Americans are drowning in a watery medical myth!

Joined
Feb 15, 2007
Messages
9
Next time anyone pesters you to drink 8 glasses of water a day, turn the table on your tormentor with one simple question. WHY?
Know what? NOBODY KNOWS WHY. In the words of a famous nutritionist at Penn State University, 'I can't tell you...and I've written a book on water.'
Maybe your kidneys need it? No, according to a kidney expert at the National Institute of Health, the average adult gets all the water he or she needs from solid food alone. And, in fact, drinking too much water stresses your kidneys and encourages renal failure!

More water myths to flush away... ​
  • 'If you get thirsty, it means you're already dehydrated.' HOW COULD IT? If this were true, every animal on earth would have collapsed and died long ago. Have you ever seen a dog that drinks when he's not thirsty? Of course not, he hasn't read the articles telling him to drink until he bursts.
  • Drinking lots of water is good for your circulation. NOPE. In fact, drinking too much water can dilute the potassium levels in your blood, raising your stroke risk.
  • Coffee and tea dehydrate you. THEY DON'T! This tactic is designed to sell you bottled water at a 1,000 percent markup.
 
Any actual evidence to come with that? You know - references and stuff?
 
Try also this Scientific American article. Not all of the above mentioned "myths" are cited, but other items are. ("myths" quotated because I do not have a source to say they are myths - though, in light of the above sources, it seems likely.)
 
Ummmm... seems sort of silly to me. How much of a burden is it to drink a couple of glasses of water a day? There's no harm, and some possible slight benefit. The great thing about water is that your body gets rid of what you don't need... so I don't see how you can get "too much", short of the ridiculous amounts required for water intoxication.

Next, you'll attack "an apple a day keeps the doctor away" as some evil orchard conspiracy.
 
OK, speculation only, but here's my comment on this particular part:

'If you get thirsty, it means you're already dehydrated.'

Well, it seems to me that you are at least having less than the optimum amount of water in your system, though how broad that range is, I don't know. One should think that in a perfect world, you get thirsty right before any form of dehydration sets in (after all, there's a difference between mild and strong dehydration), but as we all know, evolution doesn't make perfect bodies, it only makes bodies good enough (for the enviroment it expects to face, and all that).

Another thing is that I have so far only heard this claim with regards to endurance sports events like Tour de France, which is a very different situation from your average joe having his average day. I'd like to actually find out whether the claim fits for either or both situations. Unfortunately, a quick googling only came up with sources I'm rather doubtful about, so if anyone's got the real deal somewhere, bring it up!
 
Ummmm... seems sort of silly to me. How much of a burden is it to drink a couple of glasses of water a day? There's no harm, and some possible slight benefit.

It isn't a burden to drink a couple of glasses of water a day but eight may be. And with eight there may be some harm...

from the Scientific American article pointed out by grmcdorman above:

Where did people get the idea that guzzling enormous quantities of water is healthful? A few years ago Heinz Valtin, a kidney specialist from Dartmouth Medical School, decided to determine if the common advice to drink eight, eight-ounce glasses of water per day could hold up to scientific scrutiny. After scouring the peer-reviewed literature, Valtin concluded that no scientific studies support the "eight x eight" dictum (for healthy adults living in temperate climates and doing mild exercise). In fact, drinking this much or more "could be harmful, both in precipitating potentially dangerous hyponatremia and exposure to pollutants, and also in making many people feel guilty for not drinking enough," he wrote in his 2002 review for the American Journal of Physiology—Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology. And since he published his findings, Valtin says, "not a single scientific report published in a peer-reviewed publication has proven the contrary."

Not to mention all those bathroom breaks. Forget about watching Godfather II in one sitting.
 
My own objection is to the alarmist overstatement of the thread title. Just how many Americans have drowned because of this, anyway?

[anecdotal evidence]

One of my co-workers interpreted a suggetion from her doctor to drink a little more water to mean an eight ounce glass every hour. She passed out at work, and was rushed to the hospital. Her potassium was dangerously low and the rest of her electrolytes were quite messed up. She was out for a week.

Not drowning, but a pretty nasty experience.

[/anecdotal evidence]

I drink a lot of water because my skin and mucus membranes tend to be very dry. However, I keep it to a reasonable level, like four or five glasses a day, and I count my milk and juice in that.
 
Has there been any scientific studies in regards to the "coffee and tea dehydrate you" question? Last week when it was pretty hot here, the talking heads on the news said that tea and coffee don't count towards your total water intake. I know that's false, but how much does caffeine really dehydrate you?
 
I literally just sent out an E-Mail to friends based on this. We got into a very lengthy debate over the weekend when a friend said that we need to drink this amount of water per day or else we will get lots of horrible diseases, and our joints will seize up.

He used the comparison of water to motor oil, and that we need to constantly get water in our bodies to flush out old water. If you want to make that comparison, our bodies differ because we essentially have an oil filter that never needs to be replaced, filters out almost all impurities, and allows them to be expelled. If our cars worked like this, we would only need to replace the oil that has been burned off, not constantly cycle new oil into the system.

I was interested to learn where the '8 glasses a day' most likely came from:

http://dms.dartmouth.edu/news/2002_h2/08aug2002_water.shtml
Valtin thinks the notion may have started when the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Research Council recommended approximately "1 milliliter of water for each calorie of food," which would amount to roughly two to two-and-a-half quarts per day (64 to 80 ounces). Although in its next sentence, the Board stated "most of this quantity is contained in prepared foods," that last sentence may have been missed, so that the recommendation was erroneously interpreted as how much water one should drink each day.
 
Has there been any scientific studies in regards to the "coffee and tea dehydrate you" question? Last week when it was pretty hot here, the talking heads on the news said that tea and coffee don't count towards your total water intake. I know that's false, but how much does caffeine really dehydrate you?

http://www.snopes.com/medical/myths/8glasses.asp
Additionally, the idea that one must specifically drink water because the diuretic effects of caffeinated drinks such as coffee, tea, and soda actually produce a net loss of fluid appears to be erroneous. The average person retains about half to two-thirds the amount of fluid taken in by consuming these types of beverages, and those who regularly consume caffeinated drinks retain even more:
Regular coffee and tea drinkers become accustomed to caffeine and lose little, if any, fluid. In a study published in the October issue of the Journal of the American College of Nutrition, researchers at the Center for Human Nutrition in Omaha measured how different combinations of water, coffee and caffeinated sodas affected the hydration status of 18 healthy adults who drink caffeinated beverages routinely.
"We found no significant differences at all," says nutritionist Ann Grandjean, the study's lead author. "The purpose of the study was to find out if caffeine is dehydrating in healthy people who are drinking normal amounts of it. It is not."
The same goes for tea, juice, milk and caffeinated sodas: One glass provides about the same amount of hydrating fluid as a glass of water. The only common drinks that produce a net loss of fluids are those containing alcohol and usually it takes more than one of those to cause noticeable dehydration, doctors say.
 
Thinking about hydration and over-hydration made me immediately think of military training. Obviously hydration is of primary concern to a soldier, especially since many conflict zones today are in hot weather climates. I found this article which might provide a bit of scientific evidence to back up some of what has been said about proper hydration techniques.

Summary: http://stinet.dtic.mil/oai/oai?&verb=getRecord&metadataPrefix=html&identifier=ADA342352

Article: http://stinet.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA342352&Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf

ETA: I realize proper hydration for a soldier during exercises is not necessarily a standard for your average Joe who isn't fighting in a desert somewhere, but I hoped this might provide some scientific basis for discussion.
 
Last edited:
It's funny...every time I go get a massage (approximately once per month), after the massage is over, the massage-chick tells me to drink lots of water to flush out the toxins. I always want to ask "which toxins are those?" but I never do. Yes, I am a coward.
 
Water intoxication is rare, but can result in death, as in the case of Jennifer Strange.

I think we should rely on feelings of thirst. What do other animals do? They certainly don't count the number of glasses they drink: they know if they need water, because they get thirsty. Natural selection will certainly have eliminated any species of animal that didn't get thirsty when it needed water.
 
Great thread. I actually spent the last couple of weeks beating myself up for not drinking enough water. Now I feel quite fine!
 
It's funny...every time I go get a massage (approximately once per month), after the massage is over, the massage-chick tells me to drink lots of water to flush out the toxins. I always want to ask "which toxins are those?" but I never do. Yes, I am a coward.

"Um, you know, the bad ones and stuff".
 
Completely anecdotal: I've been drinking 6-8 liters of water a day for the last 18 years or so, with no ill effects. In fact, I can tell if I'm getting less water than that, because I just don't feel well without my relatively high water intake.

The idea that 8 glasses a day could be generally harmful just seems ridiculous to me. Of course, if you try to drink all 8 with a single meal, it could be a problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom