Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Terrific. I'll post MDF-related messages in that thread, but since I'm not a mod, far be it from me to politely suggest that we stick to the topic at hand.
 
I know some have said they could do it. Then when they tried, they failed miserably.

Who did this? Feel free to give examples.

This article has several quotes from various special effects artists talking about it likely being a suit:

http://www.strangemag.com/chambers17.html


Very very good custom made suit=$$$$$$$$$$$ So how would a guy who was broke come up with that caliber of costume?

Take a look at Munns attempts using a 16mm camera. The resolution on that film is not great. The PGF is better but not by much. You can't resolve things like zippers, folds, etc because of the film limitations. A suit shot from the distance in question and under the conditions seen would not be easy to identify as a suit. Just because it can't be identified as a suit, does not mean it was an expensive suit.
 
Who did this? Feel free to give examples.

This article has several quotes from various special effects artists talking about it likely being a suit:

http://www.strangemag.com/chambers17.html




Take a look at Munns attempts using a 16mm camera. The resolution on that film is not great. The PGF is better but not by much. You can't resolve things like zippers, folds, etc because of the film limitations. A suit shot from the distance in question and under the conditions seen would not be easy to identify as a suit. Just because it can't be identified as a suit, does not mean it was an expensive suit.

But it has been analyzed frame by frame, under a digital microscope. Considering how much images can be sharpened these days, I think a zipper or some other sign of a costume would at least be indicated. Even a synthetic fiber
 
I know some have said they could do it. Then when they tried, they failed miserably. The late Jonas Prohaska(sp?), who was an actor who portrayed various apes in movies, said he didn't think it was a person in a costume. But if it was, it was the best costume he'd ever seen. This is where I think the idea of it being a guy in a suit, runs into direct conflict with what has been reported about Roger Patterson. That he was broke. I would think if it was a guy in a suit, it would've been debunked years ago unless it was a very very good custom made suit. Very very good custom made suit=$$$$$$$$$$$ So how would a guy who was broke come up with that caliber of costume?

This simply is incorrect. Rick Baker has made the most convincing ape suits ever created, starting with the 1976 King Kong -- an animatronic suit with padded musculature -- and continuing through the 80s with the amazingly lifelike Greystoke chimps and Gorillas in the Mist suits, the 90s with Mighty Joe Young, and the 2000s with Burton's Planet of the Apes masks and costumes (brilliant work in an otherwise horrible movie). Today as in 1967, there are realistic and convincing ape suits with padded musculature and lifelike fur.

Janos P., as I said, said he didn't think it was a guy in a suit, but in the same interview went on to say he thought it would take "six hours" to glue all the hair onto such a suit. Prahoksa's negative opinion was based on personal incredulity that a hoaxer would take such time and care to create a hoax suit.

As to the money issue with Patterson, it's known and documented that Patterson borrowed $700 from a Hollywood attorney, which he did not pay back, and in the years since his death there have been similar accounts from relatives regarding unpaid loans. Furthermore, Patterson wouldn't have had to buy the suit outright, he might have rented it from a Hollywood effects man who was willing to go along with the gag, and/or purchased a second-hand suit on the cheap, which he himself modified with the application of hair and teats.

Personal incredulity as to how such a suit might have been acquired is illogical and insupportable, particularly when there are numerous possible explanations that are more plausibe than "a 500+-pound bipedal primate roaming NA, taking in 8000+ calories per day, in winter, while avoiding unambiguous detection by cameras and zoologists". "Guy in a suit" is simply more probable, more plausible and simpler than the absurd alternative.
 
But it has been analyzed frame by frame, under a digital microscope. Considering how much images can be sharpened these days, I think a zipper or some other sign of a costume would at least be indicated. Even a synthetic fiber

We're talking about the resolution of the film stock itself. Microscopes will not reveal a level of detail that the film and camera themselves were physically incapable of capturing.
 
This simply is incorrect. Rick Baker has made the most convincing ape suits ever created, starting with the 1976 King Kong -- an animatronic suit with padded musculature -- and continuing through the 80s with the amazingly lifelike Greystoke chimps and Gorillas in the Mist suits, the 90s with Mighty Joe Young, and the 2000s with Burton's Planet of the Apes masks and costumes (brilliant work in an otherwise horrible movie). Today as in 1967, there are realistic and convincing ape suits with padded musculature and lifelike fur.

Janos P., as I said, said he didn't think it was a guy in a suit, but in the same interview went on to say he thought it would take "six hours" to glue all the hair onto such a suit. Prahoksa's negative opinion was based on personal incredulity that a hoaxer would take such time and care to create a hoax suit.

As to the money issue with Patterson, it's known and documented that Patterson borrowed $700 from a Hollywood attorney, which he did not pay back, and in the years since his death there have been similar accounts from relatives regarding unpaid loans. Furthermore, Patterson wouldn't have had to buy the suit outright, he might have rented it from a Hollywood effects man who was willing to go along with the gag, and/or purchased a second-hand suit on the cheap, which he himself modified with the application of hair and teats.

Personal incredulity as to how such a suit might have been acquired is illogical and insupportable, particularly when there are numerous possible explanations that are more plausibe than "a 500+-pound bipedal primate roaming NA, taking in 8000+ calories per day, in winter, while avoiding unambiguous detection by cameras and zoologists". "Guy in a suit" is simply more probable, more plausible and simpler than the absurd alternative.

In a discussion over on BFF or NABF, someone did some checking & found out stretchable fake fur like would be needed to move so life-like over the musculature, wasn't available in 1967. Although Janos P.'s statement about gluing the hair on a costume does sound like something someone with a little inside info might say. And I would think that would work in place of stretchable fur fabric
 
Let's stay on topic folks. I've moved several posts dealing specifically with the Memorial Day Video into THAT thread.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
That Patty does nothing "special" in the 60 seconds of film probably also tells the Hollywood naysayers that this was not a truly sophisticated suit. A top-notch Hollywood creature costume needs to allow the actor to do a variety of things and still remain realistic and still not show evidence of being a costume. A high design suit should allow the actor to do things like grab, lift, pull, kick, jump, roar from an articulated mouth, etc.

Patty does nothing other than walk and look at the camera. The Hollywood skeptics know that if the suit was "truly excellent" in those respects, Patterson would have put it to use and had Patty do some convincing stuff. What kind of a decent hairy giant creature movie could you make if your thing can only walk and turn its head?

Winston said it was a bad hair suit. I think he could have gone on to say that it most likely would have failed miserably if it required any action scenes or was filmed any closer. You need a suit that can do all sorts of things and still not look like a suit. A good suit allows the monkey to peel and eat a banana. ;)
 
Janos P., as I said, said he didn't think it was a guy in a suit, but in the same interview went on to say he thought it would take "six hours" to glue all the hair onto such a suit.

Not exactly. If you listen closely to Prohaska, he speculates that those hours would be necessary to glue the hair onto the body of the actor. He thinks (if not a BF) that it must be a huge muscular guy with hair glued directly to his body. Interestingly, he doesn't mention the breasts and that maybe it rather ought to to be a huge muscular actress with hair glued to her body. Maybe he simply assumed that fake breasts are just another glue-on like the hair and that it would have been a male actor.
 
But it has been analyzed frame by frame, under a digital microscope. Considering how much images can be sharpened these days, I think a zipper or some other sign of a costume would at least be indicated. Even a synthetic fiber

1. You did not answer my question about what effects artists could not replicate the PGF.

2. Film has a limit to what it can resolve. You can look at it with an electron microscope and the film is not going to get any better. All you are doing is magnifying noise. Might I quote William G. Hyzer when it comes to photoshop experts. Hyzer is considered a top photogrammetrist and wrote for "Photomethods" magazine (Now called Photoelectronic imaging). He was referrred to as "Mr. Photoinstrumentation". His biospace entry read:

Mr. William Hyzer (prefers Mr. Hyzer) has conducted research, published papers, and served as an expert witness on issues involving the ability of human observers to see and react to visual stimuli. Most of his current work is devoted to visibility issues relating to what a human observer can see under existing lighting conditions. In addition, he has extensively studied the ability of other imaging methods (i.e. photography, videography, etc.) ... Mr. Hyzer's forensic work has also been devoted to photointerpretation and photogrammetric analysis of photographic and video evidence. It has been devoted to the analysis of photographs that may have been fraudulently produced. Finally, it has been devoted to the development of specialized photographic techniques for recording evidence ... in 1981, the Professional Photographers of America conferred upon him the honorary degree Master of Photography for his important contributions to the photographic sciences...Mr. Hyzer is the author of two scientific books, over 500 published technical articles, and has several patents relating primarily to the fields of electro-mechanics, electro-optics, and the photo sciences. He is the author of the column "Scientific Instrumentation" in the monthly publication PhotoElectronic Imaging.

Now, when Mr. Hyzer was handed the Ed Walters UFO photos back in the early 1990s he determined they were hoaxes. MUFON (the Mutual UFO Network) decided to get an expert to counter his claims. There expert was not as qualified as Hyzer and Hyzer made some comments about his analysis in the MUFON journal (see "William G. Hyzer responds" MUFON Journal October 1992):

There is a certain commonality that exists between some statisticians and digital-image-processing aficionados:

'Tell me what you want them to hear and I will produce a statistic to support it."

"Explain to me what you want them to see and I will create an image to buttress that perception."

The power to alter images is a cause of great concern among forensic image examiners and by those who depend upon their images to convey impartial information regarding a scene or object. Elements within an image can be fabricated, enhanced, distorted, shifted, cloned, erased and/or transferred to another image with a precision that virtually defies detection...digital image processing, even in primitive form, is a highly manipulative process capable of changing an image into something it isn't in order to highlight certain features and/or subdue others at the personal discretion of the operator.


Be careful of claims made by people like MK Davis, who claim they are seeing eyeballs, nostril hairs, teeth, or whatever in these images.
 
In a discussion over on BFF or NABF, someone did some checking & found out stretchable fake fur like would be needed to move so life-like over the musculature, wasn't available in 1967.
That's Mr Munns' opinion regarding a particular National Fibre Technology product that became commercially available in the 80's. Obviously other artists of presumably vastly greater experience (multiple Academy Award winners) seem to miss this :rolleyes:.
 
Last edited:
Not exactly. If you listen closely to Prohaska, he speculates that those hours would be necessary to glue the hair onto the body of the actor. He thinks (if not a BF) that it must be a huge muscular guy with hair glued directly to his body. Interestingly, he doesn't mention the breasts and that maybe it rather ought to to be a huge muscular actress with hair glued to her body. Maybe he simply assumed that fake breasts are just another glue-on like the hair and that it would have been a male actor.

Excellent point. Thank you for the correction/clarification.
 
A suit with animatronics that blinks and flares its nostrils is a good suit. The suit in the PGF, not so much.

1)Animatronics didn't exist in 1967
2)If it is a suit, it's good enough to have built in padding for musculature & doesn't sag anywhere.
 
The bottom line for me is this. If the film is fake, it doesn't mean Bigfoot doesn't exist & considering it was 42 years ago, if the film is real, it doesn't prove Bigfoot still exists
 
The bottom line for me is this. If the film is fake, it doesn't mean Bigfoot doesn't exist & considering it was 42 years ago, if the film is real, it doesn't prove Bigfoot still exists

I would agree that the PGF, by itself, doesn't make the case for or against Bigfoot. However, it is the best evidence the Footers have, and if it's a hoax the likelihood of Squatch existing drops very significantly.

As I've posted before, I grew up in Washington state and, deep in my heart, I actually hope that the big guy is real. The rational side of my brain, though, tells me that there's no compelling evidence for that. I keep hoping though, and probably always will.
 
I would agree that the PGF, by itself, doesn't make the case for or against Bigfoot. However, it is the best evidence the Footers have, and if it's a hoax the likelihood of Squatch existing drops very significantly.

As I've posted before, I grew up in Washington state and, deep in my heart, I actually hope that the big guy is real. The rational side of my brain, though, tells me that there's no compelling evidence for that. I keep hoping though, and probably always will.
Well yes, the best evidence in the sense that it's the longest standing piece of circumstantial evidence. But I personally think the dermal ridges in the older casts & the recent work done on the Sierra sounds is more compelling
http://www.cryptomundo.com/cryptozoo-news/crypto-ling/
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom