Al Qaida 9/11-Strategists Won

Were US-Foreign Policies since 9/11 a success from Al Qaida's Point of View?


  • Total voters
    36
Pardalis may not be amused, :boxedin: but feel free and start a new thread about this particular topic. :)

Why should he? You made the comments to begin with. You are quick to tell everyone to stay on topic, but can never stay on it yourself. You still never responded to any on-topic posts I made. All you can do is throw out links that have nothing to do with the post you are responding too or dismiss the post as off-topic.

What was the bigger threat for Al Qaida to get into Iraq? :
"Saddams Iron Fist" -or- "Iraqi antipathy" (As you're trying to point out in your reply)?

Why don't you start a thread on it. Or does this directly relate to the 911 strategy?:rolleyes:
 
Oh, I'm pretty used to the fact that not everyone sees reality for what it is. Reality in this case is that they believe they kicked asses when they certainly did nothing of the sort, and that you're easily impressed by whatever anyone who has a beef against the US government will say.

No, they took down the World Trade Center. They killed people from countries all over the world. They didn't kick anyones ass, they murdered people. They didn't bypass any security. They took advantage of a system where people enjoy freedoms to not be hassled everywhere they go, scared a bunch of passengers who were taught to do what they were told, and then commited a murder/suicide.

What Tailgater said. On top of it, the various diplomas those people hold, or in many case held, are not all that impressive, nor did they make them rational thinkers. Same goes for many death-cults, like Aum Shinrikyo in Japan, that attracted a fair number of engineers, MDs, and suchlike.

You've got to make up your mind: were they planning, or were they not ? In any case, the statement you mention (I've seen the tape too) shows that they were planning to kill many people, but that they did certainly not plan on the towers collapsing, or on NATO invading Afganistan so soon afterwards, or the USA invading Iraq.

In that tape, what's apparent is a number of naughty little kids who rejoice at how better than planned their latest trick went, certainly not some well educated strategists with a well prepared plan to take over the world through some calculated strikes. :rolleyes:

Sorry, Oliver, but if revolution against the evils of the axis of global mundialisation must come, it will certainly not be through Al Qaida :p

Bin Laden always brags about Lebanon in 1983 and Somalia in 1993, I dont see why Oliver finds this as an amusing motive of Bin Laden's.

Oliver, the Sunni insurgency welcomed al Qaeda into Iraq as an ally after the invasion and removal of Saddam from power. It was only recently that they saw the true face of al Qaeda, and turned against them. During the Saddam years the Sunnis had no reason to invite al Qaeda into Iraq - Saddam made many concessions to his Sunni tribal brethren because he couldn't control them himself through force they were in fact his support base. The Sunnis got the good jobs and all the power under Saddam - why would they invite al Qaeda in then?

You are astoundingly ignorant of the things you have a strong opinion on - you really should educate yourself before spouting off on things you know little about.

Why should he? You made the comments to begin with. You are quick to tell everyone to stay on topic, but can never stay on it yourself. You still never responded to any on-topic posts I made. All you can do is throw out links that have nothing to do with the post you are responding too or dismiss the post as off-topic.

Why don't you start a thread on it. Or does this directly relate to the 911 strategy?:rolleyes:


To make a long discussion short: Do you guy's believe that it was absolutely unforeseeable that the US would consider Iraq as a target after 9/11 and therefore: Was it impossible that Al Qaida had any strategy for the pre-9/11 era? :confused:
 
Impossible, no. However, nothing that AlQ has done or said shows that they did foresee the actual events, nor that they had a real strategy, or even realistic long term objectives.
 
I did a research about Al Qaida's strategies and they have in fact a
strategy to unite Muslims all over the world against the Non-Believers.
In fact - 9/11 was meant to provoke interventions within the Middle-
East to get support from other Muslims.

The "Combating Terrorism Center" translated this Al Qaida Book:

The Management of Savagery
"Translation of Major al-Qaeda Book that Outlines Its Plan for Defeating U.S. and Its Allies"

Available here:
http://ctc.usma.edu/publications/naji.asp

Additionally, there is also an Article about Al Qaida's strategies trans-
lated on this Site (Please note that this site is a Pro-Jihad-Website) :

Opening up new Battlefronts
"The Al Qaida Strategy to the year 2020"

Available here:
http://www.jihadunspun.com/strategy_apr2005.htm

PBS also investigated Al Qaida's strategies for their Documentary
Jihad - The Men and Ideas Behind Al Qaeda

Available here:
http://www.youtube.com/profile_video...00ger4u&page=1
 
I did a research about Al Qaida's strategies and they have in fact a
strategy to unite Muslims all over the world against the Non-Believers.
In fact - 9/11 was meant to provoke interventions within the Middle-
East to get support from other Muslims.

The "Combating Terrorism Center" translated this Al Qaida Book:

The Management of Savagery
"Translation of Major al-Qaeda Book that Outlines Its Plan for Defeating U.S. and Its Allies"

Available here:
http://ctc.usma.edu/publications/naji.asp

Additionally, there is also an Article about Al Qaida's strategies trans-
lated on this Site (Please note that this site is a Pro-Jihad-Website) :

Opening up new Battlefronts
"The Al Qaida Strategy to the year 2020"

Available here:
http://www.jihadunspun.com/strategy_apr2005.htm

PBS also investigated Al Qaida's strategies for their Documentary
Jihad - The Men and Ideas Behind Al Qaeda

Available here:
http://www.youtube.com/profile_video...00ger4u&page=1

So? What is your summary of the links?
 
So? What is your summary of the links?


Well, their plan works. I don't know if they will succeed for their
plans up to the year 2020 - but so far it looks as if there is a real
chance to get to this point.
 
Well, their plan works. I don't know if they will succeed for their
plans up to the year 2020 - but so far it looks as if there is a real
chance to get to this point.

After reading the first few pages of this one, it looks like they took a page from a Sylvia Brown how-to book on how to make psychic predictions after the fact.

http://www.jihadunspun.com/strategy_apr2005.htm

I see they don't mention how they are pissing off fellow muslims too.
 
After reading the first few pages of this one, it looks like they took a page from a Sylvia Brown how-to book on how to make psychic predictions after the fact.

http://www.jihadunspun.com/strategy_apr2005.htm

I see they don't mention how they are pissing off fellow muslims too.


I didn't see this as well - but I had the same thought while watching
their "9/11 tribute" called "Islam Remembers September 11th" on their
main-site. :covereyes
 
I didn't see this as well - but I had the same thought while watching
their "9/11 tribute" called "Islam Remembers September 11th" on their
main-site. :covereyes

Havn't some of the truthers made a CT about how AQ works for the US by using quotes that AQ knew we were going to invade Iraq? I could be wrong, but I've heard so many stories now.
 
Havn't some of the truthers made a CT about how AQ works for the US by using quotes that AQ knew we were going to invade Iraq? I could be wrong, but I've heard so many stories now.


As far I know - most Twoofers think Al Qaida is a CIA-brainwashed
Patsy-Organisation that was being set up by Aliens from Roswell. I
guess Alex Jones told that to them... :p
 
I think Al Qaeda's goals are....
1) Getting the US out of the region.
Mission is definitely not accomplished, so far.

2) Increasing the number of fundamentalist regimes in the region.
Mission is definitely not accomplished, so far. (They lost Afghanistan and haven't yet established a fundamentalist regime anywhere else. They might be able to establish fundy regimes in Afghanistan and Iraq... only time will tell.)

3) Re-establishing a Caliphate over Islam.
Mission not accomplished.

4) Destroying Israel.
Mission not accomplished.

As far as I can tell, they are no closer to their goals now than before 9/11.

One could argue that lesser goals may be accomplished. They might be more popular in the region than before 9/11. They might have more recruits (even accounting for deaths) than before 9/11. They might have caused more damage to Western interests. They may have killed more Westerners.

But those things are not the goals per se, only their strategy for implementing the four goals above.

On the flip side, the West hasn't particularly managed their goals either.
1) Spread liberalism in the region.
Marginal improvement. Afghanistan is not fundy, but Iraq is in chaos. Libya made incremental steps. Everything else is basically the same.

2) Increase personal safety
Mission not accomplished. More Americans have died after 9/11 than during it. Few people think the West as a whole is safer. At best, it's no change in the level of security.

3) Ensure a steady supply of oil.
Mission not accomplished. Iraq's oil supply is not even close to 9/11 levels.

Neither side is accomplishing their long-term goals.
 
Neither side is accomplishing their long-term goals.


Al Qaida's Strategy is planned up to the year 2020, and
their plans are in progress - while US lies rather look like
if they're failing in the Middle-East, especially because it
was AQ's plan to provoke military interventions in the ME
to kill them down there - being a much easier target for them. And they got rid of Saddam's stranglehold as well.

Or as Mr.Burn would put it: "Excellent".
 
Al Qaida's Strategy is planned up to the year 2020, and
their plans are in progress - while US lies rather look like
if they're failing in the Middle-East, especially because it
was AQ's plan to provoke military interventions in the ME
to kill them down there - being a much easier target for them. And they got rid of Saddam's stranglehold as well.

Or as Mr.Burn would put it: "Excellent".

Until a few years from now, when they look back and alter the strategy to fit the future present time. Whatever happens, they will be winning according to their own design.
 
Al Qaida's Strategy is planned up to the year 2020, and
their plans are in progress - while US lies rather look like
if they're failing in the Middle-East, especially because it
was AQ's plan to provoke military interventions in the ME
to kill them down there
So it's AQ's goal to commit genocide on America? Because their original goal had been to oust the Soviets from Afghanistant. It would seem odd of them to take a different approach.

Where can I get a copy of AQ's 13-year plan, anyway? Their stated goals have always been to get American troops out of Muslim nations, to install fundamentalist regimes, to destroy Israel and then to re-establish the Caliphate.

When did they abandon those goals in favor of just racking up their kill tally?
 
Until a few years from now, when they look back and alter the strategy to fit the future present time. Whatever happens, they will be winning according to their own design.


As far I know, Al Qaida did't alter it's plans yet - and why should
they? As long the US is present in the M-E, their plan works just
fine. And military interventions in Iran would be a success for them
as well - since Al Qaida can't operate in Iran yet - but with some
luck like in case of Saddam, this may change after the Stranglehold
in Iran is removed as well.

So it's AQ's goal to commit genocide on America? Because their original goal had been to oust the Soviets from Afghanistant. It would seem odd of them to take a different approach.

Where can I get a copy of AQ's 13-year plan, anyway? Their stated goals have always been to get American troops out of Muslim nations, to install fundamentalist regimes, to destroy Israel and then to re-establish the Caliphate.

When did they abandon those goals in favor of just racking up their kill tally?


The Strategy-Plan is available here:

Source: Combating Terrorism Center
The Management of Savagery
"Translation of Major al-Qaeda Book that Outlines Its Plan for Defeating U.S. and Its Allies"

Additionally, there is also an Article about Al Qaida's strategies trans-
lated on this Site (Please note that this site is a Pro-Jihad-Website) :

Opening up new Battlefronts
"The Al Qaida Strategy to the year 2020"

PBS also investigated Al Qaida's strategies for their Documentary
Jihad - The Men and Ideas Behind Al Qaeda
 
The Strategy-Plan is available here:
You're confusing "goal" and "strategy".

Saying a strategy is successful because it is being implemented is nonsensical. A strategy is successful only insofar as it accomplishes one's ultimate goals. The cites you gave me discuss AQ's strategy, no whether they are accomplishing their goals.

In this sense, both America and AQ have successfully implemented their strategies. AQ drew America into a regional conflict and is killing Americans. America has toppled the Taliban and Hussein.

Strategies implemented!

But will these strategies result in their respective goals? So far,neither AQ nor America seems any closer to their ultimate goals, notwithstanding their implementation of a strategy.
 
You're confusing "goal" and "strategy".

Saying a strategy is successful because it is being implemented is nonsensical. A strategy is successful only insofar as it accomplishes one's ultimate goals. The cites you gave me discuss AQ's strategy, no whether they are accomplishing their goals.

In this sense, both America and AQ have successfully implemented their strategies. AQ drew America into a regional conflict and is killing Americans. America has toppled the Taliban and Hussein.

Strategies implemented!

But will these strategies result in their respective goals? So far,neither AQ nor America seems any closer to their ultimate goals, notwithstanding their implementation of a strategy.


Well, since the current Administration did fought the wrong
country - and suddenly was confronted with terrorism in a
place that didn't have terrorism in the first place - while AQ
didn't care where to fight the US, it looks like AQ is leading
concerning the race in archiving goals...
 
Except, AQ's goal is not to kill Americans. That is the strategy selected to acheive their goal of reestablishing the Caliphate.

Yes, America invaded a country that has nothign to do with 9/11. That presumes America's only goal was vengeance. In fact, the stated goal was creating a stable region. And that goal is not being accomplished at all. The strategy they chose, even though it is being implemented will not get them to their goal.

AQ's goal is to re-establish a Caliphate. And their strategy -- luring Americans to the region to kill them -- has been implemented. It too doesn't appear to be getting them any closer to their goal.

Both sides are successfully implementing poor strategies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom