Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.

If only there was a document he could release that would show that. Also, few exceptions that seems ominous.
Some surreal icing on the cake...

ABC said:
The lawyers who wrote a letter saying President Trump had no significant business ties to Russia work for a law firm that has extensive ties to Russia and received a “Russia Law Firm of the Year” award in 2016.
We're long past being through the looking glass that was inside the first looking glass. (Think Rick and Morty.)
 
The legacy of communism allowed Russia to survive the Soviet Union's collapse. Let's see what happens when the US goes belly-up. Its economy already has many of the features of a failing Third World country (e.g massive inequality) and, unlike in Russia, people are not guaranteed a roof over their head.

In doing a quick look at homelessness in Russia circa 1990 I found this:

https://homeless.ru/en/about/

- The group of people concerned by the discrimination of homeless people’s rights created the charitable fund “Nochlezhka”.
- Same year “Nochlezhka” succeeded in compeling Petrosovet to make a decision about giving a visit cards of the buyer and main food ticket’s packs to homeless people (this documents had been giving only to residents of Leningrad who had registration), the system of “alternative registration” had been created.
- From the moment of its foundation “Nochlezhka” was striving for cancelation of clauses 198 and 209 CC RF, which were specified in institution of criminal proceedings against vagrancy, begging and parasitism (clauses had been cancelled in December 1991).

Apparently if Soviet Russia did guarantee housing for everyone, they weren't able to fulfill that guarantee. If I'm reading this correctly, prior to the actions of this agency "Nochlezhka", homeless people didn't have ration cards or resident cards, which must have made life very hard for them.
 
Perhaps it makes no sense when one ignores the rest of the picture, sure.* That requires ignoring the rest of the picture, though.

This isn't really an argument, so I'll maintain my position.

And that rather gets to one of the cruxes of that particular issue.* Few here have actually argued that the information being out there in the first place is actually a bad thing.* I certainly didn't.* When it's obtained using illegal means and is being used as a weapon to try to manipulate people to act in ways that have nothing to do with the people's benefit, though, it's entirely reasonable to be outraged at those parts of what's going on, for a number of reasons.*

I'm glad we agree that the information being out there isn't a bad thing, and that illegally accessing people's information is a bad thing. I'll note you also agreed with me that "this is an act of war" is too extreme, so to at least some extent we are in agreement that the outrage is overblown.

Furthermore, it's entirely reasonable that people be more concerned about what others are trying to do to them than what others are trying to do to others who they aren't even likely to ever have contact with, which means that your claim which is directly contrary to that is rather unreasonable.

I disagree for reasons already stated. You could argue it's reasonable from an entirely selfish perspective, but even then the actions of our own government have real effects on what others do to us and how seriously the rest of the world is going to take it when we complain about other countries.

That, unsurprisingly, has little to do with the actual reasons for outrage and so quite earns a :rolleyes:.

I disagree, but this isn't an argument, so I'll leave it there.

Nor is most of the federal government, yet you were pointedly saying that being part of the federal government, or even having any influence on it in any way, no matter how negligible, makes it a person's responsibility, in an attempted counter to me pointing out that those who actually make the decisions and carry them out are those who bear the responsibility.

The proportion of people in the federal government elected by voters is not telling the whole story, because they are often appointed by people who were voted in and so on. Congress and the Senate also have some powers and responsibilities when it comes to the CIA, as does the president. The people carrying out the actions bear the most responsibility, as I've said.

That's but one of many aspects of why.* A minor one, really, given that the ability to have some tiny influence on who is going to be doing a particular job from a very, very limited selection of people who one doesn't know personally leaves plenty of leeway when it comes to invoking a sense of responsibility for the actions of the person elected. It's also one that's much, much better applied to whether we should be paying attention to what our elected officials are doing in the first place, contrary to how you've been trying to apply it.* You've been trying to apply it to whether it's reasonable to be outraged at various things, though, while ignoring that outrage is inherently emotional and thus have been trying to argue that people should get *more* emotional about wrongs done to perfect strangers who they frequently would quite dislike anyways than they should get about wrongs done to their own selves and the people that they actually know and care about.* It really doesn't take a genius to figure out why that argument's doomed from the start.

My argument is that the amount of outrage and focus over something that's done routinely by both ourselves and others is overblown. It's not about what emotions people are internally feeling.

You're trying to spread responsibility around on the basis of working under the same very, very broad banner, not based on whether they even could have meaningfully affected anything about a decision in any way, let alone whether they even could have known about it to even try to take action regarding it.* You are, of course, welcome to add to what you said to seek to clarify the intended meaning, should what you said not have accurately conveyed your meaning, but I have no intention of trying to make up positions for you that aren't directly a consequence of the words that you've chosen to try to convey such.

What I'm saying isn't that complicated. Voters bear some responsibility for the actions of their government, and should be concerned about how their government behaves for that reason (among others). The government officials who take the actions bear even more responsibility.
 
Was the Billy Bush tape selectively edited when released? Then it did not give the public information in a notably skewed fashion.

Are you suggesting Podesta's emails were released in a "skewed" fashion, because they were "selectively edited"? Care to elaborate?
 
Some surreal icing on the cake...

We're long past being through the looking glass that was inside the first looking glass. (Think Rick and Morty.)

That has to be a Poe. OMG! :jaw-dropp

[sidetrack]
Rick and Morty you say. Had dinner with my son tonight and he mentioned he liked the Rick an Morty show. Guess I'll have to give it a look.
[/sidetrack]

I may have to watch The View now too. That was funny. (And sad.)
 
Last edited:
This isn't really an argument, so I'll maintain my position.

What I was responding to wasn't worth much more of a response to, though, given that you tried to isolate one part of what was said and then decided to address that out of context. Your position is worthless if it only amounts to being able to do that.


I'm glad we agree that the information being out there isn't a bad thing, and that illegally accessing people's information is a bad thing. I'll note you also agreed with me that "this is an act of war" is too extreme, so to at least some extent we are in agreement that the outrage is overblown.

For those who are saying that "this is an act of war" or similar, certainly. I've seen very few people who are making claims on par with that in the first place, though, and plenty with far more reasonable levels of concern or outrage, so it's hard for me to consider that to be anything remotely like a serious argument. Seriously, to compare my personal experiences with it, I think I've seen far more unreasonable and nasty outrage with regards to, for example, Birtherism, than I've seen regarding Russia's attempts to interfere with us.

I disagree for reasons already stated. You could argue it's reasonable from an entirely selfish perspective, but even then the actions of our own government have real effects on what others do to us and how seriously the rest of the world is going to take it when we complain about other countries.

You still don't have much of a leg to stand on, here, though. If the argument that I was making was, for some nonsensical reason, that there should be no outrage at what our government does to others, you would have a point. It was never even remotely that, though. Rather, it's more along the lines of the simple fact that it's entirely irrational to try to ignore the nature of outrage and, furthermore, human nature when making claims about how people should feel.


I disagree, but this isn't an argument, so I'll leave it there.

When what it was responding to wasn't a real argument, either, that's hardly a surprise. Trying to hand wave away the actual reasons for outrage with what is effectively irrelevant nonsense really isn't worth anything more than a :rolleyes:, after all.


The proportion of people in the federal government elected by voters is not telling the whole story, because they are often appointed by people who were voted in and so on. Congress and the Senate also have some powers and responsibilities when it comes to the CIA, as does the president. The people carrying out the actions bear the most responsibility, as I've said.

*sigh* Need this be traced back even further before you admit that you've been moving the goalposts quite a bit here? So! Here we go through the relevant parts!

http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-us-intervention-foreign-elections-20161213-story.html

The US has tried to influence elections in other countries 81 times between 1946 and 2000, and Russia has done so 36 times, according to this article. Not including military coups, direct invasions and things like that. And that's just the ones we know about.

The US also hacks other countries. And this was hardly a sophisticated hacked, it was just Podesta falling for a phising email.

Not saying it's a good thing. But it's clearly selective outrage over something that's very common. If the US thinks it's so outrageous they could start by not doing it themselves.
The US also has a history of assassinations and attempted assassinations, along with all manner of other actions that would generally found criminal in a court of law. The citizens of the USA are still entirely entitled to be outraged if a foreign country tries to assassinate our President, just like they're entitled to be outraged at the assassination attempts, successful or not, carried out by the US. Two wrongs don't make a right, after all.
And when it comes from members of the federal government, it's also hypocritical.
If they were actually part of the decisions and implementation, perhaps. The vast majority of the federal government is not, though.
They are part of the institution that does it (as are we as voters, in a sense).
When a guy who distributes the incoming mail to the people who will deal with it is being effectively treated on par with a CEO when it comes to responsibility for the decisions of the leaders of the company, arguments like this rather lose any meaningfulness.
What...? CEOs are not elected by employees. We, as citizens, should be concerned with the actions of our government, because we are responsible for electing officials, and because we're capable of attempting to affect change through activism, pressuring our representatives and so on. Much harder to do this in Russia if one is a US citizen, living in the US. I never said anything about equal responsibility across the board.
Nor is most of the federal government, yet you were pointedly saying that being part of the federal government, or even having any influence on it in any way, no matter how negligible, makes it a person's responsibility, in an attempted counter to me pointing out that those who actually make the decisions and carry them out are those who bear the responsibility.

So, from this and your continued insistence, you're still pretty clearly arguing that anyone in the federal government is a hypocrite if they're outraged at other countries trying to mess with us, regardless of whether they're outraged by the actions of our government messing with other countries as well and whether they are in any position to either know about or affect decisions or policy in any meaningful way. As for
The people carrying out the actions bear the most responsibility, as I've said.
I do need to ask... where did you say that? The closest things to that that you said in our discussion, by the look of it, are differentiating between the federal government and not the federal government, differentiating between being in the country and not being in the country, and clarifying that you didn't say that responsibility should be spread out equally, none of which equates to that.



My argument is that the amount of outrage and focus over something that's done routinely by both ourselves and others is overblown. It's not about what emotions people are internally feeling.

And you're failing to factor in the comparative effect that it has actually (potentially) had on people's lives and still trying to ignore what outrage actually is and why people feel it in the first place.


What I'm saying isn't that complicated. Voters bear some responsibility for the actions of their government, and should be concerned about how their government behaves for that reason (among others).

And that was never actually being disputed. Rather, you've been trying to abuse and misuse the concepts and that abuse and misuse is the only thing that was being objected to in relation to them.

The government officials who take the actions bear even more responsibility.

Far more... if they were even involved in the first place. A lesser range can be made for those who potentially could have had affected it in some way reasonably, but the vast majority of the federal government cannot reasonably be treated any differently from the average citizen.
 
Yawn. Reflexive repetition of propaganda. I've just read an article I can recommend to you. It reveals why you have been made to hate the man.

That article is a huge pile of BS. Putin is not popular in Europe, especially not in the North or East - ask Ukrainians, Poles or anyone in the Baltics.
And there is no question that he supresses all opposition and all non Orthodox religion and of course everyone pro-LGBT rights.
 
That article is a huge pile of BS.


Far from it. It's a very to the point description of what the "new cold war" is about.

Putin is not popular in Europe, especially not in the North or East - ask Ukrainians, Poles or anyone in the Baltics.


The article makes no claims about his popularity in any of those countries. (edit: ok, he claims that the US is the only country where P. isn't popular, which is not technically correct but enough for the scope of the article)

And there is no question that he supresses all opposition and all non Orthodox religion and of course everyone pro-LGBT rights.


You are obviously a reader of propaganda rags like The Guardian or the Washington Pest. Those types will immediate have their conditioning thinking "but but but they have to praise Putin" about three sentences into the article. Which will make it difficult to continue to the bigger picture, which here is described in Putin's own words, in context. But that's the nature of conditioning. I'm confident the person I recommended the article to will make it a bit further than you. Or at least try to.
 
Last edited:
Yawn. Reflexive repetition of propaganda. I've just read an article I can recommend to you. It reveals why you have been made to hate the man.

Fun fact: Putin is a reptile who murders his opponents so that he and the obscenely wealthy but insatiably greedy oligarchs can continue sucking the lifeblood out of Russia.
 
Right - the press that has an actual record of journalism is propaganda, yet some guy with a webpage know Russia better than newspapers with offices in Moscow.

Putin has called the collapse of the Soviet Union the greatest tragedy of the 20th century; not the Holocaust, not even WW2.
Stalin is worshipped with full support of the government, NGO's all all declared to be foreign agents.
At the same time, the Russian economy is a joke: the GDP is smaller than Spain's. If it wasn't for its nukes, no one would consider Russia an important actor outside it's close sphere of influence.
As a German speaker, I guess you are aware of Putin's career as KGB handler, right? And his regular speeches to the FSB?
There has never been a Russian leader who held the top spot for nearly 17 years without being ruthless operator. Only in authoritarian regimes does a President still get 90% approval rating after just long time in office.
 
As a German speaker, I guess you are aware of Putin's career as KGB handler, right? And his regular speeches to the FSB?


As a German speaker I'm aware that Putin left the KGB in the early 90s as a small light and was installed as head of FSB by Jelzin end of the 90s, for a good year.

And as a German speaker I was quite amused by your paranoid-ish musings about alleged Russian propaganda in Germany, but I didn't feel like engaging.

FYI, the (one) case of the girl being abused by migrants, which was jazzed up in Russian media, wasn't made up by THEM, but by her. And by early 2017 it has turned out that while she made up that case, she has indeed been abused before and the culprit is now on trial for child abuse and producing child pornography.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom