A Skeptical Stroke: The Confabulating Skeptic

Hi Robert! :) I haven't been on here very long, but I wish you wonderfully well.
Confabulation can also refer to a slightly different psychological construct... not false memories or mistaking fantasies for actual events, but something the brain seems to do in the dissociative disorders. It's as if evidence that would otherwise lead to the executive personality becoming aware of time loss, dissociative amnesia, alters, etc., is made unavailable to the exec self, but generally not by substituting or creating false information. Fascinating stuff. It would be interesting to know exactly what kind of relationship this phenomenon has to CVA-related confabulation. I've worked with both types of clients and I can't say that I really have any clear idea.
 
The simplest definition of confabulation is: false memories. More specifically, a confabulation is the mistaking of a fantasy for the memory of an actual event. In my case, I would wake from a dream, firmly convinced that the dream had actually occurred. This led to some interesting situations, some of which I will relate here.
..

My wife had the same problem when she was working the graveyard shift, probably due to sleep deprivation. Once she awoke from a nap and was convinced that we had bought tickets to fly on a blimp in California, but had forgotten to go. Now she was extremely concerned that we had wasted all that money.

She was fully awake when she told me this. I told her in no uncertain terms, THIS NEVER HAPPENED. After a while she took my word for it, but found it very confusing.
 
Hi Robert! :) I haven't been on here very long, but I wish you wonderfully well.
Confabulation can also refer to a slightly different psychological construct... not false memories or mistaking fantasies for actual events, but something the brain seems to do in the dissociative disorders. It's as if evidence that would otherwise lead to the executive personality becoming aware of time loss, dissociative amnesia, alters, etc., is made unavailable to the exec self, but generally not by substituting or creating false information. Fascinating stuff. It would be interesting to know exactly what kind of relationship this phenomenon has to CVA-related confabulation. I've worked with both types of clients and I can't say that I really have any clear idea.

From what I've read and experienced, it is usually people who are energetic and outgoing who confabulate, at least on a verbal level. My uncle died of Alzheimer's a number of years ago, and in the throes of the disease he confabulated constantly and vocally, long after he lost the ability to form cogent sentence structures. It's as if people want to keep their minds active even though they are no longer working properly.
 
Hi Robert! :) I haven't been on here very long, but I wish you wonderfully well.
Confabulation can also refer to a slightly different psychological construct... not false memories or mistaking fantasies for actual events, but something the brain seems to do in the dissociative disorders. It's as if evidence that would otherwise lead to the executive personality becoming aware of time loss, dissociative amnesia, alters, etc., is made unavailable to the exec self, but generally not by substituting or creating false information. Fascinating stuff. It would be interesting to know exactly what kind of relationship this phenomenon has to CVA-related confabulation. I've worked with both types of clients and I can't say that I really have any clear idea.
Interesting, Maia! it was odd how my confidence in my confabulations kept me from believing people who tried to talk me out of them.
 
It's surprising what you'll stoop to when you've been in a hospital for the eight months.

It was 5 days shy of 11 months in hospital. And, after a month of being home, we are coming up on the 1 year anniversary of the scariest event of my life. August 4th.
 
RSL,
This is a great thread in so many ways.

My mom went through a much slighter (I know - there I go using the techinical terminology again) stroke than you, but she had great moments of confabulation, too. My favorite being the nurse who was making her put her toes (mom's) too close together. They were touching each other (as do all toes, as everyone knows).

She made me pleat the bedsheet and put some sheet between each toe so they wouldn't touch... just to "show that b**** ". I tried to discuss it with her, but ultimately it was easier to just stuff some sheeting between the toes.

More important as related to this thread, though, was that we knew she was recovering when we could sit around and discuss these incidents with her some months later and laugh together.
 
*snip*

How Many Feet?

My sister Trish (not Beeg Seestor) tells me that once, I pointed at something and asked her if she would bring it to me and place it on one of my pairs of feet! This was complicated even further by the fact that I was pointing to a white board on the wall of my hospital room ( The nurses would write their names and phone extensions on it every day. why I felt I needed it on my feet is anyone's guess).

*snip*

Sounds like every experience I've had working with patients on the stroke unit.

"No, there's nobody over there, that's a wall."

"No, you can't leave until the doctors say it's green-light. You're in a hospital bed, you're a patient."

"No, you don't need to go out that window. Nothing but a seven story drop to the pavement out that way, buddy."

"Stop calling me by your wife's name."

I know there's a sense of embarrassment afterwards, during the real recovery phase: I've been stupid, and talking nonsense. I try to get one idea through to people and that is that it happens to everyone who has a hard stroke. One gal I worked with for some weeks, her husband said she had a great sense of humor, and suggested it, so we started to keep a little list of the stuff she'd say. He said when she was recovered, she'd laugh her ass off... never did find out.

On her way off the unit, however, I saw her as I was walking in. She passed by as her hubby pushed her in a wheelchair. She gave me a very happy grin.

"Hey! Discharge today? Great! Keep improving!"

to which she responded, in a slow, weak voice, with an equally big grin,

"Goooo to helllllll." :D
 
Interesting, Maia! it was odd how my confidence in my confabulations kept me from believing people who tried to talk me out of them.

The... reality they've created, I guess... does seem very real to clients with the dissociative disorders as well, even though the confabulating itself definitely is a different phemomenon. But it really is as if the ability to confabulate might be something which the brain can draw on for a lot of different reasons. This is definitely going out on a limb a bit... but I wonder if it's *always* an attempt on the part of the brain to protect itself from the knowledge of what's happened to it. There is so much physiological change involved with the neurobiology of the DD's, particularly in the more severe forms. The DSM-IV-TR actually acknowledges this in the definition now (pretty amazing, I think!) So it's maybe not as far from post-stroke status as it seems.
 
Scepticism is all very well, Robert- but did you actually check for string?
 
My dad passed away last September. Sadly, he wasted away for the last 2-3 months of his life. While your brain is going in the right direction - healing - his was shutting down with the rest of his body. But the things you posted certainly rang a bell - there were times when he swore there was a dog or cat sitting in the corner, or my mom was a nursing home employee, or he was going on some trip to the moon or something.

It's odd how our brains work, or try to work, especially when damaged.

I had a similar experience with my dad who had twice had a brain tumor removed. He never recovered and was in a nursing home for years. When he was in the hospital, he was convinced that the tracks in the ceiling (the one the privacy curtains hang on) were in fact supports where they would string his body up suspended like from the book Coma - must have been terrifying for him. :(

When in the nursing home, he often thought wild animals (lions and tigers and such) were roaming the halls at night. He often went back in time, thought he was doing jobs or things he had done in the past.

I have myself woken from dreams that were so realistic that for awhile I thought the things in the dreams actually happened. The brain is a strange thing and we are only gradually figuring out how it functions (and misfunctions).
 
How interesting, Robert!! I hope you can, in a year or less, put together a magazine article on your experience of being a stroke patient. As several posters have suggested, having had convincing but untrue memories gives one a lot more empathy for people with wild claims.

I have had a hypnogogic (?or hypnopompic, I still get them mixed up) hallucination that was absolutely realistic and believable, and seemed to me to be real for years afterwards. Being whom I am, I kept the memory mentally stored under "No explanation yet" and didn't change my entire worldview because of one event. Years later, reading an issue of Skeptical Inquirer (when it was still in the little format -- thanks, Gilmar, for lending them to me!) I discovered sleep-related hallucinations and instantly recognized what the apparent Hellhound in my backyard had been. In many ways the combination of that vivid, impossible event and of finding a reasonable explanation have made me the skeptic I am today.

I can, sadly, also report that alcohol-related brain damage can lead to confabulation. My Dad is progressing fairly rapidly down the whirlpool of booze-induced brain failure, and you can't trust a thing he says. For instance he told my stepmom that my sister had "called to say she was flying down to Los Angeles for the weekend." The only truth to that was that my sister had called, and asked for my stepmom to call back. When he was in an automobile accident he repeatedly denied that he had done so--even though he had not been drinking at the time of his accident, they did a blood alcohol level check--despite there being numerous witnesses and, more damningly, a piece of Dad's front grille left in the other car. Even when looking at the hole in his vehicle and the corresponding piece in the evidence bag, he denied that it had been him. He was not lying; he genuinely thought he had been driving on a different road. Sad, but true.

The brain is an interesting organ, and its misfires are as fascinating (at least!) as its normal function.

Good to see you posting again, hugs, Miss_Kitt
 
Great to hear this, Robert. Thanks for giving us non-TAM attending folks a little taste of your talk.

Whenever I'm feverish, I get really strange ideas (that really seem real at the time). Stuff like a powerful emotional distress over the print on a bedspread (something to do with "too many coins"). As a child, I also used to have full-blown visual hallucinations (I would see people where I knew there were no people--and no sound). Of the two, the fever-brained delusions, although much more outlandish, were much more difficult to distinguish from reality when they were going on.

It is interesting to note that a VERY high (estimate 70%) of psychic/intuitive web sites mention that they suddenly became "psychic" after suffering head injuries.
That sounds plausible, but do you have a source for this?
 
I hallucinated during a high fever once, it was dark and I was covered so I thought I was some kind of root. very very hot root, trying to be cooler.
 
I have also had very strange delusions during a high fever when I was a teenager. I had gone camping on the beach with the Boy Scouts. Sometime after the sun had set I started not feeling well. I was burning up. I had walked down the beach with a couple of the other guys about a half a mile and decided I needed to go back to camp. I started walking back alone (very dangerous but I wasn't thinking straight and the other guys didn't really know I was ill and figured a half a mile on an open beach was no big deal). I could tell something was not right and I was so hot. I kept having the vision that I should be walking into the ocean and floating on the waves and the cool water would draw the heat from me in a leech-like fashion until I was cool again, but until that happened I knew that it would be possible to just float forever on the waves, right on top like a raft, with no aid.
Of course, I was walking in and out of the surf at night, and when the cool water hit my legs I would temporarily snap back to reality and I would get an urgency to go back to camp. I made it back and crashed in the tent. The next day when we broke camp, I mentioned to the Scout director I wasn't feeling well, who passed it on to my mother when she picked me up. She measured my temperature when I got home, and it was 104 F. I spent 3 more days in bed. No one else from the camp got sick and we never determined the cause. I just remember how vivid this feeling was, that I could float forever, and convinced it was true. Silly Green Monkey's post reminded me of this.
 
This reminds me of one of the weirder calls I had as an EMT. We were taking a patient back to the nursing home from the emergency room, and he suddenly remarked that it was a strange coincidence that I had the sam last name as him. Now given that I did not I found this strange as well. He also wanted to know where we were going on the bus, not realizing it was an ambulance.

I figured out why he thought he was talking to someone with the same last name, he was talking to his son and did not recognise him and then did not realize that the person he was talking to had changed.

I really hope he got better.
 
How interesting, Robert!! I hope you can, in a year or less, put together a magazine article on your experience of being a stroke patient. As several posters have suggested, having had convincing but untrue memories gives one a lot more empathy for people with wild claims.

Not only that, but I can imagine an article of that sort as being a good read for patients and families going through stroke rehab. Instead of feeling stupid about the confabulations, which some people do, they could laugh about it, and use it as a jumping point for sharing their own stories in support groups and language rehab groups and the like.

*wonders if anyone's written anything like that before ... must look into it.*

I can't remember ever having been convinced that something I'd dreamed was real, but I do remember once, when I was in high school, spending the better part of a day trying to remember if my grandfather was alive or not. In a dream I'd had the night before, he was dead, and when I woke up, I could not figure out whether that aspect of the dream was part of the dream or part of real life. I wanted to ask someone, but could imagine all too well how my parents would have reacted.

(Happy to say that Grandad is alive to this day.)
 
"RSL! RSL! RSL!" First and foremost, it is fantastic you continue to progess..and that you are back! A similar chant of "RSL's better half! x 3", I'm sure you have heard it before but it is worth repeating - you are amazing!

As to confabulation...false memory is strange stuff. My Grandmother experienced it to an extent, convinced her husband (who had died 4 years earlier) was in the back room of their house playing cards with space aliens.
 
Wow! That's some wacky stop, Robert. The brain is a strange place, to be sure.

By the way... Do you (or does anyone) have video of your TAM talk? I'd love to see it.
I don't, ORM. but if this is like previous TAMs, a DVD set will be available later this year.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom