Black Swan Event Under Way

This seems like betting on people panicking, not on the actual risk itself.

Indeed.

And while it's a safe bet people will panic, it's not a safe bet for how long they will panic. They might already be done panicking.

In other words, stock prices have already plunged, and if I were a short term trader I would bet that they will drop at the open on Monday, as low level traders (i.e. people like us) spend a weekend thinking about how much they lost last week when they were too busy working to pay attention, and they decide to sell.

But at some point, the smart money will swoop in and take up the panic money. Will that happen at noon on Monday, or some time in 2021?

If I, or anyone else, knew that answer, they would be rich.
 
This seems like betting on people panicking, not on the actual risk itself.

Panic is a factor, but it's the smallest factor.

The reasons for the drop are more or less in the following order:

50% over-valuation, mainly due to:
Absurdly cheap funding, and driven by:
A bull run that had become permanent in many eyes

Then all that got hit by the virus, which means, in physical terms:

Slowdown in manufacturing, which caused:
Breaks in the supply chain, which causes:
Reduced economic activity, and consequently:
Reduced profits

The markets have priced in the drop in economic activity, and are now being driven by a combination of fear and margin calls. Many people leveraged their way into the market by margin trading, and if you're on a 10% margin, when the market drops 10% you have to pay to stay in, or sell right away, and in this type of market a lot of people pull the plug.
 
Prediction for the immediate future:

Even steeper falls now it's out in the wild, which will cause panic to set in.

As it becomes clearer the world isn't going to end, buyers will return, possibly by the end of the week, although it might take a couple of weeks.

Still headed into bear territory, which looks to happen Wed/Thurs.
 
Is Wednesday the day you intend to start buying?

If so, what?

If not, why not and when?

No, I don't generally buy shares and am happy just to scoop a win and get out.

If I were investing, I'd be very wary of getting back into the sharemarket quickly - the repercussions of this could take a long while to overcome. We'll probably be looking at total losses of $20-30 trillion at the end of it all, and that kind of hit isn't easy to pick up from. China's growth rate for the first quarter is likely to be zero, and they aren't done with it yet.
 
Panic is a factor, but it's the smallest factor.

The reasons for the drop are more or less in the following order:

50% over-valuation, mainly due to:
Absurdly cheap funding, and driven by:
A bull run that had become permanent in many eyes

Then all that got hit by the virus, which means, in physical terms:

Slowdown in manufacturing, which caused:
Breaks in the supply chain, which causes:
Reduced economic activity, and consequently:
Reduced profits

The markets have priced in the drop in economic activity, and are now being driven by a combination of fear and margin calls. Many people leveraged their way into the market by margin trading, and if you're on a 10% margin, when the market drops 10% you have to pay to stay in, or sell right away, and in this type of market a lot of people pull the plug.

Have you factored in the recent announcements from Microsoft, Sky, BHP, RIO, BlackRock (for example) saying they are going Carbon Negative, or Net Zero emissions through history?

The biggest companies are now banking on attracting business by being net zero.

They've divested all fossil fuel investments, and it's now a battleground to dump any assets that are going to be stranded.

Anyone who didn't plan for this has missed the boat long after it was announced would be launching.

Where would you place this influence that relates to panic in the list of factors in the Black Swan event?

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/rio-tinto-rejects-setting-targets-064704508.html

https://theconservativeinvestordail...ssure-on-big-investors-to-act-on-environment/
 
The markets have priced in the drop in economic activity, and are now being driven by a combination of fear and margin calls. Many people leveraged their way into the market by margin trading, and if you're on a 10% margin, when the market drops 10% you have to pay to stay in, or sell right away, and in this type of market a lot of people pull the plug.

Then you have the Warren Buffets and contrarian investors who might use some spare cash on some emerging (Asian) market investing.
 
Indeed.

And while it's a safe bet people will panic, it's not a safe bet for how long they will panic. They might already be done panicking.

In other words, stock prices have already plunged, and if I were a short term trader I would bet that they will drop at the open on Monday, as low level traders (i.e. people like us) spend a weekend thinking about how much they lost last week when they were too busy working to pay attention, and they decide to sell.

But at some point, the smart money will swoop in and take up the panic money. Will that happen at noon on Monday, or some time in 2021?

If I, or anyone else, knew that answer, they would be rich.

Yes.

It's good to be able to count your level of risk based on losses in your planned timeframe.

And to count your birds in your hand.

You don't want to worry about what extra profit you might not have made.
 
Can I just add that, regardless of how many people use the term, this is not a “Black Swan Event” at all? Not only have we been here before many times, but governments know how to respond.

Yes, it’s fun imagining economic collapse and Armageddon (and some in this thread do seem to enjoy the possibility of a major recession) but the reality will, I believe, be far different. Meanwhile the news here leads with a 78 year old dying from the virus. Give me strength...
 
Last edited:
Have you factored in the recent announcements from Microsoft, Sky, BHP, RIO, BlackRock (for example) saying they are going Carbon Negative, or Net Zero emissions through history?

No. That's longer term, and right now the focus is solely on the slowdown caused by the virus.

It's good to see some of the worst guys trying to do something, but as noted in the covid-19 thread, the enormousness of the downturn has already reduced carbon emissions by massive amounts.

What's bad for humans might be good for everything else.

Then you have the Warren Buffets and contrarian investors who might use some spare cash on some emerging (Asian) market investing.

They'd want to be fairly careful about when they got in, if it bursts out again in China - as I pick it will once they return to work - you wouldn't want to be on any stocks, anywhere.

A good pick would be if you could figure who will be first with either a vaccine or successful treatment - whoever does that is guaranteed many billions of dollars and a stock that goes ballistic. There are a couple of companies showing promise whose shares have already been hiked considerably.

Can I just add that, regardless of how many people use the term, this is not a “Black Swan Event” at all?

Time will tell, but I'm certainly picking a low well under a 20% drop. In fact, I think it's going to get close to suspension tomorrow morning with the news of the wild outbreak in USA.

Not only have we been here before many times, but governments know how to respond.

You're showing your total lack of economics knowledge there, sorry.

We've never been here before, in terms of a market trying to get to grips with a pandemic.

As for governments knowing what to do, you're in fairy land. It was explained to you way up the thread that governments have no armaments to fight this. They can't print their way out if when all classes of assets are falling and demand is zero.

Easing is therefore pointless, interest rates are already zero, so can't be cut, and whether there's money in the bin to spend on infrastructure looks unlikely because most governments will be spending like mad to keep their countries' businesses and employers afloat. Take a look at how many billion China is tipping into their domestic economy just to stay alive. And you can bet USA won't be ordering 10% of their population into house arrest, so their bill will be considerably larger.

Yes, it’s fun imagining economic collapse and Armageddon...

Is it? Why is it fun?

I don't see much joy in it, because as always, the poorest people will be the worst affected. If Jeff Bezos loses $50 billion, he'll still have enough billions left to not be too concerned. If someone renting a cheap home gets kicked out, they're screwed.

... but the reality will, I believe, be far different.

Put your money where your mouth is and buy some shares then.
 
No. That's longer term, and right now the focus is solely on the slowdown caused by the virus.

It's good to see some of the worst guys trying to do something, but as noted in the covid-19 thread, the enormousness of the downturn has already reduced carbon emissions by massive amounts.

What's bad for humans might be good for everything else.



They'd want to be fairly careful about when they got in, if it bursts out again in China - as I pick it will once they return to work - you wouldn't want to be on any stocks, anywhere.

A good pick would be if you could figure who will be first with either a vaccine or successful treatment - whoever does that is guaranteed many billions of dollars and a stock that goes ballistic. There are a couple of companies showing promise whose shares have already been hiked considerably.



Time will tell, but I'm certainly picking a low well under a 20% drop. In fact, I think it's going to get close to suspension tomorrow morning with the news of the wild outbreak in USA.



You're showing your total lack of economics knowledge there, sorry.

We've never been here before, in terms of a market trying to get to grips with a pandemic.

As for governments knowing what to do, you're in fairy land. It was explained to you way up the thread that governments have no armaments to fight this. They can't print their way out if when all classes of assets are falling and demand is zero.

Easing is therefore pointless, interest rates are already zero, so can't be cut, and whether there's money in the bin to spend on infrastructure looks unlikely because most governments will be spending like mad to keep their countries' businesses and employers afloat. Take a look at how many billion China is tipping into their domestic economy just to stay alive. And you can bet USA won't be ordering 10% of their population into house arrest, so their bill will be considerably larger.



Is it? Why is it fun?

I don't see much joy in it, because as always, the poorest people will be the worst affected. If Jeff Bezos loses $50 billion, he'll still have enough billions left to not be too concerned. If someone renting a cheap home gets kicked out, they're screwed.



Put your money where your mouth is and buy some shares then.

Jumping the gun again. Why?

https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/02/coronavirus-pandemic-epidemic-health/

Coronavirus is not a pandemic, at least not yet. That was the message from the World Health Organization's Director General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus in a briefing Wednesday.

“We should not be too eager to declare a pandemic without a careful and clear-minded analysis of the facts," he said, noting appeals for a declaration from some politicians and journalists.

Come back when it is a pandemic and it starts to kill people at more than a small fraction of the flu.

You have bought into the panic spread by the internet and mass media. Hopefully wiser heads will prevail, panic doesn’t prevail and that this will fade away like SARS before it.
 
Our own Health officials are using the word "pandemic".


Australia's group of state and federal medical officers, convening daily, usually by phone hook-up, is the peak point of the pure medical advice, the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee (AHPPC). No politicians sit in on their meetings.

From there, the medical advice goes to the policymakers in the National Security Committee of the federal cabinet, and this is where the politicians get involved. The NSC is chaired by the Prime Minister. This is where decisions are made and action taken. Or not.
The medical officers' "pandemic" call was a big moment. For a start, they were way ahead of the UN body that is supposedly the lead global agency on international health emergencies, the Geneva-based World Health Organisation.

Why were the Australians ahead of the world? For a very simple reason. They don't trust the WHO. The information from multiple international sources is that the WHO is under intense pressure from the Chinese government, and succumbing to it.
https://www.smh.com.au/politics/fed...rity-on-coronavirus-20200228-p545hr.html?btis
 
Come back when it is a pandemic and it starts to kill people at more than a small fraction of the flu.
Do some math. It's at the earliest stages of a pandemic. It's infectious as hell and unlike the flu that is endemic, the population has no immunity to it and it kills about 10x more people that get it than the flu.
You have bought into the panic spread by the internet and mass media. Hopefully wiser heads will prevail, panic doesn’t prevail and that this will fade away like SARS before it.

Zero chance. There has been and continues to be strong data showing how it is far, far, more infectious than SARS. This isn't fake news.
 
Jumping the gun again. Why?

:dl:

I'd say more, "ahead of the game", myself.

When I made the call on the sharemarket, the markets were at their highest ever, and TVIX was at its lowest ever.

It must have escaped you that the markets are down 13% and TVIX up 250%.

So far, I'd say I'm right on track.

(I won't even mention the shifting goalposts of market state to whether it's a pandemic or not)

Come back when it is a pandemic and it starts to kill people at more than a small fraction of the flu.

Don't worry, I'll be here all the way.

You do realise that pandemics start small? With one case, generally, and that's known to have happened with this one. In three months, that single infection has caused 85,000 cases, several thousand deaths and, according to the world's foremost voice on epidemics, is highly likely to be a pandemic.

You have bought into the panic spread by the internet and mass media.

Hard to see how I could have bought into mass panic when I was clearly in front of everyone else. Also, I don't care what mass media has to say, and if you want to check, all of my posts on the subject in all of the threads, are based on evidence and maths.

Like I've said, some people can do the maths, and if an exponential increase in cases outside China isn't letting you in on it, you'll see it when the hospitals are crushed under the numbers.

Hopefully wiser heads will prevail, panic doesn’t prevail and that this will fade away like SARS before it.

All that, and it's "hopefully"?

I hope you're right that it fades away.

However, because I work on facts, evidence and logic, my hopes are at an all-time low and my best hopes for the disease are that it isn't as fatal as current statistics show and that we can at least slow the spread to try to keep hospitals open.

Check back at the end of the week and see how our various hopes are panning out.
 
I hope you're right that it fades away.

However, because I work on facts, evidence and logic, my hopes are at an all-time low and my best hopes for the disease are that it isn't as fatal as current statistics show and that we can at least slow the spread to try to keep hospitals open.

"Facts are Stubborn Things" - John Adams
 
Like I've said, some people can do the maths, and if an exponential increase in cases outside China isn't letting you in on it, you'll see it when the hospitals are crushed under the numbers.
It depends on the exponent.

Whatever happens, a widely recognized equities bubble was due for popping. I would like to think we’ve seen the worst, but I doubt it.

ETA: I’ll check the other threads but am curious what’s the main hospital treatment. If it’s IV fluids, that can be managed without hospitalization.
 
Last edited:
FUD, pure and simple. Some people and industries profit on it. Disappointing, really.
 
FUD, pure and simple. Some people and industries profit on it. Disappointing, really.
It's like there are 2 interwoven epidemics: The literal viral one, the other a spreading fear that does not strike me as 100 percent rational.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom