Belgian Politics and the formation of a national government

MCel58

Demented Hen
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
960
Can someone explain to me the system of politics in Belgium and how it functions when it takes so long to get a national government in place?
 
Can someone explain to me the system of politics in Belgium and how it functions when it takes so long to get a national government in place?

I'm sure FromBelgiumWithLove will be happy to weigh in on this one - you might consider sending him a PM.
 
Can someone explain to me the system of politics in Belgium and how it functions when it takes so long to get a national government in place?

I'm Dutch, but I'll try to answer your question. FromBelgiumWithLove may whack me over the head for any inaccuracies. :)

Belgium has always had two main language communities; the Flemish, who speak Dutch, and the Walloons, who speak French. Since the annexation of small bits of Germany after WW1, there are also German speakers, but they number so small that they don't really matter in this.

Belgium was founded in 1830 (*) as a unitary state, with notional equality of languages, but no real equality: in the eyes of French speakers, everyone had the freedom to speak French. When Dutch speaking people wanted to make a career, they in practice had to learn French - but not vice versa. Besides French cultural dominance, there was at that time also French economic dominance: Wallonia was the first industrialized region in continental Europe.

(*) or 1839 if you will, because the Netherlands only acknowledged the loss of the southern half in that year. ;)

This has resulted in a language struggle, with the Flemish wanting real equal rights. Besides that, the economic focus in the country has shifted: Flanders now is the economically dominant part, while the Wallonian coal-and-steel industry is since long in tatters, like everywhere else in Europe, and not much else replacing it.

Since 1970, there have been six state reforms in Belgium which have changed the once unitary state into a highly federalized state. Besides the federal government, there are:
- three language communities (Dutch, French, German) with responsibilities for cultural things;
- three regions: Flanders (Dutch speaking), Wallonia (French speaking plus the German bits), and Brussels Capital Region (bilingual Dutch/French).
with their own parliaments and governments.

Depending whom you ask, there is also a cultural separation of the two main communities. When I recently discussed our countries' politics with a (Dutch speaking) Belgian friend, admittedly over a copious amount of Duvel, he remarked that when he left Belgium to work and live in the UK some 20 years ago, he had Belgian friends; now when he sees them, they're either Flemish or Walloon.

In the course of the federalization, the political parties have also split along language lines. So now there is a Flemish socialist party and a Walloon socialist party; ditto for the (center) Christian-democrats and the (right-wing) liberals, and the newer strand of Green parties. The only unitary party I can think of that has representation is the communist Workers Party. Besides those traditional international ideologies, there are nationalist parties, especially in Flanders. With the last federal elections, the big winner was the N-VA, the New Flemish Alliance, which pushes for even more federalization (and no more federal money to those lazy, unemployed, Walloons (not my view but theirs)); they won 33 out of the 87 seats of Flemish districts (**) for the federal parliament. In general, the Walloon parties are against further federalization and cutting up of the country, while the traditional Flemish parties are not against it.

(**) The Belgian federal parliament is elected by multi-seat districts, where each district equals an administrative province (or Brussels Capital Region), and the provinces are all mono-lingual (except for French-speaking Liège which also has the German bits).

The task of composing a federal government in this constellation is very complex. For ordinary laws, it only needs a simple majority in parliament, but for laws affecting the two (language) communities, it needs majorities in both, let alone for further constitutional change.

Besides that, you'd like to take on board both the Flemish and Walloon party of the same ideological strand, but the relative strengths are quite different in both parts of the country. For instance, the Walloon socialist party PS has always been by far the biggest party, while on the other hand, the Flemish socialist party sp.a has mostly been only the third party of the three traditional political strands - and in the latest elections only the fourth Flemish party, after the nationalist N-VA, the Christian-democrat CD&V and the liberal OpenVLD. The converse holds for the Christian-democrats: they have traditionally been the dominant party in Flanders, but only a distant third in Wallonia.

Closely tied-in with that wish is the wish to have some rapport, party-wise, with the regional governments of Flanders and Wallonia, which obviously is going to be difficult with a nationalist-center-right government in Flanders and a center-left government in Wallonia.

So, all of that requires a very fine line to walk for all negotiators involved to work out a very detailed coalition programme and to be able to sell it to their constituency

Hope that helps!
 
I'm Dutch, but I'll try to answer your question. FromBelgiumWithLove may whack me over the head for any inaccuracies. :)

I suppose the most succinct answer to the question asked is: because Belgium. As I probably already said in another thread somewhere, what Belgium lacks in size, it makes up in complexity.

But you provide an excellent summary of the complexities.

Just to add some more local colour to your account: it's very odd that the split formerly unitary "traditional" parties (left to right: socialists, Christian democrats, and liberals), are barely on speaking terms anymore. By that I don't mean that they necessarily hate each other, I mean it literally. The generation of politicians who had been around when there were national parties has disappeared from the political scene. Those people still had contacts across the language divide. The present-day ones don't have them. They live in separate worlds. And since no party or politician stands for election nationally, they only look at what will sell to the electorate in their neck of the woods. It's somewhat ironic that the two parties who seem to get along the best, and who do keep in close contact, are the two green parties. They were never a unitary Belgian party that split, they arose as two entirely distinct movements in the two parts of the country, in the 1970s, the same time the tradtional parties were splitting. Yet they, unlike any of the other parties, form a single parliamentary group.

Depending whom you ask, there is also a cultural separation of the two main communities. When I recently discussed our countries' politics with a (Dutch speaking) Belgian friend, admittedly over a copious amount of Duvel, he remarked that when he left Belgium to work and live in the UK some 20 years ago, he had Belgian friends; now when he sees them, they're either Flemish or Walloon.

But even on this issue, Belgium is infuriatingly complicated. There were elections in May. In Flanders, a nationalist (as in regionalist) party, that has the abolition of Belgium altogether as its main goal, became the biggest party, and therefore also the biggest party in the whole country. Yet a few months later, the football world cup came around. And the Belgian team, for the first time in ages, did pretty well. In an amazing spectacle that I never saw before, the country erupted in an outpouring of nationalism. The Belgian tricolour was everywhere. Flag sellers did golden business. People put the flag over their balconies, and on their cars. Supermarkets gave away trinkets in black/yellow/red (children, collect all three!). Bakeries made tricolour cakes. The most bizarre thing I saw (and I now wish I'd taken a picture of it to prove that this is true), was a supermarket that sold packs of toilet paper in the national colours. I swear there was not a single street I walked through at the time where there wasn't at least one flag showing somewhere. And that's in a city where the anti-Belgian separatists scored a resounding electoral victory, just weeks before. A yet a lot of those people putting out Belgium's flag must have voted, weeks earlier, for a party that wants to abolish Belgium.

It makes no sense whatsoever. But that's Belgium for you.
 
Last edited:
Thank you. Can anyone explain how it manages to function without a national government in place and is it likely that it will take over 500 days to form one this time.
 
Last edited:
Thank you. Can anyone explain how it manages to function without a national government in place and is it likely that it will take over 500 days to form one this time.
The old government (executive) has resigned, but stays on as caretaker government. It won't formulate new policies, propose new laws, but life goes on according to the laws and regulations in place. Civil servants will decide on applications for social security, will decide on applications for all kind of permits, teachers continue to teach, and judges continue to hear cases, etc. etc., and they all continue to get paid.

The only thing that's really needed is annually a budget bill, and of course, the caretaker government will propose that. But there's no such thing as a "government shutdown" as in the USA.

Where's the problem?

Now, of course, changing conditions in the world means you should change laws and policies to stay economically on top, but to say that the country stops functioning when there's no government in place is ludicrous.
 
Function was probably the wrong word perhaps react to world situations and economic issues such as the crisis would be better?
 
Function was probably the wrong word perhaps react to world situations and economic issues such as the crisis would be better?

With caretaker governments if something major pops up, the leaders of the opposition parties are kept briefed on developments
 
Thank you. Can anyone explain how it manages to function without a national government in place and is it likely that it will take over 500 days to form one this time.

To add to what other posters have already stated: Belgium is never without a government. On the day after the elections, the Prime Minister goes to the King, to offer the resignation of himself and all the other ministers. The King accepts this resignation, but asks them to stay on in a caretaker capacity. Then, the long-winded process of negotiations on forming a new federal government starts. But until the new government can be sworn in, everything continues functioning as before, and the Prime Minister and the other ministers are still at their desks. During that world-record breaking spell of a year and a half of negotations, after the 2010 elections, which foreign media often reported on as Belgium being "without a government", that supposedly non-existent government introduced (and got passed) two annual budgets, engaged in a massive intervention in the financial system to save a bank on the brink of collapse, and even went to war, sending in Belgian F16s to fight in Libya. The current caretaker government is sending some of those same F16s to Iraq.

Some more points:

A caretaker government is legally limited to two areas of operation. One is currently running matters, which means things like collecting taxes, making sure everyone entitled to a government wage gets paid on time, etc. There is never something like that ridiculous US government shutdown. Then there is the more nebulous area of "urgent matters", which require immediate action. As the caretaker government after 2010 lingered on, seemingly forever, more and more stuff that could no longer be postponed ended up on the "urgent" pile. By the time they were finally relieved from duty, they had almost started to operate like a "proper" government again. There are even contingency measures in place for the eventuality that a government might be unable to get a budget throught Parliament. In that case, the system of (my translation) "temporary twelfths" automatically kicks in. Which means that one twelfth of last year's budget is made available for spending, on a month-by-month basis, for as long as there is no new budget.

The primacy of power lies with Parliament, as the representative of the people. Parliament is always functioning very shortly after the elections. And a government, caretaker or "proper" (I keep putting that word in quotes, there is simply no direct equivalent in English that I can think of), can always act if they know there is a clear parliamentary majority for their actions. If they tried to do something without being sure of such support, Parliament could stop them.

A caretaker government is limited in a few other insignificant ways. Appointments to high-level civil service posts can only by done by a "proper" minister. In practice, when somebody retires, someone else is named to the job in, once again, a caretaker capacity. He then has to wait until the new government comes in, and the proper paperwork can be signed. Until then, he has to put a.i., for ad interim after his job title when signing letters, and that's about the only difference. A caretaker government also cannot directly introduce legislation into Parliament. But that problem is easily solved. Since Parliament is up and running, a caretaker minister can take the piece of legislation his ministry has drafted to a few tame MPs, and have them introduce it instead. Same as makes no difference.

One also has to remember that Belgium is by now a seriously decentralized country. A lot of things that are handled by national governments in unitary states are handled by the regional and community governments. They're on a different electoral cycle (5 years instead of 4), and during that period Belgium allegedly had no government, they were all up and running.

ETA: I forgot to answer the question: will it take 500 days this time. Going by the media coverage, no, it won't, and there'll be a new government in place to meet the deadline for next year's budget. Sadly for me, one whose political composition I don't like at all.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for that now I can enter into discussions with my colleagues without feeling like a complete fool
 
I forgot to add something to my earlier post, and I will now do so just before going to bed:

One of the reasons the current negotiations for the forming of a new federal government coalition will probably not take as long as the one after the 2010 elections, is that the issue of yet another constitutional reform is, until at least the next federal elections, in 2018, off the table. We went through six such reforms since the 1970s, but the most problematic outstanding issues have now been solved, and the current Parliament, elected in May, has no powers to change the constitution. (The outgoing Parliament has to give the newly-elected Parliament the power to do so, by a 2/3 majority, and they haven't done so, mercifully.)

But I would never bet any money of mine on predicting the outcome of anything political in Belgium. It might all well still go pear-shaped.
 
I have a further question do you think that the limited powers of the Belgian government during that time has meant that Belgium dealt better with the crisis. It appears not to have introduced any of the austerity measures that are apparent in countries like the UK.
 
ETA: I forgot to answer the question: will it take 500 days this time. Going by the media coverage, no, it won't, and there'll be a new government in place to meet the deadline for next year's budget. Sadly for me, one whose political composition I don't like at all.

And, there is a new government. Flemish nationalists, christian-democrats and liberals together with the Walloon liberals. With the second Walloon PM in a row.
 
And, there is a new government. Flemish nationalists, christian-democrats and liberals together with the Walloon liberals. With the second Walloon PM in a row.
Not for nothing us this coalition called "business friendly".
The agreement to install Michel as prime minster came after a marathon negotiating session ended on Tuesday with an agreement to lower taxes and raise the retirement age from 65 to 67 by 2030.
 
And, there is a new government. Flemish nationalists, christian-democrats and liberals together with the Walloon liberals. With the second Walloon PM in a row.

So they made it just in time for the second Tuesday in October, the traditional day for the Prime Minister's State of the Union speech (yes, it's informally referred to as such, using the term in English).

With that strange lopsided coalition they've cobbled together, with just one party from Wallonia involved (and thus a minority government on that side of the border), it was inevitable that the top job would have to go to them, as a sort of compensation. Belgian politics is always a matter of delicate balancing acts like that. It will also result in an almost absurd overrepresentation of that party in ministerial posts, since the federal government has, constitutionally, to have an equal number of ministers from both parts of the country (Prime Minister excepted). So now we get 40% of the people, represented by one party that only got 25% of the vote in their part of the country, and less than 10% overall, holding half the federal government posts, plus the Prime Minister. I don't think that's healthy, frankly.

But in that linked article, there it is again, my pet peeve: "Michel speaks excellent Flemish." Grrrr. (It's hardly surprising that he speaks Dutch pretty well. His father, who was party leader before him, taught Dutch before becoming a full-time politician).

And the article also displays another typical foreign misunderstanding of how Belgium operates: "Belgium held federal elections in May, but the nation had since been deadlocked on the formation of a new government." Nothing was ever "deadlocked". That word could have been appropriate for the situation after the 2010 elections, but this time, a perfectly normal, by Belgian standards, process of coalition negotations was going on.

As I'm typing this, the ministerial appointments haven't yet been announced (that's for each party to decide on their own). But to give an example of how things in Belgium aren't always how they're reported abroad: one of the names currently being mentioned as a possible minister for the Flemish nationalists is a young lawyer, local to me (very local as it happens, I see she lives just on the opposite side of the quite small city park from me), called Zuhal Demir. If you think that sound distinctly un-Flemish, it is. She's the daughter of Kurdish immigrants from Turkey. But that's not a problem for the nationalists, who are sometimes portrayed in foreign media as a racist, xenophobic bunch. I don't like them at all, but that, they aren't.
 
Last edited:
I have a further question do you think that the limited powers of the Belgian government during that time has meant that Belgium dealt better with the crisis. It appears not to have introduced any of the austerity measures that are apparent in countries like the UK.

Since the caretaker government had almost the exact same party-political composition as the government that finally succeeded it, I doubt it made any difference to policy.
 
And not in Scotland either, for the record. This is my local SNP member of the Scottish Parliament, and Scottish Minister for External affairs, Humza Yousaf. http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/msps/currentmsps/Humza-Yousaf-MSP.aspx

There is one significant difference between the Flemish nationalists and many other regional nationalist parties in Western Europe, such as the SNP. Most of them tend be on the left side of the political spectrum. But Flemish nationalism has always been dominated by the right wing, sometimes the racist and fascist right wing. That image still lingers on in a lot of sloppy foreign reporting (enhanced by the fact that foreign reporters about Belgium usually get all their information from francophone sources, and there, painting the N-VA as a bunch of xenophobic racists is a popular political pastime).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom