Anybody think Nat Fraser is actually innocent?

Fraser seems like Scotland's answer to Drew Peterson.

Regarding his wife's disappearance (and presumptive murder), in all probably Fraser's good for it.

But the reasoning for overturning the verdict seems sound.

It's not clear to me whether the information was deliberately withheld, or whether it was a bureaucratic oversight. If the former, whoever was responsible should be severely punished.
 
Maybe but since UKIP didn't win the last election and the Torys didn't get a clean win for the time being scotland still falls under the human rights act.


Yes. But that should all be dealt with without this so-called "UK Supreme Court", which is a breach of the Treaty of Union as it happens. If Scots law isn't human-rights compliant, then it should go directly to Europe. Sticking in an extra layer isn't the answer to anything.

Rolfe.
 
It's not clear to me whether the information was deliberately withheld, or whether it was a bureaucratic oversight. If the former, whoever was responsible should be severely punished.


Given what's gone on in some other cases, the Marion Ross murder just for a start, nothing would surprise me.

Rolfe.
 
Sometimes it's a bra clasp. Sometimes it's a tin box.

In the Stock murders in Nebraska, USA, forensic evidence was suddenly discovered on a car, the second time it was searched (after a fruitless initial search).

When an authority's prestige or invested theory is on the line, supposedly incriminating evidence sometimes seems to curiously turn up just in the nick of time.
 
Yes. But that should all be dealt with without this so-called "UK Supreme Court", which is a breach of the Treaty of Union as it happens. If Scots law isn't human-rights compliant, then it should go directly to Europe. Sticking in an extra layer isn't the answer to anything.
Yet you seem to have been implying that Scots law (or at least some of it) is not fit for purpose. Whose responsibility is it to put the house in order, if the people in the house are (or seem) incapable of doing so?
 
Yes. But that should all be dealt with without this so-called "UK Supreme Court", which is a breach of the Treaty of Union as it happens.

The entire UK consistution is a series of hacks as I'm sure the cornish nationalists will explain to you. Forturtunately parliamentary supremacy takes care of such issues.

If Scots law isn't human-rights compliant, then it should go directly to Europe.

Thats not possible without repealing the human rights act. The human rights act requires that that it be built into domestic law which is a bit of a problem if there isn't a court competent to hear such cases.

Sticking in an extra layer isn't the answer to anything.

The problem is the backlog at the ECHR. Avoiding tha backlog appears to be a reasonable answer and has the aditional benifit that it's slightly less far.
 
Yet you seem to have been implying that Scots law (or at least some of it) is not fit for purpose. Whose responsibility is it to put the house in order, if the people in the house are (or seem) incapable of doing so?


http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/...new-attack-on-supreme-court-rulings-1.1104396

The people whose responsibility it is, should put the house in order. Where that fails, Scotland should have direct access to the European Court of Human Rights like every other independent jurisdiction.

England has no jurisdiction over criminal matters in Scotland. This present situation is a breach of the Treaty of Union. Claiming that Scotland can't fix its own problems, or that there is a backlog in the European Court, is no justification for unilaterally interfering with an independent judiciary.

You know, if I'd wanted to have this discussion I'd have started the thread in the politics section. I wanted to discuss whether or not the Fraser case was a miscarriage of justice, actually.

Rolfe.
 
England has no jurisdiction over criminal matters in Scotland.

Which is why the court is the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom not england and wales.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom