Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

That was the point of asking the question, theprestige.
I have in mind two different questions, based on the assumption that you are using "witch hunt" to connote unjust persecution of someone:

First, is qayak saying that he thinks Cosby is guilty, but he also thinks that Cosby is being unjustly persecuted? This is the question I think you're asking.

Second, if a person really is a "witch", is it still unjust (a "witch hunt") to persecute them? This is the question I'm asking.
 
Last edited:
What I'm saying is that a reasonable person would be much more open to the possibility that an allegation of rape is true than to the possibility that a UFO claim is true. Much more open a priori, "without" the evidence, aside from testimonial and statistics. Precisely because of statistics.

I think you're arguing in binary terms, as in guilty/not guilty, while I and other people are arguing in probabilistic terms.
I'm arguing in binary terms, as in cost/no cost.

For example, "have you provided enough evidence to justify me bringing harm to the accused?"

To me, this is a binary question. Assessing the probability that the accusation is true, when no evidence has been provided, does not help me answer the question. However, the fact that no evidence has been provided, helps me very easily determine that the answer must be "no".

Which, in practice, translates to, "I should treat a rape claim without evidence as if it were false (which is the same I way I should treat UFO claims without evidence)."
 
I have in mind two different questions, based on the assumption that you are using "witch hunt" to connote unjust persecution of someone:

First, is qayak saying that he thinks Cosby is guilty, but he also thinks that Cosby is being unjustly persecuted? This is the question I think you're asking.

Second, if a person really is a "witch", is it still unjust (a "witch hunt") to persecute them? This is the question I'm asking.

I meant to imply the second, although I was asking about the first.
 
....
Which, in practice, translates to, "I should treat a rape claim without evidence as if it were false (which is the same I way I should treat UFO claims without evidence)."

The problem is the definition of evidence. Claims are evidence. Testimony is evidence. Many crimes and civil disputes often come down to one person's word against another's. "Yes, that's the man who robbed me!; No, I wasn't even there!" or "No, he gave me his money and his watch because he likes me!" "Yes, he raped me!"; "I don't even know her! or "Well, she got drunk and never said stop!" An oral contract comes down to who said what. Lawyers have complained that CSI etc. prime every juror to expect DNA, fingerprints and video in every case, and usually there isn't any. Testimonial evidence can certainly be challenged and impugned, but it's dishonest to say a rape claim can't be true if there's no additional evidence. This misconception is one of the reasons why rape victims are afraid to report attacks if they weren't severely injured: "Yeah, so you say, but where's the evidence?"
 
Last edited:
The problem is the definition of evidence. Claims are evidence. Testimony is evidence. Many crimes and civil disputes often come down to one person's word against another's. "Yes, that's the man who robbed me!; No, I wasn't even there!" or "No, he gave me his money and his watch because he likes me!" "Yes, he raped me!"; "I don't even know her! or "Well, she got drunk and never said stop!" An oral contract comes down to who said what. Lawyers have complained that CSI etc. prime every juror to expect DNA, fingerprints and video in every case, and usually there isn't any. Testimonial evidence can certainly be challenged and impugned, but it's dishonest to say a rape claim can't be true if there's no additional evidence. This misconception is one of the reasons why rape victims are afraid to report attacks if they weren't severely injured: "Yeah, so you say, but where's the evidence?"

Well said. And remember Cosby's own testimony is evidence that also supports the accusations.
 
Testimonial evidence can certainly be challenged and impugned, but it's dishonest to say a rape claim can't be true if there's no additional evidence.
Fortunately, I am not saying that dishonest thing.

I don't wish to get into a discussion about claims-as-evidence. If you like, read my "claim without evidence" as meaning "claim without additional evidence". It makes no difference to my point.

I'm saying that a rape accusation can be true without evidence, but that I cannot justify harming the accused to the accused without evidence. Thus, when I act on an un-evidenced rape claim, the practical result is the same as if the claim were not true (just like the practical result of me acting on un-evidenced UFO claims).
 
Fortunately, I am not saying that dishonest thing.

I don't wish to get into a discussion about claims-as-evidence. If you like, read my "claim without evidence" as meaning "claim without additional evidence". It makes no difference to my point.

I'm saying that a rape accusation can be true without evidence, but that I cannot justify harming the accused to the accused without evidence. Thus, when I act on an un-evidenced rape claim, the practical result is the same as if the claim were not true (just like the practical result of me acting on un-evidenced UFO claims).

Okay, I'll bite. What do you consider minimal additional evidence to convict a defendant of rape? People go to jail every day solely because a victim or a witness or a police officer testifies about what they saw the defendant do. And you know what? Some of them ARE railroaded. But not most. If a woman alleges that a man invited her to his home on a pretext (job audition, acting lessons), gave her refreshments, and assaulted her while she was too groggy to resist, what additional evidence do you require? If a woman says a frat boy took her into his room at a party while she was drunk and raped her, and he says "Sure, we had sex. She loved it!," what additional evidence do you require? And what additional evidence -- fingerprints on a glass, drug residue, semen -- would overcome the defendant's claim that whatever happened was voluntary and consensual?
 
Okay, I'll bite. What do you consider minimal additional evidence to convict a defendant of rape? People go to jail every day solely because a victim or a witness or a police officer testifies about what they saw the defendant do. And you know what? Some of them ARE railroaded. But not most. If a woman alleges that a man invited her to his home on a pretext (job audition, acting lessons), gave her refreshments, and assaulted her while she was too groggy to resist, what additional evidence do you require? If a woman says a frat boy took her into his room at a party while she was drunk and raped her, and he says "Sure, we had sex. She loved it!," what additional evidence do you require? And what additional evidence -- fingerprints on a glass, drug residue, semen -- would overcome the defendant's claim that whatever happened was voluntary and consensual?

I see no point in discussing standards of evidence unless we've already reached a consensus on the basic principle that claims should not be accepted without evidence (whatever standard we happen to set). Unfortunately I have little hope of such a consensus, as it seems you will stand fast on the point that a claim itself is evidence enough. Since I have precisely zero wish to go down that rabbit hole, it's probably best if I bow out here.
 
....
Unfortunately I have little hope of such a consensus, as it seems you will stand fast on the point that a claim itself is evidence enough.
....

You seem to be confusing evidence with proof. A claim is evidence, subject to examination, but it is not proof. The claimant might be telling the truth, maliciously lying, honestly mistaken, delusional or maybe something else. But the difference between rape and consensual sex is -- surprise! -- consent. There is no physical evidence that will reveal either party's state of mind. A jury -- or any observer -- can only hear both sides and decide who is more credible. Everything that both parties say -- "He raped me! No, she came on to me!" -- along with everything witnesses and bystanders say, is evidence.
 
You seem to be confusing evidence with proof. A claim is evidence, subject to examination, but it is not proof. The claimant might be telling the truth, maliciously lying, honestly mistaken, delusional or maybe something else. But the difference between rape and consensual sex is -- surprise! -- consent. There is no physical evidence that will reveal either party's state of mind. A jury -- or any observer -- can only hear both sides and decide who is more credible. Everything that both parties say -- "He raped me! No, she came on to me!" -- along with everything witnesses and bystanders say, is evidence.

Fair enough.

In that case, I'm content to leave it to a judge and a jury to decide the standard of evidence, and the credibility of competing claims, when the question is, "should we harm someone based on an accusation of rape?"

If you come to me (outside of a courtroom where I'm sitting as a juror) and say I should harm someone based on an accusation of rape, and the only evidence is two competing counter-claims, I will treat the accusation of rape as untrue. Just like I would do with a similar claim about UFOs.
 
I missed a couple pages. Is there a prosecutor somewhere that has decided to press charges? Has anybody actually filed a civil suit? I think somebody succeeded in getting a sealed file opened, but is that only preperatory, looking for evidence for a suit they MIGHT file? ?
 
I missed a couple pages. Is there a prosecutor somewhere that has decided to press charges? Has anybody actually filed a civil suit? I think somebody succeeded in getting a sealed file opened, but is that only preperatory, looking for evidence for a suit they MIGHT file? ?

It's confusing. At this point I think the discussion here has turned to something like, the only way Cosby is getting out of this, maybe requires him being abducted by a UFO, or something of that nature. I don't know.
 
I missed a couple pages. Is there a prosecutor somewhere that has decided to press charges? Has anybody actually filed a civil suit? I think somebody succeeded in getting a sealed file opened, but is that only preperatory, looking for evidence for a suit they MIGHT file? ?


Most of the cases are beyond the statute of limitations for criminal or civil action. The newly released depositions were taken in connection with a suit filed (actually filed) in 2005 by Andrea Costand, who reached a out-of-court settlement with Cosby conditioned on confidentiality.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/19/a...g-women-using-fame-drugs-and-deceit.html?_r=0

Several women have filed suits recently alleging that Cosby defamed them by saying that their accusations are lies.

LA police are investigating criminal allegations, but they have taken no action at present.
http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2015...o-bill-cosby-unrelated-to-recent-revelations/

New York Magazine has just run a summary of allegations by 35 women who were willing to be photographed for the cover:
http://nymag.com/thecut/2015/07/bill-cosbys-accusers-speak-out.html
 
Most of the cases are beyond the statute of limitations for criminal or civil action. The newly released depositions were taken in connection with a suit filed (actually filed) in 2005 by Andrea Costand, who reached a out-of-court settlement with Cosby conditioned on confidentiality.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/19/a...g-women-using-fame-drugs-and-deceit.html?_r=0

So she settled that case, but depositions are revealed? No new legal action?

Several women have filed suits recently alleging that Cosby defamed them by saying that their accusations are lies.
And several women have been proven to be lying. Who is defaming who, whne in the public court of opinion, the women can lei, but Cos can't defend him self?


LA police are investigating criminal allegations, but they have taken no action at present.
http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2015...o-bill-cosby-unrelated-to-recent-revelations/

New York Magazine has just run a summary of allegations by 35 women who were willing to be photographed for the cover:
http://nymag.com/thecut/2015/07/bill-cosbys-accusers-speak-out.html

Maybe Cos can sue the magazine and women for defamation ( it can be defamation, even if true) and get enough cash to come out ahead? ;)

So, all the big brouhaha, no legal proceedings. ?
 
....
Maybe Cos can sue the magazine and women for defamation ( it can be defamation, even if true) and get enough cash to come out ahead? ;)
....

Wrong. Defamation is by definition publishing a falsehood that is injurious. Cosby is free to sue anybody and claim they are lying, but he would have to go to court and testify under oath, something he has done everything he can to avoid.
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/defamation-law-made-simple-29718.html

Costand is currently asking the court to unseal the depositions in connection with her case so she can fully respond to Cosby's allegations that sex between them was "consensual." Cosby, of course, demands that his own testimony remain secret.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/07/29/us-people-cosby-idUSKCN0Q302W20150729

Most of these women would love it if Cosby sued them. They would get a chance to put Cosby on the stand under oath. The threat of a trial is why Cosby settled with Costand.
 
Last edited:
One of Cosby's victims was gay despite his claims of consensual sex.
Not just "one of" his victims, but the very one who took him to court in 2005/6 and with whom he reached a (sealed until now) settlement. People magazine adds in their article:
In the filing, attorney Dolores Troiani slams Cosby as a narcissist who didn't realize Constand (who was in a relationship with a woman at the time of the alleged assault) is gay.
(highlighting mine).

So she settled that case, but depositions are revealed? No new legal action?
Thus far, the unsealing has been done by the judge on request of the press.

And several women have been proven to be lying. Who is defaming who, whne in the public court of opinion, the women can lei, but Cos can't defend him self?
Sure he can. But he better be damn sure that the women he accuses of lying are indeed the ones lying, and that he's able to prove it. When you would be on the jury, and it's his word against that of an alleged victim, are you going to believe the master seducer with the broken gaydar? :rolleyes:

So, all the big brouhaha, no legal proceedings. ?
None yet. I can't see this playing out without any legal proceedings whatsoever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom