Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Uh, are you implying there's evidence Russia had access to Trump's emails as well, and decided not to release those?

No, I'm fairly confident that Russia had information about Trump which would have made him look bad that they did not release. Whether that was stuff about his sex-capades in Russian hotels, how much money he owes/owed them, or something else, I'm not sure.

Also, I don't agree that Podesta's emails made Clinton look worse than Trump, but that's obviously subjective.

It is inarguable that they made Clinton look worse in relation to Trump to some voters.
 
Which is called lying by omission. That's one of the major problems with these kinds of hacks. The information could be completely true (although it often isn't - another problem), but it's still just the information that the hacker wants you to see. In an election, a thing such as this could seriously slant people's opinion, even if there isn't much to the actual contents of the hack - like with the DNC hack. The point is, people think there must be something there, and the story keeps in the news.

Meanwhile, nobody is talking about the other guy, and all the problems with him.

I don't think that would be lying by omission. You are not omitting something that modifies perception about the issue. Testifying that you saw person X commit robbery, while not discussing your history of all the other robberies you have seen in other places is not lying by omission.
 
I don't think that would be lying by omission. You are not omitting something that modifies perception about the issue. Testifying that you saw person X commit robbery, while not discussing your history of all the other robberies you have seen in other places is not lying by omission.

If there is a choice between two people and you say that one is a petty criminal, and don't mention that the other has committed far more serious crimes, then it is an attempt to mislead at the least.
 
No, I'm fairly confident that Russia had information about Trump which would have made him look bad that they did not release. Whether that was stuff about his sex-capades in Russian hotels, how much money he owes/owed them, or something else, I'm not sure.



It is inarguable that they made Clinton look worse in relation to Trump to some voters.

More to the point, the release had a negative effect for one candidate and not the other. Whether or not this made the first candidate look worse than the second, it made her look worse than she otherwise would have, while the second suffered no similar fate.
 
No, I'm fairly confident that Russia had information about Trump which would have made him look bad that they did not release. Whether that was stuff about his sex-capades in Russian hotels, how much money he owes/owed them, or something else, I'm not sure.

So you think Trump owes the Russian government money or vice versa, or that the Russian government has sex tapes of Donald Trump and you are fairly confident of this. And you think they chose not to release this stuff at the same time as they were leaking Podesta's emails. Gotcha. Not sure I agree, but I understand your argument.

It is inarguable that they made Clinton look worse in relation to Trump to some voters.

Not really inarguable, but it's likely that was the case with some non-zero amount of voters.
 
If there is a choice between two people and you say that one is a petty criminal, and don't mention that the other has committed far more serious crimes, then it is an attempt to mislead at the least.

But it isn't a choice between two people. Your choice is more likely between one person and not voting.
 
More to the point, the release had a negative effect for one candidate and not the other. Whether or not this made the first candidate look worse than the second, it made her look worse than she otherwise would have, while the second suffered no similar fate.

Of course. The same was true of the Billy Bush tape, but that doesn't mean it shouldn't have been released.
 
So you think Trump owes the Russian government money or vice versa, or that the Russian government has sex tapes of Donald Trump and you are fairly confident of this. And you think they chose not to release this stuff at the same time as they were leaking Podesta's emails. Gotcha. Not sure I agree, but I understand your argument.



Not really inarguable, but it's likely that was the case with some non-zero amount of voters.

They almost certainly have compromising information about his business links with Russia.
 
A little context is important here.

I don't doubt that the U.S. has attempted to influence elections. However, keep in mind that in many of those cases, American attempts were often done as a counterbalance to those of other foreign governments. For example, their interference in the 1948 Italian election provided balance to the Russian interference in the same election....
I don't think we have any room to call Russia evil over this. We've not only interfered, we've gotten involved in deposing elected leaders, installed dictators, deposed dictators and there are many egregious examples. These often amounted to supporting the corporatocracy which were using the nations' natural resources.

So we should not be so outraged.

Rather we should expect it and take measures against it. That includes getting to the bottom of this thing with Trump and Russia.
 
It took a long time for all the deception in the run-up to Iraq War 2.0 to come to light, but it eventually did.
I am quite confident that the morass of Trump's rise to power will be discovered and published, but not very soon, at least on in the US.
But it is likely that everything the CIA/FBI knows also is known by the rest of the Five-Eyes Club, plus any Intelligence Agency with special interests Russia, such as the German BND.
As the saying goes, three people can keep a secret if...

I say let it drag out until after the 2018 election, make sure they take Pence down with Trump and that leaves third in line which will hopefully be the Democratic Speaker of the House.

It's only fair given how dishonest the 2016 election was.
 
I don't think we have any room to call Russia evil over this. We've not only interfered, we've gotten involved in deposing elected leaders, installed dictators, deposed dictators and there are many egregious examples. These often amounted to supporting the corporatocracy which were using the nations' natural resources.

So we should not be so outraged.

Rather we should expect it and take measures against it. That includes getting to the bottom of this thing with Trump and Russia.

Yes, to this.

It's as I keep saying, the problem with the election was not Trump, but the people that supported him.

Similarly, the problem with Russian influence is not the Russians, it is Americans who pass it off as no big deal.

The Russians have all the interest in trying to meddle with international elections. That doesn't mean we have an obligation to fall for it.

Seriously, who would have imagined 30 years ago that the Republicans would fall over themselves supporting a candidate who was preferred by Russia?

Ronald Reagan has to be rolling over in his grave.
 
I don't understand your question.

Well, there could be incriminating ties like saying, "his loans come from this bank that did X, Y, and Z and is ran by this terrible person" that a dumb person might this is compromising when in actually it is a completely reasonable practice. Maybe a global fund that dumb person invests in has ties to that exact same bank.

Then there is doing things that are a person more aware would see as an unreasonable practice.
 
Obama interfered in the French election. This means war.

False equivalence is false. Endorsing a candidate is nothing like using your clandestine agencies to hack servers or paying a troll army to influence opinion through comments.

Nice try, though.
 
Do you mean compromising for a stupid person reading it or compromising for a smart person reading it?
The Podesta hacks released information that was compromising if the person reading it was either stupid, naive, or already anti-Clinton. They still had a damaging effect.
 
So you think Trump owes the Russian government money or vice versa, or that the Russian government has sex tapes of Donald Trump and you are fairly confident of this. And you think they chose not to release this stuff at the same time as they were leaking Podesta's emails. Gotcha. Not sure I agree, but I understand your argument.



Not really inarguable, but it's likely that was the case with some non-zero amount of voters.
Not inarguable? How could you argue against it, then?
 
The Podesta hacks released information that was compromising if the person reading it was either stupid, naive, or already anti-Clinton. They still had a damaging effect.

Which is why I'm curious if people think Russia has incriminating evidence for smart people or just the smart people.
 
The hack resulted in more information being out there. Not really a direct negative. Wrong in principle, but I wouldn't call it a bad thing. It didn't force anyone to vote in a way they didn't want to. And there are a million factors that could have influenced the election.

More information in a notably skewed fashion, released with intent to mess with public opinion in ways that had little to do with good decision making. If a group focuses on releasing the stories of the people who die each year of vaccine-related causes to try to convince people not to get vaccinations, should we simply be happy at the added information that they put out there, especially after disease outbreaks start getting nasty and deadly?

It is selective and overblown outrage, because people are saying things like it's an act of war when it's something routinely engaged in by their own government, and other governments.

While "act of war" likely is overblown, outrage is natural, regardless of how routine it may be.

They are part of the institution that does it (as are we as voters, in a sense).

When a guy who distributes the incoming mail to the people who will deal with it is being effectively treated on par with a CEO when it comes to responsibility for the decisions of the leaders of the company, arguments like this rather lose any meaningfulness.

We elect the officials responsible for controlling the CIA. It's our responsibility to care what the CIA does.

Of course it's our responsibility to care what the CIA does, but when you're relying on a link that honestly only leads to each of us bearing a negligible amount of the responsibility, through a convoluted path that effectively removes our influence at multiple parts from the process, your stated reasoning for why we should care fails, badly.

I don't think I can express myself more clearly on this, so I'll just agree to disagree with you.

We could agree to do such, but to what end? To let you try to protect the notably flawed reasoning that you're trying to employ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom