed above, why he might feel oppressed by "atheists in general".

I was very conscious of not apply a generalization on all atheists and so I often tried to show the differing views of atheists. (If Christians take anything away I hope they take the knowledge that Atheists are not all the same.)

There is only one spot I know I applied a generalization to all atheists and that was in the last chapter. But it's the opinion I came to when reflecting on how it is often easier to explain certain ideas to Theists (whether they are Christian or Pagan) then with Atheists. It's my honest opinion and I don't expect atheists to agree with me there. :)


But I have to say that overall, I am a little bit disappointed in the book. It seems to be more like continuation of his posts rather than an anthropological quest into the strange village of Atheists. There is not much of an instructive nature in his writing about how Christians might structure their interactions with atheists.

....

It's more of a journal. But it is a fairly interesting journal, and the short time it takes you to read it won't be wasted.

A journal might be more accurate then an anthropological quest. (Although it is my own way of studying certain humans ... ) I see it as a preservation of some great discussions I had with some insights I had for myself. My hope is other Christians can use these discussions to arrive at their own insights (even if they are different then mine.)

The first appendix is a complete mystery. It seems completely unrelated to the book at all, and appears to be more of an exercise in establishing his credentials as a Christian so that other Christians won't think he is a mole.

There is a footnote in the first chapter referencing this (as optional) in the section where I briefly explain how I had just gone through some soul-searching, if you will, where I came to the belief that God is the Father of all. You may not realize this, and I didn't until after I came to this belief (I left my old church because my belief was in conflict with what they said I had to believe), that apparently not all Christians believe this or even like that thought. I felt it was important to show Christians, regardless of whether they agree with me, that these beliefs aren't simply a whim. I've thought about them and they do determine how I view other people - including the atheists I talk with throughout the rest of the book.

The second appendix is rather annoying. He suggests an interesting topic, decries his treatment by atheists, then says essentially "read this link" rather than discussing the topic. Perhaps he was in a hurry to go to press, but this sort of thing is distressingly similar to the kind of cut-and-paste "discussion" used by people who deserve a lot less respect than ACS does. I was disappointed.

I had a whole chapter on this, but no matter what I wrote I felt I couldn't do this topic Justice. (Get it?) I figured I'd let George MacDonald speak for himself. His writing was way to long to include in the book, but to important of a text to me to simply delete. I compromised by including a link in the Appendix. :)

All in all, it was an interesting read for those who like this kind of forum discussion. He has collected numerous interesting quotes by such forum luminaries as Tricky, and some incidental others. It is not, I would expect, particularly illuminating either for Atheists to understand Christians or Christians to understand atheists. It doesn't really have a message.

I don't expect atheists (at least those here) to learn much new. But it's my hope some Christians will. And I think you'll be pleasantly surprised that the few who have read it seem to be telling me things like "Wow. I didn't realize atheists thought that." or "I really could relate to that atheists concern. I sometimes feel the same way." And hopefully with that new knowledge they can empathize more with those with different beliefs or no beliefs when they meet them.

I need to get some more reviews from Christians. When I get them I'll post them or link to them here.

Thanks for posting. I appreciate it.
 
Last edited:
I was very conscious of not apply a generalization on all atheists and so I often tried to show the differing views of atheists. (If Christians take anything away I hope they take the knowledge that Atheists are not all the same.)
Funny how that stuff will sneak in when you're not looking. When I get the book in front of me again, I'll give you some examples.

There is only one spot I know I applied a generalization to all atheists and that was in the last chapter. But it's the opinion I came to when reflecting on how it is often easier to explain certain ideas to Theists (whether they are Christian or Pagan) then with Atheists. It's my honest opinion and I don't expect atheists to agree with me there. :)
Oh, I don't disagree with you at all. I think it probalby is more difficult to explain certain ideas to atheists because when you explain metaphysical concepts, one of the first big assumptions of the explanation is that the metaphysical exists. With atheists, since they tend to be physicalists, you will have a hard time getting over this stumbling block. Now if your prefaced your explanation with "Assume for the sake of the discussion that magic exists," then you might have an easier time.

A journal might be more accurate then an anthropological quest. (Although it is my own way of studying certain humans ... ) I see it as a preservation of some great discussions I had with some insights I had for myself. My hope is other Christians can use these discussions to arrive at their own insights (even if they are different then mine.)
Yeah, I sometimes cut and paste whole threads into documents so I won't lose them. As far as other Christians using them, well, I'm not sure it's the right format for that. Whenever you read a transcript of someone else's discussion/debate, it is extremely frustrating to not be able to pipe in with your own observations. That is what is great about a forum. It doesn't translate so well to the page.

But I felt that you didn't throw out enough "questions for discussion" to the Christians who might be reading your book. That would have made it much more difficult to write but, in my opinion, more likely to achieve your goals.

There is a footnote in the first chapter referencing this (as optional) in the section where I briefly explain how I had just gone through some soul-searching, if you will, where I came to the belief that God is the Father of all. You may not realize this, and I didn't until after I came to this belief (I left my old church because my belief was in conflict with what they said I had to believe), that apparently not all Christians believe this or even like that thought. I felt it was important to show Christians, regardless of whether they agree with me, that these beliefs aren't simply a whim. I've thought about them and they do determine how I view other people - including the atheists I talk with throughout the rest of the book.
That's essentially what I said. You were establishing your credentials as a Christian and describing your current view of Christianity. I think you could have done so in a paragraph or two without going into all the biblical citations. For me, it read like you were apologizing to other Christians for being A Christian Skeptic.

I had a whole chapter on this, but no matter what I wrote I felt I couldn't do this topic Justice. (Get it?) I figured I'd let George MacDonald speak for himself. His writing was way to long to include in the book, but to important of a text to me to simply delete. I compromised by including a link in the Appendix. :)
IMO, you should have gritted your teeth and left it out, rather than saying, "Here's another question that needs to be addressed, but I'm not going to talk about it." References are fine, but when the reference is all there is, well, it's a bit sloppy.

I don't expect atheists (at least those here) to learn much new. But it's my hope some Christians will. And I think you'll be pleasantly surprised that the few who have read it seem to be telling me things like "Wow. I didn't realize atheists thought that." or "I really could relate to that atheists concern. I sometimes feel the same way." And hopefully with that new knowledge they can empathize more with those with different beliefs or no beliefs when they meet them.
I certainly hope that is true. I fear your audience is going to be limited to Christians who, like you, believe that it is all right to question your faith. I am not sure there are enough of them to make your book a best-seller.:D

Sadly, I see more of them that lie closer to the "BibleForums" attitude of not wanting to hear opposing viewpoints. But of course, each Christian (like each atheist) is different.

I need to get some more reviews from Christians. When I get them I'll post them or link to them here.

Thanks for posting. I appreciate it.
I look forward to it. Feel free to copy or link my reviews as well.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I sometimes cut and paste whole threads into documents so I won't lose them. As far as other Christians using them, well, I'm not sure it's the right format for that. Whenever you read a transcript of someone else's discussion/debate, it is extremely frustrating to not be able to pipe in with your own observations. That is what is great about a forum. It doesn't translate so well to the page.

Hey - maybe some will come here and take part in the discussions!

But I felt that you didn't throw out enough "questions for discussion" to the Christians who might be reading your book. That would have made it much more difficult to write but, in my opinion, more likely to achieve your goals.

Never thought of making it a study with some questions at the end of a chapter or something. I know those are all the rage these days with many Christians. Maybe if there's some actual interest with other Christians then I can make the Small Group Study Edition. :)

IMO, you should have gritted your teeth and left it out, rather than saying, "Here's another question that needs to be addressed, but I'm not going to talk about it." References are fine, but when the reference is all there is, well, it's a bit sloppy.

I just couldn't. :)


I certainly hope that is true. I fear your audience is going to be limited to Christians who, like you, believe that it is all right to question your faith. I am not sure there are enough of them to make your book a best-seller.:D

Sadly, I see more of them that lie closer to the "BibleForums" attitude of not wanting to hear opposing viewpoints. But of course, each Christian (like each atheist) is different.

I sincerely hope you're not right. (and not because of the not being a best-seller thought. :) )
 
Thanks, I did enjoy reading, but I don't disagree with Tricky.

It was a little hard for me to imagine the target audience. Any major religion encompasses a wide diversity of thought. I was left wondering what kind of Christian a 'Universalist Evangelical' might include.

It is not so astounding that atheists also have wide diversity. The diversity btw, probably includes members of nearly all religions. Godlessness does not mean that someone is a critical thinker or unaccepting of irrational beliefs.

Being self described as a Universalist, my casual first impression of you (ACS) would be of a more 'liberal' Christian. The religious language in the book surprised me though, I associate it with more conservative or traditional Christianity. This might contribute to questions of self-honesty from atheists or Christians.

A specific example would be the references to God as a 'heavenly father' figure rather than the more neutral "heavenly parent". A general 'liberal' principle is that we should view something from many perspectives; take into account the concerns of many sides, rather than one side that is promoted as the 'right' side.

A more liberal viewpoint would probably affirm that that a father (or mother) figure is not always a positive or meaningful image for people, and could get in the way a loving relationship with God. Someone more comfortable with liberal religious language might adopt "heavenly parent" or perhaps even something like 'loving creator', etc.

So my impression is that the book's language promotes a traditionally 'liberal' position (Universalism) via rather conservative 'Evangelical' language. If this creates some mistrust in the target audience, it might be helped by just choosing different words.

For atheists, the problem might go deeper: We might ask - 'Is a Universalist Evangelical an internally consistent kind of Christian?'

I'm pretty comfortable with Christians working their way through various journeys, even if they seem a little confusing sometimes. The bumper sticker says: "The Journey is the Destination (Moab Utah) ". :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom