Eos of the Eons
Mad Scientist
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2003
- Messages
- 13,749
Oh goody, another chance to lie about how ID is a persecuted "science". Got media attention again. Who the heck invited him as a speaker in the first place, and why???
That, I think, is the most pertinent question in this whole, sorry, debacle...Who the heck invited him as a speaker in the first place, and why???
Stein’s comments came a day after UVM President Dan Fogel announced that Stein, whom Fogel had invited to address UVM’s commencement in May, would not be coming after all. Fogel said that his selection of Stein generated an intense protest, that he received hundreds of angry e-mails over the weekend, and that after he shared these “profound concerns” with Stein, Stein “immediately and most graciously declined our commencement invitation.”
Asked the nature of those “concerns” at a news conference Monday, Fogel said they pertained to views of science perceived by many to be “affronts to the basic tenets of the academy.”
“If he said this,” Stein wrote, “he is responding to complaints about an imaginary Ben Stein.”
Fogel said he had invited Stein — a comedian, lawyer, commentator and financial columnist — to speak about the economy, as Stein had done at another speech at UVM last spring. Fogel said he had been “vaguely aware” of the Stein’s opinions on other subjects.
“Mr. Stein has also expressed opinions on subjects unrelated to economics, most notably with respect to evolutionary theory, intelligent design, and the role of science in the Holocaust,” Fogel said in a statement to the UVM community Monday. “Those views are highly controversial, to say the least.”
Stein called the university’s response to the furor “chicken sh**, and you can quote me on that.”
“I like Dr. Fogel,” Stein wrote, “and feel sorry he is caught in the meat grinder of political correctness. My heart goes out to him. He’s a great guy trying to do his best in difficult circumstances.”
<snip/>
...Stein finally agreed, he said, was that Fogel is the brother-in-law of “my best friend.” (Stein was referring to Fogel’s wife’s sister’s husband, who was his undergraduate roommate at Columbia University.)
The funny thing is the Discovery Institute's spin:
It also seems highly unlikely that Stein's withdrawal was completely voluntary—after all, Dan Fogel, the President of the UVM, has been making it patently clear that supporters of intelligent design deserve second-class treatment at his school. Fogel has been all but parroting PZ’s rhetoric that “it's a real slap in the face for the university to drag in this disgrace who has been a figurehead for a movement that is trying to replace science with superstition,” as Fogel stated::
Why do people automatically dislike you when they find out you are conservative? It's bigotry and intolerance.
And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with.
Does it really matter? Is he a threat to humanity? Well, turning that question around, is it vital to the survival of humanity that Ben Stein should earn money by endorsing eyedrops? If not, why do you care about this issue? --- or could it be that some things are worth bothering about even if our survival as a species doesn't hinge on them?To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me. Ben Stein, threat to humanity?
You seem to be conflating "conservatives" with complete frickin' idiots.And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with. I'm surprised that some here seem to just go along with the idea of it being fine to hurt this man over his silly beliefs and attempts to spread them. He's not such a threat. Why is there always so much outright intolerance from the left on some of these things? Why do people automatically dislike you when they find out you are conservative? It's bigotry and intolerance.
Hello, Earth to Whiplash ... it's not political. It's about science versus nonsense and truth versus lies. It is you, and only you, who has tried to turn it into an issue of left versus right --- by conflating science and truth with the left and nonsense and lies with the right.Sigh, I completley forgot what I was in for if I even dared to wade into political topics again. And yet I do it over and over. Stupid self!
...Dan Fogel, the President of the UVM, has been making it patently clear that supporters of intelligent design deserve second-class treatment at his school. ...
Linguistics is a science, and should not be replaced by creationist rubbish about the Tower of Babel.In fact, were I President of a University, none of them would ever get tenure or grants if they are in the sciences. You can tolerate woo in Literature or Linguistics, but not in the sciences.
Linguistics is a science, and should not be replaced by creationist rubbish about the Tower of Babel.
Sigh, I completley forgot what I was in for if I even dared to wade into political topics again. And yet I do it over and over. Stupid self!
Because I recognize the institutionalized and indoctrinated mindsets I'm up against. It's impervious to anything I can muster. I don't see any way to make any progress.
To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me. Ben Stein, threat to humanity?
And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with. I'm surprised that some here seem to just go along with the idea of it being fine to hurt this man over his silly beliefs and attempts to spread them. He's not such a threat. Why is there always so much outright intolerance from the left on some of these things? Why do people automatically dislike you when they find out you are conservative? It's bigotry and intolerance.
Is it really worth boycotting a product because the pitchman holds a viewpoint you consider dumb? Just wondering.
Same reason I don't eat at Outback - their food's ok but so are many others. Others whose corporate giving does not go to pro-life organizations (loathe that name - they are only pro-forced birth. Most could give a feces less what happens with the child after birth.
... Same reason I don't eat at Outback - their food's ok but so are many others. Others whose corporate giving does not go to pro-life organizations (loathe that name - they are only pro-forced birth. Most could give a feces less what happens with the child after birth.
To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me.
Outback, or its parent company supports anti-choice organizations? Link, citation? Not that I don't trust you, but I'd like to verify.
If so, good to know so I can avoid them, but it's a pity. I always liked their filets, and they're a pretty good price.