Ben Stein's withdraws as university speaker

Oh goody, another chance to lie about how ID is a persecuted "science". Got media attention again. Who the heck invited him as a speaker in the first place, and why???
 
Who the heck invited him as a speaker in the first place, and why???
That, I think, is the most pertinent question in this whole, sorry, debacle...

Ben Stein responds to UVM flap
Stein’s comments came a day after UVM President Dan Fogel announced that Stein, whom Fogel had invited to address UVM’s commencement in May, would not be coming after all. Fogel said that his selection of Stein generated an intense protest, that he received hundreds of angry e-mails over the weekend, and that after he shared these “profound concerns” with Stein, Stein “immediately and most graciously declined our commencement invitation.”

Asked the nature of those “concerns” at a news conference Monday, Fogel said they pertained to views of science perceived by many to be “affronts to the basic tenets of the academy.”

“If he said this,” Stein wrote, “he is responding to complaints about an imaginary Ben Stein.”

Fogel said he had invited Stein — a comedian, lawyer, commentator and financial columnist — to speak about the economy, as Stein had done at another speech at UVM last spring. Fogel said he had been “vaguely aware” of the Stein’s opinions on other subjects.

“Mr. Stein has also expressed opinions on subjects unrelated to economics, most notably with respect to evolutionary theory, intelligent design, and the role of science in the Holocaust,” Fogel said in a statement to the UVM community Monday. “Those views are highly controversial, to say the least.”

Stein called the university’s response to the furor “chicken sh**, and you can quote me on that.”

“I like Dr. Fogel,” Stein wrote, “and feel sorry he is caught in the meat grinder of political correctness. My heart goes out to him. He’s a great guy trying to do his best in difficult circumstances.”

<snip/>

...Stein finally agreed, he said, was that Fogel is the brother-in-law of “my best friend.” (Stein was referring to Fogel’s wife’s sister’s husband, who was his undergraduate roommate at Columbia University.)

from the OP

The funny thing is the Discovery Institute's spin:

It also seems highly unlikely that Stein's withdrawal was completely voluntary—after all, Dan Fogel, the President of the UVM, has been making it patently clear that supporters of intelligent design deserve second-class treatment at his school. Fogel has been all but parroting PZ’s rhetoric that “it's a real slap in the face for the university to drag in this disgrace who has been a figurehead for a movement that is trying to replace science with superstition,” as Fogel stated::

The two don't quite gel...
 
Well, if Fogel was in on any shenanigans to intentionally set this situation up, it certainly seems like his "friends" at the Disco Institute are doing a good job of throwing him under the bus for their own purposes.
 
Rule Number One About Creationism: Anything that gets creationism/ID mentioned in the news is a "victory" for the religious nuts. The American Taliban see themselves as insurgents in a "culture war", and as long as they remain a force to be reckoned with, even after getting defeated time and time again, they can claim "victory". This is why they love the opportunity to debate real scientists, since even if they obviously lose, and end up looking like complete imbeciles, they still "win". So if Ben Stein was invited and allowed to speak at a university, it's a victory; if he withdrew or they canceled on him, that's still a victory for creationism since they can cry "persecution!!". Good publicity or bad publicity, it is still publicity.

I saw some snippets of that Stein documentary about ID. I found it very disturbing since I didn't think Stein was that "hard core" of a religious nut, although I knew he was a conservative. What I find especially disturbing about Stein is I think he should be intelligent enough to know better; he is either lying to kiss up to the religious right and become their new hero, or he actually does believe in ID. Either way it is troubling, but at least the religious right isn't as antisemitic as it used to be, considering the Christian fundies who love Stein now.

During the Bush years, the "political wind" in the U.S shifted much of the culture to the right(at least it looked that way, although maybe, like our economy, it was based on a series of illusions). It wasn't just politicians, but some entertainers shifted in that direction as well, like Dennis Miller for instance, and it seems Ben Stein could be included among them. I'm sure some of them probably regret kissing up to Bushy(one of the Worst presidents in U.S history) and the reich wing(especially the Christian Reich), now that Obama is in power and the neoconservatives have been so discredited.

All along though, the more power and influence the Christian Reich had, the more they claimed they were "persecuted" by the evil, left-wing "secularists".
 
Last edited:
To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me. Ben Stein, threat to humanity?

And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with. I'm surprised that some here seem to just go along with the idea of it being fine to hurt this man over his silly beliefs and attempts to spread them. He's not such a threat. Why is there always so much outright intolerance from the left on some of these things? Why do people automatically dislike you when they find out you are conservative? It's bigotry and intolerance.
 
And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with.

Whereas the Discovery Institute itself does everything it can to feed the belief that well nigh everyone on the right are advocating the exact same restrictions, though on different subjects.

While I will leave the product endorsement part out (as that doesn't affect me in any way), I will say this about Ben Stein and his right-wing friends:

I am a systematist, which means that everything I do at work (and a lot of what I do outside of work as well) has to do with evolution in one way or another. I read articles and books on the subject. I do my own morphometrics, genetic analyses, morphological analyses, and so on. From time to time, when suitable courses are held at my university, I either take them (if they are PhD courses) or teach at them (if they are undergraduate courses). I travel all over the world to search for evidence to see if my hypotheses are valid or not. I communicate and meet with scientists from all over the world to learn new techniques, new analysis tools, or new data. As late as yesterday at lunch I held a seminar on my research at the Natural History Museum in London. I publish my findings in peer-reviewed scientific journals.

Ben Stein thinks I am lying. Ben Stein and the Discovery Institute and all the rest of that crowd are basically saying that every day, I commit fraud. Every time I take a PhD course, I am being lied to by a number of unrelated researchers in various fields from all over the world. Every time I teach a course in biology or discuss my findings with my colleagues in the field or with laymen outside my field, I am lying. Every time I use the funding I've got to travel to gather data from Australia, Japan, Vancouver, or wherever I go, I am embellishing that money to have a paid vacation in an exotic location where I watch birds I would never otherwise be able to afford to watch on what is --- in my case --- largely on tax money. Every time I run an analysis, every time I look at data, every time I sequence a gene, every time I measure the preantennal head length or count the setae on the vulval submargin of a bird louse, I am participating in, and perpetuating, a vast international conspiracy to keep Jesus out of the schools.

And it doesn't stop there either, of course. We're seven PhD students at our department, plus two post docs, one lecturer, three professors, and two professors emeritus, as well as a varying number of Bachelor and Master students and temporary researchers and guests of all kinds. They are all lying, as are the small group of oddly placed bird researchers in the ecology department downstairs, who are basically doing the same as we are. Naturally this extends to every single researcher across the globe who in some way works with evolution.

So what do they base this assertion that we are lying and committing fraud every waking hour on?

Not on actual evidence they got from studying the world. Not from experiments or even experimental data published by others. Not from biometrics, biogeography, geology, morphology, physiology, genetics, ecology, or any other established branch of science.

The belief that it is so, and that it must be so, and that it cannot possibly be any other way. These people are saying that I, and the entire biological community, are frauds, because that's what their parents taught them.

Of course, in the specific case of Ben Stein, it goes even further with his belief that science --- not only the biological sciences, but science --- leads to the holocaust and killing people, which puts another layer of affront to the issue. Not only am I a fraud, an embezzler, a liar, and a member of an enormous conspiracy to keep Jesus out of schools, I am also participating in, or enabling other people to participating in, the killing of people, simply because I do science.

Now, to be more specific. Is it irrational to try to keep this person speaking? Yes, it may very well be. Is it irrational not to want him to speak at a university, in front of the people he calls liars, frauds, embezzlers, and murderers? If he genuinely hold these beliefs, then he has no business speaking at a university. His business there would be to listen.

Does this have anything to do with some kind of political left-right distinction, as you so childishly proposed in your post? Definitely not. It doesn't matter if your political leanings are to the left or to the right: if you are a scientist, this man believes you are a murderer. If you work in the biological sciences, and some other related sciences, this man thinks you are a fraud, a liar, and an embezzler, in addition to being a murderer, based on what is essentially a whim.

Does the silencing of this kind of person --- not in general, but in the specific setting of a university --- have anything to do with politics? Not necessarily. I would say that it has more to do with the feeling that we do not want to be called liars, frauds, embezzlers, and murderers. It might be true in some cases, but rarely for the reasons Ben Stein and the Discovery Institute proposes. What we want is for them to provide the evidence that we are liars, frauds, embezzlers, and murderers, and if they can't do that, they have no business speaking in an academic forum.
 
To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me. Ben Stein, threat to humanity?
Does it really matter? Is he a threat to humanity? Well, turning that question around, is it vital to the survival of humanity that Ben Stein should earn money by endorsing eyedrops? If not, why do you care about this issue? --- or could it be that some things are worth bothering about even if our survival as a species doesn't hinge on them?

I think that science is more important to humanity than Ben Stein's income from eyedrop commercials. To quote the 72 Nobel Laureates who acted as amici curiae in Edwards v. Aguillard:

Our capacity to cope with problems of food production, health care, and even national defense will be jeopardized if we deliberately strip our citizens of the power to distinguish between the phenomena of nature and supernatural articles of faith.​

As a creationist propagandist, that is just what Ben Stein is trying to do.

And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with. I'm surprised that some here seem to just go along with the idea of it being fine to hurt this man over his silly beliefs and attempts to spread them. He's not such a threat. Why is there always so much outright intolerance from the left on some of these things? Why do people automatically dislike you when they find out you are conservative? It's bigotry and intolerance.
You seem to be conflating "conservatives" with complete frickin' idiots.

The problem with Ben Stein is not that he's a "conservative", something that I for one didn't know (I'd never heard of him before Expelled) but that he's a vicious stupid liar. I'll admit that there's some overlap there, but by no means all conservatives fall into that category.

In the same way, not everyone who sticks up for science, truth and reason against crackpot creationist lies is necessarily on "the left". Why did you assume this to be the case?

As for your bilge about "restrictions on speech" Ben Stein can say what he damn well likes --- but no-one is obliged to offer him a platform, still less to award him an honorary degree.
 
Last edited:
Sigh, I completley forgot what I was in for if I even dared to wade into political topics again. And yet I do it over and over. Stupid self!

I don't even know how to respond. Honestly. I admit it. I'm floored, and don't know where to start. It's just a big head shaking moment for me. Different worlds. Different foundations. Different realities. And so much melodrama...

Because I want to actually try to stay on good terms with most people here, I'm just going to go back to fully restraining myself from politics and other more heated issues. That's not why I'm here. I don't want to end up being hated by some simply for my views on issues. Deny it if you like, but it happens. And I can't go any further in these types of discussions without my own self ending up going judgemental and combative. Because I recognize the institutionalized and indoctrinated mindsets I'm up against. It's impervious to anything I can muster. I don't see any way to make any progress.

So carry on. I'll try to take solace in the fact I provided some fertile ground for TLA hopeful's.
 
Last edited:
Sigh, I completley forgot what I was in for if I even dared to wade into political topics again. And yet I do it over and over. Stupid self!
Hello, Earth to Whiplash ... it's not political. It's about science versus nonsense and truth versus lies. It is you, and only you, who has tried to turn it into an issue of left versus right --- by conflating science and truth with the left and nonsense and lies with the right.

If you do not wish to discuss politics, then my best advice to you is not to try to drag politics into an apolitical discussion of an apolitical issue.
 
Last edited:
...Dan Fogel, the President of the UVM, has been making it patently clear that supporters of intelligent design deserve second-class treatment at his school. ...

I should say that they DO deserve second-class treatment.

In fact, were I President of a University, none of them would ever get tenure or grants if they are in the sciences. You can tolerate woo in Literature or Linguistics, but not in the sciences.
 
In fact, were I President of a University, none of them would ever get tenure or grants if they are in the sciences. You can tolerate woo in Literature or Linguistics, but not in the sciences.
Linguistics is a science, and should not be replaced by creationist rubbish about the Tower of Babel.
 
Sigh, I completley forgot what I was in for if I even dared to wade into political topics again. And yet I do it over and over. Stupid self!

Then, as Dr. Adequate asked, why drag politics into the matter? Of the three professors in our department mentioned above, only one is a socialist, while the other two, I understand, and liberals, so right there you have a 2-1 disadvantage for your assertion. Nevertheless, they share the same opinions when it comes to science and evolution, which, in my book, shows that this is not a political issue, even if some would make it so.

Because I recognize the institutionalized and indoctrinated mindsets I'm up against. It's impervious to anything I can muster. I don't see any way to make any progress.

I agree; it is sad when people are indoctrinated not to want to be called murderers, frauds, and embezzlers wantonly by people who are not prepared to back up their claims with evidence.
 
To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me. Ben Stein, threat to humanity?

And frankly, it only helps to feed the belief that many people on the left are for restrictions on speech they do not agree with. I'm surprised that some here seem to just go along with the idea of it being fine to hurt this man over his silly beliefs and attempts to spread them. He's not such a threat. Why is there always so much outright intolerance from the left on some of these things? Why do people automatically dislike you when they find out you are conservative? It's bigotry and intolerance.

I'd like to see how long I would get away with saying that christians caused the holocaust and that christianity leads to murder? Hmmm? Then if I was invited to the vatican to speak by a friend, could they ignore my outlandish viewpoint as outlined in an outrageous "documentary"?

The guy brought this on himself, and people must speak out about the absolutely horrendous things he has claimed. It is impossible to ignore. The people who defend him would never stand for the same nonsense to be said against religion.
 
Is it really worth boycotting a product because the pitchman holds a viewpoint you consider dumb? Just wondering.

Yes. Even of the sponsor doesn't care (assuming you notify them) it feels good.

Same reason I don't eat at Outback - their food's ok but so are many others. Others whose corporate giving does not go to pro-life organizations (loathe that name - they are only pro-forced birth. Most could give a feces less what happens with the child after birth.

I wasn't aware of Outback doing that – have to look it up. I don't buy Domino's Pizza or Coors "beer" for the same reason, although the fact that their products suck also factors into the decision.
 
... Same reason I don't eat at Outback - their food's ok but so are many others. Others whose corporate giving does not go to pro-life organizations (loathe that name - they are only pro-forced birth. Most could give a feces less what happens with the child after birth.

Outback, or its parent company supports anti-choice organizations? Link, citation? Not that I don't trust you, but I'd like to verify.

If so, good to know so I can avoid them, but it's a pity. I always liked their filets, and they're a pretty good price.
 
To be so full of repulsion for this man over his beliefs that one would actively set out to keep him from speaking, and destroy his endorsement deals, seem pretty irrational to me.

Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences.

Ben Stein can voice his opinion all he wants, but to imagine that he would be welcome in places where his opinion is considered offensive is ridiculous. This concept applies to all people, left, right, Christian, atheist, up, down, whatever. You can voice your opinion, but people of the opposing postion do not have to like it or provide you with income (in the case of Stein's sponsership of Clear Eyes, I don't know if commencement speakers get paid but I would be surprised if they did not get some form of compensation). People can choose to look past that if they wish to, but there is nothing about one's freedom of expression that says they have to.

And it is in no way irrational to avoid using something endorsed by someone with repulsive(to you) beliefs or desire to prevent them from speaking at an important event. I would neither buy something endorsed by an outspoken member of the KKK, nor would I want that person to speak at my university.
 
Last edited:
I have a hard time understanding the people who think it is mean or wrong to let a company know that their spokesperson is inhibiting the purchase of their product. Why do you think they pick someone to be the spokesperson??? They are looking to attach the image and the appeal of that person to thier product in order to sell more. If anything it is doing the company a favor by letting them know that it isn't all roses so that they can make an educated decision about the value of the endorsement.

It is a cold hearted process and businesses are only in it for sales volume. I am sure a lot of the people who would be pissed off if they pulled Stien's eyedrop money would be the same folks who wrote letters to have the Dixie Chicks pulled from store shelves.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom