Bazant...Why is his PE calculation so wrong?

Illuminist14

Student
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
40
His Potential Energy calc seemed to be generally accepted a few years ago.... ?
 
Last edited:
Was there really enough Potential Energy? WTC

Was there actually enough Potential energy to destroy and enable collapse of both towers?

And if yes which paper would you cite to back this up?

thanks
 
Hi,

Sorry about the vagueness, It is just that Bazants potential energy calculation for the WTC has been criticized I think because he used an average calculation for all the floors when we know the lower floors are more solid?

Are you asking us to tell you or confirm what you think? :confused:

Who has been criticizing Bazant, and where, and why is this significant?

The usual: Please provide a link or two, with a sweet summary by you, and perhaps a brief quote. And then - specific propositions or specific questions, so we know what to reply to.
 
Was there actually enough Potential energy to destroy and enable collapse of both towers? (1)

And if yes which paper would you cite to back this up?(2)

thanks
(1) Yes.
(2) None needed.

Evidence needed is:
1) The towers collapsed; AND
2) No case exists for anything other than natural processes.

Therefore it must have been natural processes - driven by gravity >> PE.

And no reference to learned papers is needed. :)
 
Last edited:
(1) Yes.
(2) None needed.

Evidence needed is:
1) The towers collapsed; AND
2) No case exists for anything other than natural processes - driven by gravity >> PE.

Therefore it must have been natural processes.

And no reference to learned papers is needed. :)

:D

Bazant for example do you agree with his potential energy calculations? Which seem to be wrong according to some.
 
Hi,

Sorry about the vagueness, It is just that Bazants potential energy calculation for the WTC has been criticized I think because he used an average calculation for all the floors when we know the lower floors are more solid?

More Solid? "We Know"?

You are not being vague, you are simply wrong.

The floors at lower levels were no more "solid" than the floors higher up. (discounting the few mechanical floors) The steel columns were heavier than those higher up, but it certainly did not make the floors "more solid"
 
:D

Bazant for example do you agree with his potential energy calculations? Which seem to be wrong according to some.
Criticising Bazant tends to be regarded as lèse majesté on this forum - a capital offence in the eyes of many.

My own position however is that Bazant wrote a series of papers. The first in conjunction with Le Zhou (read 'Zhou did the writing' :) ) is generally accepted as a valid proof that there was sufficient energy available to cause global collapse of the Twin towers once fall of the top section was initiated. I have minor concerns about the assumptions underpinning that paper but major concerns arise for me when I see other persons misapply the Bazantian reasoning.

Subsequent papers by Bazant with various co-authors refine his academic abstractions - which may be OK, BUT he applies those extended abstractions to the real collapse events of the Twin towers as happened on 9/11. IMO his applications are seriously flawed - they do not match what actually happened.

Given that I do not agree with his application to real 9/11 WTC collapses whether or not his calculations are correct is irrelevant to me.

We had a thread here on the topic about a year or two back.
"Applicability of Bazant's model to the real world "

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=184076&highlight=bazant
 
Last edited:
Thicker columns then, sorry again :blush:.

The point is Bazants block theory of crush up crush down, I have always struggled to accept, as I don't think it was two solid blocks which is what Bazant says. So are his calculations correct?
 
:D

Bazant for example do you agree with his potential energy calculations? Which seem to be wrong according to some.

Suppose Bazant is wrong.

What can you conclude from that? Or which conclusion must then be changed, and why?
For example, does that make a claim of CD inevitable, probable, or even possible?
 
Last edited:
Suppose Bazant is wrong.

What can you conclude from that? Or which conclusion must then be changed, and why?
For example, does that make a claim of CD inevitable, probable, or even possible?

Thanks for your reply, Basically my collegue says that because his block theory which I do not agree with is wrong, the potential energy calculations he made, are derived from that collapse mechanism so they must be wrong, He estimated the mass of each tower according to each floor being an average without taking into account the thicker columns on the lower levels, this is why my collegue thinks he is wrong.
 
Thicker columns then, sorry again :blush:.

The point is Bazants block theory of crush up crush down, I have always struggled to accept, as I don't think it was two solid blocks which is what Bazant says. So are his calculations correct?

Since you don't think it was two solid blocks, wouldn't you then conclude Bazant's critical error is not in his numbers for PE, but in the model itself? Within a wrong model, what does it matter if some parameter is right or wrong? Will a right value give you a right result from a wrong model?



In the real world, collapse transition and progression was mainly floors crushing down on each other, with columns following suit only after they thus lost lateral bracing. As pgimeno points out, floors themselves were neither heavier nor stronger on lower floors. Since column failure was not a significant mode that drove the collapse, it doesn't matter much that they got heavier and stronger towards the ground.
 
Thanks for your reply, Basically my collegue says that because his block theory which I do not agree with is wrong, the potential energy calculations he made, are derived from that collapse mechanism so they must be wrong, He estimated the mass of each tower according to each floor being an average without taking into account the thicker columns on the lower levels, this is why my collegue thinks he is wrong.

How much of a difference would it make if you took this variation into account, and is that difference large enough to significantly change results?

About the use of arguing within a model that you think is wrong see my reply in your other thread.
 
Since you don't think it was two solid blocks, wouldn't you then conclude Bazant's critical error is not in his numbers for PE, but in the model itself? Within a wrong model, what does it matter if some parameter is right or wrong? Will a right value give you a right result from a wrong model?



In the real world, collapse transition and progression was mainly floors crushing down on each other, with columns following suit only after they thus lost lateral bracing. As pgimeno points out, floors themselves were neither heavier nor stronger on lower floors. Since column failure was not a significant mode that drove the collapse, it doesn't matter much that they got heavier and stronger towards the ground.

Very well articulated and that is what i think (bolded) that's what I have been saying to my collegue, Yes I do think his model is wrong, but I thought his PE figures were there or thereabouts, but my collegue says there are wrong.
 
Some people I have been talking with from work....Sorry I cannot really link that.

Well then, I suggest you ask them to explain in more detail. And I also suggest you work out the potential energy of a tower, convert it to an equivalent weight of explosives using the energy density of the explosive of your choice, and consider what damage a bomb that size could do.

A good starting point to understand the energetics of the WTC collapses is Frank Greening's article on the 9/11 Myths website. Greening overestimates the mass of the towers, so his potential energy numbers have to be adjusted downwards by about 40%. Making that correction to his figure of 2.34GJ for the first drop of the top block of WTC1, we get 1.4GJ for the energy available from the least energetic impact in either of the collapses. His generous estimate of the energy required to collapse even an undamaged set of supports (and, of course, this was not the case in reality) is about 0.6GJ, so even in the least favourable case there is more than twice as much energy available than is required to sustain collapse. In subsequent impacts more potential energy will have been released, and the excess of available over required energy will be even greater.

This relates only to the initial stages of collapse, rather than the total energy balance of the entire process; it's really only addressing the question of whether the collapse was expected to contiue in its earlier stages. Outside of conspiracist circles, it's never been seriously suggested that there might not have been enough total potential energy in the buildings to cause their collapse. I suspect that a competent structural engineer would find the suggestion quite absurd.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your reply, Basically my collegue says that because his block theory which I do not agree with is wrong, the potential energy calculations he made, are derived from that collapse mechanism so they must be wrong, He estimated the mass of each tower according to each floor being an average without taking into account the thicker columns on the lower levels, this is why my collegue thinks he is wrong.
Even if Bazant's calcs are wrong - so what? The underpinning model Bazant and Zhou assumed was arguably valid as a limit case BUT no way does it match the actual collapse.

So we need to know the context that your colleague is operating in. If he is discussing what really happened than Bazant is irrelevant. If he is proving 'Bazant Wuz Wrong' without reference to real collapse mechanisms - so what? I suspect that your colleague is confused by the logic of a 'limiting case' - but that is only a guess at this stage.

Remember that I am a minority heretic here - I have never accepted any of the Authorities as binding proof - Bazant or NIST as the two big ones. I have always sought to satisfy myself on the relevant questions which for me have been and remain:
1) Do I professionally understand why the Twin Towers collapsed; AND
2) Can I satisfy myself as to "CD or no CD?"
...and I only use NIST, Bazant and any others as input data for assessment.
 
Last edited:
The point is Bazants block theory of crush up crush down, I have always struggled to accept, as I don't think it was two solid blocks which is what Bazant says.

It's a very simplified model, but it's useful mainly as a limiting case. The Bazant calculations demonstrate that the buildings would have collapsed even if the detailed dynamics of the process had been the least favourable case possible to continuing collapse. Since any real collapse dynamics would be more favourable to collapse, demonstrating that the collapse would continue in the Bazant case is equivalent to demonstrating that it would continue in any case.

So are his calculations correct?

They're not perfect, but they're enough to demonstrate beyond reasonable doubt that collapse would be total once it started.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom