August 2007 Stundie Nominations

You're nominating anyone percieved as being "truther" or "neutral" in order to make an Ad Hom.


Argumentum ad hominem isn't just a classy synonym for "insult". It refers to a particular type of argument, essentially fallacious, where the character or record of the person putting forward the proposition is attacked and this attack held thus to discredit the proposition.

I saw a classic example here the other day, when someone mentioned a CTer's web site. The response was, you don't want to pay any attention to him, he believes in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

That's an ad hom. Logically, whether or not the person believes in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion has no bearing on whether his arguments regarding the Twin Towers are fallacious or not. (Though knowing the former may help one judge what the quality of the latter may be like.)

It's a useful term. It has a specific meaning. This usefulness is removed when the term is used simply as a synonym for "insult".

"Insult" is a perfectly good word. Why not use it, and leave the technical term alone for use in its proper context?

Rolfe.

PS. If you really meant that someone's arguments were being dismissed just on the grounds that "he's a truther" and not on their merits (or lack of them), I apologise, because that is correct usage. However, it didn't appear that the term was being used in that way.
 
Last edited:
Can you use something from a movie, if you cite the movie? Or does it have to be a website on the internet?
 
Bleh. What do you get if you win the Stundies? What are you suppose to provide?

The rules at top don't really state what you're nominating exactly or why?

Also could you guys nominate me? :p
Like a statement to write up a fellow worker and you say -

"he minimizes wasted time"

Statements that have humor unless you have lost it. But even if the humorless crowd thinks it is a personal attack, take the guide if he was your friend or even you; would what he/she/you say be funny and a stundie.

OR - "if you open the bag you let in gravity"

In the course of CT, some people say funny things by mistake. That is what you are looking for. Something funny, both ways is best.

Ignore wet rags and wet blankets. Keep an open mind and here are the examples of the past stundie stuff -
My see-saw analogy renders any need for "calculations" moot.

These buildings fell in ten seconds. They’re a hundred ten stories. Now let’s just use our mouth to demonstrate this. If a pancake collapse can be described as “clunkity clunk,” how many times can you say that in ten seconds? And if one floor is “clunkity clunk, clunkity clunk, clunkity,” you cannot say that one hundred and ten times in ten seconds. So let’s even give it the benefit of the doubt. Let’s just take off the “clunk.” Let’s just say “clunkity.” You can’t say that in ten seconds, one hundred and ten times.

It is not an attack on the person, it is searching for gems like these. There will soon be a kill-joy award with a special "wet rag" and yearly "wet blanket" awards.
 
Argumentum ad hominem isn't just a classy synonym for "insult". It refers to a particular type of argument, essentially fallacious, where the character or record of the person putting forward the proposition is attacked and this attack held thus to discredit the proposition.

I saw a classic example here the other day, when someone mentioned a CTers web site. The response was, you don't want to pay any attention to him, he believes in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

That's an ad hom. Logically, whether or not the person believes in the Protocols of the Elderes of Zion has no bearing on whether his arguments regarding the Twin Towers are fallacious or not. (Though knowing the former may help one judge what the quality of the latter may be like.)

It's a useful term. It has a specific meaning. This usefulness is removed when the term is used simply as a synonym for "insult".

"Insult" is a perfectly good word. Why not use it, and leave the technical term alone for use in its proper context?

Rolfe.

PS. If you really meant that someone's arguments were being dismissed just on the grounds that "he's a truther" and not on their merits (or lack of them), I apologise, because that is correct usage. However, it didn't appear that the term was being used in that way.

Hmmm you should now disown me because you are very close to logically analysing the issue properly and the fan club hate that (They love me so. They really want me to win that "wet rag" award they've been discussing like a bunch of frat boys in pm, bless 'em). Best back track or they will see you as a target. ;)

Trouble is, as much as I'd like to elaborate on your analysis, I'm not allowed to discuss it (see my signature).
 
Last edited:
Just because arguments can be logically disproved, doesn't mean that it isn't fun to laugh at the sillier ones as well.

Rolfe.
 
Why did you call it an owl? It's clearly a tabby.
Sometimes I call my tabby "Moloch" because she sits behind the translucent curtain looking out the window, and her silhouette looks just like an owl.
 
Galileo thinks that in the U.S., a corpse can be tried for a crime. He really thinks that.

George Bush knows there aren't any bodies to put on trial because the "hijackers" are fictional characters.

That's the real reason he won't put them on trial.
 
Argumentum ad hominem isn't just a classy synonym for "insult". It refers to a particular type of argument, essentially fallacious, where the character or record of the person putting forward the proposition is attacked and this attack held thus to discredit the proposition.



I’ve told him this twelvety times before. He just doesn't want it to be true.
 
Last edited:
No, I don't mean that admission. (Even though he'd previously said that a boy scout with a plastic badge could work out that it was a missile launch track.) I mean where he saw that there was another, fainter track to the left in the picture, more obviously a footpath, probably the real "slug line" someone described, and agreed that was a path. Because it wasn't the one he was going on about.

By the way, another one. Lots of stuff on the News tonight about boy scouts. Their badges are made of fabric (that they sew on their sleeves). Not plastic.

Rolfe.

Most of your badges are sewn on your sash. Only your troop patch would be on your sleeve. And you can win some medals and such. They're probably pewter.

Here's a picture of an Eagle Scout who's probably earned about everything there is in scouting: http://www.egr.msu.edu/~masond/troop125/photographs/coh/eagle02/Ben Lack Eagle Scout.jpg

This guy, too: http://www.wcg.org/WN/02december/32-Sam_Wegner_Eagle_Scout.jpg

Having sewed at least 12 bazillion of those badges and troop patches and American flag patches and more other stuff than I can remember right now on my husband's (he was the Scoutmaster) shirt and my son's shirts (d**n kid kept growing) I can positively state that they are embroidered fabric patches.

You just had to use a Scottish taxidermied Alsatian, didn't you?

Gravy, what is that in your new avatar? And do you just change avatars because you get bored?
 
Gravy, what is that in your new avatar? And do you just change avatars because you get bored?
It's an Owlsatian: the Kat that Konfuses Kirkman. I did it for Malcolm. Because he's worth it.
 
I know it's kind of a slow start, but does the thread really need to be this horribly off-topic?
 
Most of your badges are sewn on your sash. Only your troop patch would be on your sleeve.

Must be different in Australia. We sewed our achievement badges onto one of our sleeves, and other badges (identifying district, troop, rank, etc.) onto the other sleeve.

Though I was never really in it for the badges anyway, so I might be wrong.

Noo, stay away from Crown, they are teh evilz!!!111!!!

Hehe, wasn't at Crown, though I should go sometime soon. You know, when I have money. We set up a 'Casino Night' at college - so just a casino theme for the boys, winning chips that we could redeem for drinks or 'mystery prizes' at the end of the night. I wasn't drinking much, so I had to satisfy myself by sitting at the poker table and playing a game of 'Take Everyone's Chips From Them' all night.

Went into a syndicate for the auction at the end of the night though and bid for the mystery box. My share of that was 5 Kronenburg, so I'm pretty happy.
 
Bleh. What do you get if you win the Stundies? What are you suppose to provide?

You win a super-duper virtual trophy, that most winners super-duper probably never see.

The rules at top don't really state what you're nominating exactly or why?

Sorry - should remember to put that in. You're nominating silly/absurd/ironic/etc. claims/questions/statements/etc. made by members of the truth movement. Debunkers can also be nominated.

Also could you guys nominate me? :p

Only if you promise to be extra absurd.
 
You're nominating anyone percieved as being "truther" or "neutral" in order to make an Ad Hom.

Simple enough really.

Looks like someone is angry because they haven't won a Stundie yet...don't worry William. This month could be your month!
 
Can you use something from a movie, if you cite the movie? Or does it have to be a website on the internet?

When was the movie released?

Is the movie a documentary, or a work of fiction?

...They really want me to win that "wet rag" award they've been discussing like a bunch of frat boys in pm, bless 'em...

What??? You guys have been having PM discussions and you've left me out of them??? Why, if I wasn't a benevolent tyrant...grr...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom