9/11 Truth Movement - The worst CT ever?

applecorped

Banned
Joined
Mar 8, 2008
Messages
20,145
Has there ever been a more unorganized, self-destructive, thoughtless, and manipulative CT movement than the 9/11 Truth movement?
 
Probably not, simply because before the Internet you actually had to have some form of organization to follow conspiracy theories. Now any doofus with a connection and a paranoid mindset can join in the fun.
 
Maybe scientology.

At least the truthers don't try to repeatedly sell the same dubious product to their... oh, hang on.

At least the truthers don't use gaudy, flash, empty audio-visual presentations in a cheap effort to mesmerise and gloss over their utter dearth of substantive... no, that's not it either.

Here we go! At least the truthers don't cling desperately to any passing coat-tails, basking in faded stars' dull reflections and prostituted airs of legitimacy.... erm.

Keeping their more rampant delusions private in a transparent and clumsily enacted bait-and-switch style faux-naif comportment? Hook, line, and sinker. Abandonment of social mores and conventions in favour of a cold 1000-yard stare and a monotonic repetition of vacuous mantras practically constituting a private language, occasionally interspersed with mouth-foaming rants worryingly reminiscent of drug-induced formal thought disorder, if not incipient outright psychosis? Yup. Senselessly disproportionate violence threatened - perhaps, pending due process, actually put into effect - against perceived opposition? Check. Help, I'm really drowning here.

Stickers! That's gotta be it. Truthers put up stickers, and they can sometimes brighten the place up a bit.

Ok, you're probably right.
 
Last edited:
If I remember right Heaven's Gate seemed very well organized. If only the troothers were as efficient.
 
Has there ever been a more unorganized, self-destructive, thoughtless, and manipulative CT movement than the 9/11 Truth movement?

PLANET X IS REAL, BUT NASA IS COVERING IT UP!!!!!11!1!ONE!1!PGDN

Not really the most self-destructive and organized, but possibly dumber than the 9/11 movement.
 
I think there's some mixing of conspiracy vs. cult here. Not that there isn't overlap.

But yeah, 911 twoofers are the biggest imploders:

Moon Hoaxers were usually just lone cranks who got a little media attention. The worst thing they did was stalk a national hero..who they did not consider to be a hero.

JFK CTs managed to weed out a lot of cranks from their ranks. They had effectively tossed Fetzer. They still have some ranters, but they manage to keep them from the mainstream and the worst of them never pulled any WAC stuff.

UFO CT nuts? None of them ever tried anything stupid like charging Groom Lake. I did see it suggested on USENET until calmer heads pointed out they would be only so much meat for machine guns.
 
PLANET X IS REAL, BUT NASA IS COVERING IT UP!!!!!11!1!ONE!1!PGDN

Not really the most self-destructive and organized, but possibly dumber than the 9/11 movement.

PGDN? Seriously? :D Is that actual page-down? ZOMG!!!11!!CTRL-ALT-F4!!11? Pwnageddon perhaps? :p
 
Dunno about "worst." Chemtrails is definitely dumber (although with many a twoofer, you get a twofer, so to speak). And nothing rivals anti-semitism for sheer long-term destructiveness. But the 9/11 CTist movement definitely has a certain quality all its own, perhaps because as a latter-day conspiracy, it is internet-driven and thus appeals to a lot of lonely, disaffected children. So it may be safe to say that this is the most childish and immature CT of all time.
 
Dunno about "worst." Chemtrails is definitely dumber (although with many a twoofer, you get a twofer, so to speak). And nothing rivals anti-semitism for sheer long-term destructiveness. But the 9/11 CTist movement definitely has a certain quality all its own, perhaps because as a latter-day conspiracy, it is internet-driven and thus appeals to a lot of lonely, disaffected children. So it may be safe to say that this is the most childish and immature CT of all time.[/QUOTE]

Agreed.
 
Seconded. The most striking thing about the "truth movement" is its sheer infantilism.

Moon Hoaxers were usually just lone cranks who got a little media attention. The worst thing they did was stalk a national hero..who they did not consider to be a hero.

Very little from the Apollo HBs (Hoax Believers) lately. I actually kinda miss that; it's really the only CT I have much interest in...

UFO CT nuts? None of them ever tried anything stupid like charging Groom Lake. I did see it suggested on USENET until calmer heads pointed out they would be only so much meat for machine guns.

That should read "they would only be picked up by the AF security police and given medical attention after trying to run a few miles across the Nevada desert..."
 
Dunno about "worst." Chemtrails is definitely dumber (although with many a twoofer, you get a twofer, so to speak). And nothing rivals anti-semitism for sheer long-term destructiveness. But the 9/11 CTist movement definitely has a certain quality all its own, perhaps because as a latter-day conspiracy, it is internet-driven and thus appeals to a lot of lonely, disaffected children. So it may be safe to say that this is the most childish and immature CT of all time.

Huh... I never thought about it that way. You got a good point.

Apollo Hoaxers are fairly dumb, but rather harmless.

Medical science denialists have the potential to be somewhat harmful to society (and very terribly harmful to individuals), but even in the depths of my disagreements, I don't see them as being malicious. Misguided, mostly, but not openly malicious about it.

Chemtrailers are just the retards of the CT world. The explanation is so damn obvious, and the counters to the science are even lamer than 9/11 denial. Which is one hell of a feat.

Kennedy CT'ers I don't understand yet; I've yet to study that "field".

But 9/11 conspriacy fantasists... I won't call them the worst, because Holocaust denial outranks them by whole orders of magnitude; denying the Holocaust is apologizing for evil. Yet, 9/11 conspiracy fantasy seems to have its own qualities missing from older CT's. Stellafane nailed most of the reasoning: It's primarily an internet-driven phenomenon, so it has some characteristics commonly attributed to that crowd. The unique disassociation from the truth and inability to discriminate between sound and unsound sources of information are not new or unique to the internetting fantasists, but it's astoundingly uniform and shocking to what extent very sound, very well researched issues are distrusted simply because of a couple of paragraphs on a webpage. The misunderstandings of the fantasy interpretations of NIST's report, for example, are legion, and all the threads that Mackey, Newton's Bit, Architect, rwguinn, et. al. (sorry if I left you out; this is strictly stream-of-consciousness writing here :o) where they correct people's take on NIST aptly demonstrates this.

I don't know if I'd call 9/11 fantasy the worst CT ever. But it does have some characteristics that make it one of the more obdurately misinformed CTs.
 
Last edited:
Huh... I never thought about it that way. You got a good point.

Apollo Hoaxers are fairly dumb, but rather harmless.

Medical science denialists have the potential to be somewhat harmful to society (and very terribly harmful to individuals), but even in the depths of my disagreements, I don't see them as being malicious. Misguided, mostly, but not openly malicious about it.

Chemtrailers are just the retards of the CT world. The explanation is so damn obvious, and the counters to the science are even lamer than 9/11 denial. Which is one hell of a feat.

Kennedy CT'ers I don't understand yet; I've yet to study that "field".

But 9/11 conspriacy fantasists... I won't call them the worst, because Holocaust denial outranks them by whole orders of magnitude; denying the Holocaust is apologizing for evil. Yet, 9/11 conspiracy fantasy seems to have its own qualities missing from older CT's. Stellafane nailed most of the reasoning: It's primarily an internet-driven phenomenon, so it has some characteristics commonly attributed to that crowd. The unique disassociation from the truth and inability to discriminate between sound and unsound sources of information are not new or unique to the internetting fantasists, but it's astoundingly uniform and shocking to what extent very sound, very well researched issues are distrusted simply because of a couple of paragraphs on a webpage. The misunderstandings of the fantasy interpretations of NIST's report, for example, are legion, and all the threads that Mackey, Newton's Bit, Architect, rwguinn, et. al. (sorry if I left you out; this is strictly stream-of-consciousness writing here :o) where they correct people's take on NIST aptly demonstrates this.

I don't know if I'd call 9/11 fantasy the worst CT ever. But it does have some characteristics that make it one of the more obdurately misinformed CTs.

I would have to agree that "chemtrails" is about the most idiotic CT. The Moon Landing Hoax CT ranks right up there in terms of foolishness, but seems fairly harmless in comparison to 9-11 Twoof.
The Kennedy CTs and 9-11 Twoof seem the most lucrative, in terms of the number of books written and sold, though I view the 9-11 CTers to be the worst kind of charlatans for making a business out of selling books and other merchandise by playing to the fears and paranoia of the average disenchanted young people of todays generation.

Edit: Holocaust deniers are in a league of their own, below and beyond any other typical CT. The motivation and agenda of these people is clear and obvious, and earns nothing but contempt from me. That a number of prominent holocaust deniers have been embraced by the twoof mooovement certainly doesn't lend any additional credibility to their cause.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom