yankee451
Master Poster
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2013
- Messages
- 2,794
Thousands saw the attacks in person, or were directly impacted by it in other forms. You apparently forget that one significant problem with your case.
Name them.
Thousands saw the attacks in person, or were directly impacted by it in other forms. You apparently forget that one significant problem with your case.
Peter for one. Also Margaret, I think.Name them.
Name them.
No need. GB states a number representing a (low) reasonable estimate under given circumstances. We discussed it before.
If you have one or two people who say they saw something else than the thousands mentioned, you'd better name them.
Circular logic. You assume there were thousands of people to witness what you saw on television, therefore what you saw on television occurred.
How am I contradicting my own story?By the way, for your explanation to be correct, the official explanation must be incorrect. Why do you think the engine would "pull" the wing, when the wing was disintegrated by the steel as it penetrated it? By the time the wing tip struck, it would no longer be attached to the wing.
You are contradicting your own story.
[qimg]https://911crashtest.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/wing-structure-fragmented-highlighted.png[/qimg]
Thousands saw the attacks in person, or were directly impacted by it in other forms. You apparently forget that one significant problem with your case.
Argumentum ad Populum (Literally "Argument to the People"): Using an appeal to popular assent, often by arousing the feelings and enthusiasm of the multitude rather than building an argument. It is a favorite device with the propagandist, the demagogue, and the advertiser. An example of this type of argument is Shakespeare's version of Mark Antony's funeral oration for Julius Caesar. There are three basic approaches:
(1) Bandwagon Approach: “Everybody is doing it.” This argumentum ad populum asserts that, since the majority of people believes an argument or chooses a particular course of action, the argument must be true, or the course of action must be followed, or the decision must be the best choice. For instance, “85% of consumers purchase IBM computers rather than Macintosh; all those people can’t be wrong. IBM must make the best computers.” Popular acceptance of any argument does not prove it to be valid, nor does popular use of any product necessarily prove it is the best one. After all, 85% of people may once have thought planet earth was flat, but that majority's belief didn't mean the earth really was flat when they believed it! Keep this in mind, and remember that everybody should avoid this type of logical fallacy.
(2) Patriotic Approach: "Draping oneself in the flag." This argument asserts that a certain stance is true or correct because it is somehow patriotic, and that those who disagree are unpatriotic. It overlaps with pathos and argumentum ad hominem to a certain extent. The best way to spot it is to look for emotionally charged terms like Americanism, rugged individualism, motherhood, patriotism, godless communism, etc. A true American would never use this approach. And a truly free man will exercise his American right to drink beer, since beer belongs in this great country of ours.This approach is unworthy of a good citizen.
(3) Snob Approach: This type of argumentum ad populum doesn’t assert “everybody is doing it,” but rather that “all the best people are doing it.” For instance, “Any true intellectual would recognize the necessity for studying logical fallacies.” The implication is that anyone who fails to recognize the truth of the author’s assertion is not an intellectual, and thus the reader had best recognize that necessity.
In all three of these examples, the rhetorician does not supply evidence that an argument is true; he merely makes assertions about people who agree or disagree with the argument. For Christian students in religious schools like Carson-Newman, we might add a fourth category, "Covering Oneself in the Cross." This argument asserts that a certain political or denominational stance is true or correct because it is somehow "Christian," and that anyone who disagrees is behaving in an "un-Christian" or "godless" manner. (It is similar to the patriotic approach except it substitutes a gloss of piety instead of patriotism.) Examples include the various "Christian Voting Guides" that appear near election time, many of them published by non-Church related organizations with hidden financial/political agendas, or the stereotypical crooked used-car salesman who keeps a pair of bibles on his dashboard in order to win the trust of those he would fleece. Keep in mind Moliere's question in Tartuffe: "Is not a face quite different than a mask?" Is not the appearance of Christianity quite different than actual Christianity? Christians should beware of such manipulation since they are especially vulnerable to it.
https://web.cn.edu/kwheeler/fallacies_list.html
You guys are like case studies for the logical fallacies sites.
If I was saying that I would have written that.
I am saying what I actually wrote.
That large piece of aircraft grade aluminium alloy that you showed, travelling at 800 kph carries quite a good deal of kinetic energy. I know that comes as a surprise to a mo-planer, but it is true.
The fact that it breaks upon impact doesn't change the fact that this energy has been transferred to the column.
So, even after the spar has snapped and the remaining pieces have bounced off or travelled on past, the column continues.fracturing.
The cladding, a separate piece of metal with different properties and not directly attached to the column will behave differently under that impact.
There is no necessary reason why the cladding will be severed, although it probably will.
Do you get upset when no one believes in your silly theory yankee451?
http://mark-conlon.blogspot.com/2017/12/setting-record-straight-about-michael.html
And this trait in no way reminds me of the current occupier of the White House, L. Ron Hubbard or any other cult leader/wannabe who insists that it's my way or the highway.![]()
How am I contradicting my own story?
You do know what the words "or" and "possibly" mean, don't you? If not, please consult a dictionary.
And what you actually wrote means that the spar gouged out most of a steel column (but not all of it), but somehow managed to miss the aluminum sheeting that covered that part of the column it was able to damage. What you describe is not reflected in any of the videos or photographs. It is also contradicted by the official organs like Purdue, MIT and the NIST.
Neither you nor yankee451 have posted any physics in support of your contentions.
Show me the physics of what you think we should have seen in lossy video of a distant object.
I can see nothing in any of the videos that is inconsistent with the physics of a plane crash.
It is what it is, dude. Deal with it (or continue to go off for the next 14 pages about a detail that is entirely your own speculation about how a piece of cladding should behave).
I wonder if this person was confused about a missile or a plane?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Clark_(September_11_survivor)
It is what it is, dude. Deal with it (or continue to go off for the next 14 pages about a detail that is entirely your own speculation about how a piece of cladding should behave).
I wonder if this person was confused about a missile or a plane?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Clark_(September_11_survivor)
Oh, gasp - look, a witness.
I'm looking for the wing that didn't penetrate the wall, but which the television, and Purdue, said did penetrate. What was it the propaganda organs said? "In one side and out the other," "like a bad special effect."
Thanks, whereas one jet "dragged" the steel to the right, the other didn't, yet both left almost identical damage.
[qimg]http://yankee451.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/trajectories-1.jpg[/qimg]
Why would you be looking for that when the television, Purdue and the Michael Hezarkhani's video are all in agreement? Ever hear of chaotic motion?
You are claiming that I said it misses the cladding?And what you actually wrote means that the spar gouged out most of a steel column (but not all of it), but somehow managed to miss the aluminum sheeting that covered that part of the column it was able to damage