Bigfootery Bickering and Infighting

Status
Not open for further replies.
And the people in the PA Bigfoot Society should not take offense to implied caricatures of them being puppets? Even if Sam was just making a joke? Some may have taken offense, it sure seemed to upset Billy Willard. Was the picture removed or Sam disciplined? No it was a joke, like my picture was. Get it?

:D I'm sure Jeff Foxworthy wouldn't have been banned either but then again he doesn't have a history of being suspended or banned does he?

Get it?

The arguments were not the same.

So you don't "Agree totally" with this part?

Wolftrax said:
Nice try at stereotyping your opponents though.
 
WP asked why I was banned and I told him seeing as it was the final one.


I didn't ask. I made a statement and you treated it as if I had asked a question.

I noticed the way you are willing to say things that would be taken as insult by other Bigfooters. I presumed that that willingness is what got you banned from BFF. IOW, you will throw stones at other Bigfooters.

I went on to point out that JREF BF skeptics don't seem to insult each other and certainly don't get suspended or banned for infighting (skeptic vs skeptic). IOW, skeptics here are not throwing stones at each other.

I still don't understand how I am a hypocrite.
 
:D I'm sure Jeff Foxworthy wouldn't have been banned either but then again he doesn't have a history of being suspended or banned does he?

Get it?



So you don't "Agree totally" with this part?

History of being suspended? Only from the BFF and BFD who happen to be controlled by the same people who are complicite with hoaxing.

You know, you really are a piece of work. I try to support you for one of your RARE logical posts and you still whine. Consider yourself ignored. You are really not worth it.
 
I didn't ask. I made a statement and you treated it as if I had asked a question.

I noticed the way you are willing to say things that would be taken as insult by other Bigfooters. I presumed that that willingness is what got you banned from BFF. IOW, you will throw stones at other Bigfooters.

I went on to point out that JREF BF skeptics don't seem to insult each other and certainly don't get suspended or banned for infighting (skeptic vs skeptic). IOW, skeptics here are not throwing stones at each other.

I still don't understand how I am a hypocrite.

If you dont get it, you never will. Let's just move the conversation along if possible.
 
I'd have to disagree with the skeptics not fighting part, also with any disciplinary action being directed at skeptics here, I know both are not true, but I also think that the banning or disciplinary action here depends on who is doing the reporting to the mods. Skeptics here by far outweigh believers and when more skeptics report on a believer for an offensive action, yet ignore when skeptics do an offensive action, and the mods are only paying attention to the reported actions, than it would appear to be that one side is more prone to suspension or banning. Nice try at stereotyping your opponents though.


You do not see the BF skeptics here fighting with each other. You see them fighting with BF believers. I don't know how else to describe this thing that I'm talking about. I recall a couple of skeptic suspensions that involved spats with makaya. That kid was not a BF skeptic in any real sense. I acquired a good number of infractions (yellow cards) in doing battle with makaya. Had I lashed out at him one more time I probably would have been suspended.

Bigfoot believer vs believer fighting is much more common than skeptic vs skeptic. For this, I'm not talking about believer vs skeptic.
 
Originally Posted by Drewbot
Here is a question to Bigfooters:

If a Bigfoot hunter claims to be in contact with bigfoot, repeatedly, for many years, in different states, is it indicative of:

A. That person being a really good bigfoot hunter?
B. That person being F.O.S.?
C. That person being really Lucky.


In my experience the person is FOS.
 
WGBH said:
You know, you really are a piece of work. I try to support you for one of your RARE logical posts and you still whine. Consider yourself ignored. You are really not worth it.

I wasn't whining, just making a point, but you ignoring me is actually a blessing.


You do not see the BF skeptics here fighting with each other. You see them fighting with BF believers. I don't know how else to describe this thing that I'm talking about. I recall a couple of skeptic suspensions that involved spats with makaya. That kid was not a BF skeptic in any real sense. I acquired a good number of infractions (yellow cards) in doing battle with makaya. Had I lashed out at him one more time I probably would have been suspended.

Bigfoot believer vs believer fighting is much more common than skeptic vs skeptic. For this, I'm not talking about believer vs skeptic.

Under these strict black and white definitions than no, believer vs. believer fighting is not more common than skeptic vs. skeptic. You're lumping in people who believe or allow for the possibility yet are skeptical of evidence in with the absolute believers on one side, while specifying strict absolute skeptics and excluding those who allow for the possibility or believe in the possibility yet exercise skepticism on the other side.

This is not realistic, you have a wide range of people with various beliefs and methods of applying skepticism that delve into this subject that you exclude or include based on an attempt to stereotype those you disagree with.
 
It is only dis-interesting because it doesn't support the "all bigfooters are nutters" stance. All I would have asked is the caveat of "everyone over there is saying it's a porcupine except for these two (insert quotes)." I don't like to see either side, believer or skeptic, paint the other side with a broad brush.


I wasn't trying to convey that all Bigfooters are nutters. I don't even know if those that I quoted are Bigfoot believers or skeptics. I would take porcupine-is-a-primate quotes from anywhere I could find them. It just happens that they exist on a variety of sites related to cryptozoology (the BFF specializes in Bigfoot but attracts general crypto-fans).
 
No, your point is that Parcher should give equal-time to 'Normal' bigfooters. Parcher has no obligation to quote vanilla statements from the less-kooky footers. He was trying to make an entertaining list of quotes, showing the kooky footers who think the porcupine is a monkey. He has no obligation to to show non-entertaining quotes, just to give the less-kooky Footers equal time.


I don't actually know that those people I quoted are "footers". They might be Bigfoot skeptics. For example I quoted "badger man" from cryptozoology.com.

badger man on CZ.com said:
I have to admit. I thought it was a baboon.


Badger man might tell you...

1. Bigfoot does not exist.
2. That animal in the tree is a baboon.
 
I wasn't trying to convey that all Bigfooters are nutters. I don't even know if those that I quoted are Bigfoot believers or skeptics. I would take porcupine-is-a-primate quotes from anywhere I could find them.

Bolding mine.

That's fair enough. You wanted to point out the bad so you chose examples that exemplify that point. Using Drew's analogy, you wanted to say the Senate was full of kooks, so you only quoted the kooks.

My issue, and the sole issue I have, is that you included a forum where the vast majority of posting members don't fall in line with your porcusquatch proponents.

It would be no different than me posting a quote from psychicuk on another forum as an example of the JREF mindset on ghost boxes or psychics. I'm not compelled to point out that his opinion is the polar opposite of the majority of members, and you aren't compelled to point out that your quotes are the polar opposite of the majority of the members at the BFF, but that doesn't change the fact that it is the decent thing to do.
 
Last edited:
Bolding mine.

That's fair enough. You wanted to point out the bad so you chose examples that exemplify that point. Using Drew's analogy, you wanted to say the Senate was full of kooks, so you only quoted the kooks.

My issue, and the sole issue I have, is that you included a forum where the vast majority of posting members don't fall in line with your porcusquatch proponents.

It would be no different than me posting a quote from psychicuk on another forum as an example of the JREF mindset on ghost boxes or psychics. I'm not compelled to point out that his opinion is the polar opposite of the majority of members, and you aren't compelled to point out that your quotes are the polar opposite of the majority of the members at the BFF, but that doesn't change the fact that it is the decent thing to do.

Please show where or how he painted the BFF with a they're-all-kooks broad brush. He never stated he was including everyone nor did his post even imply it.
This is a skeptic's site so you should provide evidence for your statement.
 
This is a skeptic's site so you should provide evidence for your statement.

My first post was regarding cherry picking of posts. By WP's own account, he was only looking for pro-porcusquatch posts. Going to a forum where the majority of members aren't in the pro-porcusquatch camp and taking just those few that are is the definition of cherry picking.

As I said previously, his actions are no different than me posting on another forum regarding ghost boxes and using psychicuk's posts from the JREF. Does that mean that the JREF shares the same opinion?
 
Hawklynn: porcupines dont climb trees.

Our previous disagreement aside... that isn't incompetence or deception. That right there is a whole new kind of stupid. The kind of stupid that has an event horizon from whence all intelligent thought is sucked down to a singularity of dumb.

LOL! See, you never would have hatched that chestnut if I hadn't gone cherry picking. Viva Cherrypicker![*]



* - bittermonklaw forces me to remind you that not all YouTubers are stupid. Many YouTubers said that this is a porcupine.
 
Bitter Monk said:
The kind of stupid that has an event horizon from whence all intelligent thought is sucked down to a singularity of dumb. [/SIZE]

Where did Bitter Monk say this? This is gold. I want to Nominate, but Don't know where the original is.
Found it, and nommed it.
 
Last edited:
It would be no different than me posting a quote from psychicuk on another forum as an example of the JREF mindset on ghost boxes or psychics. I'm not compelled to point out that his opinion is the polar opposite of the majority of members, and you aren't compelled to point out that your quotes are the polar opposite of the majority of the members at the BFF, but that doesn't change the fact that it is the decent thing to do.


I wouldn't care if you did that. You seem very concerned about how the BFF is portrayed and thought of here on JREF. If you are mostly worried about the way that you are percieved then you are in control of that to a certain extent.

Cool people who claim to have seen Bigfoot. Don't lump them in with the Maine tree monkey dolts. But what is a skeptic supposed to say about them? Ya know, if folks like Bitter Monk say they saw Bigfoot then maybe it really does exist?
 
Where did Bitter Monk say this? This is gold. I want to Nominate, but Don't know where the original is. Found it, and nommed it.


Coincidentally, I was nominated for a similar "bird of stupid" post. See #325. Oh there's another coincidence as the subject was makaya325.


BTW Bitter Monk, not that it may matter, but I would virtually guarantee that mak is working multiple sockpuppets on BFF.
 
What the hell's going on in here?

I smelled you guys halfway across the forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom