Yes, it is all nothing... or... it is probably the greatest conspiracy of fraud and complicity of all time. Yep.
That's just it. It would have to be the greatest conspiracy of all time were a large number of unconnected, politically or otherwise, would have to work together since the early 60s on the off-chance that this one mixed race kid (remember, the early 60s) would become the President. Nay, the first
black President. And none of these many, many unconnected people would have to be in the right place at the right time to make all of it happen with absolutely no evidence that it happened and every indication that he was born in the US.
Do you have any conception how difficult that would be? Any idea how much effort and absolute secrecy that would take for such a long shot? Especially for a plot that was originated as early at the 1960, or possibly longer given the complexity of it all. It would take at least the amount of coordination of a Manhattan Project, stretched over 4-5 decades, with no leaks at all.
All so Barack Obama would become the President of the United States.
The question is: Why? What is gained for this group of hyper-Illuminati? So they could have their man in office? Why not recruit a much more historically electable tall good looking white guy who was actually a US citizen?
The one of the many things wrong with Birtherism, JudeBrando, (aside from the complete lack of evidence) is that there was no reason for anyone to go along with a plot that didn't have a snowball's chance in hell of succeeding without being discovered, and people were looking.