• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Astrology is logic!!!!!!

woodwater said:
ive already replied. Its Chi and Yin and yang theory plus 5 elements. Nothing to do with planets.:D
Click to expand...
And they call it astrology because... :confused:!!!!!! (That's six exclamation marks. 5 elemental ones and a chi one on the end.)
 
So, woodwater, you don't believe in that crap? Ok. You're just trolling, ok. Buh-bye.
 
woodwater said:
go to his site www.astro-fengshui.com read his fshui articles and see if there is anything scientific there. I doubt.
Click to expand...
No, thank you. I just assumed that if anybody calls anything "astro"-something, they at least include some space-related nonsense. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that prefix is derived from the latin word for "star".
 
Last edited:
He's just a troll, first he defends the idea, then he says it's bull, then he defends it again, and then says it's nonsense. He's trolling or he's insane.
 
Oh, crud... the thread title intriqued me.

So if astrology is "logic"... why is that the constellations that make up the "Zodiac" are no longer visible during the time the are noted to be on the calendar? Precession over the last couple of millennia has changed the location relative to the seasons.

Of course, there is this whole bit that those particular constellations are also mostly visible in the Northern Hemisphere... so why would they impact the Southern Hemisphere?

I was born at 10 degrees latitude north. The constellations were visible, but not easily. So why would they influence me?

Why would the person born the same hour and next door to my kid have the same horoscope, yet be a completely different person?

And why would I expect the OP to even understan what "logic" was considering the quality of replies he/she has given in this thread?
 
Hydrogen Cyanide said:
Oh, crud... the thread title intriqued me.

So if astrology is "logic"... why is that the constellations that make up the "Zodiac" are no longer visible during the time the are noted to be on the calendar? Precession over the last couple of millennia has changed the location relative to the seasons.

Of course, there is this whole bit that those particular constellations are also mostly visible in the Northern Hemisphere... so why would they impact the Southern Hemisphere?

I was born at 10 degrees latitude north. The constellations were visible, but not easily. So why would they influence me?

Why would the person born the same hour and next door to my kid have the same horoscope, yet be a completely different person?

And why would I expect the OP to even understan what "logic" was considering the quality of replies he/she has given in this thread?
Click to expand...

Look dense cretin, how often do i have to say chinese astrology has nothing to do with stars or constellations, and who said i believed it guys?
Cant you read?
You would do a better job if you went to astrology Yahoo groups bashing the Masters and believers instead of picking on me,but know,you stay here in your Ivory skeptic tower:mad: :mad: :mad: :p :p :boxedin:
 
woodwater said:
Look dense cretin, how often do i have to say chinese astrology has nothing to do with stars or constellations
Click to expand...
astro = star logy = read
astro = star nomy = study

Words often define themselves. If you use a clearly defined and understood word to mean something other than what it means its is your fault if the listener misunderstands your intent. Astrology means "reading the stars" not "using chi to whatever".
and who said i believed it guys?
Click to expand...
The OP and this entire thread. If your posts are a weak attempt at sarcasm, you've failed to indicate it or correct it.
Cant you read?
Click to expand...
This is particularly ironic on a text based medium.
You would do a better job if you went to astrology Yahoo groups bashing the Masters and believers instead of picking on me,but know,you stay here in your Ivory skeptic tower
Click to expand...
Your thread. Your suggestion that there's something logical coming from your teacher about chinese star reading. Throwing chi/qui into the process doesn't make it any less ridiculous.
 
woodwater said:
feng shui and chinese astrology...unbelievable ********,yet he managed to convince all that feng shui is scientific,based on mathematical formula:):eye-poppi :boggled: :boggled: :boggled: :boggled:
Click to expand...

what is the meaning of this " f " symbol?
 
Bah, he's suspended.

Toast
Take any quantity of slices of bread
place in access slots of standard kitchen toaster
adjust setting knob or dial
depress lever arm
wait until:
- Bread is automatically forced upward
- Smoke appears
If the bread is sufficiently toasted to taste, add topping and serve.
 
Steve H said:
I'll start with the easy questions ..

Ask Master Yu to explain the actual mechanism of astrology .. just how does distant astronomical bodies influence us at a distance?

Then ask him why some astronomical bodies do .. and others don't.
Click to expand...

I'm sorry, Master Yu isn't available at the moment. Permit me to fill in.

Astronomical bodies don't influence us at a distance. As Carl Sagan once pointed out, gravity is the only force that acts over long distances, and the gravitational pull of the Obstetrician on him at his birth was greater than the gravitational pull of Mars.

If Astrology has any merit, it is because all complexity in the Universe is carved from a small tapestry of possibilities, and if you look at two totally unrelated complex systems, you will see patterns in one that occur in the other.

As we know from arguments about entropy and black holes, while the size of a given volume of space increases as the cube of its radius, the number of possible quantum microstates only increases as the square. So in a system of any size, everything can't vary independently with respect to everything else. Disparate events are linked by invisible strings few people notice.

Or Astrology could just be Total Bullsh|t. I'm sure it's one of those two possibilities.
 
Last edited:
woodwater said:
Amazing!!! My former teacher of Astrology,Master Joseph Yu of Torobnto,who has a degree in maths, said that he once wanted to prove astrology is superstition, but after doing some charts he concluded that «astrology is logical». He then became a master.No comment!!:p
Click to expand...


Anything can be logical within its own frame of reference. That doesn't mean it actually works.

The way I organize my desk is logical to me, but I feel really sorry for the person who has to look for something on it when I'm not there.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom