The analyses that were presented in this study screened for markers that are associated with the existence of conspiracies and manipulations in various industries. As previously noted, such markers may indeed occur in the absence of anticompetitive behavior; conversely, collusions and/or manipulations may occur in the absence of such markers.
Nevertheless, although this study does not provide conclusive evidence of the existence of anti-competitive market behavior (or, for that matter, any effective manipulation of the Libor rate) on the part of the banks, we do present statistical evidence of patterns that appear to be inconsistent with those that are normally expected to occur under conditions of market competition for certain of the periods under study.
Interestingly, many of these markers were readily available for review by market analysts on a contemporaneous basis. CDS spreads began to increase several months before the market entered Period 2, and yet individual rate quotes remained unchanged. Then, many of the bank quotes actually decreased while the spreads on a wide variety of instruments increased.
Finally, when allegations of potential manipulation were published on April 17, these patterns shifted again.