A Christian Sceptic
Master Poster
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2007
- Messages
- 2,288
Opening Paragraphs
A Chance Meeting
I happened upon a certain internet forum by chance. I had been watching Phenomenon, a reality series starring the stage magician Criss Angel and the self-proclaimed psychic Uri Geller, and as I surfed the web reading about the show I came upon a forum dedicated to skeptics. For quite a few years I had been playing around mentally with an observation I had made about Faith Healers. I had watched a magic act at a fair and saw the magician use many of the same hand gestures, suggestions and he even created many of the same results – except he did all this in the name of entertainment and not in the name of God.
The question I posted on this internet forum was this:
I had already been lurking for a few days on the forum, had taken part in a discussion on the home page and had seen how easy it was for a discussion to get sidetracked. The responses I got surprised me. They started out saying they agreed, but then some posters moved into questioning why I wasn’t skeptical of hypnotism and by post #13 descended into claims that my wife was highly suggestible, willingly playing along, or she was probably a liar. That was when I knew I had stumbled into unfamiliar territory for me – a virtual land that I felt a curious interest in and a compelling need to explore more of.
`But I don't want to go among mad people,' Alice remarked.
`Oh, you can't help that,' said the Cat: `we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad.'
`How do you know I'm mad?' said Alice.
`You must be,' said the Cat, `or you wouldn't have come here.'
~ Alice in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll
An Introduction
`Oh, you can't help that,' said the Cat: `we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad.'
`How do you know I'm mad?' said Alice.
`You must be,' said the Cat, `or you wouldn't have come here.'
~ Alice in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll
An Introduction
A Chance Meeting
I happened upon a certain internet forum by chance. I had been watching Phenomenon, a reality series starring the stage magician Criss Angel and the self-proclaimed psychic Uri Geller, and as I surfed the web reading about the show I came upon a forum dedicated to skeptics. For quite a few years I had been playing around mentally with an observation I had made about Faith Healers. I had watched a magic act at a fair and saw the magician use many of the same hand gestures, suggestions and he even created many of the same results – except he did all this in the name of entertainment and not in the name of God.
The question I posted on this internet forum was this:
Hi,
I'm sure you've seen those faith healers on TBN who do what they call "slaying in the spirit". It is where they touch someone on the forehead and they fall over.
Well - a few years ago I was at the state fair and saw a hypnotist. He used the exact same motions and techniques (minus any prayers). He touched them on the forehead in the exact same manner and they fell over (that is - those that got hypnotized)
Has anyone else seen any similarities? Has there ever been studies done on this? I am not completely sure how hypnotism works - can they be doing hypnotism techniques without knowing it?
Special Request: Please don't start posting your opinions on why Christianity is wrong because of fake faith healers, how these people are mean, dishonest, etc. This will only distract from this discussion. My concern in this post isn't those aspects of faith healing but rather
what technique they may be using.
Peace!
I had already been lurking for a few days on the forum, had taken part in a discussion on the home page and had seen how easy it was for a discussion to get sidetracked. The responses I got surprised me. They started out saying they agreed, but then some posters moved into questioning why I wasn’t skeptical of hypnotism and by post #13 descended into claims that my wife was highly suggestible, willingly playing along, or she was probably a liar. That was when I knew I had stumbled into unfamiliar territory for me – a virtual land that I felt a curious interest in and a compelling need to explore more of.