A foreshadowing of life under SOPA?

I think the point a few people seem to missing is that in this circumstance, UMG didn't actually make a copyright claim. They used a backdoor method that allows them to remove ANY content they don't like regardless of copyright or ownership.

They didn't want people on Youtube to see Megaupload's video so they unilaterally removed it.

And that has nothing to do with SOPA and everything to do with corporate culture...
 
O too bad, did the person making the video have legal right to use the images and music under original work? Even if they do, why should Youtube have to host it? You can't force McDonalds to have ads for Burger King.

Why should they be able to force Youtube to act against its wishes, and what does this have to do with SOPA?

I support SOPA, I do not support the extension of copyright beyond 20 years, but people do not have the right to freely distribute other people's work.

The issue here isn't that Youtube took the video down, Universal Music Group did. The content of the video did not belong to UMG, they simply didn't like the message. There was no copyright involved.

It did not violate Youtube's terms of service, if it did I wouldn't say anything.

It's the fact that UMG acted to censor and remove speech they didn't like from Youtube, not that Youtube took down a video. Can you not see the difference?

I mention SOPA because this is exactly the kind of power over content the entertainment industry is seeking to have handed to them wholesale.
 
I thought that anyone that likes the MythBusters might like to read Adam Savage's take on SOPA (Link)
 
You know sneering and all but calling them whining brats isn't a sound rebuttal, right?

Did i do that? No I did not. (My 'oh too bad' was rather strong and out of place)

I have pointed out that they have used a false flag about the issue. SOPA is standard copyright material, I personally am more concerned about online piracy.

I do not think that internet piracy is a good thing, do you?
 
Last edited:
The issue here isn't that Youtube took the video down, Universal Music Group did. The content of the video did not belong to UMG, they simply didn't like the message. There was no copyright involved.
I know that now, but the issue is not SOPA at all, but the power of UMG has with Youtube as a corporate entity, not SOPA.
It did not violate Youtube's terms of service, if it did I wouldn't say anything.
And it does not involve SOPA does it? but corporate power brokering. I control advertising dollars is not SOPA
It's the fact that UMG acted to censor and remove speech they didn't like from Youtube, not that Youtube took down a video. Can you not see the difference?
Yes I do, so what does it have to do with SOPA?
I mention SOPA because this is exactly the kind of power over content the entertainment industry is seeking to have handed to them wholesale.

They are two separate issues, SOPA is also a tool for people who create content and don't want it illegally copied, like small graphic designers.

Lowes bowed to bizarre pressure to pull ads from 'All American Muslim', that does not involve SOPA does it?
 
Here's what this has to do with SOPA:
SOPA gives exactly this power to everyone. It won't just be UMG with Google via a contract loophole - it will be a bank censoring your criticism of them, the police censoring your video of them violating your rights, etc. And 50 years from now, when everyone has forgotten why SOPA exists in the first place, it will be the government going around the Constitution to silence criticism. I don't mean to sound paranoid, and maybe none of these things will happen - but we should be wary of the possibility.
 
here are my points:

1. The issue in the is not SOPA, it is corporate power, UMG used its commercial power to force an action, that does not involve SOPA. This a 'bait and switch', I do not approve of the abuse of corporate power, the same issue makes it very hard to purchase Canada Dry because of the distribution contracts in my town. Until Canada Dry became carried by Coke it had all but disappeared from shelves. The same is true for gas stations in my area, a distributor forces contracts on people. WalMart engages in similar deals, they force deal on their providers and their providers force deals back on them. I disagree with these practices, but they are not part of SOPA, they are part of corporate power, which is getting worse.

2. SOPA may be poorly implemented and will be when it goes through, just liek Disnet fighting Mickey rat is the past. However currently there is a huge amount of illegal copyright violation going on, people who do not have the property rights to music, copy it and illegally distribute it, just like the old 'bootleg' tapes and CDs at flea markets. I do not believe that should be legal. Regardless of people getting used to it. Now how to deal with it is never going to be popular. But if musicians want to own their material, I think that is good. If you make software and someone reverse open it or hacks your network, you should be able to protect it.

3. An ideal system will be hard to create.

5. Currently there is some really 'bad' stuff going on on the internet, and DNS control is one way to take care of that. The 'not very nice people' who create products like Cloud AV 2012 use shell servers and proxies to avoid being caught and stopped. This is a real problem, DNS control is one way to stop it. Conficker is a great example, the international body that registers domain names had to deal with it. We need DNS control at some level. Point 3 again, no implementation will be ideal, however what is happening now will just get worse. people who have their sites banned can still use direct IP numbers unless router control takes place. You can still go to 172.16.28.251 even if you can't use DNS to go to www.freesexandmusic.net

5. The false flag of the government, yes I agree that corporate spying is terrible, the fact that some people in certain places hack into corporations and small businesses and steal their copyrighted material is very 'bad' and terrible. Stories of people having their products made in other countries before they can make them are sad and bad for every one. Corporations stealing from the people who do the research and work is not a good thing, but there is also the false flag of government, just like the Patriot Act, they will use noble causes to do illegal end runs on civil right. I disagree with that.


6. The false flag of people in general talking about the freedom of the internet. My son says that SOPA will bring down the internet, why? because someone else said so, now he did tell me that the owner of Reddit says that SOPA will be bad for Reddit, I do not know if that is true or not. And I think that complaint has some legitimacy. However we currently have system where you can go and get illegal copies of movies, music, video games (and some malware) through bit torrents and the like. People can also practice corporate warfare on the net and other are truly pirates, trashing machines and data, stealing. the false flag here is the cry of freedom, when there is a lot of illegal activity that is not freedom, but illegal activity. No I do not think I teenager should be fined $250,000 for illegal downloads, but i also do think we have to plug the holes. Again point 3.

8. Internet piracy is not good and getting worse. The loss of personal income and time is overwhelming.
 
Here's what this has to do with SOPA:
SOPA gives exactly this power to everyone. It won't just be UMG with Google via a contract loophole - it will be a bank censoring your criticism of them, the police censoring your video of them violating your rights, etc. And 50 years from now, when everyone has forgotten why SOPA exists in the first place, it will be the government going around the Constitution to silence criticism. I don't mean to sound paranoid, and maybe none of these things will happen - but we should be wary of the possibility.

And so i ask, how is this different then the current legal system for other media? The system is abused, i agree. But Burger King already sues people as does McDonalds, is it the speed of implementation?

However what limits should be placed on the illegal use of people's work and effort, should not a graphic designer have the right to their work, or a software programmer.

now i agree the control and oversight of the government is always an issue.
 
here are my points:

1. The issue in the is not SOPA, it is corporate power, UMG used its commercial power to force an action, that does not involve SOPA. This a 'bait and switch', I do not approve of the abuse of corporate power, the same issue makes it very hard to purchase Canada Dry because of the distribution contracts in my town. Until Canada Dry became carried by Coke it had all but disappeared from shelves. The same is true for gas stations in my area, a distributor forces contracts on people. WalMart engages in similar deals, they force deal on their providers and their providers force deals back on them. I disagree with these practices, but they are not part of SOPA, they are part of corporate power, which is getting worse.

2. SOPA may be poorly implemented and will be when it goes through, just liek Disnet fighting Mickey rat is the past. However currently there is a huge amount of illegal copyright violation going on, people who do not have the property rights to music, copy it and illegally distribute it, just like the old 'bootleg' tapes and CDs at flea markets. I do not believe that should be legal. Regardless of people getting used to it. Now how to deal with it is never going to be popular. But if musicians want to own their material, I think that is good. If you make software and someone reverse open it or hacks your network, you should be able to protect it.

3. An ideal system will be hard to create.

5. Currently there is some really 'bad' stuff going on on the internet, and DNS control is one way to take care of that. The 'not very nice people' who create products like Cloud AV 2012 use shell servers and proxies to avoid being caught and stopped. This is a real problem, DNS control is one way to stop it. Conficker is a great example, the international body that registers domain names had to deal with it. We need DNS control at some level. Point 3 again, no implementation will be ideal, however what is happening now will just get worse. people who have their sites banned can still use direct IP numbers unless router control takes place. You can still go to 172.16.28.251 even if you can't use DNS to go to www.freesexandmusic.net

5. The false flag of the government, yes I agree that corporate spying is terrible, the fact that some people in certain places hack into corporations and small businesses and steal their copyrighted material is very 'bad' and terrible. Stories of people having their products made in other countries before they can make them are sad and bad for every one. Corporations stealing from the people who do the research and work is not a good thing, but there is also the false flag of government, just like the Patriot Act, they will use noble causes to do illegal end runs on civil right. I disagree with that.


6. The false flag of people in general talking about the freedom of the internet. My son says that SOPA will bring down the internet, why? because someone else said so, now he did tell me that the owner of Reddit says that SOPA will be bad for Reddit, I do not know if that is true or not. And I think that complaint has some legitimacy. However we currently have system where you can go and get illegal copies of movies, music, video games (and some malware) through bit torrents and the like. People can also practice corporate warfare on the net and other are truly pirates, trashing machines and data, stealing. the false flag here is the cry of freedom, when there is a lot of illegal activity that is not freedom, but illegal activity. No I do not think I teenager should be fined $250,000 for illegal downloads, but i also do think we have to plug the holes. Again point 3.

8. Internet piracy is not good and getting worse. The loss of personal income and time is overwhelming.

"False flag"?

Or: Missing the point, strawman, strawman, argumwnt from ignorance... NTS: address when home.
 
And so i ask, how is this different then the current legal system for other media? The system is abused, i agree. But Burger King already sues people as does McDonalds, is it the speed of implementation?

However what limits should be placed on the illegal use of people's work and effort, should not a graphic designer have the right to their work, or a software programmer.

now i agree the control and oversight of the government is always an issue.

I seem to recall a law called DMCA...
 
Most websites that wish to be seen as respectable will take down content without a formal DMCA notice. This has the advantage that people see you acting in good faith on copyright matters and that fewer lawyers get involved.

For example the first stop for people trying to get stuff removed from wikipedia for copyright reasons are our various volunteer staffed email addresses. The advantage of this is that genuine cases can be dealt with more quickly and that less genuine cases (usually Bridgeman Art Library v. Corel Corp. or over the top trademark claims) can be argued against without immediately getting lawyers involved.
 
"False flag"?

Or: Missing the point, strawman, strawman, argumwnt from ignorance... NTS: address when home.

False flag as in wagging the dog, that which a scoundrel drapes themselves in, etc...

If you wish to discuss i shall read, and the DNS is not an argument from ignorance, I said it was not an ideal solution.
 
Just wanted to add this last thing in before I left for the holidays: (WTF is SOPA?).

Just wanted to wish everyone a Merry Christmas! And, for those that don't celebrate Christmas, A Happy Holiday to you instead! See you all again after the holidays.
 
I think the issue is what i call "wild west syndrome".

Imagine back in the day you live in a lawless town, and that's the way you like it. That is the way you live your life, and you don't want to change, because you don't like the idea of having to follow laws.

Does this make the laws wrong? No, they are just coming into conflict with what people want.

You can see the same thing any time an employer closes loopholes that allow folks to get away with things. Internet blocking, no books at workstations, things of that nature. People just hate to give up something they have, regardless of if they should have it.

And imho, this is the same thing that is causing the uproar over sopa. People have gotten used to just being able to download a movie, or a game, that , to a lot of people is what the internet is for. It doesn't matter that it is wrong, or illegal, they have something now, and they don't want to give it up.

I've been saying for a while now that the internet is due for a massive change in the next decade or so. Laws and the implementation thereof are going to get stricter and easier to enforce, and despite what they would like to claim, sits like isohunt, etc. get the bulk of their traffic, not from these folks who want to download John Smith's whack at creating a horror short, but want to see tron legacy 2 weeks before it comes out.

We are in the same situation the fellow living in the lawless town was, we may know that these laws are good, and that they are protecting folks from not getting proper compensation for their ideas, and products, but dag gummit, we are not going to give up our free ****.

Personally i hold to the following opinion, its great while it's here, but its going away, enjoy it while you can.

The only point that could really be made against a crackdown on piracy, is that piracy will go back to " The guy who knows a guy." kind of piracy, more common in the vhs era. No more free films with the ease of a click, but having to buy possibly non working copies from a friend of a friend who knows how to make them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom