9/11: How they Faked the Videos

Good analysis. Furthermore, let me note that the angle of the remaining fuselage between the two pictures above is substantially different.

What Itchy Boy failed to realize is what kind of scale we're talking about here. If the front of the wing crumples and gets destroyed, the back of it is still several metres away from it, and you can't expect to be able to discern significant deformation with that resolution.

Thanks.

I had to pull those images from the lone "high resolution" video on Youtube and because I only have Photoshop Elements I had to fight the program to get all of that up. I have four more frames wherein you can see dust from collapsing cement floors billow out of the rear (main entry hole) and the side of the tower just before the fuel ignites.

However it's very clear that the plane's fuselage and wings buckle as they slam into the building.

I also felt like a sleaze ball for even having to do that. There are people on that plane and people in the impact zone. I can't image the depths of sociopathy one must sink to in order to become a No-Planer.
 
One very important concept that the ping ball analogy misses (if applied to the real life event) is that material strength, uniformity, and stiffness are very very different when expanded from the scale of a little ball paddle and an air filled ball.

Dynamics of surface area, structural attributes, and kinetic energy applications expand exponentially when applied at the scale of a ...... sky scraper.... and a passenger air liner... for one. If the ones portraying this "fakery" are relying on the analogy of a small scale analogy to explain the dynamics of a full scale event.... it is missing the very important fine print about the limits of application
 
One very important concept that the ping ball analogy misses (if applied to the real life event) is that material strength, uniformity, and stiffness are very very different when expanded from the scale of a little ball paddle and an air filled ball.

Dynamics of surface area, structural attributes, and kinetic energy applications expand exponentially when applied at the scale of a ...... sky scraper.... and a passenger air liner... for one. If the ones portraying this "fakery" are relying on the analogy of a small scale analogy to explain the dynamics of a full scale event.... it is missing the very important fine print about the limits of application

While you are obviously right, I'd say the pingpong ball analogy demonstrated the points we wanted with an acceptable accuracy. That includes the possibility of the fuselage exploding under the right circumstances. In the case of WTC the destroyed front of the fuselage hasn't been sufficiently sealed (unlike with the pingpong ball), so it hasn't happened. It probably did happen to Swisair 111 hitting water in a nosedive at high speed. The plane disintegrated into estimated 5 million pieces what I find rather hard to imagine as a sole result of a rapid deceleration. Don't worry, I know water can be hard. I had my share of diving from 10 m tower and have 2 fused vertebrae to prove it ;-)). But I would more tend to believe water filling the fuselage through the destroyed front at high speed acted like a piston compressing the air in the back to the point of explosion. In fact, I find harder to imagine this DIDN'T happen, than that it did.
 
OP read.

Blown out of the water by post #2.

I know. Talk about a colossal lack of knowledge of NYC.

NBC's headquarters are at 30 Rockefeller Center, CBS's HQ (Blackrock) is at 51 W 52nd St, ABC is over at 77 W 66th St #13 (furthest away), and Fox News is at 1211 Avenue of the Americas. I don't know about ABC and Fox but CBC and NBC are 4 miles away and it was no problem to put cameras on their rooftops to film.

All of them are north of 1 World Trade Center.

South of the WTC is the Hudson Rover, and scenic Bayonne New Jersey.

Not many places to mount a high resolution camera without a good reason (like knowing there would be a second plane which would strike from the south).
 
This is a great example of how so many CT-ists are so desperate to refute any and all questioning of their pet theories that they forget what they were actually arguing for.
yankee451: You said there were holes big enough for a missile to pass through. I noticed that a 14-inch-wide missile could not pass through a 14-inch-wide hole without getting jammed.
You responded with a link explaining how a missile would not need a hole, because it could blast its own way through.
You are therefore arguing against yourself, and also inadvertently destroying your whole theory.
Please highlight the 'clean exit hole' your own link says the missile would make, and then explain why you have been arguing that a missile passed through a hole, thus proving that it was a missile and not a plane, when your own link says that won't happen.

How can I ignore you and simultaneously respond? Why would you think the missile would jam?

Once again, using your own figures: the gap is 14 inches. The missile is 14 inches wide. It cannot pass through the gap without jamming.
You explained this by quoting a source that said it would blast through, leaving a missile-shaped hole. This, according you the photo you keep using, did not happen.
Therefore there was no missile.

Why would you think the wing could cut the steel, but neglect to cut the aluminum cladding that covered it?

Perhaps you missed the entire Burden of Proof conversation. To remind you: your claim is missiles, therefore the BoP rests on you. I do not have to answer that question.
Your own sources disprove missiles. You need either to disown your sources, or admit your theory is wrong.
 
Just seeing how this turns out. Not a lot to work with...

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/TaGo1p6.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/Oix8MjL.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/J2ZcygW.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/2iz4d7I.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]https://i.imgur.com/bsPJ7jE.jpg[/qimg]

Thanks for the photo (sorry, originally by Axman). The stream of fuel pointing backwards confirms a "hydraulic action in all directions". In one of my earlier posts I suspected it to be responsible for some bits and pieces being bent in directions not consistent with a frontal impact that OP is using for his "missile theory". Again, there may be other explanations too.
 
Forget the nitty gritty details, for a sec....

There would need to be TEAMS of artists making these layers all look realistic and consistent, and several LEVELS of TV producers to make sure it got out on time, to be considered "live" TV. That's already hundreds of people who would know something nefarious is going on.

It's NOT impossible for that to happen. But, I think it's simply stupid.

The challenge I have for you, is to explain how faking airplane collisions to this level is SMARTER than getting far fewer people to hijack real planes.


THIS!

In the 1997 movie, Titanic, there was a scene where they morphed the sunken wreck of the foredeck of the ship into the floating brand new RMS Titanic on the surface in Southampton dock...



''..that clip was only 7 seconds long, a little shorter that the actual clip which was more like 12 seconds long (although the actual morph transition frames, a single viewpoint fluid motion tracking shot from left to right across about 45°) occupied only 3 to 4 seconds.

That one shot took a team of dozens of compositors and digital artists over 600 hours to make. Yankee would have us believe that dozens of videos from dozens of angles, all much longer than the Titanic 3-4 sec clip, were prepared and distributed within seconds of the impact.

Ain't happening.
 
"Secret military tech," will be the answer.

In my lengthy military experience, I have found that the "tech" in the military has often lagged behind that in the private sector. For example, in the 1970s civilian airliners were routinely using inertial navigation systems - our C-130Ks were still using an AN/APN70 LORAN-C !! (Oh, and so were the US Navy and USAF C-130s)
 
Video layers and drawn on smoke.

This explanation satisfies you, and only you, because you have no grasp whatever of the challenge you are proposing.

It has a similar absurdity to your imagining that wing damage could be faked with missiles flying in from either side and raking across the face of the building. Although this falls apart immediately as the missiles did not exist, imagine if they had: Consider for a moment the accuracy and precision required to avoid making "wing" impressions which were a few feet too long or too short, or were offset from each other, or at the wrong dihedral angle.

Perhaps you could estimate a suitable accuracy spec for your missiles and then see if anyone has ever made such a thing. Perhaps you prefer to avoid trying.
 
Once again, using your own figures: the gap is 14 inches. The missile is 14 inches wide. It cannot pass through the gap without jamming.
You explained this by quoting a source that said it would blast through, leaving a missile-shaped hole. This, according you the photo you keep using, did not happen.
Therefore there was no missile.



Perhaps you missed the entire Burden of Proof conversation. To remind you: your claim is missiles, therefore the BoP rests on you. I do not have to answer that question.
Your own sources disprove missiles. You need either to disown your sources, or admit your theory is wrong.

Just to add to this: I believe that yankee451 is saying the missiles struck at an angle? Is that correct?
If it is, then there's no way either size (14" or 12" could have passed through the gap without either getting stuck or blasting a visible hole into the structure.
I've had a quick skim, and it does look like this is the claim.
 
Just to add to this: I believe that yankee451 is saying the missiles struck at an angle? Is that correct?
If it is, then there's no way either size (14" or 12" could have passed through the gap without either getting stuck or blasting a visible hole into the structure.
I've had a quick skim, and it does look like this is the claim.

Yes. His fantasy version is that missiles scored across the face of the building from either side at a shallow angle, gouging deeper as they headed toward the middle. Plus some other number of missiles as required to fill in the big holes for engines and the fuselage.

Mere inches of lateral error in the point of impact would have made feet of error in the length of the wing impression created. And it's not at all clear how a "wing" missile could carve a wing-thick hole while an "engine" missile somehow made a giant engine sized hole rather than punching another wing-thick hole.
 
In my lengthy military experience, I have found that the "tech" in the military has often lagged behind that in the private sector. For example, in the 1970s civilian airliners were routinely using inertial navigation systems - our C-130Ks were still using an AN/APN70 LORAN-C !! (Oh, and so were the US Navy and USAF C-130s)

Dude, he has conjecture based on years of assumptions! That beats your actual experience.

But yes. The missile system I worked on was transitioning from tube based to solid state back in the late 80s, early 90's. The main reasons for this was that tubes worked, it was battle tested, and those logistic lines are long.

In my current experience working for the federal government, we are working with state of the art 1960's tech trying to upgrade it into, hopefully, early 2000s software.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom