Archeologly proves the Bible?

And are you implying that if Jesus' virgin birth is not a original concept then it can't be true?
I am implying that there is no evidence for the virgin birth, therefore it can't be true. We do have evidence for many similar myths and legends.
 
He was already elected president when he attended weekly church services in the US capitol building (so much for separation of Church and State)
So? Are you saying politicians don't try to maintian political support through PR means?

And I agree with you, Jefferson's actions are clear example of why the seperation of church and state is so important. It's way to easy to gain influence through religious games.

Then you are fully, 100%, completely and uncategorically wrong.

"I have performed this operation for my own use, by cutting verse by verse out of the printed book, and arranging the matter which is evidently his, and which is as easily distinguishable as diamonds in a dunghill.
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to John Adams, October 13, 1813"

What are the "Diamonds" and What is the "Dunghill" in Jefferson's Statement?
 
He was already elected president when he attended weekly church services in the US capitol building (so much for separation of Church and State)

Yes


I believe Obama also attends church. Ergo, he is a christian contrary to right wing fundamentalists who claim he is Muslim. Your logic has proven this without a doubt, so could you inform your church going friends that the matter has been settled?

I find it odd that reading all of the quotes Jefferson has made on the subject of christianity haven't swayed you from the ad nauseum replies of him considering the words of Jesus to be sublime, DOC. Your narrow minded view of believing what you want does you a disservice.

Monster
 
Last edited:
I believe Obama also attends church. Ergo, he is a christian contrary to right wing fundamentalists who claim he is Muslim. Your logic has proven this without a doubt, so could you inform your church going friends that the matter has been settled?
DOC, himself, only states that "Obama claims to be a christian". He almost never (at least I can't remember him) ever stating unconditionally that Obama IS a christian. Makes you wonder...
 
On the other hand I believe it was Augustine who said the growth of Christianity without miracles would have been the greatest miracle of all.

Maybe I shouldn't even ask this question... no, it's more like I highly doubt there's anything to be gained from asking this question. But what on earth was the point of this statement supposed to be???
 
Maybe I shouldn't even ask this question... no, it's more like I highly doubt there's anything to be gained from asking this question. But what on earth was the point of this statement supposed to be???

It's an attempt at wit, not unlike when truthers claim that the "real" conspiracy is the "official" accounts.
 
Doc:

Are you going to respond to my posts, or is your Christian "witness" as hollow as it seems?
 
On the other hand I believe it was Augustine who said the growth of Christianity without miracles would have been the greatest miracle of all.

Maybe I shouldn't even ask this question... no, it's more like I highly doubt there's anything to be gained from asking this question. But what on earth was the point of this statement supposed to be???


The point is that miracles must have happened, otherwise a miracle would have happened. Welcome to the vortex of Doclogicology™

Now come and sit here with the rest of us on the "Ignore" bench.
 
I'm talking about the introduction section to the Gospel of Mark in by Bible not the actual Gospel. My bible is published by Tyndale.
Thanks for the source. I'm off to read that introduction, if it's available on-line.
I think there are threads already dedicated to Jefferson and his version of Jesus' sayings. It seems unnecesary to mention him in this particular thread.
 
The NLT intrduction is available on-line, for a fee.
What I did find in a review of the translation was this paragraph dedicated precisely to the NLT introductin to Mark's Gospel:
Mark’s gospel will serve as a fine example. The timeline lists the birth of Jesus (BC ~6-4), Jesus’ baptism (AD 28), Jesus’ crucifixion and resurrection (Passover, AD 30 or 33), the Jerusalem Council (AD 49-50), Mark writes his gospel (AD 65-70), Jewish Roman War (AD 66-70), and the destruction of the temple (AD 70). While I generally date the Gospel of Mark a little earlier, it just shows one way how the NLTSB team has attempted to give each book its historical significance. Quotes from William L. Lane and James R. Edwards can be found in the margins, and there is a rundown of Mark’s meaning and message (including, the person of Christ, the death of Jesus, Christian Discipleship, the ‘messianic secret,’ and the coming of God’s kingdom).

http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cach...oduction+Mark+gospel&cd=1&hl=es&ct=clnk&gl=es

Later than DOC claimed, I think.
 
Mt. Sinai. Where is YHWH?

I have flown all around Mt. Sinai and can't find YHWH.




Just a moment. Is that him, but where?

He must be hiding.



Robert
 
Last edited:
Kinda, DOC gives a date of 60-65 CE which is only 5 years earlier, still incorrect but not by that much.

Quite right, Simon39759, not by that much.
Perhaps I didn't make my point clear, which is that DOC consistently uses sources which are basically 'home goals'

This source is no different, in that DOC originally quoted it as a
"Bible says".
After asking three times for a chapter and verse, I'm finallly answered with "it's in the introduction to the Gospel in my edition, not the text itself".
So I hunt out the introduction, only to find that DOC seems to have misquoted it.
All this over several pages of the thread.

Simon39759, you are absolutely right, 5 years isn't much and even less in the context of crumbling papyrus fragments.
But it's a lot when the citation is used as a source.

Actually, this last is simply yet another example of a misquote, deliberate or not.
All in line with the 5000+ manuscript misquote.
Or the misinterpretation of Sir William Ramsay's findings.
And the others which have surfaced in this and other threads.

At the end of the day, paximperium and others are right, of course, in asking "So what?", given there are no original 'documents', and even if there were, they'd only constitute a belief system, not facts.
Still, it's interesting to me to see these underpinnings of a belief in the inerrancy of the bible.
 
Christianity spread for more than 30 years by oral tradition. A friend of a friend of my brother in law etc is how this superstition spread. There were no news broadcasts in those days, no TV nightly news. With each re-telling, inaccuracy is bound to take over the telling. Exaggerations of a miracle worker was one way of gathering converts. A promise of eternal life would sway a sizable portion of the population, and the urgency, the kingdom of god was at hand. This in the first century is what started the movement we today call christianity.
That today, in the 21st century most of the worlds population still believe this claptrap is truly a miracle.
 
Quite right, Simon39759, not by that much.
Perhaps I didn't make my point clear, which is that DOC consistently uses sources which are basically 'home goals'
This source is no different, in that DOC originally quoted it as a
"Bible says".
After asking three times for a chapter and verse, I'm finallly answered with "it's in the introduction to the Gospel in my edition, not the text itself".
So I hunt out the introduction, only to find that DOC seems to have misquoted it.
All this over several pages of the thread.
Simon39759, you are absolutely right, 5 years isn't much and even less in the context of crumbling papyrus fragments.
But it's a lot when the citation is used as a source.
Actually, this last is simply yet another example of a misquote, deliberate or not.
All in line with the 5000+ manuscript misquote.
Or the misinterpretation of Sir William Ramsay's findings.
And the others which have surfaced in this and other threads.
At the end of the day, paximperium and others are right, of course, in asking "So what?", given there are no original 'documents', and even if there were, they'd only constitute a belief system, not facts.
Still, it's interesting to me to see these underpinnings of a belief in the inerrancy of the bible.


I see, you are merely pointing out a pattern of fuzzy 'scholarship', then?
 
I hardly think 'fuzzy' is an adequate term.
However, 'merely pointing out' does sum it up.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom