Administrators at Loose Change forums are 15 year young kids.

Fair enough. For what it's worth, I'd rather Rev be here (hopefully learning something) than other sites on the 'net.
Agree. I think he can learn things here and perhaps post in some of the other forums. I think he would find the same kind of tough debate in the Religion or Science sub-forums as he finds here discussing CT's.
 
This thread is very telling. It's titled "What did you do? Before joining the forum".


We all know, our buddy Revolutionary91 is a 15 year old, and an administrator at the LCF. But it came up, that Sureshot is also 15, and an administrator. Not anything against 15 year olds, but they are moderators on a forum concentrating on a very complex and globally important issue.

Some comments:

Sureshot: "I was 9 when 9/11 happened, and back then I was a little dude that spent most of his time on playing video games and watching Lord of the Rings over and over ... Then about 4 years ago I stumbled upon Pentagon Strike and became obsessed about it."

Thehighwaymanq: "I was an uneducated, immature, in-the-dark adolescent who enjoyed playing sports, sometimes video games, watched way too much tv, wasn't informed and didn't care, did nothing remarkable with my life, and was nothing but a bore."

Revolutionary91 in reply to the above post: "I was the same except not into sports."

And so on..

This plays into every belief we have, seemingly right beliefs. Kids, bored, become obsessed with something they feel is very important. And Dylan takes full advantage of them. Some posters are older, of course. But the average age of admins is in the teens.

ref, It saddens me to see a person posing as intelligent expose himself by attempting to belittle our young people in other forums.

I know the person who started the thread "what were you doing" and I can tell by your use of that thread, several things.
1. you have no respect for our young people
2. you don't have a life
3. you lack ingenuity for finding subject matter
4 you have to venture into other forums to find a topic for discussion
and copy

very revealing, very sad indeed, for all you young people out there, pity him:)
 
ref, It saddens me to see a person posing as intelligent expose himself by attempting to belittle our young people in other forums.

I know the person who started the thread "what were you doing" and I can tell by your use of that thread, several things.
1. you have no respect for our young people
2. you don't have a life
3. you lack ingenuity for finding subject matter
4 you have to venture into other forums to find a topic for discussion
and copy

very revealing, very sad indeed, for all you young people out there, pity him:)
Ah, yes - how clever "you don't have a life." If you are trying to be insulting, at least put some effort into it.
 
ref, It saddens me to see a person posing as intelligent expose himself by attempting to belittle our young people in other forums.

It's not sad, it's relevant. How many of these kids have any real experience in any scientific field? Yet they post with certainty that the events which occurred on 9/11 couldn't have happened the way they did. What experience tells them this?

Ideally, as individuals age, they learn more about the world around them. People with college backgrounds and real-world experience in technical fields try to explain basic principles of physics to these kids. This is the only good coming from the truth movement. Some kids are actually learning a little bit more about science and math.
 
I'm going to defend Rev's opinion, in part.

While constant mention of his age, lack of driver's license, lack of life experience, etc. may not meet the classic definition of an ad hom, the overall result is to attempt to cast doubt on what he says in any thread simply due to these factors.

I believe his arguments should stand on their own. If his age goes directly to the argument (for instance, if he claims to have voted for Gore in the last election) then you can use his age to call him out as a liar.

Otherwise, we should let it alone.

If you feel the need to let someone know his age, PM them.

Bringing it up time after time doesn't seem productive, IMHO.

It may not be productive, but the last 200 posts from Rev have been a model for "non-productivity".

As for whether mentioning his age is an ad hom...

If it is used to state that a point he has made is worthless because of his age, than it is an ad hom. However, to mention, as a general comment that the user lacks life experience, and the perspective that can provide, because of his age, then that is a valid comment, and I would have a MAJOR BONE to pick if a mod were to flag such as a violation.


ref, It saddens me to see a person posing as intelligent expose himself by attempting to belittle our young people in other forums.

I know the person who started the thread "what were you doing" and I can tell by your use of that thread, several things.
1. you have no respect for our young people
2. you don't have a life
3. you lack ingenuity for finding subject matter
4 you have to venture into other forums to find a topic for discussion
and copy

very revealing, very sad indeed, for all you young people out there, pity him:)

fortuneteller...

While attempting to make comment on Ref, who by all acounts is a mature, intelligent, diligent, kind, but HUMAN, person, you have yourself insulted him directly, which is a violation of the forum rules, and have yourself matronized him, with your tone and list of criticisms, which is the very thing you seem to be admonishing him for...

TAM:)
 
It's not sad, it's relevant. How many of these kids have any real experience in any scientific field? Yet they post with certainty that the events which occurred on 9/11 couldn't have happened the way they did. What experience tells them this?

Ideally, as individuals age, they learn more about the world around them. People with college backgrounds and real-world experience in technical fields try to explain basic principles of physics to these kids. This is the only good coming from the truth movement. Some kids are actually learning a little bit more about science and math.

experience is no replacement for intelligence.

with age, individuals loose their cognitive abilities.

there is obviously something you can learn from young people.
 
I can honestly say, that if I were to look back at myself as a youth, there is NOTHING that my younger self could teach me of any real worth, with the possible exception of living life for the joy of it, and the freedom that comes with no financial burden...which I hope to one day enjoy again.
 
experience is no replacement for intelligence.

with age, individuals loose their cognitive abilities.

there is obviously something you can learn from young people.

ok, take a WWII Vet, who was an officer in the armed forces, then after WWI was over, became a teacher....

Sit him next to a 16 year old straight A student...

Who will teach you more about life, how to handle things, how to "read" somebody, how to be appropriate in various settings...the list goes on.

TAM:)
 
Who will teach you more about life, how to handle things, how to "read" somebody, how to be appropriate in various settings...the list goes on.

TAM:)

since when does the mass-murder of thousands have anything to do with
LIFE ?

eta - a suggestion was made that older persons have something more to teach our youth about 911, my god, they're living in the midst of our mistakes, if ANYTHING, we should apologizing to them.
 
Last edited:
since when does the mass-murder of thousands have anything to do with
LIFE ?

so are you implying that our WWII Vets were guilty of mass murder? Is that what you think of all soldiers, who fought, and died for your country?

War can teach alot...it teaches comradery, it teaches discipline, it teaches the horrors of war, the horror of death. Plus I said he went on to be a teacher.

Are you honestly trying to argue that a 16 year old student has more to offer someone, in terms of teaching them about life, than a WWII veteran???

TAM:)
 
since when does the mass-murder of thousands have anything to do with
LIFE ?

eta - a suggestion was made that older persons have something more to teach our youth about 911, my god, they're living in the midst of our mistakes, if ANYTHING, we should apologizing to them.

I agree, and as the generations go on, the more disgusted our seniors should be.

I am not anti youth...I see alot of good come out of the minds of the young, but your suggestion that a youth has more to teach us about 9/11 than a senior simply does not add up to me.

TAM:)
 
If "sureshot" is indeed a teen, then I owe him an apology.

I think I confused him with someone else at lcf.

So, consider this a formal apology to "sureshot."

I hope your stay here is rewarding for both you and us.
 
I agree, and as the generations go on, the more disgusted our seniors should be.

I am not anti youth...I see alot of good come out of the minds of the young, but your suggestion that a youth has more to teach us about 9/11 than a senior simply does not add up to me.

TAM:)

In reality, our youth should be disgusted with us for allowing forces to destroy the world they have inherited. as stewards, we have essentially
created a holy mess

everything our soldiers died for during the last century seemingly has been in vain, because we have allowed criminals to rob us of the very thing they gave their lives to preserve
 
I have not blamed the youth for todays problems, but neither will I give them credit they have not earned...

Their future, and what they will make of it, has yet to be seen...and I will be an older man when they get their chance.

TAM:)

Oh and incidently, I am proud as a Canadian, to pass on my country in the state it is in, to the next generation....

TAM:)
 
I have not blamed the youth for todays problems, but neither will I give them credit they have not earned...

Their future, and what they will make of it, has yet to be seen...and I will be an older man when they get their chance.

TAM:)

we are to blame for today's problems.
you should give them credit for putting up with us.
we made their future what it is, they have no future, thanks to us
they may never GET a chance
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom