A few more ideas, which others are certainly invited to tweak, change, and improve upon.
maccy: the Quick Draw McGraw Award, for so consistently being able to produce smack-down evidence in a hurry.
e^n: the Fair and Balanced Award for maintaining a calm, cool, collected demeanor even when fending off all manner of personal attacks when he posts at the loose with the truth forum.
CHF: the Rollerblades of Doom Award for his great debunking work at the recent Toronto Troofers event.
jaydeehess: the Patience of Job Award for his longevity in the Christopher7 thread about WTC7.
bje: the Brilliant Parody Award for his 911booger website.