A report tells us

[Qureshi1_78]

I think the patient is malingering - just like you

my duty was to engage you. I have done my job

Its now Wol doctor turn... over to him.

 

[Nucular]

Re: Re: Re: A report tells us

At this stage, if I demand to disclose your identity with qualification then this question would not be irrelevent.

Why? I make no claim to have a medical qualification, my degrees are in psychology and criminology.

Oh dear, When a child born? who give a name to that child? Yes, father or mother?

Pardon?

Hahnemann is your father (allopaths) because he given the name to allopathy.

Well, I doubt that medical doctors (who don't call themselves allopaths) would agree with that odd statement (that Hanhnemann is the father of modern medicine), any more than Hahnemann himself would have.

Allopaths found no irregularity and abnormality in this case as all reports were clear or normal but patient was screaming due to pain. Allopaths sent back the patient at home with remarks that he has no disease. It was the homeopaths who dealt the case and observed so many symptoms in him and prescribed a perfect remedy.

Was the point of this thread simply to present us with a completely unverifiable anecdote?

Qureshi, what are your views on the evidential value of anecdotes? Are there any better forms of evidence, do you think?

 

[SezMe]

What is your opinion? What can you offer? Go to home? or you will try to treat him?

I thought part of homeopathy was a complete, custom work-up of each case. Is this not so? Why, then, would you expect a diagnosis when, by your own practices, there is insufficient information?

 

[Mouthfire]

Re: Re: Re: A report tells us

At this stage, if I demand to disclose your identity with qualification then this question would not be irrelevent.

Oh dear, When a child born? who give a name to that child? Yes, father or mother?

Hahnemann is your father (allopaths) because he given the name to allopathy. Allopaths found no irregularity and abnormality in this case as all reports were clear or normal but patient was screaming due to pain. Allopaths sent back the patient at home with remarks that he has no disease. It was the homeopaths who dealt the case and observed so many symptoms in him and prescribed a perfect remedy.

What kind of nonsense are you talking about? Hahnemann had nothing to do with conventional modern medicine, and he surely did not give birth to modern medicine

If anyone was the father of western medicine, I would have to say it was Sir William Osler... and NOT that kook Hahnemann by any stretch of the imagination.

You seem to be asserting that because Hahneman called western medicine "allopathy", that he is the father of it. What a load of rubbish and illogical thinking.... Conventional medical practitioners don't even use the term "allopathy"....