Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Too far? She is setting the pace.

bobbieshort on JREF said:
"In my opinion, they NEVER tracked her at all, she dropped at the end of that film... also it's only been in recent time that this kind of detail could be seen in the film..."

"Titmus never tracked Patty across the creek to an overlook where she sat down. He lied.."

"Watch this sequence of frames from the Patterson film....direct your attention to the right side of Patty's back; specifically the lower right lung/kidney region. A few frames will flash by when nothing appears to happen then suddenly there is an anomaly in the region I directed you to watch.....I ask for your patience, it will take watching the sequence of frames many times over.......study it closely before you conclude that I'm nuts, ....I have studied & reviewed this sequence continuously since last summer and granted, it IS difficult to follow, but keep your eyes on that area of Patty's back."

"Patty has at this point been hit a number of times with steel jacketed 30.06 rounds..."

"I am NOT claiming anything. It appears to me (my opinion is NOT a claim) that there is a high probability the subject in the Patterson film affectionately known as "Patty" (be it Heironimus OR Sasquatch) was, in my opinion, shot, yes in the back....and in the leg... and elsewhere."
 
The BFF crowd is also now trying to recall the story of the "other guys" that saw P&G at Bluff Creek the day of the filming. We discussed this last year. I think Sheriff Edson is telling a lie.


Recollections of Charlie Edson

It wasn't sheer coincidence that Red and I happened to be tracking in that area that day we accidentally saw Patterson and Gimlin go galloping past of on horseback. Of course, at the time we didn't know who the hell those guys were or what they were up too. We only knew we didn't care to get involved in any kind of social chitchat; not have to explain what we were doing in the area. We just squatted down and hid behind some underbrush until they rode past us. When we saw they were lugging a lot of equipment with them on a packhorse, I guess we just figured they were timber surveyors. Either that or gold miners as there had been a lot of prospecting for gold in that area in recent months.

It wasn't until later that we found out it was only about a half hour after we spotted them that they must have spotted that female Bigfoot and gotten their historical 16mm film.
 
Even if Edson's story is true, it doesn't rule out a hoax at all.

My theory is that P&G were alone on October 20th. The filming of the suit guy was done prior to that day. Long enough in the past to get the film developed, check it out, and edit the thing. Make sure that you like it before you tell anyone that you have it. Then go back to the camp to stage the big announcement. Get the trackway all spiffy because folks will want to see it. When everything is set to go... you zoom off to Willow Creek and put on your best excited snow job for the other Bigfooters. We got the son of a buck on film!

No, you don't have anybody else with you on October 20th.
 
RiverRun on BFF said:
Patterson in his own words (no misquotes, or reporter error) signed a letter stating they tracked the creature for "about three miles". Thats pretty hard to dispute.

Gigantofootecus said:
Then why would Gimlin deliberately contradict Patterson? He knew what Roger had claimed, yet didn't go along. Did he miss the "let's keep our stories straight" meeting? Doesn't make sense. What was his motive?

The dispute is not about the tracking incident as a real event. Everyone (I think) knows that that is a lie. Gimlin is implying that Patterson lied about that. Gimlin is denying it happened because it destroys the timeline if he goes along with it. The point is that Roger lied to everyone, and even did it in the newsletter which folks paid to get. Ask Gimlin why Roger felt compelled to lie about that. You guys just filmed Bigfoot for the first time and you go tell a boner like that? WTF is on your mind, Roger?

Then we have the bent stirrup incident. Roger showed Hodgeson a bent stirrup only hours after it had happened. It was his way of proving his foot had been crushed by showing a piece of evidence. Look at this, Al. The horse fell so hard on me it bent the stirrup itself. Gimlin says it didn't happen. The horse reared and Roger slid off. That does not bend a stirrup and Gimlin knows it. It seems that Roger bent that thing himself to be used as a phony prop. But why would you do that if you had just filmed a real Bigfoot only hours earlier? The foot crush/bent stirrup thing was another lie. But this one is different because a prop was prepared in advance of telling the lie. Ask Gimlin if Roger bent the stirrup in camp, or if he did it in his workshop before going to Bluff Creek.
 
It's being discussed on BFF and here are a few selected quotes from various posters...
Simply amazing (to me, once again) people's inability to discern and otherwise decipher good from bad, right from wrong etc. Without knowing the handle or identity of a single one of those posters I can say without reservation those people don't have a ******* CLUE what they're talking about. Firstly, Byrne's 'reputation' has never been 'in question' that I know of. Second, do they realize he, a world renowned 'big game hunter', was THE ONE given the million(s) of dollars to seek the big hairy monster and when he came up empty actually admitted it with humility and honesty? Sorry all you wannabes on the BFF, not everything and everyone is 'the same' regardless of how contemporary they might be with one another. I've admitted I don't know much of Titmus, but what I've learned (recently) of him, and in just a few of apparently many instances, is more 'questionable and controversial' than anyone can claim of Byrne in his entire career. People just love to speak without first pulling their head out of their ***, and it surely shows on the BFF in this instance. Cripes!

... Then we have the bent stirrup incident. Roger showed Hodgeson a bent stirrup only hours after it had happened. It was his way of proving his foot had been crushed by showing a piece of evidence. Look at this, Al. The horse fell so hard on me it bent the stirrup itself. Gimlin says it didn't happen. The horse reared and Roger slid off. That does not bend a stirrup and Gimlin knows it...
And not simply because it didn't happen, but because it COULDN'T have happened. Taking only a small leap here, the stirrups on the saddles that they would have been using (western saddles used for work/pleasure) in MOST instances have no capability of being bent as TYPICAL stirrups are made of laminated/steam formed wood and not metal/steel. And even if they were 'two hipsters' going against the 'cowboy grain', steel stirrups just don't bend by being fallen on on otherwise soft/earthen ground. I've never bought that 'bent stirrup' story.

As for the bigger fish, Patterson, it seems, would say whatever came to his mind at the time? And not necessarily always in compliance with previous versions of 'the story'? And with Patterson's death Gimlin was left to defend and/or otherwise deflect the scrutiny and criticism of all these years? My question is why on earth would he do that? Has to be because he started out telling 'the story' and staying with it at least makes him consistent, if not FOS?
 
Snip......
As for the bigger fish, Patterson, it seems, would say whatever came to his mind at the time? And not necessarily always in compliance with previous versions of 'the story'? And with Patterson's death Gimlin was left to defend and/or otherwise deflect the scrutiny and criticism of all these years? My question is why on earth would he do that? Has to be because he started out telling 'the story' and staying with it at least makes him consistent, if not FOS?

Just a total WAG on my part but I think that as long as Patricia Patterson is alive he is obligated either legally, or via a promise.
 
Last edited:
Just a total WAG on my part but I think that as long as Patricia Patterson is alive he is obligated either legally, or via a promise.
I bet you that's it huh! I'm not hopeful he'll come clean before he dies, which then leaves just her and she's not spoken publicly (to any degree of worth) about any of it, ever, has she? Not sure he's got much to gain by telling now anyway, except possibly a 'clear conscience'.
 
Wouldn't the horse be injured by the stirrup? I don't know jack about horse riding, but what bends the stirrup when the horse falls over? If it's the horse's body, wouldn't the horse have an injury?

I suppose it could be protected from injury by the leather or some equipment, but given the location of the stirrup it seems like the stirrup would have injured the horse.

And what about the equipment Roger had strapped to the horse? Wouldn't some of that be under the horse in a fall?
 
There is good evidence that the film did not leave California before processing. This is only a side issue while other issues predominate. The Bluff Creek incident is a very, very, tangled web that has taken me a very long time to unravel. As far as I'm concerned, it is understood now, at least for me. It is not surprising that this film has generated such a maelstrom of controversy, when it was edited and produced for that very purpose. It is intended to entice and to mislead. The only thing that has saved the day, is that the editing was not good enough. Enough of the original survives. M.K.
 
There is good evidence that the film did not leave California before processing. This is only a side issue while other issues predominate. The Bluff Creek incident is a very, very, tangled web that has taken me a very long time to unravel. As far as I'm concerned, it is understood now, at least for me. It is not surprising that this film has generated such a maelstrom of controversy, when it was edited and produced for that very purpose. It is intended to entice and to mislead. The only thing that has saved the day, is that the editing was not good enough. Enough of the original survives. M.K.

I assume n your next post you start pushing the bullshaw about the genocide f the whole tribe and corresponding cover up? I presume you have something you'll show to back this "theory" up?
 
M.K. Davis,
IMO here and now is as perfect an opportunity as any for you to lay out precisely your 'story' of both what you know and what you believe regarding the entire PGF affair. Your assertions to 'now knowing the real picture' must also be worthy of public review given the magnitude of your past contributions to the same cause. The question: At whatever the risk, possibly even voiding or contradicting (documented) past instances of your expressed opinion, what is the FINAL PGF skinny?
 
There is good evidence that the film did not leave California before processing. This is only a side issue while other issues predominate. The Bluff Creek incident is a very, very, tangled web that has taken me a very long time to unravel. As far as I'm concerned, it is understood now, at least for me. It is not surprising that this film has generated such a maelstrom of controversy, when it was edited and produced for that very purpose. It is intended to entice and to mislead. The only thing that has saved the day, is that the editing was not good enough. Enough of the original survives. M.K.

Would you say that the in-camera original rolls, in total, were never screened, at least not publicly? If not, what do you think was shown? Short intact section/s of the original? A Copy of the original, in total? Or shorter sections with splice editing?

Do you suspect that actual individual frames have been tampered with (apart from splice editing)? On the original? Only on copies? Or both?
 
Last edited:
I think the film was already edited that Sunday when it was shown to people at DeAtley's place.

It is quite possible the film was already filmed and edited and ready to show, when Roger and Bob set off on their adventure into the Bluff Creek.
 
It is quite possible the film was already filmed and edited and ready to show, when Roger and Bob set off on their adventure into the Bluff Creek.

Oh yeah. The editing pretty much had to be done before Sunday if it was already edited when shown Sunday morning.

Way before Sunday would certainly fit. :D

Then there is the question of the second roll and when and where it was processed/edited.
 
Then there is the question of the second roll and when and where it was processed/edited.


There doesn't seem to be any reason why the "second roll" could not be filmed, developed and edited prior to Oct. 20th. The film can that Roger displayed to Hodgeson could have been a hoax prop just like the bent stirrup. They may not have filmed anything on Oct. 20th and instead pretended and lied about that.

If Roger already knew that he could and would edit the film, then he could have even filmed the plaster pour and cast display scenes before he filmed Patty. He even told Krantz that he created and filmed a faked trackway just days before Patty and at Bluff Creek. Did he throw that film away, or is it the scene we can see today?

Maybe the missing portion of the original "first roll" contains scenes which are now called the second roll. Split up a single 100' roll and pretend that it was two rolls.
 
From Chris Murphy. There is more at the link...


The second roll of film Roger Patterson and Bob Gimlin used at the film site continues to elude us, but I believe I have probably obtained most of the images of any importance. You have to think about this a bit. A 100-foot roll of 16mm film would contain about 4000 individual frames. Now, with the camera running at 16 frames per second, that is about 4 minutes of filming, which is not a lot of time.

Rene Dahinden had about a ten-foot strip of film from the second roll that was given to him by Roger Patterson. He had several photographs taken from the frames (I went down an picked up the photos for him while he was away). The photos seen here are from this strip. They match the appropriate frames Thomas obtained, except the casted print appears to have a handwritten mark. I have no explanation for this. I had the strip in my possession for a week or so, and do recall looking at the first few frames with a magnifying glass. I recall seeing shots of a horse or horses – close ups from the front. At the time, I was not totally aware of the significance of the strip – I was simply doing Rene a favor.

The second film roll was definitely shown at the University of British Columbia on October 26, 1967. I am sure the type of film is the same as that used to film the creature (first roll). If there is an issue with the film development time for the first roll, then the same would apply to the second roll. While I believe both rolls were developed at the same time and place, if one believes otherwise, the second roll was developed within four (4) days (not counting the day the men traveled back to Yakima, and the day they traveled to the University). This is not enough time to get the film to, and back from, Palo Alto, California. Any alternate scenario whereby it is suggested that the films were taken much earlier that October 20, 1967 creates a whole series of other problems beyond the scope of this discussion.

Why does Murphy mention Palo Alto? Why would they ever have any roll developed in Palo Alto? Isn't the common assumption that all undeveloped roll(s) went to Yakima by one method or another?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom