Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

Whenever it's rich person's lawyers against underpaid prosecutors, the deck is stacked in the rich person's favor.

But a lot is going to depend on what evidence can be introduced. I don't know the legal rules about introducing a deposition that was released to the public if the defense decides not to call Cosby.

People don't take well to an old man giving young girls drugs and then calling the sex consensual. By a lot of definitions if the prosecutor presents the case well, consent cannot be had with an intoxicated partner.

Sadly, those without the capital get the punishment. Cosby will have the best legal team money can buy. I've read enough comments sections to know there are plenty of misogynists out there. If one or two get on the jury, and Cosby's legal team muddies the waters enough, it might be all the justification they need for a "not guilty" vote.

I predict a hung jury.
 
Wouldn't "Hey tootsie, how about some drug induced casual sex?" make it consensual? I've done it myself- she had a hotel room, wanted me to bring pot and alcohol. No coercion applied.

This is a criminal proceeding. You remember, "beyond a reasonable doubt". I doubt there will be any physical evidence. He said/she said in a promiscuous back ground? I can't see any 12 people NOT having reasonable doubt.

And also, like Trayvon/Zimmerman, this trial sounds purely political.
 
Wouldn't "Hey tootsie, how about some drug induced casual sex?" make it consensual? I've done it myself- she had a hotel room, wanted me to bring pot and alcohol. No coercion applied.

Good point. Even if I wanted to have sex, I'd still need drugs to have sex with a 67-year-old Bill Cosby.
 
Double jeopardy? It's SOP to not do a civil trial until the criminal trial is over, otherwise double jeopardy can moot the criminal trial. Does it here? And here they are using Cosby's own statement against himself too- was he read his Miranda rights?

Nah, I could see this trial lasting about an hour and a half. I wonder who's side the prosecutor is on. He just might be giving the Cos a clean bill of health.
 
Sadly, those without the capital get the punishment. Cosby will have the best legal team money can buy. I've read enough comments sections to know there are plenty of misogynists out there.

So a juror who thinks the case isn't proven automatically hates women?

Wow.
 
Double jeopardy? It's SOP to not do a civil trial until the criminal trial is over, otherwise double jeopardy can moot the criminal trial. Does it here? And here they are using Cosby's own statement against himself too- was he read his Miranda rights?

Nah, I could see this trial lasting about an hour and a half. I wonder who's side the prosecutor is on. He just might be giving the Cos a clean bill of health.

Civil <> criminal. Double jeopardy does not come into play.
 
Sadly, those without the capital get the punishment. Cosby will have the best legal team money can buy. I've read enough comments sections to know there are plenty of misogynists out there. If one or two get on the jury, and Cosby's legal team muddies the waters enough, it might be all the justification they need for a "not guilty" vote.

I predict a hung jury.

So if he gets off it will have to be blokes?
 
So a juror who thinks the case isn't proven automatically hates women?

Wow.

Not even close to what I said. There may be one or two men on the jury who are the type who never believe women when they accuse men of raping/molesting them, and will always side with men. Just as there are people who never believe the cop's side, and people who always believe the cop's side.
 
There's something I don't get. It seems very likely to me that he is guilty, but.....

The charge is for an alleged assault in 2004. According to news reports, there wasn't enough evidence to charge at that time, in the eyes of the prosecutor. The case was reopened, following a new election for a new prosecutor, on the strength of testimony from all of the other women he is alleged to have drugged and assaulted.

But, when the incident was reported, didn't they do a toxicology test? Wouldn't the presence of a sedative have been detectable? It seems to me that if it was done, and the results are available, that would be incredibly strong evidence, one way or another, and if it wasn't done.....huh? Why not?
 
....But, when the incident was reported, didn't they do a toxicology test? Wouldn't the presence of a sedative have been detectable? It seems to me that if it was done, and the results are available, that would be incredibly strong evidence, one way or another, and if it wasn't done.....huh? Why not?


As is often the case, the victim hesitated to act, and she didn't go to police for almost a year. Way too late for testing.
http://www.businessinsider.com/one-...-12?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=referral
 
Last edited:
As is often the case, the victim hesitated to act, and she didn't go to police for almost a year. Way too late for testing.
http://www.businessinsider.com/one-...-12?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=referral

Oh. Well, then, not guilty.

Of course I'm not on the jury, and we'll have to see what comes up, and he probably is guilty, but unless there's something pretty powerful, I can't see how to get past reasonable doubt.

It seems perfectly plausible that a non-victim could hear about all the other women who were victims, and decide to make a false allegation. This could be done for a couple of different motives.

1) The obvious one would be to cash in.
2) She could be sympathetic to the real victims, and decide to go after him with a false allegation in order to gain justice for them.

While I wouldn't believe those motives necessarily, I have to wonder about a year old rape allegation. It makes no sense to me. That means reasonable doubt.

Will the jury agree, or will they decide that he must be guilty of some of those other alleged rapes, so they might as well convict him of this one, too? Or will the judge throw it out?
 
Oh. Well, then, not guilty.

Of course I'm not on the jury, and we'll have to see what comes up, and he probably is guilty, but unless there's something pretty powerful, I can't see how to get past reasonable doubt.

It seems perfectly plausible that a non-victim could hear about all the other women who were victims, and decide to make a false allegation. This could be done for a couple of different motives.

1) The obvious one would be to cash in.
2) She could be sympathetic to the real victims, and decide to go after him with a false allegation in order to gain justice for them.

While I wouldn't believe those motives necessarily, I have to wonder about a year old rape allegation. It makes no sense to me. That means reasonable doubt.

Will the jury agree, or will they decide that he must be guilty of some of those other alleged rapes, so they might as well convict him of this one, too? Or will the judge throw it out?

You're a lot of steps behind. Cosby has admitted giving her drugs and having sex with her, but claims it was all consensual. He also has admitted under oath that he routinely gave Quaaludes to women that he wanted to have sex with. She went to the police in early 2005 about the event that happened in 2004, long before the recent publicity. She later filed a civil suit that Cosby settled out of court. And there are numerous reasons why a young woman would fear confronting a rich, powerful international celebrity, and some of the women have talked at length about why they remained silent for decades. If you want to argue that rape couldn't have happened if it wasn't reported the next day, you won't find much support.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/31/b...column-region&region=top-news&WT.nav=top-news
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/31/b...=WhatsNext&contentID=WhatsNext&pgtype=article
 
Last edited:
If you want to argue that rape couldn't have happened if it wasn't reported the next day, you won't find much support.

He's not arguing that it couldn't have happened, only that the delay in reporting it leaves reasonable doubt. There is a huge difference.
 
He's not arguing that it couldn't have happened, only that the delay in reporting it leaves reasonable doubt. There is a huge difference.

"Reasonable doubt" would mean a rapist could never be convicted if the victim didn't go to the cops immediately. That's not the way the system works, nor would most people want it to work that way. The jury is entitled to wonder why the crime wasn't reported, and the victim's fear, guilt, shame, confusion and denial are all recognized, comprehensible explanations.
 
"Reasonable doubt" would mean a rapist could never be convicted if the victim didn't go to the cops immediately.

Never? No. Less likely? I'd agree with that.

That's not the way the system works, nor would most people want it to work that way. The jury is entitled to wonder why the crime wasn't reported, and the victim's fear, guilt, shame, confusion and denial are all recognized, comprehensible explanations.

Those are all valid arguments to present to a jury, but it's still up to the jury if enough of them agree with it. Let's be honest, the odds are against the victim.

I don't disagree with you, I just think it's unnecessary to misrepresent Meadmaker's statement in order to make your own points.
 
"Reasonable doubt" would mean a rapist could never be convicted if the victim didn't go to the cops immediately. That's not the way the system works, nor would most people want it to work that way. The jury is entitled to wonder why the crime wasn't reported, and the victim's fear, guilt, shame, confusion and denial are all recognized, comprehensible explanations.

Indeed. It's all up to the jury, and they can go with whatever they believe. I'm just saying that this whole reasonable doubt thing makes it really hard to be sure. There are plenty of reasons that someone wouldn't report a crime immediately. There are also plenty of reasons why someone would report a crime that never happened.

Knowing what we all know about the scores of rape allegations against Cosby, I'm pretty sure he's guilty as sin of some of the rapes of which he is accused. That could include this one.....or not.

Theoretically, if the jurors decide that he is a serial rapist, but they can't be sure about this particular assault, they are supposed to vote not guilty, because they are only deciding guilt or innocence of this particular crime. I think the verdict will rest on whether or not they actually follow that rule.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom