9/11: How they Faked the Videos

And once again, for those of you with short attention spans, the burden of proof lies with the person making the claim,...
So true. And the "burden" is to present the proof that they rely on. In this case those representatives of "officialdom" who presented the extant hypothesis. And who have met their burden of proof by presenting the proof they rely on. (We could include the many professionals who support the same but lets keep it simple to expose Yankee's dishonesty.)

Here is where you go astray yankee451. (And given you have been playing this nonsense for years it CANNOT be ignorance - so it must be deliberate lying.)
.... not we who call BS to the claim.
Hogwash of course. THAT is the claim to which BoP attaches - YOUR claim that the extant hypothesis is wrong. Your burden to prove your claim that the so called "official version" is wrong. Or at the least those bits YOU claim are wrong.

The original claim being, on 9/11 mostly hollow aluminum jets burrowed into the ground, bored through a concrete and brick building, and sliced through steel skyscrapers like butter.
OK - if we take that as near enough what YOU claim is wrong. YOUR Burden of Proof to support YOUR claim.

[/EndIntroToLegalBasics000.5]
 
Last edited:
you really have no clue what physics is

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wc-zmb3jAgo

oops, density, you have no clue

Beat me to it.

The ping ping ball is orders of magnitude less dense and lower mass than the bat, yet it punched right through it (and disintegrated) and actually broke the bat blade off at the handle. THAT is what Newton was talking about!

NOTE: If you were hit by that supersonic ping pong ball, it would to a lot of damage - broken bones, torn flesh etc, and depending on where it hit you, it might even kill you instantly.
 
Beat me to it.

The ping ping ball is orders of magnitude less dense and lower mass than the bat, yet it punched right through it (and disintegrated) and actually broke the bat blade off at the handle. THAT is what Newton was talking about!

NOTE: If you were hit by that supersonic ping pong ball, it would to a lot of damage - broken bones, torn flesh etc, and depending on where it hit you, it might even kill you instantly.

Yes, but we could see the ball breaking apart immediately upon impact and before it had fully penetrated.
That's what we don't see in the plane video and I don't believe that can be chalked up to video resolution, though I'm sure you will do so.
Unlike the plane, the ball displayed real crash physics.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but we could see the ball breaking apart immediately upon impact and before it had fully penetrated.
That's what we don't see in the plane video and I don't believe that can be chalked up to video resolution, though I'm sure you will do so.
Unlike the plane, the ball displayed real crash physics.
Again I am unclear on what you expect to see in the video.

I can't imagine what else you would expect to see.

You say that the videos are not what you expect to see.

Can you carefully describe what you do expect to see and explain why.

That would help me understand your position.
 
Again I am unclear on what you expect to see in the video.

I can't imagine what else you would expect to see.

You say that the videos are not what you expect to see.

Can you carefully describe what you do expect to see and explain why.

That would help me understand your position.

I expect to see damage to the plane upon impact, similar to what beachnut's ping pong video shows. I owe beachnut a 'thank you' for proving that the plane impact videos are fake.
 
Yes, but we could see the ball breaking apart immediately upon impact and before it had fully penetrated.
That's what we don't see in the plane video and I don't believe that can be chalked up to video resolution, though I'm sure you will do so.
Unlike the plane, the ball displayed real crash physics.

I have a distinct feeling there is something fishy with the video (how else it could fit in your fantasy world ;-)). A close examination reveals, the creators have filled the ball with water to make things easier. You can clearly see the rear of the ball bursting by hydraulic action (that's the part I was trying to get your attention to when talking about wing hitting the building), the ball opening outwards and the water escaping.
Mythbusters https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qV4xVAYCK8Q made a similar experiment, but didn't cheat. Here is a screenshot:
 

Attachments

  • Capture.JPG
    Capture.JPG
    39.4 KB · Views: 4
Last edited:
Yes, but we could see the ball breaking apart immediately upon impact and before it had fully penetrated.
That's what we don't see in the plane video and I don't believe that can be chalked up to video resolution, though I'm sure you will do so.
Unlike the plane, the ball displayed real crash physics.

And here is what you are missing.

The difference between the densities of the ping ping ball and the blade is slightly colossal; at least a couple of orders of magnitude greater than the difference between the building (a hollow, extended cubical structure composed of 90% air and 10% building materials ) and the aircraft (a hollow tubular structure composed of 90% air and 10% aluminium superstructure).

You seem to have this picture in your head of the aircraft being "swallowed whole", of remaining largely intact until it disappeared from sight. Get this picture out of your head, its wrong; it is not what happened - it only looks like that from the outside.

In reality, the aircraft started to crush and deform from the moment of impact. At the point where the wing roots are entering the building, the forward fuselage has already disintegrated beyond recognition.
 
I have a distinct feeling there is something fishy with the video (how else it could fit in your fantasy world ;-)). A close examination reveals, the creators have filled the ball with water to make things easier. You can clearly see the rear of the ball bursting by hydraulic action (that's the part I was trying to get your attention to when talking about wing hitting the building), the ball opening outwards and the water escaping.
Mythbusters https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qV4xVAYCK8Q made a similar experiment, but didn't cheat. Here is a screenshot:

Rubbish.... it would not be possible to accelerate a water-filled ping ping ball up to mach 1.4 with the equipment they had.....and your screenshot is from a different video from the one beachnut posted, and that we are talking about.
 
Last edited:
I have a distinct feeling there is something fishy with the video (how else it could fit in your fantasy world ;-)). A close examination reveals, the creators have filled the ball with water to make things easier. You can clearly see the rear of the ball bursting by hydraulic action (that's the part I was trying to get your attention to when talking about wing hitting the building), the ball opening outwards and the water escaping.
Mythbusters made a similar experiment, but didn't cheat. Here is a screenshot:

OK, then shouldn't the fuel filled wing break apart like the water-filled ball?
Plus, if they had to 'cheat' doesn't that mean an unfilled ball would have fared worse - ie failed to penetrate? If so, doesn't that mean the fuselage would have failed to penetrate?

Don't get me started on the MythBuster clowns or we'll be talking more Moon landing nonsense.
Now that I wATCHED YOU MB VID, it change nothing. Again we see real crash physics - at the end in slo-mo. The ball is a lot shorter than the plane and so the debris disappears to fast to see in real time. But we have slo-mo of the plane too, and still see no crash physics. All your ping pong videos do is prove my point - that the plane videos do not show real crash physics and therefore must be fake. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Rubbish.... it would not be possible to accelerate a water-filled ping ping ball up to mach 1.4 with the equipment they had.....and your screenshot is from a different video from the one beachnut posted, and that we are talking about.

Well, rubbish or not - what is the clear stuff visibly escaping at the rear of the ball? A strawberry pie?
How the creators of the video prove the speed is 1.4 M?

Lets admit the possibility the speed is CONSIDERABLY lover and all is falling in place, including the breaking of the paddle that hasn't occur in the MB experiment.
 
Rubbish.... it would not be possible to accelerate a water-filled ping ping ball up to mach 1.4 with the equipment they had.....and your screenshot is from a different video from the one beachnut posted, and that we are talking about.

Neither does it appear that what looks like water was in the ball.If you slow the YT video down, it appears to follow the ball and when it hits the bat, it doesn't drip like water. It looks more like Saran-wrap.
 
OK, then shouldn't the fuel filled wing break apart like the water-filled ball?
Plus, if they had to 'cheat' doesn't that mean an unfilled ball would have fared worse - ie failed to penetrate? If so, doesn't that mean the fuselage would have failed to penetrate?

Don't get me started on the MythBuster clowns or we'll be talking more Moon landing nonsense.
Now that I wATCHED YOU MB VID, it change nothing. Again we see real crash physics - at the end in slo-mo. The ball is a lot shorter than the plane and so the debris disappears to fast to see in real time. But we have slo-mo of the plane too, and still see no crash physics. All your ping pong videos do is prove my point - that the plane videos do not show real crash physics and therefore must be fake. Thanks.

I never succumb to extortion. The possibility of you becoming to discuss the moon landing is frightening, but not enough for me to divert from my rule of not getting in a serious discussion with a nut.:D
 
Well, rubbish or not - what is the clear stuff visibly escaping at the rear of the ball? A strawberry pie?
How the creators of the video prove the speed is 1.4 M?

Lets admit the possibility the speed is CONSIDERABLY lover and all is falling in place, including the breaking of the paddle that hasn't occur in the MB experiment.

Regardless, in each case, we seer real crash physics - the ball breaks in in your MB vid, pieces even bounce backwards. Fake plane videos proven! Well done gentlemen.
 
Last edited:
Well, rubbish or not - what is the clear stuff visibly escaping at the rear of the ball? A strawberry pie?

The "clear stuff" is not escaping, its the remainder if the cling film that was used to help create the vacuum to accelerate the ball

How the creators of the video prove the speed is 1.4 M?

The same way you do it in any such an experiment, by measuring the time v the distance travelled - that's what the green and red stripes were for; as a known reference for measuring the speed on the high speed camera. FFS, have you never watched any of these episodes where they deal with the velocity of objects?

Lets admit the possibility the speed is CONSIDERABLY lover and all is falling in place

No, lets not. I don;t accept falsehoods.

including the breaking of the paddle that hasn't occur in the MB experiment.

The bat didn't break in the MB experiment because it was only loosely held. The bat did break in the Purdue experiment because it was being held in a ******* vice!
 
Regardless, in each case, we seer real crash physics - the ball breaks in in your MB vid, pieces even bounce backwards. Fake plane videos proven! Well done gentlemen.

Pieces of plane bounced backwards too... some of them even fell to the ground on the impact sides of the buildings.
 
Rubbish.... it would not be possible to accelerate a water-filled ping ping ball up to mach 1.4 with the equipment they had.....and your screenshot is from a different video from the one beachnut posted, and that we are talking about.

O.K., let's look at it again. I am aware of the existence of the Gladrwrap or whatever, but there seems to be something else there. The ball is definitely showing signs of bursting outwards by internal pressure, not collapsing inwards and forward as a result of rapid deceleration. It is possible it could be air pressure, but SOME pressure by all means. Thanks for your explaining me of how speed is measured at HS footages, but you came about 50 years late with it :-). I did't notice the stripes on the video. As for the way the bat is being held - possible, but I would tend to say at M 1.4 it would make little difference. No point arguing.
There is, obviously, a question why this ball burst and the MB one didn't. I believe either scenario is possible with some differences in variables like speed, temperature, materials etc.
By no means either of these alternatives prove there is anything wrong with the official version of the 9/11 events.
 
Last edited:
There is a gap. Not big enough for a cruise missile to fit through.

How do you figure? The columns were 14 inches wide. The warheads, the AGM-86 D has a 14 inch warhead, and the AGM-158 has a 12 inch warhead. Using the known measurements of the columns, the warheads of either of these missiles could do the deed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-86_ALCM

http://www.airforce-technology.com/projects/agm-158-jassm-standoff-missile/


Interesting.
Can you explain how a 14 inch missile warhead can pass through a 14 inch space without getting stuck fast?

"The warhead performed as predicted and met all expectations," said Elmer Lueker, the JASSM payload integrated product team leader in Phantom Works. "After experiencing shock loads as high as 12,000 Gs, there was no deformation of the casing and the fuze timing delay performed to the millisecond." The warhead struck the thick, reinforced concrete target, penetrated through it and traveled another half mile down range. The clean exit hole it left indicates that it had maintained the desired straight trajectory while traversing the thick target.
https://boeing.mediaroom.com/1998-02-09-Boeing-Conducts-Successful-JASSM-Warhead-Test

This is a great example of how so many CT-ists are so desperate to refute any and all questioning of their pet theories that they forget what they were actually arguing for.
yankee451: You said there were holes big enough for a missile to pass through. I noticed that a 14-inch-wide missile could not pass through a 14-inch-wide hole without getting jammed.
You responded with a link explaining how a missile would not need a hole, because it could blast its own way through.
You are therefore arguing against yourself, and also inadvertently destroying your whole theory.
Please highlight the 'clean exit hole' your own link says the missile would make, and then explain why you have been arguing that a missile passed through a hole, thus proving that it was a missile and not a plane, when your own link says that won't happen.
 
Pieces of plane bounced backwards too... some of them even fell to the ground on the impact sides of the buildings.

As stated earlier, I see nothing falling on the impact side in any video until After the explosion.
I see no Damage to the plane like we see to the ball despite the pane taking longer to pass through the wall than the ball through the bat.

There'a no getting around it. beachnut's and cat's attempt to belittle my understanding of physics backfired.
 
O.K., let's look at it again. I am aware of the existence of the Gladrwrap or whatever, but there seems to be something else there. By all means, the ball is definitely showing signs of bursting outwards by internal pressure, not collapsing inwards and forward as a result of rapid deceleration. It is possible it could be air pressure, but SOME pressure by all means.

You do know that ping ping balls are sealed, right? Of course it burst instead of collapsing inwards.

There is, obviously, a question why this ball burst and the MB one didn't.

No there isn't, both ping pong balls burst, its just that they did so at different times. If you watch the MB video, the ball totally disintegrates. Its also travelling a lot faster than the Purdue one - 1100 mph v 700 mph. That means I would expect the MB ball to penetrate the bat further before becoming deformed and bursting.

By way of illustration let me tell you about something I discovered very early on when I was just getting interested in guns. My first hand weapon was given to me by my Dad. It was a .177 Webley air pistol, very similar to this one...

file


It was a single shot, charged by cocking the top lever forward and back. It had one muzzle velocity and was great for shooting empty aluminium soda cans off a log.

Some years later, I bought one of these similar to a Crosman .177 BB/Pellet gun...

file


It was also a single shot, cocked by pumping it up (working the lever). The first thing you notice is that the more you pump the lever, the higher the muzzle velocity, and that had the curious effect (at least to me at that time) that at lower muzzle velocities (2-3 pumps), it would knock these cans off the log and back a few feet and leave a big dent in the front, but at higher muzzle velocities (7-9 pumps) it would hardly move the cans at all, leave a much smaller dent, but punch a hole right through.

At the time, this seemed totally counter-intuitive to me, I would have thought that the higher muzzle velocity would result in a bigger dent in the can, and the can being knocked further back. That is not what happened, and the fact that it didn't made me, a young man (still at high-school) curious enough to want to know why, so I investigated in the physics involved and used it as part of a school assignment on energy and momentum.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom