9/11 Truth and Mental Health

More proof that you have no understanding or empathy for individuals who honestly believe that 9/11 was an inside job.

9/11 was one helluva shock for most people.

But we were given explanations which fit our understanding of what was going on in the world and at home.

We were re-assured about who, how, and why.

And then we saw the rarely viewed news videos of WTC7 dropping like a brick.

And so did our hearts.

MM

Very insightful. Perhaps there is something to it? Truthers having subjectively experienced trauma?

Gage's "ESO" film features psychologists talking about how the shock that you, MM, and your ilk experienced may cause you to believe lies.
Perhaps they are right after all?
 
I found a colorful bird of woo on the list of donors to Gage's current "ReThink911" campaign:

Albert Venczel

Just from clicking through his photos:
Has psychic visions.
Believes in UFOs.
Is associated with Coast to Coast AM.
Believes "guardian angels are real and the occupant of nut's & bolts UFO's"
Sees, and feels threatened, by "powerful symbols" all around him.
Believes in Apollo Hoax.
Supports the Occupy Movement, and thinks Bohemian Grove is evil.
Believes in 9/11 Twoof.
Believes the "Rothchilds are a tool for the devil".
Believes that "Evil Aliens are here posing as human running the USG."
Attended the Toronto Hearings.
Wants to see Larry Silverstein hanged.
Believes Reptilians rule the world.
Believes in a Zionist-led NWO.
Believes in vaccines hoax.
Believes global warming is a hoax.
 
I had a thought, along the lines of MM's PTSD tinted posting. This is after reading in the Fetzer thread and thiniing that Fetzer is getting even further unhinged, and getting the impression of other Truthers seeming to get more and more frazzled.

What I wonder, is whether the remaining Truth Movement adherents are feeling increased mental stress as time goes on, leading to more frazzled behavior. The stress would be from a few factors:

  • Not making any significant progress getting "the world to wake up"
  • Not seeing any more evidence come forth that their beliefs are true after so long, including anyone coming out and confessing.
  • Having to come up with wilder theories to reinforce their beliefs because of the above two facts [for example, blaming the Jews].

The last point about having to come up with wilder theories is more because they are fighting off having to admit they are wrong, even if just admitting it to themselves.

In other words, maybe the passage of time leads adherents of Trutherism to mental health issues, as long as they desperately cling to their faith.
 
^Is there a split at some point where some of the adherents indeed get even more frazzled, but some just get bored or disillusioned with the whole truther game and wander randomly back onto saner territory?

ETA: we've been adding the Boston Marathon Bombers to the list of truthers-gone-over the edge, and it seems like a good possibility that the Ricin-laced letters recently in the news were sent by people/person of a like mindset. This would come as a surprise to none of us, I'm sure.

LSSBB if you are trying to play "chicken or egg" I'd have to say the mental illness comes first and is just manifested in such things as irrational adherence to strange tales of varying degrees of unbelievability.
 
I found a colorful bird of woo on the list of donors to Gage's current "ReThink911" campaign:

Albert Venczel

Just from clicking through his photos:
Has psychic visions.
Believes in UFOs.
Is associated with Coast to Coast AM.
Believes "guardian angels are real and the occupant of nut's & bolts UFO's"
Sees, and feels threatened, by "powerful symbols" all around him.
Believes in Apollo Hoax.
Supports the Occupy Movement, and thinks Bohemian Grove is evil.
Believes in 9/11 Twoof.
Believes the "Rothchilds are a tool for the devil".
Believes that "Evil Aliens are here posing as human running the USG."
Attended the Toronto Hearings.
Wants to see Larry Silverstein hanged.
Believes Reptilians rule the world.
Believes in a Zionist-led NWO.
Believes in vaccines hoax.
Believes global warming is a hoax.

So much contradiction...clearly is a believer in God, but aliens too? We couldn't get to the moon but aliens could get here? Are the Jews Aliens, cause don't most of the proponents of alien visitation maintain the government is in league with them? So is the nWo really an alien invasion? WTF?!?!!?!?!!?!?!
 
I found a colorful bird of woo on the list of donors to Gage's current "ReThink911" campaign:

Albert Venczel

Just from clicking through his photos:
Has psychic visions.
Believes in UFOs.
Is associated with Coast to Coast AM.
Believes "guardian angels are real and the occupant of nut's & bolts UFO's"
Sees, and feels threatened, by "powerful symbols" all around him.
Believes in Apollo Hoax.
Supports the Occupy Movement, and thinks Bohemian Grove is evil.
Believes in 9/11 Twoof.
Believes the "Rothchilds are a tool for the devil".
Believes that "Evil Aliens are here posing as human running the USG."
Attended the Toronto Hearings.
Wants to see Larry Silverstein hanged.
Believes Reptilians rule the world.
Believes in a Zionist-led NWO.
Believes in vaccines hoax.
Believes global warming is a hoax.

Wow.He just needs to become a Moon Hoaxer to be batting .1000 in the conspiracy nut derby....
 
A Truther named Mike Cook was committed a few years ago:



All told he spent about 6 months in various facilities. The Web Fairy (aka Rosalee Grable) revealed in an interview that she had been institutionalized by her family:



And if you watch that interview it is not hard to believe. Rosalee was an important early Truther and her website was commonly cited in early Truther postings.

The leader of the Arizona Truther group was Kent (Cow Killer) Knudsen. Kent took his own life about 3 years ago.

There was an Australian Truther who was committed a few years back but I am not finding the information right now.

Let me add too that there are plenty of Truthers who have screwed up their lives in pursuit of the Holy Fail. Richard Gage's wife divorced him over his nuttery. Steven Jones was fired from BYU. Numerous Truthers have talked about the fact that they don't have any friends any more because they scared them away--Jon Gold and Bob McIlvaine are only the tip of the iceberg. Of course, to Truthers this is a sign of their commitment, but to us sane folks it's a symptom of nuttiness that may not quite require being institutionalized, but is certainly edging in that direction.

Thank you. This is the sort of information I'm interested in seeing.

Apparently, Truther and Holocaust denier Chuck Boldwyn has also been described by a psychiatrist as suffering from moderately severe psychiatric problems. Apparently this diagnosis comes from an incident completely unrelated to his bizarre image of the world.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=9278799#post9278799

I presume there must be all kinds of stories like this.
 
While I value my JREF acquaintanceship with Truther ergo, I started this thread so that another thread, in which he was a part, would not get hijacked. In turn, I hope for the same standards with this thread. I do not want to talk about conspiracy theories or other delusionary ideas.

One point that might be meaningful is ergo's use of the term "statistically". I don't know what you got taught in your intro psych class. I suggest you pursue this idea with a reading about Bayes' Theorem. Wikipedia provides an good introduction, although it quickly becomes too technical for most people to follow.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayes'_theorem
I like this discussion, but it is reasonably technical and probably beyond your level.
http://www.trinity.edu/cbrown/bayesweb/

I will try to find something that is more accessible. But really, have a look at Bayes' Theorem. An understanding would help you discuss this issue in a way that would make sense to statistically knowledgeable people. And readily...I'd like to be able to talk to you in a way that makes sense, instead of this mashed up very of things in which you randomly insert 'learned' words.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, okay. Enjoy the "discussion" here, Scott. It shows how well you're putting your own academic achievements to use. ;)

Thank you. I appreciate the compliment. Here's a good reference for you that's not too technical that offers an interesting application of Bayes' Theorem.

Why Psychologists Must Change the Way They Analyze Their Data: The Case of Psi
http://behavioralhealth.squarespace.com/storage/Bem6.pdf

I'm a little concerned that the article deals with a statistical refutation of ESP. I know you are a friend of 9/11 Truth, and in other posts you have expressed a belief in the secret mind control technology advocated by some Christians groups and spy movies staring Charles Bronson. So it is possible you also believe in ESP, coprophilia and spoon-bending as actual human abilities. If so, you may miss the point of my example. Just plug your ears and focus on the idea of Bayesian probability as introduced in paper. It's such a good explanation, I think even someone handicapped with these kinds of ideas should be able to get it.

And remember, Telefone is just a movie. But it is a really good one.
 
Last edited:
Really, I am trying to discourage advocates of the 9/11 Truth from posting responses to this thread. There are threads I hope to have responses from you fellas, but I can never seem to get them when I want them. But sure, I'd like to hear what you have to say about the mental health of people who disagree with you. First, I'd like you get some knowledge of what's meant by mental health. It doesn't just mean crazy ideas. In fact, if you've read the thread, you'll see I'm not concerned about more stuff on the nutty things that you Truther-types believe. I want to know if any Truther-types have records of involuntary committal, substance abuse or histories of anti-social behavior. If you're aware of any among that group that publicly opposes advocates for a 9/11 Truth, I'm open to this, as well. If you and your 'colleagues' in scholarship can point to any meaningful patterns, I'd be happy to write about this.

But if you want to do this, let's start another thread. Because here - like it says in the OP - I'm trying to find out about mental illness among friends of the 9/11 Truth Movement. Got it?
 
Last edited:
I know two people who are truthers.

Both have suffered from severe depression, neither is well endowed, women find them creepy.

Thank you. I don't doubt this is true. Are they active Truthers? Even on the Internet? Particularly, are they active on Facebook? If you want to send this in a pm, that would also be fine for me.
 
Thank you. I don't doubt this is true. Are they active Truthers? Even on the Internet? Particularly, are they active on Facebook? If you want to send this in a pm, that would also be fine for me.

I only had one of them on facebook and he's not mentioned it on there. Curiously as he's started beating his depression he's moved on from 9/11 truth or has stopped mentioning it as people would take the piss.

The other guy, who has thankfully moved away, he was a tool, he was much more active and tried several times to persuade some of my friends about the truth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom