Archeologly proves the Bible?

The lack of evidence for most of the better known stories in the bible by the literally thousands of digs in and around Israel reflects the world of later authors rather than actual historical facts.
It is very doubtful there was an exodus, very doubtful the tale of Joshua's conquest of Canaan and David and Solomon's vast empire. There is just no archaeological evidence for none of it.
 
...The garbled account in 2 Kings appears to result from an attempt to accommodate history to some degree, while still making Yahweh supreme with the fabricated story of the angel slaughtering the 185,000 Assyrians.

Thanks for clearing that up, TimCallahan, I appreciate your explanation.
So the utter defeat of Israel is true, the invasion is true, the massive tribute to Assyria is true.
The only thing which wasn't true was the 'miracle'.
 
The lack of evidence for most of the better known stories in the bible by the literally thousands of digs in and around Israel reflects the world of later authors rather than actual historical facts.
It is very doubtful there was an exodus, very doubtful the tale of Joshua's conquest of Canaan and David and Solomon's vast empire. There is just no archaeological evidence for none of it.

Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items. One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage? How do you explain that?

Also I need to dig for some other info but I do seem to remember they recently in the last few years or so uncovered some of the old city of Jericho? I will try to find this info again, but I'm sure I have seen this on a documentary as well.
 
Last edited:
Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items. One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage? How do you explain that?


That is the way coral normally grows. It is radially symmetrical in general.

http://animals.nationalgeographic.com/animals/invertebrates/coral.html
 
The lack of evidence for most of the better known stories in the bible by the literally thousands of digs in and around Israel reflects the world of later authors rather than actual historical facts.
It is very doubtful there was an exodus, very doubtful the tale of Joshua's conquest of Canaan and David and Solomon's vast empire. There is just no archaeological evidence for none of it.

So it would seem, amb.
Still, the most fantastic thing about archeology, and science in general, is that there are always more discoveries to be made.
And studied.
 
hi, kurious_kathy
Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items. One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage? How do you explain that?

That's a most interesting documentary, indeed. I think you'll find it has been discussed here, I'll post up what I can find on the subject this evening, if other posters don't beat me to it.


Also I need to dig for some other info but I do seem to remember they recently in the last few years or so uncovered some of the old city of Jericho? I will try to find this info again, but I'm sure I have seen this on a documentary as well.

Again, I think you'll find this has been discussed here, including the latest datings of the findings.
 
hi, kurious_kathy


That's a most interesting documentary, indeed. I think you'll find it has been discussed here, I'll post up what I can find on the subject this evening, if other posters don't beat me to it.




Again, I think you'll find this has been discussed here, including the latest datings of the findings.

If that is the documentary I have seen. It is BS. It was made by the Ron Wyatt "Archaelogical" Foundation, a mob that has been thoroughy debunked by professional Archaeologists. The late Ron Wyatt was funded by a fundamentalist Christian Church to prove by any means the "truth" of the bible.

Remember also that the Exodus never happened. Read any reseach by Finklestein.

So if you believed that you must believe pigs can fly.





Robert
 
Last edited:
Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items. One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage? How do you explain that?

Also I need to dig for some other info but I do seem to remember they recently in the last few years or so uncovered some of the old city of Jericho? I will try to find this info again, but I'm sure I have seen this on a documentary as well.

Man has always been a pattern seeking animal. The proof of this is the many faces of jesus or the 'virgin?' in the most unlikely places, like a slice of bread, a concrete floor etc. Coral can grow to a host of shapes, including wheel looking.
The ruins of Jericho have been found. But what does that prove? In the story in the O/T Joshua was to blow horns and the walls would crash to the ground in an outward fashion. Nothing of the sort has been found. Not one stone from this wall facing outward.
 
Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items. One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage? How do you explain that?

Also I need to dig for some other info but I do seem to remember they recently in the last few years or so uncovered some of the old city of Jericho? I will try to find this info again, but I'm sure I have seen this on a documentary as well.


a) Pareidolia means that people will see patterns anywhere, for example, Michael Jackson's face in a tree-stump.
b) Lying for Jesus, it's far from uncommon, especially if the team has to justify the many thousand of dollars they have been spending in month of pointless research. That'd explain why they never brought the 'wheel' back, they knew they were nothing to it.
c)The area has been uninhabited for 6000 years. For example, the Hyksos invasion of Egypt (through the Sinai) most likely happened on chariots.
There is nothing to suggest that this particular wheel, even if real, came from this particular event in the many thousand years the Sinai serve as a point of passage for armies and merchants.
 
Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items.

Perhaps you should watch different documentaries.

One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage?

Yes, I have.

How do you explain that?

Very simple. That's the way that particular species of coral grows, and it is not limited to that particular area.

However, Ron Wyatt - the crank who found the supposed "chariot wheels" - claimed they were gold-plated. Coral does not grow on gold.

How do you explain that?

There's also the niggling problem of the fact that Exodus claims that the Pharoah himself (or herself - see below) was killed when the Red Sea waters closed in on him/her. Given the chronology, that would mean the Pharoah in question would have been Thutomose II, Hatshepsut, Thutmose III, or Amenhotep II. The mummies of all four of these Pharoahs have been found*, meaning they most certainly did not die in the event described in the Torah.

How do you explain that?

Superficial resemblance does not an artifact make. Of course, given the Egyptians' knowledge and use of watercraft, even if there were chariot wheels down there, it wouldn't be evidence of Exodus.

Curiously, though, all of the "evidence" Wyatt said he obtained has been "lost" or "stolen" by various governments. His grandiose claims, and suspicious lack of independent review of his "discoveries," have made even his fellow Biblical literalists very skeptical of his claims.

Also I need to dig for some other info but I do seem to remember they recently in the last few years or so uncovered some of the old city of Jericho? I will try to find this info again, but I'm sure I have seen this on a documentary as well.

... :confused:

Jericho has never been lost. It is one of the oldest continuously populated cities on the planet, and there have been archaeological digs going on there for decades, and likely will be for the foreseeable future. "Old city?" Archaeological evidence shows settlement at Jericho going as far back as 9,000 BCE - several thousand years before creationists think the world existed.


(* The identification of Hatshepsut's mummy is still somewhat tentative, and very recent. It does seem likely correct, given that the identification was made by comparing her DNA with that of a known relative.)
 
Now wait a minute. I have seen a doumentary on the Exodus crossing and the pictures underwater do reveal some very interesting items. One is the coral reefs, they really do look like chariot wheels! And the way coral grows it does make sense when you see the round forms that they started from the reckage. Have you seen this footage? How do you explain that?

Can you be a bit more specific? What's the title of the documentary? Who produced it? Can you give us a picture of these coral reefs? Can you tell us the size of the chariot wheel formations?

Without these specifics, it is impossible to make a reasoned judgment on what the documentary asserts. "I've seen a documentary," really doesn't give us much to comment on.
 
Can you be a bit more specific? What's the title of the documentary? Who produced it? Can you give us a picture of these coral reefs? Can you tell us the size of the chariot wheel formations?

Without these specifics, it is impossible to make a reasoned judgment on what the documentary asserts. "I've seen a documentary," really doesn't give us much to comment on.


As others have mentioned, the documentary KK is talking about used material (or was produced by) Ron Wyatt, first class nutbar.

More nuttery.
 
Ron Wyatt

Here is where it gets stupid. Have a look at the Wyatt site - this page:
http://www.wyattmuseum.com/red-sea-crossing-02.htm

For those who have Google Earth, use it.

IF and a big IF the Hebrews left Egypt from Pi-Rameses and Ron Wyatt found a beach on the Gulf of Aqaba which could easily have held the multitude, their flocks, and also pharaoh's army. The Gulf of Aqaba is miles from the logical spot for a crossing. The scenery of that area shows up well on my flight siumlator. I shall take a plane over it and see what is there now. I don't expect to find Moses' camp.



Robert
 
hi, kurious_kathy.
I've read all the answers to your comments on the 'wheel' video.
Following this link
http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cach...ed+Hassan&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=es&lr=lang_en

will take you to a site which discusses most of the reasons why even Christians think this 'discovery' was fraudulent and urge caution in believing Wyatt's story.
A shame, isn't it, kurious_kathy.
I confess to being rather disapointed by these mythological aspects of the early books of the OT. Perhaps this is unreasonable, as it seems likely this history of national identity is rooted in heroic fantasy.
Just to show you what I mean, kurious_kathy, here's a question:
What was the name of the Pharoah who died in the Red Sea?
Can you answer that? Can anyone?

Anyway. I'm still assimilating the Hezekiah 'miracle', as well as the story of Jericho. If you haven't read my posts on the subject of Jericho in this thread I'll repost them for you, kurious_kathy, because Jericho is, of course, only the tip of the iceberg. What I mean by this is that Jericho was only one of the cities the OT claims Joshua's invading army devastated and there is much to indicate Joshua's invading army never existed.
Anyway, thanks for bringing up that Wyatt video, kurious_kathy. You provided me an excuse for websurfing on the subject of fraudulent archeological claims.
 
hi, kurious_kathy
On the subject of Jericho:
If you go to page 24 of this thread, you'll find the posts and links on the subject, starting from your own post 929.

The links all still function so if you missed them the first time around, you can even now enjoy them. They are most interesting.
As you can see from those posts on page 24, kurious_kathy, you yourself cut off the discussion about Jericho with an appeal to Josh McDowell:
So you call my circular reasoning not logical but I say your wrong. I believe there is logic in mostly any kind of reasoning. If you do not heed things pertaining to the spiritual nature you must ask yourself what am I missing because God is always trying to break down that wall you put up. Is the wall skepticism itself? Maybe now would be a good time to be open to some new teachings and teachers? People who know the truth have much to offer this world and our lives here seem to be nothing more than a journey of discovery.

Are you going to take me up on my free book offer? If you haven't read Josh Mc Dowell's book "Evidence That Demands A Verdict" you will benefit a lot as he has well documented the historical evidences.

I wish Josh had actually documented the historical evidence, kurious_kathy. We know he's used ghostwriters for at least part of one of his books, so it's really difficult to take this sort of claim seriously.
Back to Jericho and the 'invasion' of Canaan.
 
According to the biblical account, the Israelites camped at a place called Kadesh-barnea for 38 of the 40 years of wanderings in Sinai. The general location of this place is clear from the description of the story in Numbers 34. It has been identified by archaeologists with the large and well-watered oasis of Ein el-Qudeirat in Eastern Sinai. A small mound with the remains of a late iron age fort stands at the center of this oasis. Yet repeated excavations and surveys throughout the entire area have not provided even the slightest evidence for activity in the late Bronze Age, not even a single shred left by a tiny fleeing band of frieghtened refugees. [Source, The Bible Unearthed]
 
Last edited:
Kathy:

Having looked at the Ron Wyatt sites, what I see are a few vague images that could be chariot wheels if one uses a lot of imagination and a very few that are more likely to be chariot wheels. Now if this area of seabed were utterly covered with the remains of chariots, plus the skeletons of horses - lots of them, plus lots of human skeletons; you would have stunning evidence. However, what we seem to have instead are, at most, a few chariot wheels.

Even had there only been a few horse skeletons etc. carbon dating of the bones could establish the time period, and we could see if Egypt suffered any collapse of military power at that time. This has always been a major problem situating the Exodus, and particularly the miricle at the sea in history: From the inception of the 18h. dynasty ca. 1500 BCE on to the end of the Bronze Age ca. 1100, the only dip in Egyptian power occurred at the time Akenaten (1350 - 1334). This was the result of Akenaten's failure to counter the rise in Hittite influence in Syria and the Levant. Even then most of Canaan was under Egyptian control. Following the battle of Kadesh in 1275, an Egyptian - Hittite accord settled where the Hittites would have influence and where the Egyptians would hold sway. Canaan remained under Egyptian influence, which included Egyptian garrisons in the Levant, through the reign of Ramesses III (1182 - 1151). Merneptah, son of Ramesses II, who ruled from 1212 to 1202 set up his victory stele in 1207. In it we find the first mention of a people called Israel already living in Canaan. Thus, from 1207 to 1151 a period of over 50 years, Israel lived in Canaan under Egyptian rule. Yet no mention is made of any Egyptian presence in the land in either Joshua or Judges.

The evidence of Egyptian origins of the people of Yahweh is limited to the names Hophni and Phinehas recurring among the Levites. These names, along with Moses, have Egyptian origins. Hophni means "tadpole," and Phinehas means "dark one." Moses seems to be derived from the Egyptian suffix mose (pronounced MOH-seh) meaning "child" or "child of" (as in Thutmose, "child of Thoth" or Ramesses, "child of Ra"). This is the only sign of Egyptian origins, and its limited to a single tribe, the Levites.

According to the patriarchal narratives, which make up most of Genesis, the people of Israel all came from the region of Padam Aram, in the vicinity of the city of Haran in northwest Mesopotamia. The patriarchal narratives also make it clear that they did not intermarry with the locals in Canaan, and the story of Joseph makes it clear that this people, holding itself separate, went down to Egypt. Logically, then, they should have been Aramaic speakers. Yet the people of Yahweh spoke a West Semitic language - Hebrew.

Using linguistic and cultural cues, and considering the lack of archaeological and historical evidence to support the Exodus and Conquest narratives, the picture that is painted is that, while there were Egyptian-influenced elements among the Levites, who may have brought the worship of Yahweh up from Edom (where the earliest inscriptions of the name "Yahweh" occur); and while there may have been elements of pastoralists from Padam Aram; the main body of the people who coalesed to form the tribes worshipping Yahweh were native Canaanites who left the city states in the plains for the hill country. This area had been abandoned earlier, and the people settling it thus had access to free land.

The people of Israel seem to have formed in the period of the decline of Bronze Age civilization, a rather precipitous collapse of power structures referred to as "the Catastrophe." While there immigration to the hill country of Canaan may well have involved an escape from tyranny and corruption - archaeological evidence shows a great disparity of grave goods between the rich and poor at the end of the Late Bronze Age - the grand, heroic narratives of Exodus and Joshua seem to be the stuff of legend.
 
Ha, ha, ha...sorry, but even trying to use conservapedia means you're done. "founded by an atheist" - if true, so? I like playing a game of plugging in random words into conservapedia and seeing what happens (what usually happens is after 5 minutes I feel sick and need to lie down).

Obama - he used mind control, is a communist and a muslim, etc (they talk about shoes his wife wore to a food bank). http://www.conservapedia.com/Barack_Obama

ACLU - censors god and intelligent design, harms the boy scouts, protects pornography and same-sex marriage, the current CEO is gay (nooo, say it ain't so!).http://www.conservapedia.com/American_Civil_Liberties_Union

Evolution - did you know that there are NO transitional fossils?
(no more links, you know where to go)
Global warming - some sort of liberal plot apparently.
Atheism - no comment, just scroll through, note the linked main articles and cringe.

But hey, the full title is "Conservapedia : The Trustworthy Encyclopedia" so they must be telling the truth.

You listed some of the things Conservapedia said (which I haven't checked) but I noticed you didn't give any evidence to the contrary of what they said.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom