Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

That is a nice picture. The clarity is awesome !

Thanks! For those just joining us, Jeff Meldrum included a diagram on page 119 of his Sasquatch book which he claims is a "typical posture" for an elk. At the risk of beating a dead ~erm~ horse, I checked before I posted the deer photo and I see the BFRO is STILL promoting the Skookum Elk Cast.

Higher resolution version of the deer photo found here:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/matthetube/7917470716/sizes/o/in/photostream/
 

Attachments

  • Meldrum-Diagram-350x244.jpg
    Meldrum-Diagram-350x244.jpg
    20.5 KB · Views: 2
Thanks! For those just joining us, Jeff Meldrum included a diagram on page 119 of his Sasquatch book which he claims is a "typical posture" for an elk. At the risk of beating a dead ~erm~ horse, I checked before I posted the deer photo and I see the BFRO is STILL promoting the Skookum Elk Cast.

Higher resolution version of the deer photo found here:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/matthetube/7917470716/sizes/o/in/photostream/

Nice picture.

IIRC we posted pics of elk bedding the same way as your deer, but it didn't do any good.
 
Not sure, but you'd think by now he'd have written up something significant and compelling, and had it published in a peer-reviewed journal. It's been 12 years.

RayG
 
Thanks! For those just joining us, Jeff Meldrum included a diagram on page 119 of his Sasquatch book which he claims is a "typical posture" for an elk. At the risk of beating a dead ~erm~ horse, I checked before I posted the deer photo and I see the BFRO is STILL promoting the Skookum Elk Cast.

Higher resolution version of the deer photo found here:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/matthetube/7917470716/sizes/o/in/photostream/

WADR to your photographic capabilities, one can find numerous images of elk lying in that position.
"typical" can mean almost anything. Intentional or not, Meldrum makes a logical error. The issue at hand is whether or not an elk could reasonably have been lying in posture "A", that would have made the imprint. Instead of addressing that issue, he shows a different posture "B" and says, in effect, "elk sometimes lie in posture B."
 
Last edited:
I don't think that Meldrum would ever declare the Skookum Cast an error (mistaken identity). For the same reasons that he won't declare any plaster casts in his collection to be fakes.

Firstly because you step on toes or toss people under the bus when you announce mistake or hoax upon evidence that others still uphold, especially bad when the upholders are friends or cohorts. Secondly because you then create a slippery slope of runaway skepticism which you cannot control. That is, if you speak of the criteria used to uncover the problem then you empower people to go forth and declare other evidence to be problematic using your criteria. A kind of wildfire that starts with a single debunking by Meldrum.

He won't do that.

It would take very special circumstances for Meldrum to declare the Skookum Cast to be an elk lay. He would need most of the other important people to say it first. He won't say it before Noll says it. I think Jeff would want to be the last person to declare almost anything held in regard among Bigfooters as being a hoax or mistake.
 
Not sure, but you'd think by now he'd have written up something significant and compelling, and had it published in a peer-reviewed journal. It's been 12 years.

RayG

Meldrum presented an abstract in 2004, before the Pacific Division of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Apparently it didn't go farther than that.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that Meldrum would ever declare the Skookum Cast an error (mistaken identity). For the same reasons that he won't declare any plaster casts in his collection to be fakes.

Firstly because you step on toes or toss people under the bus when you announce mistake or hoax upon evidence that others still uphold, especially bad when the upholders are friends or cohorts. Secondly because you then create a slippery slope of runaway skepticism which you cannot control. That is, if you speak of the criteria used to uncover the problem then you empower people to go forth and declare other evidence to be problematic using your criteria. A kind of wildfire that starts with a single debunking by Meldrum.

He won't do that.

It would take very special circumstances for Meldrum to declare the Skookum Cast to be an elk lay. He would need most of the other important people to say it first. He won't say it before Noll says it. I think Jeff would want to be the last person to declare almost anything held in regard among Bigfooters as being a hoax or mistake.


Here's 130,000 reasons why he'll neve deny bigfoot:

• $130,000 to Dr. Jeff Meldrum, from the Mayfield Foundation in support of Meldrum’s project titled “North American Ape Project (NAAP): 2008. ”The North American Ape Project (NAAP) seeks to detect and collect evidence through support from the Mayfield Foundation. This will be undertaken primarily by means of hair snags monitored by camera traps. In addition, fieldworkers will record vocalizations, document tracks and sample associated scat. Habitats will be analyzed for availability and distribution of food resources.
http://www2.isu.edu/headlines/?p=1345

There's also speaking fees and selling bigfoot trivia so no one knows how much he makes from his sideline.
 
Yes, but I was talking about him denying a specific Bigfoot evidence thing... not Bigfoot in general. He could choose to deny (declare fake) any of the casts in his collection - but he won't.
 
.... you step on toes or toss people under the bus when you announce mistake or hoax upon evidence that others still uphold, especially bad when the upholders are friends or cohorts.... I think Jeff would want to be the last person to declare almost anything held in regard among Bigfooters as being a hoax or mistake.


news/interview story
that Meldrum will undoubtedly disavow:
Meldrum hates that his book appears in the New Age section of bookstores more often than it does in the Natural History section. He will tell you the Bigfoot camp is full of nut jobs. He’s careful not to affiliate with Bigfoot groups based on enthusiasm rather than science – which are pretty much all of them.
 
Last edited:
"However, if a large land mammal such as an elk can lay next to a roadway, why can't another large land mammal? If one of the largest species of deer can lay down (as do most large land mammals) and can be found on or near roadways, what would preclude a larger than life primate? Seems the argument is about large animals laying down and being near roadways."

If a sasquatch is so concerned about humans seeing his footprints that he would lay down and roll around to get to food, rather than walk in soft soil to get it, then why in the world would it be so bold to lay down by a road? Are they aware of their own footprints, but completely unaware of what roads mean?

"I don't want man to find my footprints, so I will lay down to get food planted by man. Oh hey, is that a road? So it is. What does road mean anyway?" (back to rolling in the mud)
 
Heh. The bigfoot work in mysterious ways.

In their report they noted how the site was within "earshot" of their "base camp" to buttress the connection between noises they heard and the bigfoot lay. But the fact the lay was within feet of the road was carefully excised from their descriptions.

So they're telling us they know the road is an enormous problem. Look how detailed their reports are - everything from the weather to re-arranging chairs around the picnic table. This pretense of detail-orientation "research" is blown out of the water with one picture showing the bigfoot lay next to the road.
 
Footers must have inside info that BF likes hanging by the side of the road. The Babes in the Woods Monsterquest had the babe's getting a shot of a passing auto with their trail cam, IIRC.

How deeply involved was Noll with the MQ program?

The footers like to claim their is no money to be made in BF but Noll, Munns, Meldrum, TheMelba, etc all have shown their is darn good money to be made in BF if you are a con artist with no sense of decency.

No doubt the Elbe trackway would have been featured prominently in an upcoming BF program until the "experts" realized that none of them laid down the tracks.

Does Derek Randles have a money making scam he is operating? I confess to not knowing anything about him.
 
"However, if a large land mammal such as an elk can lay next to a roadway, why can't another large land mammal? If one of the largest species of deer can lay down (as do most large land mammals) and can be found on or near roadways, what would preclude a larger than life primate? Seems the argument is about large animals laying down and being near roadways."

Hehehehe. Saw that piece of flawed reasoning at the other thread too... Its Ace's, right? He/she must be wearing believer's blinders, I say.

Its not about large animals laying down and being near roadways. Its about large animals laying down and being near roadways which never become a roadkill or are killed by hunters. Heck, feel free even to present an example of a small animal which lays down and is near roadways but has never been killed.
 
Footers must have inside info that BF likes hanging by the side of the road. The Babes in the Woods Monsterquest had the babe's getting a shot of a passing auto with their trail cam, IIRC.

How deeply involved was Noll with the MQ program?

The footers like to claim their is no money to be made in BF but Noll, Munns, Meldrum, TheMelba, etc all have shown their is darn good money to be made in BF if you are a con artist with no sense of decency.

No doubt the Elbe trackway would have been featured prominently in an upcoming BF program until the "experts" realized that none of them laid down the tracks.

Does Derek Randles have a money making scam he is operating? I confess to not knowing anything about him.

The fact that Noll still endorses the Skookum elk lay as BF is exactly why hes not worthy of the alpha footer position he holds. Elbe didnt help, but his take on reality vise a vie bigfoot is sad.....

And maybe the babes were afraid to actually enter the woods.
 
Googled Derek Randles and found the Olympic Project page. Yep, DR is right up there with Noll and the rest.

I didn't realize the Skookum elk arse was the "first" BFRO expedition, tho.
 
This thread is a great re-read if you have the time.. Too bad the links to the old BFF are dead.. Those were some good discussions..

Here is the official report at BFRO

http://www.bfro.net/news/bodycast/expedition_details.asp

In reading back through the thread, there was an article that stated the Skookum expedition was financed by an Australian film company ..
I didn't remember that ..

ETA:

It's a good re-read up to a point.. there is a serious de-rail that amounts to pages of stuff with nothing to do with the Skookum event..
 
Last edited:
Sorry I just caught the thread switch...

The tires on that photo of the vehicle dont even appear to have mud or dirt.. well the entire vehicle looks pretty clean. Yikes !
 
Reading this and looking back just hit me in the head like a baseball bat, this frigging thing is 12 years old, man i am getting old fast.
 
Reading this and looking back just hit me in the head like a baseball bat, this frigging thing is 12 years old, man i am getting old fast.

We all are.. well so is Patty .. and well ? Thanks for posting that picture on the other thread. That really was helpful for me.

Tom

oh.. Edit:

Greg joined the Army !.. and Mr. P changed his gender while we were gone !!

Dont mind me btw... Hope everyone is doing well .
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom