'Batman & Jesus' movie -- trailer just released

Between biography and hagiography, it isn't obvious that the gospels (or similar works such as Philostratus' Life of Appolonius) fall clearly into the former genre. For that matter, we cannot rule out the Hebrew prophetic/midrashic literature which predate Greek notions of biography.

Jesus of Nazareth supposedly spent much of his sermonizing relating moral parables to his audience, stories which didn't need to be rooted in history to have a worthwhile moral point. Who's to say that his disciples didn't do likewise?

Plutarch's bioi are also mainly concerned with making moral points more than history, yet they are valuable sources (when you keep that in mind). It's a feature of the genre, actually.

I'm not saying one can exclude Hebrew tradition. But a great deal is obviously to be learned from examining the Gospels as Greek literature written in a Greek literary tradition. Mythicists tend to ignore this - I imagine few of them can read Greek in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Yup, Carrier and Price have to be the only ones making an effort to do that.

However, if you read the Price link, he makes no mention of other Greek literature, instead resorting to anachronistic diversions. Carrier just barely does, but fails to make the connection to e.g. Plutarch's lives, instead he refers back to pre-Hellenistic times, which is just silly.
 
Last edited:
Yup, Carrier and Price have to be the only ones making an effort to do that.


Quite a bold claim. Doherty also touches on the problem of genre, saying that the "entire genre of wisdom collections of the time [was] a genre which the earliest layer of Q belonged to." It is his contention that Luke and Matthew hung biographical details on an earlier document which certainly could not be characterized as biography, both of them borrowing heavily from Mark.

As to Mark itself, it isn't too difficult to find a mythicist friendly treatment of that one: https://www.facebook.com/MythicistMKE/posts/1429299583829509

Haven't read MacDonald yet, but he surely isn't a lightweight in the field, and definitely cares about genre.
 
Quite a bold claim. Doherty also touches on the problem of genre, saying that the "entire genre of wisdom collections of the time [was] a genre which the earliest layer of Q belonged to." It is his contention that Luke and Matthew hung biographical details on an earlier document which certainly could not be characterized as biography, both of them borrowing heavily from Mark.

As to Mark itself, it isn't too difficult to find a mythicist friendly treatment of that one: https://www.facebook.com/MythicistMKE/posts/1429299583829509

Haven't read MacDonald yet, but he surely isn't a lightweight in the field, and definitely cares about genre.

Odyssey and the Illiad? Rather than contemporary Greek literature? Are you really bringing up this as an example of serious genre analysis?

"In his death and burial, Jesus emulates Hector, although unlike Hector Jesus leaves his tomb empty. Mark’s minor characters, too, recall Homeric predecessors: Bartimaeus emulates Tiresias; Joseph of Arimathea, Priam; and the women at the tomb, Helen, Hecuba, and Andromache."

Seriously? This reeks of just-so story pseudohistory. I'm sure the author has a very vivid imagination. The Odyssey and Illiad influenced probably ALL Greek literature. What's interesting is how the gospels compare to Greek literature written around the time they were composed. Any summary of a remotely serious analysis would mention this.
 
Last edited:
What's interesting is how the gospels compare to Greek literature written around the time they were composed. Any summary of a remotely serious analysis would mention this.


There may be some reason to expect the authors of the gospels to focus solely on Greek literature written around the time the gospels were composed, but you have not mentioned what that reason might be.

Personally, I would not expect a highly syncretic nascent religious movement willing to blend Hebrew monotheism with Greek cultural elements (in the process creating something surprisingly new) to play by such a conservative set of rules. The presence of obviously midrashic retellings of stories from the Torah certainly militates against the hypothesis that the authors felt constrained to the Greek biographical format.
 
Matthew 28 1After the sabbath, as the first day of the week was dawning, Mary Magdalene went to see the tomb. 2And Jesus said, "Is she with you?" 3And Batman said, "I thought she was with you."
 
There may be some reason to expect the authors of the gospels to focus solely on Greek literature written around the time the gospels were composed, but you have not mentioned what that reason might be.

Personally, I would not expect a highly syncretic nascent religious movement willing to blend Hebrew monotheism with Greek cultural elements (in the process creating something surprisingly new) to play by such a conservative set of rules. The presence of obviously midrashic retellings of stories from the Torah certainly militates against the hypothesis that the authors felt constrained to the Greek biographical format.

The gospels were written by culturally Greek people. In Greek. I don't know where you grt "solely" from, but it's blindingly obvious that contemporary literature is more relevant than the Illiad.

You are making things up and putting them in my mouth. I NEVER said that Greek biographies were the ONLY relevant comparison, only that thwy are conspicuous in their abscence in these crackpot theories. I get that it's difficult to have it pointed out that your hero-Authors dance around an incredibly obvious comparison just because it happens to undermine their point, but that doesn't make it okay.
 
When those people read the epistle indicating that the gospel was "first for the Jew, then for the Greek" did they identify with the latter group rather than the former?

You realize that Paul is the 'Apostle to the Gentiles" and that you are grossly abusing that quote, right? And that not all gospel authors were Jews?

Not that I'm surprised - ignorant nonsense typical of mythicist crackpots.
 
You realize that Paul is the 'Apostle to the Gentiles" and that you are grossly abusing that quote, right? And that not all gospel authors were Jews?

Not that I'm surprised - ignorant nonsense typical of mythicist crackpots.

Resorting to smears of "ignorant nonsense" really helps your case. I defer to your clearly superior wisdom in all matters henceforth.
 
When those people read the epistle indicating that the gospel was "first for the Jew, then for the Greek" did they identify with the latter group rather than the former?


Huh? When the people who wrote the gospels read a letter about the gospels they had yet to write?

What are you asking?
 
The gospel predates the gospels, just as events predate the news.

Your point here being? Many of Mark's narratives are obviously "framing" source material that appears to consist mostly of quotations in order to explain them. It looks a lot like a pedagogical collection and contextualizing of source material in the form of quotes and basic narratives of key events.

The most important thing here is that there is no contradiction between Mark not being concerned with the factuality of every event relayed, while at the same time understanding himself to be communicating a moral/spiritual truth about a real person. This is instead entirely in the spirit of Greek literature.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom