Merged Bigfoot Body in Georgia!

Ben Radford from the same link:

In a report in The Times, Ben Radford, managing editor for Skeptical Inquirer said: "It's smelling to high heaven like a hoax. They can claim to have DNA, but its not going to be possible for them to prove through DNA analysis that they have Bigfoot because there's no specimen in a jar that says, This is Bigfoot, to match it to.
"And the video?... it'll be what's known in the Bigfoot research community as a Blobsquatch, an indeterminate, dark blob that may or may not be a man, a bear, a Bigfoot, an elf, a dragon...who knows?"
 
"They say they have a body, photos of the body, and DNA evidence — some or all of which will be revealed this Friday, Aug. 15, at a press conference in Palo Alto, Calif."

I hope it's all & not some. & if it is some, I hope that some is the DNA. :)
 
Last edited:
Nightwing has been creating those faces for years. The costume has been on that website for at least a couple years (if my memory is correct).

You say "there's a feeling now" as if a decent number of people are actually asserting the link. That sounds like an exaggeration to me.


It was first stated the costume appeared around March, 2007. 16 months. You're correct about Nightwing though.

It's not about numbers. The post was made. It was unchallenged.
 
$#!+, I can't hear what they're saying. The audio on my computer just died. My wife can fix it, but she's out tonight on some sort of hens night or something (at least I hope she is).
 
Here is the complete MELDRUM response, I took it from MABRC, Darkwing (Who some of you might remember, Came over to the JREF and tried to talk Creekfreak down) Posted it. http://www.mid-americabigfoot.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=18057#p18057

http://www.sciam.com/blog/60-second...igfoot-expert-weighs-in-im-extreme-2008-08-14 I took out some of the background stuff and posted it below.


Scientific American from MABRC Darkwing said:
Bigfoot Expert Weighs In: "I'm Extremely Skeptical"


ScientificAmerican.com contacted Jeffrey Meldrum, a prominent researcher on Sasquatch (bigfoot) and professor of anatomy and anthropology at Idaho State University in Pocatello, who has studied bigfoot prints and other clues like hair samples. Meldrum has written a book on the subject of whether or not the mystery beast is real, and has previously said that "the evidence that exists fully justifies the investigation and the pursuit of this question."

An edited transcript of what Meldrum had to say about this week's supposed discovery follows.

What do you think of this announcement of a bigfoot body being found in Georgia?

I'm extremely skeptical about this bigfoot claim. I haven't been contacted by any of the principal [people] involved in this. I've had interactions with Tom Biscardi [the bigfoot hunter holding the press conference] in the past, and based on that history, I would say that anything he is involved in is suspect. The fact that the two Georgian men [who said they found the body] turned to him and not anyone with scientific credentials is very questionable.

What about the pictures?

So a picture is worth a 1,000 words. What I've seen so far is not compelling in the least, and I think the pictures cast grave doubts on their claim. It just looks like a costume with some fake guts thrown on top for effect. Even if [the bigfoot carcass] had have been eviscerated by a predator or a scavenger, [the entrails] wouldn't just be sitting up on top like that. Someone says [on the Internet] that they've found an off-the-shelf costume that looks a lot like the figure in these pictures.

So apparently [the bigfoot finders] stuffed the body into a freezer. You look at it and there doesn't seem to be any mass there, of muscles and bones and so forth. Also, they tried freezing the corpse in a block of ice—you wouldn't do that if you were trying to preserve a specimen, unless you're trying to hide the details.

So what is the story with the Sasquatch DNA evidence?

All the rumors about the bigfoot DNA results are just that: rumors. I spoke to Curtis Nelson (a biologist from the University of Minnesota) who is doing the DNA tests, and he all he could say is that there are no results yet—he can't say anything more due to a nondisclosure agreement. Apparently Curt just received a vial of tissue in the mail, and there's no chain of custody, no validation that this tissue came from the corpse in question. Since there is no known Sasquatch material to compare it to, he may just end up with a sequence that doesn't match any other primates, at best.

Why would anyone stake such an outrageous claim without proof?

I don't know what their motivation would be. I don't see how they think they can perpetuate such a hoax in this day and age. You hold out hope that bigfoot will be found one day, and to some extent this is probably what that event would be like. But assuming that this kind of scenario transpires at some point, hopefully it wouldn't unfold in such a carnival atmosphere and the proper authorities and scientists would be involved.

Photo: Professor Jeffrey Meldrum
Image Credit: AP
 
Last edited:
Well, there you go...Not certain Nelson will have anything to report, and Biscardi will be selling this as a documentary...and Russians...

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/Story?id=5583488&page=1

Scientific Findings Promised
Biscardi said he gave tissue from the body to Curt Nelson, a research scientist at the University of Minnesota with a personal interest in Bigfoot. Biscardi said he and his colleagues will present Nelson's findings this afternoon's press conference.

But on Thursday, Nelson told ABCNews.com that he's not certain he'll have anything to present at the conference.

For the world to really believe the existence of bigfoot, Nelson said, teams of unbiased scientists would have to collect and analyze DNA and thoroughly inspect the body.

"It would take a lot more than I'm doing," he said, noting that people will want to see an actual body rather than just tissue samples. "If the guy claims to have a body, he really should produce one," Nelson said.


Instead, Biscardi said he plans to keep the body at an undisclosed location while scientists, including two Russian hominid specialists, study the creature. Biscardi said the entire process will be filmed and then released as a documentary.

...
 
Last edited:
deep44, care to show where the faces differ?


It's irrelevant, because even if they appear to be identical, it doesn't prove that there's a mask shown in the picture. What if the (alleged) real Bigfoot creature just happened to look like the mask?

There's no reason to even speculate - they say they're going to have all these scientists look at it, DNA tested, etc. Until that happens (with sufficient transparency), their claim is meaningless anyway.
 
It's irrelevant, because even if they appear to be identical, it doesn't prove that there's a mask shown in the picture.

Are you aware that this is a skeptical site? It's naturally chock brim full with people who are skeptical.

Are you aware of the changes in the stories these folks have told?

Are you aware of this:

After seeing the corpse, Dr Van Buren says: "It's obviously a male, we looked at a very, very large primate male, it doesn't fit into any of the taxonomic groups I can think of.

"Unbelievable, I'm still shaking... I've never seen anything like this before."

However, Dr Van Buren was later outed as being Mr Whitton's brother, Martin, and the pair was forced to concede in a subsequent video that the interview was a hoax.

Are you aware of Biscardi's prior promises to show us a bigfoot?

Do you still maintain that the similarity to the costume should be considered irrelevant by JREF members?
 
Do you still maintain that the similarity to the costume should be considered irrelevant by JREF members?


It's irrelevant in the sense that it doesn't prove anything. I already said that I also suspect that it's a hoax.. but I have no proof of that. Therefore, I will listen to what they have to say at their press conference with an open mind.

Unless they can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the creature is real, through DNA evidence and whatever else, I will continue to believe it is a hoax; however, unless I can prove that, or they admit to it, it will remain a suspicion.

Burden of proof works both ways.
 
http://bigfootdiscussions.invisionz...php?s=&showtopic=2944&view=findpost&p=1398206

QUOTE (bartlojays @ Aug 15 2008, 04:44 AM)
I'd bet you anything, it's not the possibility of the animal's existing he fears, it's the reality that most people who believe in the possibility of the animal's existing are much smarter then he is.


Drew said:
I'll wager a Guinness just for the hell of it.

PARCHER, Are you afraid of either A. Bigfoot really existing, or B. That Bigfoot Believers are smarter than you?

Just answer the Afraid part, I've got a bet riding on this.
 
Let me get this straight:

There are posters here who actually think this claim could be for real??? :jaw-dropp

Incredulous,
BillyJoe
 
Drew, I don't fear either one of those.

I am a bit fearful of Bart for his aggressive bravado. I've read plenty of his postings on BFF and BD. His online personality is one that occasionally develops within those who claim eyewitness encounters with Bigfoot.

I'm here.
I've seen Bigfoot.
And I'm in your face!
 
anderson cooper 360 just showed the picture again. anderson then mentioned tomorrow's press conference and said "i dont think cnn will be covering this live.":D

Perhaps not, but they have made the front page of cnn.com this morning:

Body proves Bigfoot no myth, hunters say

I predict this "unveiling" will either be "postponed" or will consist of a rehash of more of the same old crap.

It seems simple enough. You either publicly present your evidence to a group of legitimate researchers for evaluation, or you STFU.
 
It's irrelevant in the sense that it doesn't prove anything.

You mean it's irrelevant to you? The faces are identical. The only way out of that is to make the same silly claim that was made about the wooden feet...which I see has already been made.

The idea that any regular here is closed minded is silly.

After all of the discussions we have had, and all of the theories we've voiced, and all of the digging we've done, etc., on bigfoot, the PGF, and every purported film and picture that has come up, how can anyone possibly say we are closed minded?

Closed minded people don't take all the time and put in all the effort that the regulars here have done.

For example, I actually paid good money to get the actual manuals for the camera Roger Patterson used, so that I would know about it, and not just be guessing.

Tube has done a lot of work on several subjects.

Parcher has obviously looked at an awful lot of material, as has Diogenes, as have several others.
 
As I have mentioned before, us scoftics know more about Bigfoot ( lore ) than most footers do ..

Take a look at all the newbies showing up at BFF who don't have a clue ..

It's like Atheists knowing the Bible better than most Christians, or any of the skeptics here knowing more about the paranormal claims than the people who are trotting them out as proof of something...

Lu admonished us to ' read Krantz ' ... We did, and guess what ? Still no Bigfoot...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom